39 ms·
The "world order" will look very different by the time Trump leaves office. He wants to cede more of the Middle East to Russia, reduce our participation and lea
by snowwrestler 10y ago
The "world order" will look very different by the time Trump leaves office. He wants to cede more of the Middle East to Russia, reduce our participation and leadership in NATO, reduce our military presence in South Korea and Japan, and cancel or renegotiate trade deals, including the TPP.
The result will be a world that is more clearly apportioned among 3-4 major powers. Small Asian countries, if they can't get a feeling of solid support from the U.S., will eventually ally themselves with China. And the EU and Russia will battle (hopefully not openly) over the lands between and near them.
It's essentially the end of "pax Americana". I think it's incredibly short-sighted. Trump looks at international relations as a quarterly balance sheet but almost certainly does not properly account for the value of the stability the U.S. provides throughout the world now.
- user837387 10y agoAnd of course once the shit hits the fan everybody will refuse to accept responsibility and somehow it will be the Democrats fault. And again the cycle will begin where the Democrats have to again clean up the Republican's mess. Nobody remembers 2008.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoWhy should American taxpayers fund 'Pax Americana'? What's in it for them?
- cloakandswagger 10y agoThe value of stability to who? Other nations? America has ample military resources for defending its own shores, and I fail to see how we'll be negatively impacted by exiting the Middle East (aside from wailing from the pro-Israel lobbies). Trump knows exactly what he's doing, and it is completely in line with his "America First" slogan. It's about focusing on improving our own citizens' lives before pouring trillions into wars, offshore military bases, NATO defense payments and UN programs in the name of globalization.
- hsitz 10y agoAre you unaware that Trump wants to increase military spending?: http://www.cnn.com/2016/09/06/politics/donald-trump-defense-spending-sequester/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2016/09/06/politics/donald-trump-defense-...
- trendia 10y ago> History shows that when America is not prepared is when the danger is greatest. We want to deter, avoid and prevent conflict through our unquestioned military dominance My suspicion is that he wants less direct military involvement and a greater threat if military involvement is required. That is, he's proposing that we replace the "World Police" model with the Swiss model.
- eru 10y agoThat's a somewhat rational reconstruction of his argument. I am not sure that's the only possible reading. (At least one other one is that he was or is simply not coherent.)
- cloakandswagger 10y agoIt goes hand in glove with his push for nuclear rearmament. Trump wants a strong, military deterrent but wants to stop nation state building and proxy wars. I don't think those two things are mutually exclusive.
- DoofusOfDeath 10y agoI suspect we actually know very little about Trump's intentions. I believe that, like Clinton, he was willing to say just about anything to get into office, regardless of what he truly intends.
- jrockway 10y agoWhat were Clinton's outrageous promises? If anything, I think what killed her is that she is a very unexciting stay-the-course President. No major changes, just incremental improvements. Very likely what is actually happen in any Presidency. What's sad is that the American people punished her for actually being realistic about what a President can actually do. There's not going to be a new border wall and there's not going to be any more jobs for the middle class. Clinton knows that, Trump doesn't.
- nilkn 10y agoI wouldn't be surprised if there will in fact be a new border wall. If there's anything I've learned from this election cycle, it's that many of us have repeatedly and consistently grossly underestimated what's possible in politics. Presidents generally do try to fulfill their campaign promises, and building the wall is the biggest, most concrete, and earliest campaign promise he made. Realistically, it's also one of the most straightforward of all his promises to achieve, and at $25-30B it's not very expensive in the grand scheme of a presidency. Its overall effect will be minimal, meaning that it won't wreak havoc, it won't do much good either (in fact it might ironically backfire by keeping people in instead of out), but it will satisfy his supporters.
- DanBC 10y agoAs job creation schemes go I'd much rather people build stupid walls than build bombs and weapons. I'd be interested to know the CO2 estimates for a 5,000 mile wall.
- CamperBob2 10y ago
- qaq 10y agoIf he plays his hand wisely he actually has a chance to negotiate better terms for US as the opposite party will be pretty sure he is capable of pulling the plug.
- paublyrne 10y agoI'm not convinced he really wants to do the things you list. We will all find out in time, but as I watched him sit with Obama yesterday and also with Paul Ryan, both of whom looked like seasoned politicians who knew what was expected of them, I saw in Trump a man who looked lost and uncertain. I suspect that he liked the idea of being president more than he will enjoy doing the job.
- MichaelApproved 10y agoTrump has been as consistent as Bernie over the decades with regards to foreign policy. Here he is in 1988 on Oprah saying similar things to what he's said on the campaign trail https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEPs17_AkTI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEPs17_AkTI I don't agree with Trump but to think he really doesn't want to do the things he's been saying over the decades seems wrong.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- paublyrne 10y agoInteresting. He also says in that interview he doesn't really have the inclination to be president. That's what I wonder about now, if he really wants this.
- MichaelApproved 10y agoHe said "if it got so bad, I would never want to rule it out totally". He's been saying this for decades. I guess he finally thought it's bad enough for him to step in. I feel like I need to keep adding a disclaimer that I'm not a Trump supporter because my comments make it seem like I agree with him. I'm simply stating his views because I keep seeing people project their own feelings onto him even though he has been clear about many parts of his platform. Sure, he's had to walk back many statements or clarify that he was "being sarcastic" but there are many parts of his platform where he is crystal clear, yet people don't think he'd actually pursue those policies.
- MichaelApproved 10y agoThis is an argument that Trump has been making for decades. He believes US is getting the short end of these deals because he sees the US almost as mob guys providing protection but forgetting to collect protection money. He sees the US as spending money protecting Japan, S. Korea, and Europe without getting proper return. I believe we've been getting peace and favorable trade deals in return. He thinks that isn't enough and that it's time to collect. The same thinking has him arguing that we should get the oil fields after the Iraq war. I don't agree with this reasoning but we're about to see this play out. Edit: here's a video that I linked to in my other comments. It's an Opera interview from 1988 where Trump says Japan is "beating the hell out of this country" and "they aren't paying" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEPs17_AkTI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEPs17_AkTI This has been the most consistent part of Trump's platform. America is getting the short end of the deal. Again, I'm not a Trump supporter but this policy is what Trump genuinely believes and will likely pursue.
- jrockway 10y ago> He thinks that isn't enough and that it's time to collect. Amazon sells their extra servers as a product. The US can start selling their extra nuclear weapons as a product. Business 101!
- danblick 10y agoFirst off let me clarify that I'm no Trump supporter either. :) That said, I've been reading a book called "The Accidental Superpower" that I find very insightful, and the author makes arguments similar to the ones you mentioned. He argues that since WW2 the US has defended free trade around the world (through "the Bretton Woods system") essentially "for free" - even though we shoulder the defense burden for the rest of the world we haven't used this to negotiate treaties that are biased in our favor. The author sees this system ending in the next 20 years (i.e., the US will no longer defend the world's commerce for free) and he spends a large portion of the book discussing how different countries around the world will have to adapt. A couple interesting notes: the author predicts that in a world with less free trade the US would do relatively well thanks to shale oil and our other natural resources (like rivers and rich farmlands). He also talks a lot about demographic changes. He says in the US this will cause some pain from ~2020-2030 as the baby boomers retire, but we'll recover as millennials enter the most productive years of their careers (40s-early 60s). However he also predicts much more dire consequences for Russia due to demographic changes, and suggests they might not recover from a decline starting around 2020. Compare: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Russia_Sex_by_Age_20150101.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Russia_Sex_by_Age_2015010... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USA_by_Sex_and_Age_2015-07-01.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USA_by_Sex_and_Age_2015-0... I can't repeat the entire analysis from the book in this box but I've found the author's comments to be thought-provoking so far. :) Of particular interest to the HN crowd, the author also argues that demographic issues mean that right now there is an unusually large amount of investable capital available, but this will soon change as baby boomers begin to retire and switch from accumulating and investing their money to trying to stretch what they've already earned to last the rest of their lives. He predicts we'll see much less money available for risky investments starting in the next few years, due simply to demographic changes around the world.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoDistinct possibility those countries will dislike us less though. Currently we're like their overprotective (attack) helicopter parents. I am a little bit less worried about the major powers as I am the less predictable ones like North Korea.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cylinder 10y agoFine with me (although I disagree all that will occur under him, but it will be inevitable, all empires decline). It's not my responsibility to pay taxes to police the world (while European and other friends gloat to me about their welfare system). We've got a geographic advantage, we should use it. What's shocking is how has the rest of the world not realized that the US' track record in policing the world has been abysmal and destructive? I would prefer these decisions be distributed across the world rather than resting on the hands of the US population (don't get me started on them).
- eru 10y agoWhat if the US is actually already making a net gain on the security they provide? The Pax Americana had its upsides for the hegemon. (The Brits certainly liked their time at the top.)
- iheartmemcache 10y agoAfter Nelson's victory at Trafalgar, GB had delivered a global message loud and clear "We took out Napolean's France and the Bourbon Spanish fleet, we can take you out too". Global security for trade at the time was provided by the Royal Navy. Financial security for the investor was given as Lloyd's of London ensured a way to hedge against losing your entire shirt, should the ship you bought 20% stake in not return. The a market ripe for the middle-class titleless but incredibly affluent landed gentry (because no one of title would ever be considered a worker, how disgraceful!) to re-invest the profits gained from industrialization into other ventures. The other (arguably more important) component that differentiated Pax Britannica from the Pax Americana was colonies. The US was brought into WWII with an ideological high-mindedness that prevented us from doing what GB/France did in WWI with the Sykes–Picot Agreement and chop up colonies as war proceeds. Those colonies are precisely what kept Britain afloat -- i.e., from Indian spices, Indian silks, and high quality Wootz steel, as well as from rich land - Virginian soil that was ridiculously fertile and prime for tobacco. (All of which had to be routed through GB and taxed, often to return to its origin to be processed, leading to a bunch of pissed-off rich white landed gentry to commit treason.) I digress. Pax Americana would have occurred regardless of our (overinvolvement) in national affairs. Quite simply, there was no one left with an infrastructure intact post WWII to produce the materials for reconstruction. A well-executed Marshall Plan in place ensured an economically secure US post-WWII, the profits of which allowed a "Leave it to Beaver" suburban (somewhat artificial) saudade. Teamsters needed to load that cargo on and off ships, machinists needed to work the lathes to create those widgets being exported to a reconstructing Belgium. This also was during an era when the highest federal tax rate was 91% rather than 35%, because yes, _wars cost money_. If congress declares a state of war, the executive administration has the moral obligation to the country to increase taxes appropriately (not print 30 year notes like they were going out of fashion, leaving the mess for the next administration / generation to clean up). Surely, there are people making a net gain off of the security provided by the armed forces. But it's definitely not John in Minnesota working the Bridgeport. Those jobs are all mechanised. The net gain exists is going to someone working logistics in a nice bespoke suit from Saville Row will flying First Club BA from JFK to Heathrow. The profits will then get routed to some holding company that owns the majority stake in some set of Lichtenstein AG's with an executor being some nameless attorney in the Dutch Antilles who isn't allowed to reveal the name of his client. He'll keep his money there, or maybe move it to UBS if he's accrued enough capital to be invited into the Private Wealth community. Maybe he'll be advised to move that money into a holding corporation based in Hong Kong, buy US 30 year notes and take the small hit on the 11% HK tax and tiny purchasing power loss if the coupons + payout doesn't beat inflation because you'll be claiming the profits at 15% long-term capital gains anyways (and that's if you even want to remit the money back into the US). (I'm not a tax attorney (especially not one with experience in international tax law), CPA, nor a chartered accountant, but I do enjoy reading technicalities (in any system) because semantics of category is like a game of chess to me. An actual professional will obviously not execute the series of strategies I delineated above in that exact form, but it covers the gist of how Romney had an effective tax rate of 13.9%. For more details, PricewaterCooper has a PDF floating around for corporate tax minimization. Julius Baer, a former private bank for high net-worth individuals, was one of the first major Wikileaks. It delineated the methodologies of legal money movement for individuals and their method de jour at the time (though its an arms race against tax institutions, so they constantly evolve like infectious bacteria vs antibiotics (you pick which is which ;) ))).
- blahi 10y agoExcept China wants to keep the status quo. http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-election-china-media-idUSKBN1350P6 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-election-china-media-i...
- danielvf 10y agoI agree with you that it certainly makes larger conflicts more likely. This backing off on world power actually began with Obama, and has been a theme throughout. I'm on mobile right now and can't dig them up, but there a lots of state and military papers on it. Here's the Secretary of Defense speaking in 2011: "But in my opinion, any future defense secretary who advises the president to again send a big American land army into Asia or into the Middle East or Africa should “have his head examined,” as General MacArthur so delicately put it."
- rdtsc 10y ago> does not properly account for the value of the stability the U.S. provides throughout the world now. Countries destroyed by brutal dictators propped up and supported by US might have something to say about the "stability" part there. > I think it's incredibly short-sighted. Or we could try a few more regime changes in Libya, maybe create another ISIS because that was lots of fun. I think "pax Americana" sounds not like you think it sounds to many countries in the world.
- ivm 10y agoDon't forget the war on drugs that continues to claim thousands of lives and destabilize countries in Latin America.
- someboredguy 10y agoI think America will really have to become "Great Again" because by electing Trump they have shown that he is right. The country who openly voted for a racist and a xenophobe is surely not great. The faster democrats and other get out this stupid rust belt explanation phase the better.
- trhway 10y agoOne can see it as a market division between those 3-4 players instead of them competing with each other everywhere.
- chillacy 10y agoI think that's true, but for most of his supporters this probably doesn't matter. Even though America has been doing well on the world stage in influence and soft power, the benefits are perceived to have been bestowed on the wealthy and not shared evenly with those in rural areas torn by economic changes from globalization.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoEveryone who thinks of themselves as a "rival" to the US is right now throwing parties with swimming pools filled with fine, expensive champagne. It's like your main competitor, who was always 10 steps ahead of you, just got as a CEO that guy who's yelling loudly all the time but knows nothing about the industry.
- matwood 10y ago> He wants to cede more of the Middle East to Russia, reduce our participation Maybe it was a different week, but I thought his complaint was that we were weak against Russia and letting them do whatever they want. That's where his whole he's know Putin respects power but we have not been projecting it came from. Again, maybe that was said at a different time. It is why I keep saying we'll have to wait and see what he really does and not just says.
- Arwill 10y agoMy bet is that Trump will do what presidents before him did, much the same way. Presidents do what their consultants tell them, and what political and business interests and deals dictate. If he asks an Asia expert, that expert will say to Trump the same as what he said to Obama. Campaign speech and slogans is one thing. What substantial changes have resulted from Obama's "hope" campaign slogan?
- BlackjackCF 10y agoJust saw on the news that after Trump met up with Obama, he's announced he wants to retain some core parts of Obamacare. The broken promises already started. And they're going to keep going. "Draining the swamp" already isn't happening. A lot of Washington insiders are on his team. I don't know if he's actually going to be able to do any of the things he's promised now that he's in the know.
- snowwrestler 10y agoSome provisions of Obamacare are very popular, even among Republicans. Requiring insurance companies to cover pre-existing conditions was supported by 74% of Americans, including 62% of Republicans, in a Harris Poll survey this past May. Of course, how do you keep insurance companies from going out of business under the weight of that provision? That's where the individual mandate came from--which is the least popular part of the law. So: good luck with making the numbers work, Trump.
- enraged_camel 10y agoYeah, what puts "Affordable" in "Affordable Care Act" is also the most unfavorable part. That's why I believed it was essentially designed to fail (politically) and be repealed, and that's indeed what is about to happen.
- st3v3r 10y agoMeh, let someone else do that. They'll just repeal the ACA wholesale, and get back to the important stuff of Benghazi and email hearings.
- jessaustin 10y agoDon't worry, he'll pardon her for her crimes, eventually.
- noonespecial 10y agoRequiring insurance companies to cover pre-existing conditions... I always believed that once you accept this as a required outcome, you initiate a dependency chain that ends in single-payer government health care. There's just no way around it.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoRightly or wrongly I think a sizeable portion of the world is tired of the flavour of stability the U.S. provides. It feels a bit like the U.S. thinks the rest of the world isn't capable of looking after itself. And perhaps it isn't, and some boarders will be redrawn, but I get the feeling a lot of people are ready to give it a shot. Especially considering the U.S. as de facto self-appointed global police, is doing a terrible job of looking after it's own citizens with regard to education, healthcare, the war on drugs, shooting black men, mass shootings, etc etc etc. Personally, the way I feel about the U.S. as the purported bastion of "The Free World™", the leading light of Democracy is this: It has to stop. No one believes the charade any more. And with the presidential election being a choice between terrible and wacko, the U.S. would be the laughing stock of the world if the situation wasn't so frightening. I'll give one strong example: In October 2013, the incarceration rate of the United States of America was the highest in the world, at 716 per 100,000 of the national population. While the United States represents about 4.4 percent of the world's population, it houses around 22 percent of the world's prisoners.[1] How can you take yourselves seriously? 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_incarceration_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_incarceration_ra... Edit: fixed randomly incorrect reference
- quanticle 10y agoRightly or wrongly I think a sizeable portion of the world is tired of the flavour of stability the U.S. provides. I agree. However, I also think that a lot of the world, especially Europe, has a strange and unrealistic vision of what a multi-polar world would look like. A multi-polar world looks like 18th and 19th century Europe writ large, with nation states jockeying for power, and war being considered as a logical extension of economic and political policy. It isn't nations coming together and negotiating peacefully at the EU or UN or wherever. It feels a bit like the U.S. thinks the rest of the world isn't capable of looking after itself. Arguably because the rest of the world isn't. If you look at the "free world", who actually spends even 1% of their GDP on defense? Heck, half of Germany's air force can't even fly because they've pared their maintenance budgets back too far to buy spare parts for their planes. When France and Italy bombed Libya, they had to rely on the US to provide necessary logistical support, like tankers and reconnaissance, and even the smartbombs themselves. Taiwan explicitly relies on US carriers to guarantee its territorial sovereignty against Chinese aggression. Japan likewise. A world in which the US is in full retreat is not a more liberal, peaceful world. It's a world in which even more autocratic powers, like China and Russia advance. EDIT: By the way, I totally agree that the US is overstretched. But unilateral retreat, leaving our allies in the lurch to face hostile powers on their own is not the correct way of addressing that problem.
- belorn 10y agoJust wanted to throw a word on the trade deals. The major aspect in the current trade deals that got negotiated in secret (like TPP and TTIP) were not tariffs or trade barriers. Tariffs are currently the lowest they ever been between nations and its more or less just a formality to finally have them completely removed. What would have a major effect on the world is the new copyright and patent laws and the investor-state arbitration. The world will less be changed from not having those, and by many views for the better. I don't expect China or Russia to try impose harsher copyright and patent laws, destroying ship loads with generic drugs or implement a world-wide investor-state arbitration.
- peloton 10y agoRecent data suggests trade restrictive measures are at an elevated level. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-10/trump-or-not-the-rich-world-is-already-in-a-quiet-trade-war http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-10/trump-or-n...
- avar 10y ago> It's essentially the end of "pax Americana". > I think it's incredibly short-sighted. Whatever you think of Trump's policies, the US portion of world GDP has been going down since the 1950s. How long do you think it's tenable for the US to maintain its current commitments? When it's down to 20% of world GDP? 10%, 5%? The US is still coasting on foreign policy that was essentially made in 1945 after WWII. There's just no way that policy can be maintained indefinitely. Trump has made comments to the effect that he'd like to lay the foundations of a new type of foreign policy that'll last for decades to come. Whatever you think of his plans I think it's clear that the US can't maintain these foreign entanglements indefinitely, and will need to distribute some of the load to their current allies.
- msabalau 10y agoUS defence spending as share of GDP is in broad terms stable, and lower than the 50s and 60s, so the basis of saying the policy can't be maintained indefinately is unclear. Of course, US spending could have been even lower still if we avoided using false pretences to engage in a pointless war of choice in Iraq, which, of course, had nothing to do with commitments to Europe or Japan.
- avar 10y agoThe basis for citing US share of world GDP is that the US has military commitments against adversaries whose collective share of the world GDP pie is growing, and their militaries along with it.
- siculars 10y agoI actually think the exact opposite. Obama's actions have clearly ended, or diminished at the least, Pax Americana. He's basically withdrawn completely from the Middle East enabling Russia to fill the vacuum. Obama's abandoned our friends in Easter Europe enabling Russia to fill the void. That's just factual.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- random314 10y ago> the value of the stability the U.S. provides throughout the world now. https://chomsky.info/fateful02/ https://chomsky.info/fateful02/ > We have to understand “stability” to mean maintenance of specific forms of domination and control, and easy access to resources and profits. And the phrase “fundamentalist religious zealotry,” as noted, is a code word for a particular form of “radical nationalism” that threatens “stability.”