5 ms·
The reason people don't feel they are getting the benefits of globalization is because the benefits are not as direct as the costs. When prices for goods are lo
by cortesoft 10y ago
The reason people don't feel they are getting the benefits of globalization is because the benefits are not as direct as the costs. When prices for goods are lower, it is not obvious to the average person that this is because of globalization. When your factory job is shipped overseas, the cost is readily apparent. No one makes the connection between the lower costs for things and globalization.
- psyc 10y agoCosts of what? Consumer electronics and appliances? The staples of life that matter most - food and housing - have not decreased in cost.
- AngrySkillzz 10y agoNot true on food.[1] CPI for food has fallen off a cliff in the last year+ compared to core CPI (ex food and energy). It is even negative currently, so yes food prices are decreasing. It seems to have been moderately lower on net since the end of the great recession. [1] http://imgur.com/a/p0ELF http://imgur.com/a/p0ELF
- api 10y agoYou're right about food, which yo-yos like other commodities and is somewhat tied to energy. Housing, health care, and college tuition are the great Satans of the economy for the middle and working classes. These have inflated without bound regardless of what wages or employment are doing.
- bernawil 10y ago>. No one makes the connection between the lower costs for things and globalization. I think they do. I'm pretty sure most people know all the implications MADE IN CHINA carry. They see they are getting 1 unit of benefit for 2 units of hindrance.
- lordnacho 10y agoI think the point is people say "oh how nice my stereo is only $300" and then "OMG I'm losing my $40K job". Losing a job is a biiiig lump. Paying a bit less on various items is a bunch of hard to measure little wins.
- sooheon 10y agoSure people do make the connection. But no amount of lower costs across the board will help a newly unemployed person. For that person, the costs and benefits just don't match up. Structural unemployment is an inevitable result of globalization, we need ways to mitigate this. Trade from the POV of rich countries is often a redistribution from the poor (uncompetitive labor) to the wealthy (multinational corporations), justified by the "gains from trade". We must be willing to aggressively redistribute these resulting gains back to the disenfranchised or see populist backlash.
- ansible 10y agoI'm generally for free trade, but there has to be a more equitable arrangement than what we've got now. If the USA is enforcing environmental regulations for their factories, this will obviously cost more than just dumping used chemicals outside in a pit. So the cost of goods in another country will be less if it doesn't have good (or any) environmental regulations. This is separate from labor prices. So it is not fair to the USA, and it isn't fair to the people living in countries without good environmental regulations.
- stefs 10y agoignoring environmental protection costs for monetary success is mostly short-term planning and will - i'm a software developer, so i'll take this as a comparison - have the same consequences as short term planning and accumulating technical debt in software development. see it as an indirect investment in infrastructure that ultimately benefits everyone (but also you). you can't run a factory without government funded roads and railways, aka funded by your tax payer money. it's the same for environmental expenses: skimp now, and you might not have a market to sell to in a decade. so, if you outsource to another country it wont help in the long term because climate is global. that much is clear. the rest is sufficiently explained by dawkins stable dove-hawk systems. you might want to try to gamble the system for personal gain, but if everyone does it, it'll collapse and everyone dies. so you shouldn't and protest transgression by others, otherwise the system might collapse. i'm convinced you can play fair and still make a profit.
- 10y ago
- antisthenes 10y agoThere are also swathes of evidence that most of the costs associated with running a typical household have gone up. So while the goods that are mostly part of discretionary spending (think clothes and electronics) are cheaper, the essentials that can't be outsourced have also increased in price (education, healthcare, housing)