34 ms·
Twenty years ago I was a tea-totaller, but there was a group of people I wanted to hang out with who would get together to drink wine so I decided to try to dev
by lisper 10y ago
Twenty years ago I was a tea-totaller, but there was a group of people I wanted to hang out with who would get together to drink wine so I decided to try to develop a taste for it. I eventually got to be a pretty hard-core wine snob. My wife and I even ran a wine-tasting group for several years. Then one day we decided to start doing blind tastings, and we soon learned that there was very little correlation between what we liked and what the wine critics and the market liked. The real turning point came when we did a blind tasting of Cabernets, all from California. The wines ranged from a $5 bottle of Barefoot cab up to a $100 bottle of Silver Oak. There were twelve of us in the group and every single one rated the Silver Oak dead last, and the Barefoot either first or second. Since then we've repeated similar experiments many times, usually with similar results. We can still freak out wine snob friends on occasion by sneaking a bottle of Barefoot in to a high-end tasting.
On another occasion we were at a bed-and-breakfast that served afternoon wine and cheese. The whole room (including us) was raving about how complex and delicately nuanced the white wine was. It turned out to be Gallo Rhine Wine in a box.
(BTW, it's absolutely not the case that all cheap wines taste good. We tried the notorious two-buck chuck and thought it was absolutely horrible.)
The point is: wine snobbery is bullshit. Find what you like and drink that, and don't pay attention to anything that anyone else says. If Beringer white zinfandel is what turns you one, more power to you. (Actually, the worst possible outcome for a real wine fan is to discover that they really do enjoy Romanee Conti or Screaming Eagle. I really like Opus 1, but I wish I didn't :-)
So I think this roll-your-own-wine blender is a terrific idea. I can't wait to try it. (I wish I'd thought of it!)
- berntb 10y agoOne thing you wrote made me curious: That good wine box -- will a wine box from another batch also impress as much? I assume one of the problems with the cheap stuff is the std deviation values? I might add that I got a Moldovan 2 bucks wine in a PET bottle this week and quite liked it. :-) (I prefer dry red Spanish that you almost have to chew (I think the English term i s "rich"?). I should probably just admit defeat and replace the wine with a bit of vodka in espresso. :-) ) Edit: Hmm, I guess the cheap stuff is blended in giant volumes and hence consistent? Thanks for the information, lisper. I should try to widen my experience.
- lisper 10y agoActually one of the nice things about the mass-produced "plonk" is that it is very consistent. One bottle of Barefoot cab will taste pretty much the same as another, whereas with more expensive wines you get a lot more variation, particularly from year to year. (Wine snobs consider this a feature!) > vodka in espresso Whatever works! My wife likes vanilla vodka with olives, and raspberry martinis with a dash of tabasco. But I love her anyway :-)
- swensel 10y agoBarefoot and other mass produced wines are chemically treated. This is why they always taste the same. Variation from year to year is actually a good sign that what you're tasting is not just chemical flavoring.
- flubert 10y agoYou might also enjoy: http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2011/10/you-are-not-so-smart-why-we-cant-tell-good-wine-from-bad/247240/ http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2011/10/you-are-no...
- altm 10y agoFormer wine store worker here. Was it the case that the Silver Oak bottle probably needed some time to open up? Still, I agree with your general thrust. I find that my favorite wines, especially per dollar spent, are between $8-20.
- lisper 10y ago> Was it the case that the Silver Oak bottle probably needed some time to open up? This was a long time ago so it's hard to say. But I've had plenty of reds that tasted great straight out of the bottle, so IMHO any wine that needs to "open up" is not as good as one that doesn't. Also, while it is absolutely true that the taste of a wine will change over the course of an evening, it's far from clear how much of this is due to the flavor of the wine changing and how much due to your perceptions changing. Taste buds can get fatigued (I get "wined out" after trying 5 or 6 different wines) and food makes a huge difference too. My bottom line: I now know plenty of wines that reliably taste great (to me) straight out of the gate and keep tasting great through the whole bottle even if I keep it for a couple of days, and which cost a lot less than Silver Oak. So I just drink those :-)
- CPLX 10y ago> IMHO any wine that needs to "open up" is not as good as one that doesn't. Yikes. Gonna have to disagree with you on that. The effect of a wine being aerated/oxidized after being opened and/or decanted is obvious even to a casual wine drinker. > I now know plenty of wines that reliably taste great (to me) straight out of the gate and keep tasting great through the whole bottle even if I keep it for a couple of days And, by the same token, the taste of red wine degrades fast and is generally completely unrecognizable within 24-48 hours of opening, even if it's well kept with a fancy stopper. Reading those two comments of yours makes me seriously doubt your ability to make observations that generalize to other people.
- ogig 10y agoExactly this. There are a huge range of wines that need to be decanted. The effect is not only obvious but marvelous, how they start smelling and evolve into something much deeper, specially on the oldest bottles. Same with the degradation. I have a vacuum pump for the bottles I left open and the degradation is still obvious.
- dspillett 10y agoIt is amazing how much apparently unrelated information can sway out impressions of the taste of a product, hence the infamous "dyed white wine described as you would a red by experts" experiment - the visual cue can have a massive effect on how the wine tasting experience was reported. Another classic example is many people not being able to distinguish between the small of parmesan and vomit, how they rate the smell of either being affected by what they are told it is (in this case the key molecules that the nose picks up on are the same, or at least similar enough to activate the same receptors, so the subconscious bias caused by other verbal or environmental cues is enough to sway the perception one way or the other). The results of such priming experiments are notoriously varied though - reproduction is often unreliable.
- lisper 10y ago> hence the infamous "dyed white wine described as you would a red by experts" experiment That turns out to be somewhat of an urban legend. http://sciencesnopes.blogspot.com/2013/05/about-that-wine-experiment.html http://sciencesnopes.blogspot.com/2013/05/about-that-wine-ex... > The results of such priming experiments are notoriously varied though - reproduction is often unreliable. Yes, this is why it's important for everyone to just do these experiments for themselves and decide what they like, and not bother with what anyone else thinks.
- DonaldFisk 10y agoI was challenged on this after repeating the misleading account of Brochet's experiment, and I, and everyone else with me, could easily tell the difference blindfolded. However, none of us was an "expert" wine taster, we knew that one glass was white and the other red, and our eyes were covered. It transpires that colour does affect your perception of flavour, the subjects in Brochet's experiment were deliberately deceived, and "experts" would have more to lose if they described a wine as white if it really was red.
- lisper 10y agoYour expectations have a huge effect on your subjective perceptions. One thing I've found is that wine tastes better to me in a "proper" glass, i.e. one with a large bowl and thin walls. But I have no idea whether this is a "real" effect or all in my head because there's no way to do a blind comparison. On the other hand, does it really matter? You can suck all the pleasure out of just about any activity by overthinking it.
- Ntrails 10y ago> Twenty years ago I was a tea-totaller, but there was a group of people I wanted to hang out with who would get together to drink wine so I decided to try to develop a taste for it. Could you go into a bit more detail on this? The very idea of forcing myself to "acquire the taste" for alcohol seems distasteful in itself. I've got additional reasons for choosing not to do so, but I'd be interested to hear another point of view and why you'd want to make a fairly drastic change.
- Grishnakh 10y agoYou don't drink wine for the alcohol, you drink it for the flavor. It's just like tea; no one drinks a nice cup of Earl Grey with Bourgamot for the caffeine. If you want to get liquored up, there's far cheaper and more efficient ways to do it than wine, and if you want caffeine, there's faster and more effective ways of getting that too that don't require carefully heating water and steeping a teabag. A lot of people do like the effect of the alcohol, but it's a side-effect, not the main purpose of drinking wine. Personally, it seems to have no effect on me, but I also don't drink very much at a time. Forcing yourself to "acquire the taste" for wine is no different than forcing yourself to "acquire the taste" for expensive, fine cheeses, or doing the same for fine cuts of meat instead of eating a McDonald's burger.
- metanoia 10y ago> You don't drink wine for the alcohol, you drink it for the flavor. I really wish that synthehol (of Star Trek fame) were a thing. I was at a champagne tasting of 60+ wines from the best producers (Krug and Roederer come to mind), and made it through 25 or so, spitting each one, and was still terribly buzzed. If there were a way to enjoy the taste without the effects I would be all for it.
- Grishnakh 10y ago>I was at a champagne tasting of 60+ wines from the best producers (Krug and Roederer come to mind), and made it through 25 or so, spitting each one, and was still terribly buzzed. I've never actually had that feeling, and always wondered what this "buzz" effect is. I've been to wine tastings, drank multiple glasses at once, etc., and never felt a thing.
- djrogers 10y ago> We tried the notorious two-buck chuck and thought it was absolutely horrible Then you should try it again! Not only are there many varietals, but they change far more year over year than your traditional wine would as it's basically a blend of whatever was available as overage from many different California wineries. Some years there is a bit of a hidden gem worth spending a few bucks to find.
- dllthomas 10y agoIn my (somewhat dated) experience, grabbing a bottle of Charles Shaw of arbitrary year and varietal was about like grabbing an arbitrary ~$10-$15 bottle of wine. There's some good stuff and some stuff not worth drinking. Not much that's amazing, but surprising for the price point.
- tpeo 10y agoI don't quite understand why you winos take your critics so seriously in the first place. Critics are just people with opinions. Sometimes they can provide good justification for why whatever they're reviewing is good or bad. But not one of them is impartial enough that their opinion can be taken at face value, specially if you're not into the stuff they're pushing. This is more obvious with film and videogame. It wouldn't matter at all if a critic I liked ever said that there's this one Adam Sandler movie that everyone should totally watch. I'm not into that crap.
- gohrt 10y agoVery efficient decision-process, when you know that no one's opinions can be strong enough to overcome your preferences. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punch-Drunk_Love https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punch-Drunk_Love
- crispyambulance 10y agoA good friend of mine is actually a food/wine critic. He has said (and I think this applies to all good critics) that there's nothing special about the tastes of a critic. Some people may be more sensitive than others but critics are pretty much in the same population as the rest of us. The difference between a good critic and someone flapping their gums on Yelp is the ability TO WRITE something worthwhile about the subject, be it wine or food. Boiling what a critic says down to "good/bad" or "like/dislike" means the reader hasn't taken the time to really understand what was said-- or the critic wasn't very good.
- vinayan3 10y agoI will say that some people's palate are quite limited. They only identify a few things as good. I've met people who basically wouldn't eat a green vegetable because it was yucky. I'd expect critics to have eaten enough where they can judge many things. I do agree putting it into words so someone else could have a sense of what it would taste like and possible be able to say if they would like it.
- pimlottc 10y agoI agree. To me, a good critic is not necessarily one with impeccable tastes, but one whose reviews give me all I need to know about whether I will like the subject in question.
- crispyambulance 10y agoPoint-of-sale wine blender, the time has come! I agree it is best to not to depend on price, score, or reviews when finding a good wine. Its all about your own senses. The best advice I ever got at a wine tasting was, actually, tasting advice. Basically just savor a glass of wine and develop a memory of the sensory experience. If one takes the time and attention to do it right the mind will automatically tuck that away and recall it for comparison when tasting other wines months or years into the future.
- thesimpsons1022 10y agoi wonder if it's the same for whiskeys or really any alchohol.
- lisper 10y agoYes, absolutely. Since the infamous cab tasting we've done blind tastings of spirits with similar results. Our favorite vodka, for example, turns out to be Seagrams Extra Smooth, which is about half the price of a "high end" vodka. Unfortunately, it doesn't always turn out that way. My favorite scotch turns out to be Lagavulin or Laphroaig -- I really like the smokey flavor of Islay malts -- both of which are rather pricey.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoVery neat to hear, as I've been trying all sorts of different vodkas since one pivotal tasting. So I knew a Frenchman who was in the wine business and thought the market was too saturated, too tough, so he looked into spirits and saw vodka's large (~30%) market share and jumped in to the ultra premium space, the shelf above Grey Goose. His trick was to hire a skilled French distillery to run the vodka through 9 times, effectively cleansing it far beyond what most processing would be like (at the time). I had it over ice and can absolutely recall the pleasant experience drinking that came through. It was like no other vodka I'd had. In the 10+ years since, however, I can go to my local shop and pick up a made in Texas (!) vodka distilled 6 times for about $20 a liter. Is it as good? No. Is it leaps and bounds better than what I remember from college and in general drinking out and about? Drastically better. People look at me funny but I claim to be able to taste the copper still pots used in the making of Titos. Can't really over OJ, but if it's stiff enough. Just not my thing!
- eric_h 10y agoPersonally, I find that whiskey, beer, tequila and mescal are the only alcohol products where price really does line up with quality.
- tptacek 10y ago
- sampo 10y ago> the notorious two-buck chuck At least this year, the "two-buck chuck" (which, depending on your state, usually costs around $3 now) comes in 7 different varieties: 3 different reds, 3 whites, and 1 rose. https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2016/05/ranking-trader-joes-two-buck-chuck-from-worst-to-l.html https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2016/05/ranking-trade...
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoAnd for the sake of redundancy, try the Oak Leaf brand sold by Wal Mart, if that's an easier store to get to.
- bambax 10y agoThis was published in 2008: The Wine Trials: 100 Everyday Wines Under $15 that Beat $50 to $150 Wines in Brown-Bag Blind Tastings https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0974014354/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0974014354/ It currently can be found for $0.01 (!!) It's a great book.
- ogig 10y agoMy father has been a wine lover for all his, now long, adult life. He has an impressive cellar with some of the best wines of Spain and France. He was also fooled in some blind tastings, like believing a white wine was actually red. But he can also tell the difference between most of his favorite wines, and so do I. So this is not a black or white situation. While some blind taste tests are difficult, others are easy to pass. Depends on what are you prepared to or exposed to. There are plenty of sommelier competitions where they tell apart years and zones very precisely. On the other hand. I don't know about those wines your are talking about but throwing, for example, a 34 years old wine to compete in a blind test against a cheap modern wine is a bad idea and I might prefer the modern one too in that setting. You need to prepare a good meal or cheese to have that old wine with, a table and good people, time for the wine to breath, good glasses... a pleasure setting. Then, only then the 34 years old wine will reveal why it costs that much. I still agree with you that there are many good wines on the low price range, and people should drink what it tastes best for them. The wine blender idea seems terrible to me. I can't believe it will output anything good, but hey, I would try it. I'm from a wine region in Spain, by the way.
- steven777400 10y agoHonest question. Your example of the external conditions that enable the 34 year old wine to shine. How does that work with the wine? In other words, if I substitute the cheap modern wine that otherwise won in the blind taste test, what happens differently in the setting you describe?
- ogig 10y agoSimple example; I used the whole day to prepare a strong wild boar stew and that will be a perfect pairing for a very strong wine, possibly old. If you bring a light wine of the year to that table it will get diluted on the strong flavors of the stew. We might have a good night but the wine won't shine.
- not_ed_snow 10y agoIt seems like you are saying that the wine's qualities and how they pair with the food are very important. I don't think anyone would disagree. The question at hand is whether a cheap/expensive wine, of the same type, would matter in the boar stew example. Personally, I have no reason to believe that a more expensive wine would only shine under these types of conditions. I also think it's a matter of subjective taste, and there is no arguing matters of taste ;). From the non-oenophile POV, my objection is the pretension of objectivity. "This wine is better than the other one" is a subjective statement masquerading as an objective one.
- Grishnakh 10y agoYears ago, I had a relative who was running a restaurant, and she did a wine-tasting for the staff to educate them on wines and pairings, and I got to sit in on it. It wasn't a blind taste-test, but they opened a bunch of bottles of wine, port, and champagne (only ones that'd be served at a restaurant though, not some ultra-cheap supermarket stuff). Invariably, I found that I liked the cheapest varieties the best. The $100/bottle port tasted like crap to me ("Grandfathers"? I think that might have been the name), whereas the cheapest port was fantastic paired with chocolate, which was something I had never tried at the time. Same with wines and champagnes; the cheap Asti Spumanti tasted good to me, the expensive stuff was just nasty. I also think the roll-your-own is a great idea. Wine snobbery is annoying; I try to only buy bottles where they show right on the label what kind of wine it is (sweet vs. dry) instead of a bunch of stupid flowery language about notes and aromas. I also wish they'd cut it out with the stupid corks. Those make as much sense now as wooden spokes on car wheels, or 50-pin SCSI ports on computers. Screw-on caps are superior in every way.
- samstave 10y agoHad a private tasting with JGregory (Mark Jessup, who was the original wine maker for Opus 1)... The tasting was amazing, the experience was amazing... Bought several bottles for $68/each Got them home - had some later, tasted nothing like what we had in the tasting room... weren't as impressed. Same thing with Raymond, but Caymus is always consistent. But if you like to drink wine - it doesn't make sense to drink a 30/60/90 dollar bottle of wine a week. You need to find a bottle that is something you like and is also affordable. Save the Special Selection for a special occasion.
- samstave 10y agoOh, you can go to wineries and make your own blend, then they will save the recipe for you and you can go back and get more of them at any later date.
- megablast 10y agoWhat, every winery will do this for you?
- samstave 10y agoWell, I know that Buena Vista will - and I am going there tomorrow... but the people I am going with know a hell-of-a-lot more about this than I do. But the last two times I went to Buena Vista, this was brought up by my date and the group. They did it once. You create your custom blend - then they keep that on file and you can request/buy it any time. https://www.buenavistawinery.com/ https://www.buenavistawinery.com/
- acchow 10y ago> Find what you like and drink that, and don't pay attention to anything that anyone else says. This is of course the right approach to most things in life. But just because "to each their own", that doesn't imply there aren't real complexities and nuances in foods that exist only in more expensive things. Take for example someone who eats fast food burgers every day and try to take them to eat sushi. They just won't like it. In the case of wine (heh), sure different palates like different wines. But I think a lot of people take that and jump to the conclusion that "all wines are the same, the only difference is the palates". I don't think the conclusion is true.
- Bulkington 10y agoWell, except that blending is a big part of what a winemaker does and, basically, it should be left to professionals. All else is monkeys and typewriters. If you can't tell the diff between a Barefoot and a Silver Oak, what do you think home blending is going to accomplish? Wine snobbery may be bullshit, just like jazz snobbery. But that's not the same as 'appreciation,' which requires some education and experience, maybe even some aptitude. Or think instead of sex: Wow, that sure was great! Why would I want to try anything different? tl;dr: You don't know what you're missing, or you're doing it wrong--or, more likely, both. https://winemakermag.com/95-blending-batches-tips-from-the-pros https://winemakermag.com/95-blending-batches-tips-from-the-p...
- ythl 10y ago> But that's not the same as 'appreciation,' which requires some education and experience, maybe even some aptitude. OP's point is that without the information about the price and make of the wine, your brain alone can't "appreciate" anything not matter how educated and experienced you are. If someone tells you you are drinking a rare extremely expensive french 100-year-old vintage, your brain will "appreciate" it, even if it's actually cheap box wine.
- Bulkington 10y agoNot a biggie, but thus the "doing it wrong" bit. Sure, everyone can like can what they like, but it's inaccurate to equate discernment with snobbery--except in snobs who, themselves, are doing it wrong. Cheers, as I grab a jug of Paisano to take to the patio while I grill burgers. The 2010 Silver Oak cab continues to collect dust and cat hair on the wine rack. Thus the downside of good wine: afraid to drink it.
- danieltillett 10y agoI wish that I couldn't tell the difference between expensive wine and cheap plonk. While there are plenty of expensive duds, there are very few cheap good wines. The wine industry might not be able to make good wine on demand, but they can certainly make sure no good wine is cheap. The only real exception that I know of is Hunter Valley (Australia) wines. The Hunter Valley is a very unreliable wine region and it only gets a really good vintage every 5 to 10 years. Wine makers just can't charge the correct price for hunter wines in the good vintages because they have to be able to shift their production the rest of the time. In a good year you can get totally amazing wines for a very reasonable price - the only problem is the long wait.
- emodendroket 10y agoI don't know a lot about wine in particular. But this does ring a little bit like an argument that because more people enjoy reading Harry Potter than Moby Dick that therefore the latter has no merits over the former. Not so sure about that.
- xorgar831 10y agoI've found that over the past 20 years my taste in wine has gotten more particular, it's really more about how your palate changes over time. The expensive and famous wines aren't completely without merit however, and if you go off of the taste alone, well that's not really what wine is about either. :) Wine is also your company, the food, the smell of the earth (terroir), the balmy afternoon. But I've found I have had to get more clever about the wines I like by finding vineyards near to the fancy ones, such as a wine from Gigondas vs. its more expensive neighbour Chateau-du-Pape, or a good Cremant or Prosecco vs. Champagne. Even at that not every supposedly "great" wine is transcendent, but from the right areas I've occasionally I gotten lucky and it's really something else. And some of the best wines I've had weren't for sale, small hotel in Tuscany making it's own wine, or a professor in Hungary who happened to own a vineyard were stunning.
- tomcam 10y agoWait… It isn't about the taste alone?
- greenshackle2 10y agoI'm not a connoisseur at all but I like the Barefoot Pinot Grigio. I've tasted better whites but most cheap whites I've tried were worse.
- cloudjacker 10y ago> and we soon learned that there was very little correlation between what we liked and what the wine critics and the market liked What the market "likes" isn't correlated to taste, it is correlated to scarcity. Certain climates and variations in climate that one year, coupled with name, garner the premiums. It isn't age or "complex nuance". Although these are one form of magic the industry relies on being perpetuated by consumers, the other is the idea that climates cannot be replicated.
- jogjayr 10y ago> There were twelve of us in the group and every single one rated the Silver Oak dead last, and the Barefoot either first or second. I've always been of the opinion that Barefoot punches above its price, so to speak.
- twoodfin 10y agoAnd Silver Oak is literally and figuratively vanilla. Not a great California red, and particularly not at its price.
- thyrsus 10y agoMy problem with wine is that I know what I like when I taste it, but as best I can tell, there is no language with which to express that, after "red". There's "headache flavor", which never shows up in cheap wine: it doesn't taste bad, but it means I'm going to get a headache if I drink more that 4oz of a wine tasting like that. No bottle has ever been labeled with "headache flavor". I ask wine people, and they hand wave something about tanins, but I've tasted high tanin and low tanin wine, and the flavor is completely orthogonal. Given the lack of information, I never bet a lot on a bottle. My favorite wine ever was a Consumato Nero D'Avolo from 2010 (I paid $22), but other years of that label have been wildly inconsistent, and now I can't find it any more. It was very close in flavor to a wine I had at a wine bar that they called a "California Malbec" which I've never found again, and another at a restaurant where - WTF restaurants! Whenever stumble on a wine I especially like at a restaurant, I go to Google and find out the label doesn't exist! It's some fictional house label! Not my very favorite, but something I liked with meals was Corbet Canyon Malbec, so of course they don't make it any more. Even if I had the time and money to make thorough study of this, I'd have spent a year being drunk and discovering perhaps a dozen excellent bottles - which would henceforth never be made again. Screw that. Inexpensive box wine for me. Or, just as often, an IPA. The beer people know how to produce consistent quality and have categories where the product consistently meets expectation, while still having entertaining variations between brewers.