13 ms·
How 2K Killed Irrational Games
- dogma1138 10y agoSWAT 4 didn't sell that well tbh, Tribes Vengeance was pretty bad and Vivendi stopped supporting the game 6 months after it's release, it was primarily a multiplayer only game and received only 1 patch, and Freedom Force was a joke. It's also should be noted that Ken Levine is somewhat known to be hard to work with, there was a fall out with Vivendi/Sierra and there were issues with employees leaving Irrational after having fights with him (you can find various posts on industry forums) which also lead to Nate Wells (Executive Art Director) leaving Irrational for Naughty Dog.
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoand Freedom Force was a joke What was wrong with Freedom Force? City of Heroes, it was not, but it was a fun little game. It also had a great modding community before the cease-and-desist orders from Marvel started. Scored well critically, too: http://www.gamerankings.com/pc/340353-freedom-force/index.html http://www.gamerankings.com/pc/340353-freedom-force/index.ht...
- dogma1138 10y agoScored well yes, so did tribe vengeance (was 80-85%) and SWAT 4 doesn't mean they were a success. P.S. The link is for the original game, FF vs the 3rd Reich was released in 2005.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoIt doesn't meant they were a success, but you said Freedom Force was a joke, and it wasn't. The scores don't prove anything, but support that is wasn't a joke.
- bitwize 10y agoAny game that diesn't sell well and make a lot of money for the studio is a joke.
- lochlainn 10y agoI think this isn't necessarily true, especially in an era where returning to underground/cult IPs that didn't sell well is becoming a more common strategy. Shenmue 2 and Nier were both games that didn't make back nearly enough to support the developers, and yet they both have anticipated sequels on the horizon that devs/fans/news outlets are taking seriously.
- dogma1138 10y agoA joke in that almost no one bought it and it's utterly forgotten, look at the Wikipedia entries for those titles vs other games ;)
- rexicus 10y agoTribes: Vengeance was awful. Irrational/Vivendi destroyed the franchise and back-stabbed an amazing modding community.
- MrZongle2 10y agoAmen. They could have phoned in a re-skinned/graphically updated Tribes 2 and it would have been an improvement.
- dleslie 10y agoScored well, but of the few people I know who owned it no one finished more than a few levels. It lacked a compelling goo, for me.
- 1123581321 10y agoI played through the entire game in 2004 (the original, not Third Reich.) The ending works pretty well emotionally. There were a few levels that almost got me to quit, though, particularly the underground/ant levels.
- Kurimo 10y agoI played through the whole original Freedom Force when it was originally released. Loved it. Didn't go for the "Third Reich" expansion because I was not super interested in more WW2 sounding stuff at that point and as a youth my gaming budget was quite restrained.
- stryk 10y agoI agree. It was a great VIDEOGAME. Bleeding edge graphics -- nope, but it made up for it in spades with good, fun gameplay. Reminded me (in substance rather than style) of a PC-equivalent to a first-party Nintendo game -- not everything needs to be a sweeping epic of action movie sizzle, or super dramatic story telling. Call me old fashioned, but sometimes I like playing videogames that are games.
- MrZongle2 10y agoI agree about Tribes:Vengeance; a pox on whoever decided the game needed a "prequel" that focused on a single-player mode and ignored all the aspects of the previous two games that made them so great. That entire franchise has suffered since it left the hands of Dynamix. I can't get on board with you regarding Freedom Force, though. While some of the levels were a bit tedious, the character customization and feel of the game was superb. I can't think of another superhero game since (at least, outside of the MMO realm) that allows you that degree of freedom (no pun intended). FF was a decade too early; had it come out in 2012 it could have ridden the Avengers wave.
- jay_kyburz 10y agougg, how did this make it onto the front page of HN. It's been floating around the internet for a few days. I worked at Irrational Games / 2K Australia from Freedom Force right up until shipping Bioshock 2. I was a team lead, producer, and even ran the Australian office for about year before I left to make Neptune's Pride. To me there is nothing really controversial in this article. Running big studios full of people with big personalities is really hard. People didn't get along. Things fell apart.
- MBCook 10y agoI just saw it tonight on Twitter and thought it was interesting. I know nothing in it is terribly unique compared to what other studios have gone through, but I still thought it painted an interesting picture of the inside of the industry and what happens to the individual parts that make up the mega-studios we're all used to. This person is obviously unhappy, but I'm not suggesting there is a major scandal here.
- andrewflnr 10y agoI thought it was interesting, too, for the same reasons. I'm glad it made the front page.
- jay_kyburz 10y agohaha, yeah, I guess in my mind there were major scandals, but none of them are in the article. ;)
- imdsm 10y agooh you're just gonna put that line out there for us to bite are you? i bet we're getting nothing
- thecatspaw 10y agoof course we're getting nothing, would you risk your career for a few points on here?
- fuqted 10y agoFrom the comments: "...Now to correct one thing, what keeps 2k and Take 2 afloat is Rockstar Games. They produce multimillion dollar games that go on to produce over 700 million dollars from their online mode alone. Their games are the top sellers in their years and even decades. Firaxis Games as of now is a failure of a studio. Years back yes they did develop the wildly successful Civilization 5 which went on to sell over 9 million units and Xcom Enemy Unknown that went on to sell over 3.4 million units. [1] Then they developed Beyond Earth which tanked at 1.4 million and Xcom 2 at .8 million, a game so bad by even it’s supporters admission it needs mods to be playable. Civlization VI is off to a rough start and will probably match Beyond Earth. It hasn’t even broken its first million yet. Given how poorly they are doing, my money on the next studio closure is going to be them if they are not overhauled instead. I have no clue how their capacity to develop has declined so fiercely but sadly it has. On to your question as to how a game can sell 1.7 million units and not be profitable. I’m going to break this down for you, on console sales the publisher only gets on average $27 for every $60 sold. Digital is more profitable at 70% of total sales. For that 1.7 it turned out $45.9 million, give or take a few million. After development and marketing the fact it sold significantly less than Borderlands 2 is why it is considered a failure. You sold 14% of what Borderlands 2 did. Worse and I am going to give you the consumers perspective on this, the game is god awful. For starters it story is loaded with virtue signaling, but that’s only a minor annoyance. What truly cans it is the fact it is either the Pre Sequel is canon or 2 and the books are canon. That’s how atrociously written the presequel was. Even the voice actor of Handsome jack sounded miserable spewing out those out of character lines. The game was received so poorly that within months it was being bundled with Borderlands 2 to desperately sell units. While I understand that development on The bureau wasn’t your fault it also was atrocious. I must say I loved their original version of the game that was first shown off. The final red flag for the games low quality should have been the YOLO trailer, but sadly I still purchased it, much to my regret. Autralias other projects aren’t exactly well recieved. At best they are controversial, Bioshock 2 is hated by half the community at least, CodShock was an embarassment that alienated the entire original audience for the game and came with a story only the greatest of idiots thought was intelligent that ultimately damage the continuity of any future Bioshock games going forward in the manner of public perception. It sold well on the hype of Bioshock in the Sky, instead it was Call of Duty with color. I understand that people put a lot of passion and work into those games, but that doesn’t make them by default good or profitable. Thanks for giving us insights into what transpired though. Even if they are through tinted lenses it is always great to see insights into what transpires behind closed doors inside the industry."
- shard972 10y agoWhy is it so hard to run a tech company in Australia? Some days it feels like I either need to start my own company to find out or just leave this country to find job with a career.
- girvo 10y ago> Why is it so hard to run a tech company in Australia A number of reasons, I think. Our terrible internet, the lack of support from the state governments (and the lack of _understanding_ of our industry for those governments that are trying; see: QLD), an investor base that (after spending the last 7 years navigating it) appear to be desperately afraid of B2C start-ups, and don't quite get B2B start-ups either... the list goes on, really. Not going to stop me trying, though!
- jfoutz 10y agoYou'd think Atlassian leaving and being really vocal about it would have helped. 6 billion dollar company now.
- jay_kyburz 10y agoWhat makes you think it's any harder than anywhere else? Part of 2K Australia's problem was that we grew very big when the Aussie dollar was low, then when it came back up we were a very expensive studio. We had very little turnover and a lot of well paid, senior developers made us look even more expensive per head. We were working closely with 2K China who were a lot cheaper per head.
- programminggeek 10y agoNOTE: Don't make the company you work for your life. It will end in sadness.
- jay_kyburz 10y agoTerrible advice. The highs and lows are what make life intresting. Be passionate about what you do and give it your all. Make it personal. Give a damn. It's the only way to live.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoTerrible advice! Unless you have equity (and even then it must be a large amount), you are a cog that can be replaced at will, trading X hours per week of your life that you won't ever get back for your currency of choice. Give a damn and make it personal: about your growth, your compensation, and your career path. If you want passion, work towards financial security and then work on something fulfilling, where you control your destiny. No one is looking out for you but you. Source: 15 years in tech, also watching a friend lose everything (EDIT: friends from 80+ hour weeks, job and house when let go) when High Voltage Studios (a game studio in Illinois) started its decent into failure
- jay_kyburz 10y agoUgg no! Are saying is that unless you can afford to start your own company you should not care about what you do all day every day? Absolutely agree that you need to be thinking about your own growth and compensation, but let's be honest, your growth probably going to happen inside somebody elses company, I don't think you should let that hold you back on enjoying every day and trying to be the very best at whatever it is that you do. I would argue you should not put off passions for some future day. Life is short. Be passionate today. I dont know how your friend "lost everything" when High Voltage went bust. Did he go to jail or something?
- xeromal 10y agoYou might want to look at the OP you replied to. They've cut their teeth on game making.
- shmerl 10y agoStill waiting for Bioshock Infinite to come out on GOG (or any Bioshock games for that matter). But 2K aren't interested in more sales it seems.
- gruez 10y agoHow much extra sales can you really get from DRM-free sales years after the fact?
- shmerl 10y agoAny amount means profit. Is there any sensible reason not to release them DRM-free? Besides psychological / political ones (like 2K being scared of DRM-free conceptually), I don't see any reasons.
- gozur88 10y agoMaybe they're still making money on Steam?
- shmerl 10y agoHow does it prevent them from making more money? It doesn't really answer the question why they can't release it on GOG. Most of those games are in the phase where people who never played them buy them because they got interested in them. So it means it's not a huge, but at the same time stable influx of sales, since there are always people interested in good classic games. So selling them as wide as possible only brings them additional profit.
- debaserab2 10y agoThe people like yourself who are specifically holding out for a DRM-free version aren't a significant enough percentage of the market to care about. Everyone else will just buy it on Steam.
- partycoder 10y agoUsually acquired studios pay for the mistakes of their parent companies. I don't know to which point it is a good idea to acquire a profitable company for millions of dollars, to set it for failure and then close it.
- gspetr 10y agoFunny how the article mentions Bureau as the point where it all came crashing down. I actually quite liked the game. The problem I think is that there was a market mismatch with that title. XCOM 2012 caught a lot of flak for it being too different from the 1994 original. Only brilliant execution made it possible for it to succeed. An XCOM TPS (Which is what Bureau is, to a degree) is just too much of a stretch, most of XCOM's audience are not that open minded unfortunately. I believe that ultimately the aforementioned market mismatch was too difficult to overcome, even without the publisher's interference and micromanagement.
- eksemplar 10y agoI grew up with the original x-com and terror from the deep, and regularly play them to this day. I personally didn't mind the FPS/third person shooter bit, and I think it even felt a lot more "under invasion" and scary than the x-com remakes. So I actually liked it, but because it was so poorly made technically I never bothered to Finnish it. Maybe I'll force my way through it one day, because of the story and atmosphere, but it's frankly one of the worst pieces of gameplay I've ever tried.
- gspetr 10y agoThe latter part of the game is tedious but in the end I think it was worth it as I was pleasantly surprised by the ending. Did not see that one coming.
- violentvinyl 10y ago> So I actually liked it, but because it was so poorly made technically I never bothered to Finnish it. Maybe I'll force my way through it one day, because of the story and atmosphere, but it's frankly one of the worst pieces of gameplay I've ever tried. I'm a bit late to the party here, but this is where "Let's Play" videos on YouTube are really great. You can get all the bits you want without any of the frustrating gameplay. The trick is just to find a YouTuber you can stand for the duration of the video (Nerd Cubed is one of my favourites, but he would be an acquired taste).
- Sacho 10y ago
- gilgoomesh 10y agoThis article quotes sales numbers in the millions and asserts that this means games like Bioshock Infinite were "hugely profitable". That's not necessarily true. Bioshock Infinite in particular was "disappointing" compared to projections: http://www.p4rgaming.com/take-two-in-retrospect-ken-levines-200m-projected-bioshock-infinite-sales-was-fairly-unrealistic/ http://www.p4rgaming.com/take-two-in-retrospect-ken-levines-... 2K posted losses in the hundreds of millions in the year leading up to Bioshock Infinite's release (Bioshock would have been a significant percentage of that) and continued to lose money in the year of its release: http://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2013-05-13-bioshock-infinite-hits-3-7-million-boosts-take-two-sales http://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2013-05-13-bioshock-in... People often ignore that these games may cost over a $100 million to develop and the same again to market (Bioshock Infinite ads were everywhere). Selling 5 million copies might only net $100 million back again (after taxes and other distribution costs).
- throwwit 10y agoHas the games industry adopted Hollywood Accounting? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting
- pcr0 10y agoI'd say it qualifies as Hollywood Accounting if the revenue exceeds the budget and yet the project is still deemed unprofitable. I haven't really heard of this in the games industry. Typical Hollywood Accounting is when companies make up overhead figures. But in the games industry the costs seem too transparent to be able to get away with posting fictious overheads as most of the cost is dominated by marketing and salaries.
- shinymark 10y agoIf it exists anywhere it would be in third party publishing deals where the developer takes an advance on royalties with the possibility of more royalties if the project is profitable. I've been involved in a few deals like this and although I have no proof of Hollywood Accounting I've had my suspicions.
- lazyjones 10y agoA minor issue: Borderlands 2 sold 12 million copies (as of 2015). Borderlands: the Pre-Sequel was quite disappointing compared to it (both sales and reviews) and it seems to be mostly based on Borderland 2's code. So at least part of its short development time and small team can be attributed to it not having been written from scratch.
- Thimothy 10y agoYeah. I've been a fan of the Borderlands franchise since the first game and I couldn't believe the guy had the courage of pointing to the pre-sequel as a success. It felt over-extended, and it should have been cut to a third, at most, and sold as a DLC for Borderlands 2. While the Borderlands 2 and most its DLCs have been really fun and great value for the money, the pre-sequel has left me wary of the 2k shenanigans around the franchise. Won't make the mistake of pre-ordering again.
- yen223 10y agoStarting a studio in Canberra seems like a peculiar choice. Canberra doesn't have the population, nor the standards of living needed to attract tech talent. It isn't even a cheap city to live in.
- NumberCruncher 10y ago>> the team was so huge and unwieldy that he (Ken) wanted to go back to basics and build a game with a skeleton crew like in the old days That happens not only in the gaming industry. An approach that works on the small scale may not work on the large scale. If you are small you are forced to take care about your product, customers and employees (maybe not in this order). If you are at a big corp you have to deal with people who only care about company politics and the ego-game, even if you do not care about these things.
- Pica_soO 10y agoI m trying to see the other side of this whole affair. Usually buisness-leaders, expect a royal household to form around them, who is rewarded on perceived loyalty. Now creative personal, can be "unsettling" from that perspective, it might be not that extreme in the video games industry as on the theater-stage, but from the CEO-medieval perspective, the constant fluctuation of signals might seem like betrayal and back-stabbing. Reaction would be the exactly wrong approach- getting more involved and keeping a tighter control on everything, resulting in content, where the more "extreme" fluctuating personal is leashed. Now the resulting product would miss the extremes, which is exactly what attracts the audience in the first place.
- alias_neo 10y agoAs much as I love the Bioshock series, I take all of the figures with a pinch of salt considering I, presumably not alone in this, own at least 3 copies of each on various platforms. I'm also about to buy the remastered for PC, just because. The sad part is that the real people who made these great games will see none of this continued income.
- ebbv 10y agoWhy would that make you take the numbers with a pinch of salt? It doesn't matter that you bought 3 copies, they sold 3 copies. The numbers are still accurate for copies sold, they aren't claiming active players or something, there's no subscription fees here.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Paul_S 10y agoList of studios bought by ea. Orange ones are the ones they closed down officially but a lot of them exist only in name. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_acquisitions_by_Electronic_Arts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_acquisitions_by_Electr... Buying a studio 9/10 is the end of its existence in any meaningful way.
- SXX 10y agoLarge publishers like EA and Ubisoft always operated differently compared to other companies. Smaller companies usually just hire contractors or use 3rd party companies to work on their projects since they can't afford to employ someone to work on concept art, audio or voice over full time. Large publishers able to keep employees even if they have months between different projects. Still they move people around their subsidiaries and projects a lot since in game development most of staff only work on certain part of project for limited time. So closing isn't always mean someone was fired at all and in same time any acquired studio might be soon only exist on paper since all people might be working in different studios on different projects.
- skizm 10y agoThis was written 4 days ago and says Bioshock Infinite sold 4.3 million units, yet the Wikipedia page says it has sold 11 million copies. Where is the disconnect? Seems like a huge discrepancy. Is "units" normalized to full price or something where "copies" just total games sold even at sale price? That is the only guess I could come up with.
- Kurimo 10y agoThe number cited in the article is probably limited to a certain release-based window.