5 ms·
Why 2016 is such a terrible year for the Mac
- tomkadwill 10y agoI think a lot of devs use a mac because they get a UNIX machine without the hassle of installing linux. Now, it feels like the barrier to entry for installing linux is falling and at the same time the mac has stopped evolving. Also, the price seems to have jumped significantly (I live in the UK so part of that is exchange rate)
- zanny 10y agoThat and several System76 notebooks and the Dell XPS one are fairly high quality. They might not meet the Macbook standard, but a lot of that is just bragging rights at the end of the day anyway. You really don't even need to install Ubuntu anymore. Other distros, yeah, but you also know your hardware is fully supported at least.
- jm547ster 10y agoI'm hearing mixed reports on System76, issue with hw compatibility with the pre-installed OSes and the hardware itself just being a rebrand of other machines
- base698 10y agoI saw a bunch of horror stories on Reddit. I'm definitely off the Mac train currently, so I hope I find an alternative.
- dangoor 10y agoIt's not that installing Linux is a hassle. I just love a lot of the apps I can run on my Mac. OmniFocus, 1Password and DevonThink are two I have running now. I've also got OmniGraffle, Affinity Photo/Designer, Pixelmator and Keynote at least that I use fairly regularly (and I'm sure I'm forgetting some). I do a fair bit that is cross-platform and would work fine on Linux, but there are a lot of Mac-specific apps that are really well designed and a joy to use and I would miss them. (And, yes, there are open source replacements for all of these that run on Linux. I know, but the UX is not the same!)
- pier25 10y agoDesign tools on Linux are still not good enough. It would be awesome if Affinity released their software for Linux since Adobe is not going to.
- dijit 10y ago1password was a weird one for me, I operate on BSD/Linux and very seldomly my Mac (I use an iPhone though) and I wanted to stick with 1password because it allowed me to access my passwords from my phone. Luckily they use an open specification for the database they use which has a python module[0] and I've started building my own interfaces[1] to interact with the keychain in much cooler ways. It's no 1password.app though. :( [0] https://pypi.python.org/pypi/blimey/0.9.4 https://pypi.python.org/pypi/blimey/0.9.4 [1] https://git.drk.sc/dijit/password-utils https://git.drk.sc/dijit/password-utils
- rdavis 10y agoThe lack of a native 1Password client is one of the last major pain points I live with day to day in Linux. Those Python utilities actually look really useful but as far as I can tell, they only interface with the older .agilekeychain version of the 1Password vault. I've been looking for something similar that understands the newer .opvault format but am yet to find anything that just works.
- wlesieutre 10y agoThe Windows 1Password client actually works fine under Wine, including its browser integration. But the Windows version is't nearly as nice as the Mac one, and you get the usual Wine sorts of issues. Biggest one is that the password prompt will pop up and have a blinking text cursor even though it's not actually the active window, just the active window within the Windows layer. Whoops, hope you didn't type your master password anywhere leaky.
- lj3 10y ago> It's not that installing Linux is a hassle. I just love a lot of the apps I can run on my Mac. I think that's a huge X factor a lot of the latest discussions are missing. People LOVE MacOS apps. They're beautiful. They work well. They're typically fast. They're user friendly. Windows and Linux apps are none of those things. In my experience, Mac users don't mind paying for Mac apps because they tend to be of high quality. Windows and Linux users won't pay for apps unless they absolutely have to because the quality of the available apps varies so much.
- madaxe_again 10y agoI'm in the same ship - I have a nice several year old MBP but unless apple come up with something compelling my next machine will be something else running Linux. That all said, I think apple are up to more than is immediately apparent. They're spending huge amounts on r&d. From the frankly incremental improvements seen on their existing hardware line over the last several years the majority is going somewhere unseen. We saw patents for hmd/ar related tech a few years back. I wouldn't be surprised if they do something nobody currently expects and move aggressively into the hmd/ar space.
- shams93 10y agoFrom the pro audio side of things Bitwig is a game changer, I can actually run bitwig and renoise on my asus chromebox running crouton on an sd card and it all runs shockingly well considering I spent less than $200 for this device.
- HalfwayToDice 10y agoI live in the UK so part of that is exchange rate UK Macbook Pros are the cheapest in Europe dollarwise, so that can't be true.
- kgwgk 10y agoBeing the cheapest dollarwise doesn't conflict with prices having jumped recently (in local currency) due to the movement in exchange rates (price changes tend to be abrupt with Apple products because they rarely change the price of a product until the next generation is released).
- dguaraglia 10y agoIt's a huge difference. As someone who's lived in the UK before: paying ~£1500 for a computer is a lot. A good software engineer salary in London is ~£60k a year, with only really good salaries going significantly beyond that (I've heard of quants and super senior people making ~£100k, but that's the exception not the norm.) That means that, if you live in the Bay Area and make a reasonable $120k, you are basically paying double for your Mac in London. I recall at some point, some software prices (like the full Adobe suite) were so inflated in the UK that it was cheaper to fly to New York, spend a couple days there, and buy the licenses there, than it did to buy them in the UK. We (as in, us living in the Bay Area and the US in general) live in a bubble where the iPhone is barely more expensive than other phones and Macs, while expensive, are still comfortably within our reach because our salaries are way above average.
- soneil 10y agoThis isn't really a mac problem though. Brexit sank the pound. Others will start correcting their prices too (if they haven't already)
- dguaraglia 10y agoActually, Apple products were always almost a 1:1 USD to GBP translation, which doesn't really make sense. If anything, I'm surprised that Apple hasn't increased their prices to match the depreciation of the sterling.
- RoboErectus 10y agoTwice I've tried going a year exclusively on Linux. Both times (2009 and 2015) I spent enough time fiddling with things to give up. Cygwin is pretty good. With sshd and putty you've got a decent setup. But there are still little things that osx does better. Virtual desktop support finally showed up in Windows about a decade late. But keyboard shortcuts are still a crapshoot. Text selection and cursor navigation being uniform across everything is nice once it all becomes automatic. Osx has its own list of problems... But most of them are solvable in a well supported way. Running Linux desktop full time.. logging in every day is a roll of the dice. The Year of the Linux Desktop(tm) just isn't here yet.
- edblarney 10y agoSuper interesting is that Mac has become an important development computer in the last 10 years - this was not the case before. But I think the dev community is pretty small in terms of users. That said - wouldn't photoshop/creative types want more than 16G as well?
- shurcooL 10y agoIf they made 32 gb max, you'd want to get it because it's soldered to mobo. That means even higher price. Damned if they do, damned if they don't.
- toyg 10y agoBut at that point you have a best-in-class laptop that can command the higher price. The problem is that the current configuration is expensive and is not really better than the competition in anything but trackpad.
- tomwilson 10y agoAnd screen (p3 colour and macOS still handles hidpi better than anything else), and SSD throughput (3.1gbps), and probably a million other tiny things that you forget about cos they aren't as obvious as a number that says 16 vs 32.
- emp_zealoth 10y agoFor 3200$ in a macbook I get a quad core i7, 16GB of ram, crappy AMD GPU, 256GB at 3.1 GB/s, very good screen and battery, no ports and dongle hell, thermal throttling For 1500$ I get quad core i7, 32GB of high performance ram, nvidia 960M, 256GB at 3.1 GB/s SSD AND a 1TB HDD, SD card reader, ethernet, USBs and HDMI port, fullsize keyboard, worse screen and worse battery life, proper airflow, anodized black alubody Thats a model from last year btw.
- fatbird 10y agoOne of our designers at work got an iMac with 32G, and immediately maxed it out, bragging "I'll never have enough RAM!" So, yeah. I think one of the good points made last week is that at this point, you're into workflow management when you hit limits like RAM because, yes, you could run two more VMs on your laptop if you had 32GB instead of 16GB, but you're already running 4, and then you'd run 6 and complain you couldn't run 10. Your base laptop will always have some limit that you'll need to deal with. The question remaining unanswered for me is how much developers, like creative professionals before them, are influencers that drive secondary sales. I remember people crying doom for Apple when they gave up being the primary education computer with sweet deals for schools and students, because KEY DEMOGRAPHIC KEY INFLUENCE POINT KEY... and yet it didn't appear to hurt them at all. I actually question the whole "influencer" theory of marketing because of it.
- hashtagMERKY 10y agoSomeone who knows more about this than me: given the significant negative reaction to the new MacBooks and the state of the mac lineup in general, is Apple likely to release a more suitable lineup in 2017 in response, or will they largely ignore the reaction?
- conception 10y agoI would be surprised if they didn't bump the procs to the new Intels next year, maybe add a 32Gb option. The look/features won't change for another three to five years.
- baddox 10y agoThe 32GB option should come "for free" with the next Intel CPU generation (it's already out, but perhaps too late to make it in these Macs). I doubt Apple gets off on withholding that, it's just a limitation of the Intel chips they're using (correct me if my misunderstanding is wrong).
- kozhevnikov 10y agoOnly the mobile ones are out for ultraportables, desktop Kaby Lake that would go into a MackBook Pro expected in January 2017 plus another month for manufacturers to catch up.
- renaudg 10y agoPretty sure that only the iMac has desktop-class Intel CPUs, the Macbook Pro has, well, mobile CPUs.
- kozhevnikov 10y ago13' ones use U (ultra-low power) processors, while 15' use QH (quad-core with high performance graphics). Same with Dell updating XPS 13 with Kaby Lake last month, but XPS 15 would have to wait till next year. http://www.everymac.com/systems/by_processor/intel-core-i7-macs.html http://www.everymac.com/systems/by_processor/intel-core-i7-m... https://superuser.com/questions/940168/meaning-of-intel-processor-suffixes https://superuser.com/questions/940168/meaning-of-intel-proc...
- adolfoabegg 10y ago"For those on the margins, the question will be if staying on Apple products is worth the pain, or if it isn’t." For me it isn't. I started looking at Clevo laptops already.
- drakenot 10y agoThey have terrible battery life. My first laptop I purchased in college was a top of the line Alienware. Never again will I do that. If you value portability and battery life at all I would reconsider. If you want power and discrete graphics get a desktop.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dom0 10y agoWhat's your point? "If you want power and discrete graphics get a desktop." is true about any notebook. Every notebook - except maybe those built from actual desktop hardware (which is mainly a configuration difference anyway) - will be far less powerful and more noisy than a desktop at the same price point. Depending on the brand you'll always pay a 2-6 times premium for laptop hardware. Re. battery life; it obviously depends a lot on the model. Some are quite okay, the gaming ones aren't.
- drakenot 10y agoMy point is that I've personally experienced the pain of purchasing a "high-performance laptop." It was incredibly heavy to where you unconsciously start deciding to leave it home because of the discomfort of lugging it around. The battery life was so poor you have constant anxiety about when it will run out or if you will make it through your two classes. The performance also ultimately wasn't that great and had terrible thermals. I was left with a laptop that never left my desk. I would have been better off purchasing a cheap chromebook and a mid-range desktop for the same money. The "performance laptop" is compromise incarnate.
- thro32 10y agoIs it really a terrible year? Financially they do great. It sucks for mac users, not for the company. And I am very happy, desktop Linux will see more users.
- fiatpandas 10y agoApple's rumored transition to in-house ARM-based CPUs for their Macbooks couldn't come faster. For such a critical component, relying on a single third party to continue innovating on a timeline which aligns with where you want your products to be is not ideal.
- jeffjose 10y agoThat'll mean a whole new set of softwares. The current software (think photoshop) won't work on ARM processor
- fzzzy 10y agoApple's done two architecture changes already. Both 68k backwards compatibility on PowerPC and Rosetta PPC backwards compatibility on Intel worked well.
- w4 10y ago> Rosetta PPC backwards compatibility on Intel worked well Rosetta worked, but I don't know if I'd say it worked well. It was brutally slow to the point of being unusable with some apps on mid/low end Macs.
- DonHopkins 10y agoDon't forget the architecture change from the 6502 to the 68000!
- petecox 10y agoThey never provided CPU emulation for that. Their solution for Mac LC was effectively an Apple IIe shrunk down to a PDS expansion card.
- DonHopkins 10y agoThere were some good third party Apple ][ emulators for the Mac!
- tbarbugli 10y agoI wonder what's the energy cost introduced by having 16 extra GB of RAM. Is that a space issue (more RAM = less space for batteries) or a power consumption?
- dom0 10y agoabout ~1-1.5 watts under full load.
- josephg 10y agoHow about while idle? It seems like you'd still need a fair bit of power to refresh them, but I'd be interested to see the actual numbers. For comparison the 13" MacBook Pro has a 50wh battery, so apple's 10 hour battery claim depends on the machine averaging 5 watts of power consumption during normal use. Adding 1 watt of consumption would reduce the battery life by 2 hours.
- dom0 10y agoSomething on the order of ~50-100 mW.
- pier25 10y agoEven if that was the case, why not let users decide for themselves if they wanted 32GB and 8 hours of battery? 8 hours of battery is still pretty awesome. I think the narrative that Apple presented about not giving the 32GB option because of battery time doesn't make much sense if you consider all the design decisions around these new machines. It makes more sense that Apple thought only a minority of users wanted 32GB and then it backfired.
- kiddico 10y agoIf I remember correctly it's not the ram that they're going for, but the processor the ram attaches to. The skylake low power mobile cpus all use the low power ram(as one would expect), and for some reason is limited to 16gb on mobile. So if apple wanted the low power cpu, they had to limit everyone to 16GB.
- shermablanca 10y agoI'll be building a Hackintosh with 64 gb or ram and the latest processors and ssd. There is a strong community for that now and it's apparently more robust than it used to be. Here's a good article by one developer on his experience: https://medium.com/swlh/building-my-1-200-hackintosh-49a1a186241e#.r0t16ep1z https://medium.com/swlh/building-my-1-200-hackintosh-49a1a18...
- whywhywhywhy 10y ago> My audio doesn’t work From the article. Not sure why people still pass this around as if it's positive.
- sctblol 10y agoIt probably can be patched with this: https://github.com/toleda/audio_CloverALC https://github.com/toleda/audio_CloverALC You can also use a USB headset as I do.
- yardie 10y agoIt's unavoidable. Most PC motherboards everything is swappable to the Mac equivalent. You can change the wifi daughter card for a compatible model. You can change the video card for a compatible model. You can't change the built in audio chip that's on the motherboard. But you can alleviate it with a superior USB DAC
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- izacus 10y ago> Not sure why people still pass this around as if it's positive. Well, there IS a site out there that lists 100% compatible hardware which includes (yes!) working Audio and other hardware.
- jacquesc 10y agoTo be clear, his audio jack doesn't work. He gets audio via USB. So no less broken than an iPhone 7.
- rch 10y agoOne thing the article seems to miss is that the Mac Pro wasn't well received when it was released either, so lack of updates isn't an issue. Everything I used to do with those machines is now happily running elsewhere, so an update would be irrelevant. The same thing could happen with the MBP if enough people are as frustrated as I am.
- jacobolus 10y agoThe Mac Pro was well enough received by some, at the time. It really excels if you need beefy AMD GPUs (from a few years ago) and want something compact and quiet and good looking on your desk. The problem is that while it has pretty good performance in general, there are crucial bottlenecks for a number of different potential customers which make some other product a better fit. For folks like software developers or anyone else who is bottlenecked by single-threaded CPU performance, the Mac Pro is no faster than a machine like an iMac, and not necessarily even much faster than a current laptop. For folks like photo/graphics/video pros who care about the best large high-resolution display, previous-gen Thunderbolt connectors/protocols and external display hardware weren’t quite ready until the past year. Apple could hack around the problems with the iMac because everything was internal, but the problems hadn’t quite been solved for a desktop tower. For folks needing beefy GPU performance, the market is segregated between those needing workstation class GPUs and ECC memory, etc., many of whom are running CUDA software that will only run on nvidia chips (oops), and those who want to play video games or similar, and would rather cut costs with consumer-grade hardware. For folks worried about future-proofing a big purchase, there was a lot of uncertainty about ongoing product support and upgradeability. And of course for anyone trying to cut costs, there are a variety of cheaper Windows PC towers optimized to particular use cases. Etc. Ultimately, for many customers (say, university computer labs, software developers, photographers, graphic designers, even pro audio and video people), an iMac makes a better desktop machine than the current form of the Mac Pro, whereas for the folks who need absolute max performance, it makes more sense to run their work on some server cluster or something. Pro creative software that used to run primarily on desktop workstations doesn’t necessarily need them anymore in the same way. Video game players who make up much of the PC tower market are happy to stick with Windows. It’s not that easy to find a cohesive market of folks who really need a super-expandable mid-to-high-end Mac desktop tower, and sell a specific bundle of features to them. If they release a new Mac Pro within the next year or so, with the same concept/chassis as the first one but upgraded internals, it might become a reasonable fit for some of those customers, or they might have been chased away by now, it’s hard to say. This bit from the OP also rings true: > In this case, Apple’s timing appears to have been bad. There’s no way to know for sure, but it seems like Apple decided to dance to its own rhythm, skip an Intel chip generation, and then wait for the good stuff, only to get bitten by slippage in Intel’s schedule. If that’s what happened, it’s hard to blame it on Intel. After all, it was Apple’s gamble. I think if there had been a couple of additional Mac Pro hardware updates since the original release people would be substantially less pessimistic about it now.
- jaequery 10y agoI attached an external ssd on my old 2011 Mac mini and it performs just as faster than my 2015 MacBook Pro. This makes me realize that OS X still runs very fast even on older models and makes me wonder if this is the reason why apple isn't really keen on providing macs with faster cpus or even more ram. So to those of you who asks for more ram or CPU, unless you run very memory / CPU intensive apps, it's most likely you don't require them.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- CSDude 10y agoI ageee, also CPUs do not really get much faster over years and I/O is more likely to matter to most applications. Only reason to upgrade just for processor would be for longer battery times, but it is already long enough for 2015mbp.
- jcoffland 10y ago> CPUs do not really get much faster over years This is a relatively new development. 15 years ago CPU speeds were increasing like mad.
- sqeaky 10y agoI must disagree. I know exactly how much RAM and CPU time my tasks take. On my Ubuntu machine a build can easily take 20gb of RAM and saturate the CPU for half an hour. If I want to test my software on windows, that means a VM taking another chunk of RAM. I have seen my system consume almost all of 64gb. I have seen the difference between each generation of i7 and my build times keep going down. For about 5 million LOCs of C/C++ the first takes about half an hour and the 6 gen takes about 3 minutes. For systems developers this makes the Mac Book Pro a poor choice. But other laptops are almost as good as Desktops until we start needing things like CUDA (or more than 8 cores).
- marze 10y agoI'm confused by the negative reaction. To me, these new laptops seem like the ultimate pro dream machines. I can understand the frustration with with lack of other Mac updates somewhat, but really, Intel has not been giving much reason to update the cpu for a while now, so it is somewhat justified. Ram speed, and ssd speed, are more important by far now. What puzzles me more is the lack of Mac mini action. Isn't this an excellent route for Apple to introduce new customers to the Mac? Why don't they make it compelling, and a tiny bit a loss leader? I know Mac revenue is a minor fraction of apple's revenue now, but on the same token, a reduction in asp for macs would be minor overall as well. My guess: they don't want the cost and hassle of providing apple-grade support to new Mac users.
- xenobioticants 10y agoPeople are angry that they pretty much took the 2015 Macbook Pro 13" base model and popped $300 on the price, and in the process gimped it compared to its more expensive versions.
- walshemj 10y agonot sure I describe the new MacBook or any laptop really as a "pro" machine - Pro to my mind means the sort of use case where you using a workstation class machine with a Hot i7 or Dual Zenon and possibly some of the high end video cards for CUDA etc.
- HalfwayToDice 10y agoPro also means having an ESC key I think.
- dguaraglia 10y agoWhere I come from, it does!
- muninn_ 10y agoI've noticed a lot of people complaining about USB-c and having to buy adapters or whatever. USB-c is a transitory period as we move to a state of being where "crap does anybody have HDMI to DVI" or whatever is non-existent. We're moving away from physical cables and having to buy different connectors or adapters between products. It's a pain right now, because manufacturers haven't caught up (and might have an interest in never "catching up"), but the move Apple is making in standardizing ports and removing things like the headphone jack (while giving you an extension cord for backwards compatibility) are all moves in the right direction.
- izacus 10y agoI don't get this argument. Having 3 USB-C ports and a USB-A port would be the same kind of future proof, just without pissing off the users and making Pro use laptops really really annoying to use in daily life. Why are you selling the option of having ONLY USB-C or ONLY USB-A as a binary thing?
- muninn_ 10y agoNo need for the USB-A. Just switch to C. You won't need to orient your power cord, and you'll have more throughput If you maintain the USB-A, users will keep using it instead of switching to the superior alternative and driving progress. I want a world of one universal connector and/or no wires/cords. USB-C is the start of this future.
- kbutler 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_syndrome I'd find the "Apple is doing this for our own good with a single unified connector standard" position more credible if the new iPhone used USB-C.
- guitarbill 10y ago> No need for the USB-A. Just switch to C. You won't need to orient your power cord, and you'll have more throughput Sadly, almost everything is still USB-A. USB sticks, 2FA tokens, mechanical keyboards, mice, and - oh yeah - iPhone charging cables. Would I like to move to USB-C? Sure. But as a professional, there's going to be some situations where I need that backwards compatibility, if not for me then for some client. There's going to be a really long transition period, because all that USB-A stuff is still 100% functional. And if you argue that adapters are the solution, then clearly we still need at least 1 port, so why not leave it? Design is supposed to improve usability. Technology is always a compromise, but for many people, thickness wasn't an issue in the first place. (BTW, magsafe power cords don't need orientating. Kind of a solved problem) > If you maintain the USB-A, users will keep using it instead of switching to the superior alternative and driving progress. This argument is backwards. If it's superior, then people will switch. For many use cases, USB-C offers no practical benefit - in other words, it's a solution to a problem that doesn't exist. Is one USB-A port too much to ask for, for the sake of backwards compatibility and potential emergency use? On the other hand, ironically people (including me) would pay $$$ for a USB-C iPhone. That application of USB-C is clearly superior!
- jrobn 10y agoMy guess would be new intel cpus will be a paid upgrade for another $500 sometime next year. Apple will then abandon macs because they aren't moving ridiculously priced hardware. More likely is that apple is phasing out its pro line in favor of premium consumer macs. Xserve is dead. Mac Pro is on its death bed. MacBook Pro is next. Not to mention they have been slowly killing off their pro software as well. I was actually surprised final cut got an update.
- gutnor 10y agoOne remaining pro software they need to kill before that is possible: XCode ! A cloud version, optimised for iPad Pro unveiled at an event with a bigger iPad Pro and a few big companies all around singing praise and showing off uber cool plugins, and the Mac is gone
- ebbv 10y agoI think Apple has definitely over-optimized the MacBook Pro for thinness and lightness. Those are both nice qualities for a Pro product but they should not be weighted so heavily that they give up important features like MagSafe and limit hardware specs in impactful ways (like the 16GB of RAM limitation.) I've seen commentators (Gruber) make the false claim that Apple COULDN'T deliver a MacBook Pro with good battery life and more than 16GB of RAM because Intel doesn't make it possible. That's horse apples. It would just have to be a thicker product with more battery capacity. I love Apple and I love my rMBP and my iMac. But I'm actually hoping that this new MacBook Pro fails miserably so that Apple pulls back and refocuses on making true pro products. As a professional who has used Macs exclusively for my livelihood I have absolutely no reason to upgrade from my 4 year old rMBP to a new one. It brings nothing to the table that helps me do my job.
- npunt 10y agoThin & light had nothing to do with Magsafe. That's all USB-C, which in its spec offers power delivery. Either they'd have two types of power delivery (USB-C and Magsafe), or one. Not hard to see why they went with one. Both MBPs lost half a pound (16% on 13", 11% on 15"). That's not enough thermal room to both fit a faster intel processor and requisite battery increase, and same for AMD graphics on the 15". Granted, that IS enough to go from 16GB to 32GB max RAM, but Apple probably felt faster disk IO (3.1GB/s) would compensate for all but the most demanding workloads. Since a tiny % of users need 32GB, and LPDDR4 is probably going to deliver that when Intel gets around to adding it, they chose to slightly slim down the next chassis as they always have, and in a year or two it'll work itself out. Totally reasonable way to optimize a multi-year product launch. Honestly I think people are blowing out of proportion what's possible here. Intel is slow to add important features (like LPDDR4), and USB-C is a temporarily annoying transition. Given the typical constraints Apple has always tried to follow (battery life, thermals, build quality, margins), this release says tons more about what Intel can ship than what Apple can.
- chrischen 10y agoI would like to provide a counterpoint. I think in a laptop thinness and lightness is one of the most important factors to me as a pro user, otherwise I'd get an iMac. People who buy a macbook are not trying to get a desktop replacement. The whole point of a laptop is portability. Their breaking online preorder sales records indicate that they've made the right choice.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoMy almost six year old MBA 13 is in bad shape with the keyboard worn out and on its 3rd battery. Lots of heavy use. It was a good value. For two weeks I have been looking at Asus Zen Books, Surface 4 Pro, Dell xps 13 Linux edition, etc. Yesterday I bought a MacBook, even though it was not really what I was looking for. It does not seem very solid so I set a calendar alert for 11 months to buy Apple Care for it. This will be the first time I have ever bought Apple Care. So, the total cost will be about $1500 to get a laptop that should be good for at least three years. Performance wise, it is better than I expected. It is very quick using IntelliJ, and reasonable using Haskell + Emacs + Intero. I am getting an adapter Monday for my large monitor. Except for the high cost, I think I will be happy enough with my new MacBook.
- berntb 10y agoHow are the modern keyboards? (I got a Dell Latitude last time and will probably buy another one next year. Good for Linux, lots of ports, ok screen, not so expensive and sturdy. But an ugly plastic box that is not so well designed. The touch pad sucks compared to Apple's, etc. The deciding factor was that I need apt and had problems with the package managers before on MacOS.)
- jacobolus 10y agoYou should go to a Microsoft Store and an Apple Store and try a large variety of laptop keyboards. Someone isn’t going to be able to intuit your preferences via text conversation.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoGreat advice. Also, stores like BestBuy and Walmart often have a wide range of laptops on display to try.
- dmd 10y agoIf you know you're going to buy Applecare, why wait 11 months to do so? The coverage starts from the purchase of the computer, not of Applecare.
- rsync 10y agoThe problem with Apple is that they have solved certain use cases and form factors - and once solved, there is less and less money to be made on fine tuning and iterating on those designs. For example: Apple solved the laptop computer with the aluminum, unibody macbook (air ?) with chiclet keys and glass screen/trackpad. That's it. It's over. The laptop computer is solved - and all anyone wanted was a retina macbook air. That's it - that's all we wanted. The same old macbook air with magsafe, multiple USB ports and a graphics port. With retina. Another example is the Mac Pro (tower) - this is a long-standing form factor in computing that is now solved. There is no doing this better than Apple did it with the last versions (2009 and later) of the mac pro tower. All anybody wanted was a Mac Pro tower with sata3 and usb3 and newer gfx connections. That's it - it was solved. But we didn't get any of those things, did we ? Minor iterations of existing designs are not enough for Apple - they have to do new things for economic reasons. Honestly, as someone who has no interest in an ipad or an iphone or an iwatch and has always worried that focus on those items would cannibalize Mac and OSX ... looking back I wish they had focused even more on the iDevices and just left the Mac products alone - albeit with the little iterations of processor/ram/usb3/sata3/etc.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoYou're going to need a lot more evidence to support the extraordinary claim that Apple "solved" any of these in a final way. Especially considering every MacBook Pro review I read picks out specific, non-iterative features of competing products that the author wishes Apple considered. I have all Macs, and I'd be pretty pissed at the universe if the best laptops feasible in this reality were just my current hardware when you take the limit as versions of USB and Thunderbolt tend towards infinity.
- rsync 10y ago"You're going to need a lot more evidence to support the extraordinary claim that Apple "solved" any of these in a final way. Especially considering every MacBook Pro review I read picks out specific, non-iterative features of competing products that the author wishes Apple considered." I think you're referring to touchscreen/convertible/etc. ? I don't think those are laptops. They're interesting and exciting and maybe they are even better than laptops. But they are not laptops. "I have all Macs, and I'd be pretty pissed at the universe if the best laptops feasible in this reality were just my current hardware when you take the limit as versions of USB and Thunderbolt tend towards infinity." Why ? I'm happy with hammers just the way they are. Sure, I'd like a superlight, super strong hammer made of unobtanium, but the form factor doesn't need to change.
- nunez 10y agoHonestly, now that Windows has Docker and Ubuntu, I realized that I could combine the iPad Pro with my MacBook by buying a Surface Pro. So that's what I'm doing. I'm selling my MacBook and getting a Surface.
- jsz0 10y ago> A larger danger for Apple, I think, is affordability. This was is interesting because Apple had previously been reducing the costs and expanding the options available for entry level Macs. This makes me think they will be doing a major revamp of the non-Pro line next year that may include moving them to ARM. Moving the higher volume consumer products to ARM first makes sense for a lot of reasons. I think it's even plausible we could see some type of macOS/ARM compatibility come to the iPad next year. In all the hysteria about the Mac recently everyone has kind of forgotten that the iPad is Apple's biggest problem child right now.