6 ms·
> This is great (although it's not enough) and more cities should do it. Something similar is common in the US, and is typically framed as a homestead exemptio
by matwood 10y ago
> This is great (although it's not enough) and more cities should do it.
Something similar is common in the US, and is typically framed as a homestead exemption. Basically, set a high property tax rate and if people prove their house is owner occupied give them a rather large discount. My property taxes are ~$1500/year because I live in my house. People who rent out or do not live there pay $6000-$8000/year in my neighborhood.
- rhino369 10y agoHomestead exemptions punish renters, which there isn't a compelling policy reason for.
- nickff 10y agoBritish Columbia punishes renters, as it taxes 'passive income' (i.e. rent), which discourages owners from renting out existing properties or building-to-rent.
- snrplfth 10y agoWhich is one reason why condo ownership is so ubiquitous there.
- nickff 10y agoYes, the tax on 'passive income' discourages apartment buildings.
- will_hughes 10y agoMaybe I misunderstand the taxation that BC is applying, but why should 'passive income' be taxed or treated any different to regular income for taxation purposes. i.e if I earn $100 by working at a job, and $100 through renting out a property, shouldn't I be taxed the same as if I earn $200 through my job instead?
- nickff 10y agoI don't know why the BC government makes this distinction, but it does. The $100 from working at your job is taxed at a lower rate than the $100 from renting out a property, though I should add that there are various schemes to avoid paying the 'passive income' tax.
- sdm 10y agoThis isn't actually the case now is it? Are you confusing corporate income tax with personal income tax? Normally if you're renting a place out you'd be doing it through a hold co. As the rental income would be your main business income it would be tax at the very low Canadian Controlled Small Business rate; not the general rate. Even if you were to take the unwise, for both legal and tax reason, choice to not use a hold co, income from rent is FUNDAMENTALLY different from regular income. In that, if you make a loss, you can claim it. That's just not possible with regular income. I.e., if you rental unit is unprofitable, it reduces your taxes in general -- potentially applied in future years. This is not the with "active" income.
- TallGuyShort 10y agoI'm also concerned about how arbitrary the line is between passive and active income. Let's say I rent out a lot of properties. I have legal obligations to maintain those properties. That might be a lot of work. A full-time job, even. Let's say I make a lot of money on investments. I might be ensuring the success of those investments by advising and doing research on / for the companies I'm investing in. Both of those things get called passive income, but they very well might not be in reality.
- skewart 10y agoMe too. Distinguishing between passive and non-passive income seems in any kind of technical, legal seems incredibly difficult. It reminds me of the old "I know it when I see it" definifinition of pornography, which is a terrible definition for a law. I'm actually really curious about the law now. Stock dividends must be considered passive income. So would interest from your local bank savings account. So would a SaaS app that you set up and basically runs itself with minimal maintenance.
- shawnee_ 10y ago> * British Columbia punishes renters, as it taxes 'passive income' (i.e. rent), which discourages owners from renting out existing properties or building-to-rent.* There are so many incorrect statements in this sentence, I don't even know where to begin. Taxing vacant properties does not punish renters. It "punishes" people who buy properties for speculation, or (as the AirBNB trend is going) attempt to control a piece of limited supply. The purpose of taxing passive income (lazy landlords, rent collecting) more aggressively is because it is not actually work. It is technically wealth extraction. As a renter, 100 percent of your rent is a "tax" (it's not going to offset any of your long-term assets); and when you pay 70-90 percent of your income in rent as a tax (as many minimum wage workers do), it is massively difficult, if not impossible, to save enough to acquire any assets that help you build wealth. On the landlords' side, it's even easier to use all that extracted wealth (from poor people) to acquire assets that build wealth. No, collecting rent is not work or a job. Even if you have a whole fleet of illegal immigrants scrubbing the toilets, throwing down cheap carpet, and painting the walls of your units every few years. The moment you enter the territory of needing to pay somebody else to manage your asset (even if it is "just" scrubbing the toilets after your AirBNB tenants or renters leave), you're entering passive income territory.
- RHSeeger 10y ago> No, collecting rent is not work or a job. I rent, by choice. My landlord takes the risk of owning the property, and I pay a premium for that. Something breaks, I make a call and it's his responsibility. Just because some landlords are bad people doesn't mean landlords are bad people in general. I appreciate the benefits I get from renting (and, to be fair, from having a good landlord). By your logic, owning a small company with some employees is passive income and "bad", because you have people doing work for you. Some small company owners are bad people but that doesn't mean all of them are (and, in fact, we tend to consider them fondly from what I've seen).
- shawnee_ 10y agoMy landlord takes the risk of owning the property, and I pay a premium for that. You pay a premium so your landlord can take risk to get the most lucrative profits? Why, you are a benevolent renter, aren't you? By your logic, owning a small company with some employees is passive income and "bad", That is not at all what I said; your reading comprehension needs work. Owning a company with employees[1] means you are responsible for allocating the income into business profits among your employees. Most people who scrub toilets and wash sheets for AirBNB rentals are NOT employees or the owners of the properties. Along the same lines: the right way to treat employees involves giving them part ownership of the company they are working for, and thus they are rightfully entitled to some of the income from business-generating assets. Landlords do not do this. They farm out the work required to manage or maintain the assets, and demand the lion's share of the profit. [1] There is a definite legal definition of "employee", and you don't seem to understand what that is. See the IRS's definition. https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/independent-contractor-self-employed-or-employee https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...
- hhw 10y agoThere's no such tax on 'passive income', it's just taxed as business income, which is exactly what it is and taxed no higher than employment income. It's just not taxed as capital gains nor has dividend tax credits, which it shouldn't be/have. The only tax that discourages renting out is that the portion of your principal residence used for renting out no longer qualifies for tax-free capital gains. Considering how almost nobody in BC ever declares this, and barely anything is done to curb it, it's kind of a moot point.
- Spooky23 10y agoRenters are a net drain on any city. It's always a smart move to incentivize ownership. Making rentals more expensive pulls in more Federal money in low income property and encourages purchases by middle class families.
- mstodd 10y agoThere's no good reason for any of this other than simply being able to take more money from people. It's wrong for the government to pick who wins and who loses, and never works how it's sold.
- matwood 10y agoNo, it takes money from the owners of the property. Rents are market based more than anything else. I don't care if the tax is 0 or 100k, the owner can only rent for what he can find people to pay. In my area (a vacation spot and college town), they could drop the property taxes to $0 tomorrow and rents will still go up. A high tax does not even really set a price floor since the owner would rather get something than nothing.
- gozur88 10y ago>No, it takes money from the owners of the property. Rents are market based more than anything else. I don't care if the tax is 0 or 100k, the owner can only rent for what he can find people to pay. The subtlety you're missing here is the reduction in supply of rental units.
- meganvito 10y agoI guess you are not in California.
- matwood 10y agoHeck no! I don't make enough money to live there in a way I would enjoy.
- cloudjacker 10y agoIf you like camping you'll enjoy San Francisco
- mmanfrin 10y agoNot since the 8th, though.
- meganvito 10y agoIs it because the Berkeley dudes ain't that hippy any more?
- mmanfrin 10y agohttp://voterguide.sfelections.org/en/prohibiting-tents-public-sidewalks http://voterguide.sfelections.org/en/prohibiting-tents-publi...
- cloudjacker 10y agoOh cool, how can I find the sf results? Not interested enough to google it thanks for the public service!
- diego 10y agoInterestingly California has a homestead exemption but it's a joke (capped at $70).
- tikhonj 10y agoThe part about higher taxes for people renting property out seems to amount to yet another subsidy for home ownership over renting—which is not obviously a good thing. A tax just on properties that are unused (ie not owner-occupied or rented) makes more sense to me.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoHow about "rented by a local landlord with a small number of properties" to get a similar discount? This would also seem to attack the problems of limited property supply allowing the bourgeoisie to profit without work and of a lot of local money moving away because of property ownership by distant entities. Reasonable?
- kbenson 10y agoOr allow deductions from this tax for landlords paying for maintenance or improvements, and an exemption if you can show that all maintenance requests were acted on within 30 days and resolved within 90 days (for those that keep their rentals in good shape). I think that might aim it more squarely at slumlords.
- toomanybeersies 10y agoIs there no requirement for timely repairs in the USA (or at least in some states)? Here in New Zealand, I can hand my landlord a 14 day notice to remedy, and if they don't fix the problem within 14 days (or at least start remedying, if it's a larger problem), then I can take them to the Tenancy Tribunal, where they can be ordered to, and sometimes even get fined punitive damages. The same works the other way. If I leave the house in an unsatisfactory condition (e.g. not cleaning the property, not keeping the garden under control), then I can be given notice to remedy and taken to the tribunal if I don't fix it. It's a win-win system, both parties can take action against the other for problems. The tribunal is not meant to be biased towards the landlord or the tenant (although in practice they tend to side with the tenant a bit more), and is a neutral third party. They usually try mediation first, before actually ordering people to do anything.
- tuna-piano 10y agoThere are two types of residents - owners and renters. The renter is just renting from a property owner, who will just pass on the tax. In this example, assume the mortgage payment is $1k / month. 1. If you own the home, you will pay $13,500 ($12k mortgage + $1500 taxes) per year. 2. If you own the home, and want to rent it to a tenant, you must charge the tenant at least $18,000 ($12k mortgage + $6k taxes) to break even. Renters are in generally less wealthy than owners. Why have this extremely regressive tax? Why should the poor renter subsidize the rich homeowner?
- roel_v 10y ago"Why should the poor renter subsidize the rich homeowner?" He's not subsidizing, is he? The tax just goes to the government. Essentially it's an extra tax on renting.
- ianferrel 10y agoIf the renter pays a higher tax rate than the owner, and they both have the same right to government services, that could be seen as a subsidy.
- woofyman 10y agoLandlords get their own subsidies. All maintenance and improvements are tax deductions. Plus they get to depreciate the property.
- WalterBright 10y agoSuppose a business buys goods at $80 and sells them for $100. You're suggesting that his profit is $100 and he should be taxed on $100 income?
- majormajor 10y agoThat's how sales tax generally works, no? (Which suggests that the cost gets passed along and so it is a hit to the renter.)
- hyperbovine 10y agoThere is also a capital gains penalty (15% of net gain) when you sell an investment property.
- kspaans 10y agoYou pay capital gains tax on all capital assets you sell, with the notable exception of your primary residence. There is no reason to call it a "penalty".
- hyperbovine 10y agoYou can exclude the tax under certain ownership conditions even if it is not your primary residence. Tomāto tomăto.
- Trombone12 10y agoHow is it similar? The tax Vancouver is introducing applies if the house is empty, and the tax you describe is concerned with differentially taxing non-empty houses.
- gozur88 10y agoIsn't the net effect of something like that to drive up the price of rent?