23 ms·
2017 Chevrolet Bolt EV
- Shivetya 10y agoI know some don't like the packaging but CUVs are selling in ever increasing numbers and should help with sales more than if this were a sedan. I was very impressed with the range they obtained with both EPA and how some individual drivers fared. Going to be real curious what drop off it experiences in winter. I am seriously considering a lease for one of these, I would not buy any first generation practical EV; I don't consider any of the sub 100 gang to be practical. What I am really curious about is how this will effect pricing on the short range EVs. I don't see the pricing to remain steady on anything short of 200 miles going forward. Even Consumer Reports likes it, though they state the boxy form is dork like it in no means goes full dork like the i3. Again, CUVs are the where the market is hot now and this was a great choice by GM. CR review https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIYG0NR42LU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIYG0NR42LU
- mr337 10y agoIt will trash the short new and used EV market less than 200, Leaf, i3 etc. Even now the depreciation on Leafs are crazy, and this just makes it more so. The way I look at it right now the EV market is like fast moving computers, everyone is scared to buy in that they will miss the next upgrade and have buyers remorse, and that is the 200m mark. This just confirms it.
- aetherson 10y agoMy father was leasing a Leaf. He just leased a new one, brand new, otherwise identical to the one he had before, and substantially lowered his (already insanely low) lease payments. If I were in a two-car household, I'd probably make a Leaf my second car right now because, for all that it's a way worse first car than a 200 mile range EV, it's not much worse of a second car, and the cost pressure downward on it is insane right now.
- mr337 10y agoAgreed, I bought a used one with 25K miles for $10k about 14 months ago. The pricing is even worse now and for our family it has become our primary car, we are putting around 2500 miles each month and drive our ICE twice a month. I'm a bit worried about the battery but looks like I'll be getting it replaced before the battery capacity warranty is up (60k miles).
- mrfusion 10y agoWhy are you getting the battery replaced? Expensive? Are you noticing range fallling?
- mr337 10y agoYup, I'm at 76% of the original capacity, and that makes a huge difference running heat or doing highway miles. Out of warranty, to get a new battery, you don't get to keep the core, is $5,500. That warranty runs out at 60K miles. I was delighted to see the Bolt warrantied for 100K miles but will need to look at the details to see if that covers accelerated capacity degradation.
- djrogers 10y agoAck - 25% capacity drop in 25k miles? Is that normal for leafs, or did the PO have particularly poor driving habits?
- antisthenes 10y ago25,000 miles is about 300 full cycle recharges for a Leaf. That is definitely the cycle number where you'll start to see a capacity drop, but 25% still seems very high for that range. First and 2nd gen batteries will generally have to be replaced around 600 +-10% cycles. It's 'normal' for all pure EV vehicles - so the durability of the battery pack is directly proportional to its capacity.
- wccrawford 10y agoI have a Chevy Sonic now and like the way it looks, and this thing looks a little more SciFi than the Sonic. I think saying it looks "boxy" or "dorky" is wrong, and it's in the eye of the beholder. There's no need to tell people how they should feel about it, so I'm disappointed in that reviewer.
- gbrown 10y agoIf you're not ready to make the jump, the Volt gets to play electric car for most journeys, kicking over to being a fuel efficient hybrid for long ones. The Gen 1 is cheap right now, and gets around 42 electric miles in the summer, 35 in the winter. The newer ones have increased range.
- davisr 10y agoI have a 2013 Volt, and in the summer I actually get around 55 miles to the charge, one just needs to learn to be less aggressive with the accelerator (there's an indicator on the dash that helps with this).
- gbrown 10y agoI started out by doing that, but now I just ignore it and drive as usual. The 42 mile range is enough to get to and from work (my wife and I actually carpool, and she can charge it for free at work).
- leecarraher 10y ago"However, the exponential effects of aerodynamic drag" quadratic? otherwise we're in trouble
- aetherson 10y agoPeople in informal language constantly use "exponential" to mean "more than linear." Which drives me completely insane, but I think it's time to just accept it.
- herge 10y agoWell, it's big-O of exponential!
- JoshTriplett 10y agoPeople often use big-O (asymptotically bounded above) when they really want big-Θ (theta, asymptotically bounded above and below). Strictly by the definition, for instance, binary search is O(e^x), as well as O(x^12), O(x), and O(lg x). However, binary search is Θ(lg x), and not Θ(any of those other functions).
- JadeNB 10y agoI think that your parent was making precisely that point as a joke.
- mjhoy 10y agoWith big theta you strictly have to talk about best and worst cases, because for e.g. insertion sort, what's true of worst case is not true of best case (and vice versa). For big-O, what's true of worst case is also true of best case, so talking about worst case suffices. Big-O is less precise and therefore more useful, because average case usually = worst case anyway.
- smallnamespace 10y ago
- canada_dry 10y ago"60.0 kilowatt-hours of energy (equivalent to about 1.8 gallons of gasoline)" Interesting. Just for an oranges to apples comparison, I wonder how many KWh the most efficient gas powered generator can produce on 1.8 gallons of gas.
- brianlweiner 10y agoLiterally posting one of the first google results so I cannot guarantee accuracy. "The gasoline-powered generators produce at best 6.13 kilowatt-hours per gallon of fuel, at worst 4.42, and a median of 5.7." [1] So it sounds like it's ~5x as efficient as a gas generator. [1]https://settysoutham.wordpress.com/2010/05/26/portable-generators-about-half-as-efficient-as-power-plants/ https://settysoutham.wordpress.com/2010/05/26/portable-gener...
- tjalex 10y agoThey covered 238 miles on a trip w/ 34 miles indicated remaining, so if they went ~250 miles total on 60 kW-h that would be equivalent to a ~140 MPG car.
- sebnukem2 10y agoCombustion engines are about 15-20% efficient. Toyota has 30+% engines in their Prius. Electric motors are about 90% efficient. So electric motors are about 5x more efficient than ICEs.
- timthorn 10y agoBut don't forget the losses in charging the battery as well.
- Cshelton 10y agoThat's about 10%, and it's all heat. So to charge a 90kwh battery, you need roughly 99kwh of energy. Which for me, since it's charging in my garage, the excess heat is actually kind of nice as it will keep my garage slightly warmer in the winter and thus my house as my garage is on the lower floor. Either way, it's still WAY more efficient than any time of combustion engine. Including hydrogen. Hydrogen is kind of a wasted effort (unless we are doing fusion ;p )
- BBTN6 10y agoFor many people this won't have the mythos or upstart appeal of the upcoming Tesla Model 3-- and that's a shame, cause they did a real good job on it. Yet I do believe the 200+ mile range and price will get enough people in one and really start to shift the EV from being an early adopter accessory to a viable everyday car. Good on ya, GM.
- arviewer 10y agoThat's 375 km for the rest of the world. Anyway, how quick does it charge, either to full or 50 or 80%?
- Llevel 10y ago40km per hour of charge time, 9 hours for a full charge.[1] It doesn't look like it has the ability to use superchargers, or charge quickly in any way. [1] http://www.chevrolet.ca/bolt-ev-electric-vehicle.html http://www.chevrolet.ca/bolt-ev-electric-vehicle.html edit: I am wrong, the article mentions quick charging, but the official website doesn't.
- enjo 10y agoThe article contradicts that: For $750, Bolt buyers can opt for direct-current fast-charging capability via a Combined Charging System (CCS) port. As of September 1, 2016, there were 1061 CCS fast-charging connectors in the United States, versus 2010 Tesla Supercharger hookups. Most CCS stations charge at 50 kilowatts, and Chevrolet claims they can be expected to add 90 miles of range in 30 minutes of charging. Not bad, but that’s roughly half the rate of Tesla’s 120-kW Superchargers, and access to CCS chargers definitely isn’t included in the price of the Bolt.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- herpderpherpder 10y agoEV are only viable for those who own their own homes. Many electric vehicles have been adequate for my needs, but I continue to drive a car with an internal combustion engine because I can always buy gas. My apartment building has two EV charging stations (always taken) and my work has 9 (always taken). I don't think vehicle technology or execution has been the limiting factor for a while.
- chrisper 10y agoSteve Wozniak got rid of his Tesla and got one of these. http://www.hybridcars.com/aples-steve-wozniak-choosing-practical-over-stylish-with-chevy-bolt-over-tesla/ http://www.hybridcars.com/aples-steve-wozniak-choosing-pract...
- arviewer 10y agoBeam me up Bolty!
- Cshelton 10y agoExcept for a week later he ditched the Bolt and was back in his Tesla. He was just trying it out because he had a demo. He quickly found out that the Bolt is no comparison really and switched back to the Model S.
- chrisper 10y agoOh. That sucks. I do not seem to be able to find any source on that, though.
- Cshelton 10y agoI'll look for it. The media for some reason loves to hate on Tesla, so the follow up didn't get much attention. You can check his twitter, also he checks in to Tesla charging stations all the time.
- martincmartin 10y agoDo you have a source for that? I can't find any information on it anywhere.
- tinbad 10y agoI give credit to GM for being able to scrape its parts bin for the last 4 years to come out with a car that's slightly better than the 5 year old Leaf. However it still shows a company that is clueless about the future and has no real plan or vision other than producing a "me too" product made out of bits and pieces of other, subpar, disposable Chevys. [edit: wow so much hate]
- maxerickson 10y agoOkay, let's address the substance of what you said. Which subpar Chevy did they pull the battery and drivetrain out of? Because the 230 mile electric platform is the interesting part of the car.
- tinbad 10y agoIs it? Tesla has been mass producing cars with that range since 2012 now. GM being able to put the same range on a $30k car is just batteries getting cheaper.
- maxerickson 10y agoYeah, I agree, progress in electric vehicles is largely due to batteries getting cheaper (and improving).
- salmon30salmon 10y agoWhere is the sub 30k Tesla? Being able to design a car such as the model 3 is a huge feat, no doubt. However execution is equally as important, and no matter which way you slice it, GM hit the market first. It is not always fair, the innovator should receive the rewards, but in this case the existing player executed first.
- djrogers 10y agoI'm looking at ~2.5-3x range, more interior space, much better performance, and better handling. Which metrics are you looking at that are merely 'slightly better'? Oh, and which parts bin did GM scrape that 60Kw/230mi drivetrain from?
- phmagic 10y agoGreat timing on GM's part to eat at the majority share of the EV market dominated by the Leaf.
- djrogers 10y ago> A 10.2-inch touchscreen is standard equipment, but a navigation system isn’t offered. Instead, you’ll have to rely on a connected phone to pull up Android Auto or Apple CarPlay. Hallelujah! I really hope the rest of the manufacturers and their car lines come around to this model. I know they make more $$ on their $2000 nav packages, but people are rejecting them in droves because they are horrible and need to be updated through clunky, often expensive processes.
- wlesieutre 10y agoAgreed. Even people who have nav systems built into their cars still use their phones instead. http://money.cnn.com/2016/10/10/autos/car-navigation-frustration/ http://money.cnn.com/2016/10/10/autos/car-navigation-frustra... The phone navigation apps are made by software companies who actually have to compete with each other to make the best system. Compare to car nav systems where you only have one option, and the comparison of navigation systems between different cars is going to be a very very small factor in which car you end up buying. You buy the car you want and take whatever you get for navigation. Car manufacturers (to generalize a bit) are not particularly good at software, and do not have much incentive to get better at it.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoThe navigation assistance in my car is significantly better than the one Google Maps offers. For one thing it doesn't lose its mind every time I go under an overpass. For another, the UI is vastly superior: it shows me the distance to the next waypoint prominently in the center of the display, between the speedometer and the tachometer. When approaching a turn, the same area of the display is used to show the configuration of the intersection, even complicated ones like double forks or t- or y- shaped intersections, or even acute turnbacks. My car never barks orders like Google Maps does. If it needs to say something, it is awfully polite, saying things such as "If possible, make a legal U-turn." And finally my car's navigation responds to a voice command to stop navigating, which Google Maps doesn't seem to know. In my experience the only thing Google Maps navigation has going for it is superior data. I really wish I could have my car's UI with Google's data.
- robodale 10y agoMy water pump went out on my (gasoline engine powered) car today. All 6 of my fuel injectors did earlier in the year, so I'm a little sensitive about vehicle repairs today. Out of curiosity, I wondered if the upcoming Tesla Model 3 has any water pumps. It has no need to cool an engine, right? So, maybe I'd avoid replacing fuel and coolant parts. Less parts, means lower cost of ownership, right? ...Maybe? Teslas have 3 water pumps, to pump ~26 quarts of coolant to keep the battery cool. Sigh. Maybe I'd have no fuel injectors to replace in a Tesla, but the physics of getting me from 0-60 in a reasonable amount of time must necessitate a minimum complexity. I wish I could fast forward ten years to see total cost of ownership of EVs versus gas/petrol powered vehicles.
- cloudwalking 10y agoThe motor and drivetrain is significantly less complex than an engine. A Tesla has a dozen moving parts in the drivetrain. Your gas car has thousands. Not only does a Tesla not have fuel injectors, it doesn't have a fuel pump, or spark plugs, or valves, or piston rings or pistons or connecting rods or rod bearings or a cam shaft... The electric powertrain is magnitudes simpler.
- taeric 10y agoNot only that, but while it is orders of magnitude more difficult to fix than a classic gas engine, those don't really exist anymore either. Pretty much any engine electric or otherwise is out of range for typical home repair. (And I say this as someone that still has a manual with the thought that I could replace the clutch on my own, if I want to.) I hasten to add that I do not know the expected cost of repairs between the two types of engines. Would be a good fact to know.
- cloudwalking 10y agoYou are partially correct. The battery is very difficult to fix at home. But the motor and stator can be replaced in your own garage with just a few hours of work -- again a magnitude less time and effort than replacing an engine.
- honkhonkpants 10y ago"The Bolt starts at $37,495 in LT trim, but a $7500 federal tax credit will pull the price under $30,000." I don't understand this because the last time I went into the VW dealer they had the MSRP of the e-Golf crossed out with a sharpie, and the price was written in higher, by the exact sum of the state and federal credits. How can the buyer expect to capture all of the federal incentive?
- sowbug 10y agoThey were literally* marking up the price. It's not uncommon for popular models. Offer a couple thousand below MSRP and see how it goes. *A rare proper usage of the term "literally"
- jacquesm 10y agoOne of the first things EV manufacturers will have to take care of is standardization of their fast charging networks so that the network of one manufacturer can be used by cars from another. If they don't get that worked out it will be a huge stumbling block to EV adoption. It's being worked on (there were some talks between Tesla and a French manufacturer) but it isn't there yet.
- flavor8 10y agoYep, this is a mess: > As of September 1, 2016, there were 1061 CCS fast-charging connectors in the United States, versus 2010 Tesla Supercharger hookups Let's not do this.
- Cshelton 10y agoYup, we will have a world with many adapters. I don't think it'll be a big of a problem though. Also, Tesla has already done so much for any car manufacturer: - They have made all patents free to use by anyone. - Elon has stated that he would welcome other car makers to join in on the Tesla Supercharger network if they are willing to contribute in an equal manner. Seeing as Tesla has more Evs on the road than anyone else by a large magnitude, and they have proven their charging network far more than anybody else, it's odd nobody else wants to join in. But that's Wall Street for you. Nothing will be given away "free", and we can't be seen working with the competition. Despite many of the 'shareholders' are institutions who likely would own shares of both companies regardless. And at the end of the day, Wall Street is a secondary market that should mean jack. Hell, the only reason other companies are now pushing for EVs so much is because Tesla lit a fire under everyone else and despite Wall Street betting against them (high volume of shorts), Tesla is now the top selling luxury sedan in the U.S. Now everyone else is scrambling. We will see one or two major automotive companies that have been prominent in the last century fall. They will either A. not keep up with the EV world (maybe they receive too much money from the fossil fuel industry) or B. Their tech will not keep up and/or fail and they will lose all their competitiveness.
- honkhonkpants 10y ago"Seeing as Tesla has more Evs on the road than anyone else by a large magnitude" The Chevy Volt is the most common plug-in electric car. Tesla is 3rd behind Nissan in cumulative sales.
- sickbeard 10y ago38k MSRP isn't exactly cheap. You could get Merc GLA 250 for that kind of money
- masmullin 10y agoNo kidding eh? The Bolt seems to be relatively comparable to the Sonic in size, which can be had for $16k. I don't think buyers are going to save 22k in gasoline over the course of the life of the car.
- dangrossman 10y agoThey're factoring in the fact that most people will take $7500-$10000+ off that price via tax credits (either themselves or via the leasing company), so it's a $28-30K car. There's no avoiding the remaining markup: that's essentially the cost of the battery.
- csours 10y agoThe performance of the Bolt EV is MUCH better than a Sonic (6.5 second 0-60 for the Bolt EV; 8.7 for the Sonic; 6.4 for the Mercedes GLA mentioned above), and the feel of the electric drive is smoother than any gasoline powertrain (barring possibly a Bentley); so you are definitely getting more than fuel savings with your extra $22k. It is still up to the buyer to decide if those features are worth it. Disclaimer: I work for GM and drive a Sonic. I did not work on this program.
- sickbeard 10y agoisn't this a laughable metric for what is a small sized family car?
- csours 10y agoI'm not sure what you mean, so I'll talk generally about the Bolt EV: it's hard to categorize. It's not marketed as a luxe vehicle like the Tesla; it doesn't have the same performance as the high end Teslas. It's more expensive than seemingly comparable vehicles, until you try to find a vehicle to compare it to. It's quicker than most (nearly all) compact cars and crossovers. It doesn't have the ground clearance to be regarded as a Crossover/SUV, but it is too tall to be considered a hatchback. While being a tall vehicle, it has a low center of gravity due to the battery being very low and heavy. It is a small car, but it is heavy, again due to the battery. All in all, this car will have to make it's own market, because there really is nothing exactly like it. (disclaimer again, I do work for GM)
- Someone1234 10y agoThe Bolt may work in terms of range and charging but it remains impractical for most of the general public. A Bolt costs roughly $32K (depending on incentives, maybe more). A Toyota Camry Hybrid starts at $26,790. And, I know what you're going to say, "electricity is free!" That's just untrue. Recharging electric cars is far from free. The Bolt costs roughly $10 to recharge its 238 mile battery. A Camry Hybrid can drive approx 680 miles on a full tank and costs $37 to completely refill. So you're saving about $8 per every 680 miles you drive. So the breakeven for the cost difference of the two vehicles (@$5,210) is 442,850 miles. Neither car is going to make it to 400K miles, so therefore you won't make your money back from a Bolt. PS - Yes, my post uses tons of assumptions: Incentives for the Bolt, cost of electricity, cost of gas, average miles figures, and so on. You cannot make a post about this topic without doing so. Feel free to pick particular figures/assumptions apart, but pointing out "this is all based on estimates!" isn't very constructive within itself.
- greglindahl 10y agoThere are many reasons, besides lower cost, why people buy particular cars. Also, are you sure you aren't being confusing with how you're using "impractical"?
- Someone1234 10y agoUnaffordable is impractical. Most families cannot afford an extra $5K unless there is a reasonable amount of benefit to them, they don't have that kind of disposable income. So unless they can quantify why a Bolt is superior to a Hybrid (and cost definitely isn't a winning argument) you'll struggle to convince the average American household to own one. To me that is impractical.
- djrogers 10y ago> Unaffordable is impractical. Most families cannot afford an extra $5K unless there is a reasonable amount of benefit to them, they don't have that kind of disposable income If 'most families' acted in the rational manner you present above, then people wouldn't be leasing/financing new cars at the insanely high rate we do in the US. Given that there's a market for it though, the Bolt seems like a great option for GM to offer....
- simonsarris 10y ago> PRICE AS TESTED: $43,905 (base price: $37,495) > can be had for less than the price of the average new car. Emphasis mine and obviously they are factoring in the $7,500 tax credit which I guess is fine. I dislike this "price of the average new car" line and it gets repeated a lot. Car manufacturers must love it since it tries to normalize that price as "average" when its not very representative. Grand total "average new car" price that the media is using everywhere is $33,666, but that's only because of the average price of luxury cars and trucks driving the number way, way up. There's a breakdown by sector in KBB's numbers: http://mediaroom.kbb.com/new-car-transaction-prices-up-2-percent-march-2016 http://mediaroom.kbb.com/new-car-transaction-prices-up-2-per... Scroll down to the second table for more realistic numbers. At any rate the median new car price, if we could get it, would be much more telling. Sadly I can't find it anywhere. After the tax credit the base model is the average cost of a Mid-size Pickup Truck ($30,045) or average cost of a sports car ($30,712) But well above the average cost of a mid size car ($25,095) or crossover ($27,056) or subcompact ($17,218)
- Zigurd 10y agoThere are a ton of systemic subsidies for gasoline powered cars. It isn't irrational or unfair to subsidize a new technology until it has proliferated enough to challenge such an ingrained technology as hydrocarbon fuels. Costs will come down as volume goes up, and early state R&D gets paid down.
- simonsarris 10y agoI tried to specifically point out that the tax credit accounting of "cost" is fine by me and that I am including its benefit in my numbers for comparison. My post is not about that.
- sndean 10y ago> At any rate the median new car price, if we could get it, would be much more telling. Sadly I can't find it anywhere. The best I can find is $24000 [1], which sounds believable. But that's not referenced. There's a lot of articles stating that most people actually can't afford new cars [2]. Those articles, and studies they're talking about, are comparing median income and average car price, though. [1] http://www.financialsamurai.com/the-110th-rule-for-car-buying-everyone-must-follow/ http://www.financialsamurai.com/the-110th-rule-for-car-buyin... [2] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/02/your-money/new-cars-are-too-expensive-for-the-typical-family-study-finds.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/02/your-money/new-cars-are-to...
- ebbv 10y agoI am really excited about the Bolt and planning to get one next year when the lease on my Nissan Leaf is up. However, I really dislike how leather seats are bundled with other options on cars nowadays. I do not want leather seats. They are annoying to maintain and easily damaged by my big dogs. I'm really hoping there's some way I can order a Bolt with the other options (especially heated seats) and no leather seats, but there probably isn't.
- k26dr 10y agoIs it possible to heat non-leather seats without a fire hazard?
- syntheticnature 10y agoNot the person to whom you're replying, but I've looked at multiple cars with factory heated, non-leather seats, so I would assume so.
- Kadin 10y agoGM has heated cloth and leatherette seats on many of its trucks. I think the decision to package heating and leather together is for marketing reasons, not because of any technology-compatibility issues. (They're both "premium" options and bundling them together makes sense if you are constructing a multi-thousand-dollar package.)
- Someone1234 10y agoLeather seats have the same padding below them as non-leather. It isn't a solid chunk of leather, just a leather outer layer. So in answer to your question the fire hazard of both is identical and many MANY vehicles with non-leather seats have seat warmers (including mine).
- ebbv 10y agoOf course. Both of my cars have cloth heats with seat heaters.
- illumin8 10y ago
- nikrdc 10y agoctrl-f "bmw" ctrl-f "i3" surprised no one has pointed out how much this car looks like the BMW i3!
- robterrell 10y agoi3 driver here. IMO, the Bolt looks better. And true four doors instead of suicide doors makes a big difference for the kids (mine still can't remember which door closes first.) It looks like a normal car. As it should. Can't wait for the days of auto manufacturers bashing their EVs with the ugly stick to end.
- bluehawk 10y agoDang, just looked up the suicide doors. That's... interesting. The driver and passenger seatbelts look like they are attached to the rear doors, so when you pick up someone, and they get in the back, you have to unbuckle so they can open the door. Are the major car companies even trying to make reasonable electric cars? They all look so weird and have weird design decisions that make me not want to buy them at all.
- robterrell 10y agoIt's improving. The Golf EV and Fiat 500e are basically the same exteriors and interiors with EV drivetrains. The Mercedes 250B EV looks extremely normal. I believe Ford has some normal-looking EV options. But BMW went all-in on a new platform and new materials, and that led them to the suicide doors. I don't think there's any excuse for the front end, though.
- bduerst 10y agoReally? It looks more like Ford's CMax Hybrid: http://www.cmaxownersclub.co.uk/uploads/1/new-cmax.jpg http://www.cmaxownersclub.co.uk/uploads/1/new-cmax.jpg
- 35bge57dtjku 10y ago"sharknado"
- dmalvarado 10y ago> "EVs often require a warm-up period before they can deliver maximum regen braking. Tesla gives the driver a warning when full regenerative braking is unavailable. Chevrolet doesn’t do so. This can be alarming to the driver who lifts off the right pedal expecting significant deceleration and gets virtually none" Whoa, inconsistent brake feel? That's kind of terrifying. You'd think Chevy would calibrate the brake feel across states.
- andrewtbham 10y agoit's not brake feel... it's the feel off the accelerator. when you let of the accelerator in a Tesla, it doesn't coast, it's like letting of the trigger of an electric drill.. it quickly grinds to a halt. it's strange to get used to at first but you get the feel by the end of a test drive. it is strange to still be pressing the accelerator as you pull up behind a car at a red light. this weird feel is one of the problems that halted tesla's collaboration with toyota on electric rav4 drivetrains.
- birdmanjeremy 10y agoDo you have a source on the last part? The rav4 EV has an aggressive regen mode, it's just not the default state of the 'transmission'.
- andrewtbham 10y agohttp://insideevs.com/insight-toyota-tesla-partnership-marred-clashes-engineers/ http://insideevs.com/insight-toyota-tesla-partnership-marred... Toyota’s rejection of Tesla’s proprietary regenerative braking system, as it enabled the system upon release of the accelerator which Toyota felt was too abrupt and disconcerting for their customers. Any adjustment meant opening up and sharing either Tesla or Toyota’s “code” – of which neither was willing to do
- birdmanjeremy 10y agoThanks. That sucks, the Rav4 EV really is a great car. It's too bad it exists in such small numbers.
- programminggeek 10y agoThat's a lot to pay for a car. I bought a used 2001 Mitsubishi Gallant 10 years ago and it still is a solid daily driver. I think I paid $7,000 or so for it. Perhaps in 5 years a used Bolt will be a sensible purchase. Until then, I'll let everyone else buy them new and pay the depreciation for me.
- ams6110 10y agoYep, $7-$8K is my market for cars. You may have to look around a bit but you can find something well-cared for, reliable, and with many years of life left for that money.
- programminggeek 10y agoHere's my little trick... My brother used to sell used cars and a good friend runs a couple small dealerships nearby. I call him when I need a car, tell him what kind, how much, what features and he goes out and finds one at auction for me. It takes a month or so, but I always end up with a great deal. If you know someone who can do that for you, it's a great deal for you and an easy sale for them.
- vpeters25 10y agoI wonder if anybody close to the auto industry could shed some light as to whether there are engineering reasons behind what appears to be a deliberate effort to make their EVs look as ugly as possible.
- maxerickson 10y agoI imagine much of it is that cargo space still helps sell small cars.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chiph 10y agoAerodynamics. Mercedes had a concept car in 2005 that was modeled after a fish Ostracion cubicus, which supposedly has the lowest coefficient of drag found in nature. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercedes-Benz_Bionic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercedes-Benz_Bionic
- aembleton 10y agoThat looks very much like the original Honda Insight https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c9/HondaInsight.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c9/HondaIns...
- XJOKOLAT 10y agoAgreed, I just spent 5 minutes perusing the threads here ... talking about range and charges and base price ... I support electric, and my next car -will- be electric .. but at the end of the day. this car is as ugly as hell. I'll support it only to the support the industry and more entrants.
- csours 10y agoThere is one front end shape that supports both aerodynamic constraints and safety considerations; that is why the front of pretty much every vehicle looks the same. Only trucks look really different, and that is because most truck buyers would eviscerate any truck that looks like a car. For the back end of this car, it is good to know that the battery pack looks something like this ____==== . It is slimmer in the front, and taller in the back. The rear must be taller to allow any room for rear passengers and cargo. Additionally, the whole industry is moving from sedans to crossover/SUVs, and the Bolt EV is indicative of that As for the styling cues, there are a lot a people who still want to remind people that they own and drive an environmentally friendly car. I don't know if I just got used to it, or if they changed it extensively, but the styling of the production vehicles seems muted compared to the pre-prod vehicles. Can you point to any particular styling cues or reason you think the vehicle is ugly? (I work for GM, but not on this program)
- gkfasdfasdf 10y agoNo autopilot?
- esaym 10y agoI think I'll stick with my 2000 Ford mustang with 220k miles. The syncros in the transmission are mostly out, so I have to double clutch to down shift, but that just makes me feel more in control. Plus I can do awesome burn outs when ever I feel like it.
- EdHominem 10y agoI doubt your Mustang can smoke the tires at 80+ mph. Test drive a Tesla. Also, while we grew up thinking of gas engine sounds as powerful, after driving an EV gas engines just sound like angry lawn-mowers. People in their hot cars seem like kids with playing cards in their bike spokes.
- esaym 10y agoAt least for the next 10 years of my life, I don't think I would ever pay more than $10k for a car (used of course). And unless I wreck my current car, I'll probably still be driving it in 10 years. And if the Tesla can smoke tires, I'm sure they'll release a software patch to "fix" that in the future.
- bjourne 10y ago> Those who venture farther afield will find that the charging network is the one arena where Chevrolet is still handily outscored by Tesla. Can't the same charging stations be used for different brands of cars? Seems wasteful if each manufacturer has to build their own network.
- peter303 10y agoRemember this is GM's third generation EV, so they have a lot of experience, but not the volume of Telsa (yet). The first generation lead battery was almost mythological- loved by their customers but hated by GM. GM was probably losing a fortune on each leased.
- mikeyouse 10y ago> Remember this is GM's third generation EV, so they have a lot of experience, but not the volume of Telsa (yet). GM is definitely at about the same volume as Tesla -- They've sold ~130,000 Volts / Amperas, maybe ten thousand Spark EVs, and a few thousand Cadillac ELRs.. As of the end of Q3, Telsa has sold 160,000 total vehicles, so GM and Tesla are likely within ~10%-15% of each other in total EV sales.
- bit_logic 10y agoThis will be an unpopular opinion, but I think it's too early to push full BEV cars. I think the perfect car now is the plugin hybrid and this is what the industry should be pushing across all types (SUV/CUV, small car, mid-size, etc.) Reasons are: * Supercharger can charge at 1.2kWh per minute. (90kWh/75minutes). That means a 10kWh battery can be charged in about 8 minutes which is comparable to a typical gas station time. * Many plugin hybrids have about a 10kWh battery that gets about 25-30 mile EV range. * The battery in one Tesla (90 kWh) could be used to build 9 plugin hybrid cars. Since the battery is so much smaller, the additional car price is also much less. * Big improvement for the environment. The US likes SUVs. And many car trips are short distance (getting groceries, going to school, etc.) If these can be covered by the battery, then the impact of the low-mpg SUV is much reduced. * Ironically, it would allow a business opportunity for gas stations. Imagine a EV quick charge cable right next to the gas pump. Fill the up the gas tank and quick charge the 10kWh battery at the same time. * It would be a good fit for those without garages (such as apartments). The EV part of the car is simply a nice to have. The charging is quick enough to do it at those charging stations at supermarkets, workplaces, etc. But it's ok if they can't find any empty EV parking spots, the gas engine will get them home.
- sheer_horror 10y agoDon't bother with hybrids if all of the shortcomings are covered with gasoline. A good EV or a good gasoline car are both better than a hybrid, so what is the point? Who wants to buy a car that is heavier and slower than their full gas and full electric counterparts? It's always too late to push for something that is just a bad product.
- Kadin 10y ago> A good EV or a good gasoline car are both better than a hybrid, so what is the point? I don't think this is true. A plug-in hybrid will always have an advantage over a gasoline car, in that it can do short trips without starting the gas engine at all. So for repeated short trips, it acts like a BEV. But unlike a BEV, there's no range limitation or worrying about where to find a charging station. I've thought fairly hard about a pure BEV and I can't see myself getting one except as an additional vehicle. But I could see getting a plug-in hybrid like the Volt in the near future. Anecdotally, all the people I know who are seriously considering BEVs are buying them as second or third cars. There's certainly a market, but I think it's going to saturate pretty quickly, because a lot of people don't want to have one vehicle for known-distance commuting and then another vehicle for unknown-distance or long trips. While these trips may represent a small percentage of driving in terms of actual mileage, they're enough to shape the choice of cars. (E.g. someone may not drive to grandma's house out in the sticks more than a few times a year, but if the car can't handle that drive, it's not going to get purchased, period.)
- ryandrake 10y agoWhat gets me is the subsidies going to buyers of these expensive new cars. Of all the things the public can spend taxpayer money on, we pick luxuries for (by and large) already-well-off people. California has mitigated this to a degree by making their state subsidy means-tested: [1], which is a good first step. 1: http://arstechnica.com/cars/2015/07/electric-vehicles-incentives-work-but-not-without-consequences/ http://arstechnica.com/cars/2015/07/electric-vehicles-incent...
- bluthru 10y agoCarbon doesn't care about what class it comes from. Tesla would have never gotten off the ground if rich people didn't give them money. Now we have the Model 3 to look forward to thanks to people buying luxury cars.
- Gibbon1 10y agoTesla did the right thing considering, they built a toy that wealthy people wanted. That opened a lot of doors for them.
- Kadin 10y agoThere's a public benefit to those subsidies in that it's creating a marketplace for electric cars that probably wouldn't have otherwise existed. Who buys them is largely immaterial. It would be nice if the funds for the subsidy came directly from fuel-carbon taxes, but those sort of revenue earmarks are mostly for appearance's sake anyway.
- mikeash 10y agoIt's meant to jumpstart the market. The federal subsidies begin to phase out once the manufacturer sells 200,000 qualifying vehicles. That means that the total cost of the subsidies, in the grand scheme of things, is not all that high.
- Gibbon1 10y agoSounds like the government is saying, we'll pay 200,000 cars X $7500/car -> $1.5 billion to help fund electric vehicle development. This is like $5 per capita (1.5X10^9 divided by 300,000 people) over 2-3 years. I'm having trouble getting upset.
- iandanforth 10y agoInterested in an EV but think $30k is a bit pricey? A 2013, 2014 and even 2015 Nissan LEAFs can be had for $9-11K. I just bought a 2015 Nissan LEAF (S trim) which adds many of the features of the higher SV trim from 2013/2014. Total price at 26k miles? $11,200 (with tax and fees in CA). Not a solution for the long distance folks, but for my 46 mile round-trip commute, I can charge each evening on 110 and don't worry about going out to dinner or other side trips I want to add to my day.
- cpursley 10y agoWhat was your average max range when required with 26k on the clock?
- thecodemonkey 10y agoWe did the same thing. 2014 Nissan Leaf had about 18k miles on it, still had full battery capacity (no "lost" bars). The range is just north of 80 miles.
- cpursley 10y agoThat's very compelling. Maybe I'll wait until there's some used Bolts on the market.
- iandanforth 10y agoOn full charge the car estimates a range of 90 miles. That assumes eco mode and my driving style. It's a guess at best. The battery is at full health, I didn't consider buying a car that had a degraded battery.
- csours 10y agoYou are kind of comparing apples to used apples; EVs are currently unproven and have extreme loss of residual value.
- philipkglass 10y agoThis looks like a great deal if you live in Washington and drive daily. Our gasoline prices are second only to California in the continental US (will be #1 if the carbon tax ballot measure passes) but electricity is very cheap here -- I pay less than 7 cents per kWh.
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoWe own a 2016 Volt and a 2016 Tesla P90D. Both are great cars, and I expect the Bolt to kill the "LEAF" market, and take a bite out of the lower-end Tesla market.
- Animats 10y agoSo who wants to go into the charging station business? GM has said they're not going to do it. There's a startup, "EV Oasis", which has a few charging stations in Southern California. Uber, maybe?
- Buge 10y agoWell there's Chargepoint.
- rootusrootus 10y agoI think it's not a perfect replacement for a traditional car yet, but it's an incredible leap forward towards that goal for EVs. We are legitimately close to seeing widespread adoption of EVs by regular folks. My takeaways: 1) Lease! EVs are evolving so rapidly that buying one outright seems unnecessarily risky. Or wait and buy one used for cheap. 2) We really do need standardized charging. If it's free, as I have heard, why doesn't Bolt and other forthcoming EVs support the Tesla Supercharging technology? Being instantly able to leverage that network would be a big deal. 3) The holy grail is going to be 500-700 miles of range, where you can do road trips (goal being a reasonable driving distance per day, not swapping drivers).
- ec109685 10y agoIf the car will be cheap in three years, the lease will be expensive.
- plg 10y agoI'd like the one that's the same color as my cat poo please (always wondered why people buy brown cars)
- linsomniac 10y agoI'm really curious to see how the traditional auto companies do with electric cars. Tesla owns the dealers, Chevy has a network of dealers that are used to making significant money on service. According to Edmunds, 44% of a dealers profit comes from service. Losing 44% of your profit is going to be a big deal to a lot of dealers. I'm wondering if the Tesla model that so many dealer networks have been battling will be required to make the transition to EVs. A manufacturer that has, say, 40% of their dealers dry up is probably going to, for survival sake, start dealing direct. That's my theory anyway.
- ams6110 10y agoThere will still be a good bit of service work. Crash repair/body work, brakes, tires, air conditioning, random little faults like switches and sensors and fans, etc.
- linsomniac 10y agoThere will definitely be service work, but I'm expecting it is going to be a lot lower frequency than with a traditional ICE car. I mean, I have a really good relationship with my Audi service guy... Don't get me wrong. But I'd prefer to do less chatting that ends with a thousand dollar plus invoice.
- chx 10y agoI am looking at all these calculations here on HN and can't stop thinking "in 30 years all of this is gone. just gone." there won't be individuals owning cars any more. Mostly. If not 30, 50. Doesn't matter.
- pcurve 10y agohopefully I'll still have my current 2014 mazda 3 manual tranny hatch in my garage 30 years from now. It will be a classic. ;)
- chx 10y agoYou might have it but the insurance will be so high for a human driven vehicle you won't have it and then you don't want to drive on a public road. I am pretty sure it'll be insurance who will drive this change.
- Tempest1981 10y agoSo many binary arguments: it's better, no it's worse. It won't work for me. Just want to point out that it's a continuum -- both in people that the technology is well suited for, and at this point in time in 2016. The technology will continue to evolve. There are early adopters, late adopters, and some clinging to their V8s.