6 ms·
What about those of us who don't have internal voices?
by StavrosK 10y ago
What about those of us who don't have internal voices?
- a_humean 10y agoI've identified a Philosophical Zombie. Someone contact the nobel committee, for I have refuted Physicalism. I knew your kind would finally let it slip. I jest! http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/zombies/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/zombies/
- StavrosK 10y agoHuh?
- eivarv 10y agoWhat does inner voices have to do consciousness or sentience?
- StavrosK 10y agoI wonder if deaf-mute people have them.
- n0us 10y agonot sure about deaf-mute people but https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosopagnosia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosopagnosia is an area of interest for people who study philosophy of mind
- grownseed 10y agoPerhaps not quite the answer you're after, but I was deaf as a child, though I was able to hear as a toddler and had therefore been exposed to spoken language before going deaf. I absolutely had inner voices while I was deaf, to a practically debilitating degree. The isolation inherent to deafness caused me to have strong inner dialogues, to develop a full world inside my head. I would often "go away" in my head, to the point that I was completely detached from and unresponsive to the physical world. It's apparently very unsettling to people standing right by you. My grandfather used to be fascinated by it, he'd say that I'd gone to my secret garden and that it was ok to leave me alone. Even after recovering my hearing years later, I kept this habit (whether it's good or bad is debatable). Over the years I developed a better hang of it and I can now trigger it mostly at will. The level of introspection that came with all this is rather hard to explain, though for all my quirks, I don't regret it one bit.
- StavrosK 10y agoHmm, that's interesting. Was it voice as we know it, i.e. sounds? Inner voices are usually "sounds" instead of, say, images, but if you were deaf, what sounds did you know? Or was it because you could hear as a toddler?
- armitron 10y agoRather than getting into dualism or non-intuitive philosophy/metaphysics, it's better to view humans as philosophical zombies from the get-go. Consciousness is not something we possess from birth, but a self-model that gradually emerges as the organism's cybernetic interactions with the environment increase. It then follows that any process that could disrupt this would lead to people with a not fully-developed sense of self or in other words partial PZombies.
- projektir 10y agoI strongly disagree that it's better since that's effectively implying solipsism and that there are no ethical considerations for doing bad things to people since they, well, don't really exist as agents-that-can-feel-things. Regardless of how hard it is to describe philosophically, and what kind of terms one tries to use, the fact that we process things we feel is the reality of our existence and it drastically modifies how we act.
- voxic11 10y agoWhy do you think entities without consciousness are not worthy of ethical consideration? Most animals and even human babies don't have it but most people still make a big deal about their ethical treatment.
- projektir 10y agoI don't. I think there's a conflation where "zombie" is interpreted as "lacking consciousness". But the description I'm seeing in the Encyclopedia, as well as LW's definition and my own definition is closer to "entity that doesn't process what they feel" (doesn't feel what they process? Sees blindly? Blargh). > by definition there is ‘nothing it is like’ to be a zombie Non-conscious animals are still often perceived as processing feelings and therefore capable of the concept of suffering. You could try imagining being a simple animal, even if it's as simple as a single signal that goes 1 and 0. Zombies don't process any feelings and ethical consideration in their address wouldn't make much sense, it's like being concerned with the ethics relating to a sun or a hydroelectric dam.
- Filligree 10y agoVoiceless people, represent! I had a long discussion on this subject over on Lesswrong, back in the day. Suffice to say that a lot of people have trouble imagining it's even an option.
- gm-conspiracy 10y agoCan you speed read?
- Joof 10y agoIt would have to be. People didn't start out with language, but could undoubtedly think. I'm fairly mixed, probably like the majority. Some things are images or words and occasionally just ideas (although I'm not certain how to describe that).
- StavrosK 10y agoI know exactly what you mean. It's that process where an idea just forms, wordlessly, and you just "know" it now. Sometimes I start narrating it to myself, but then stop mid-way, realizing it's pointless, since I already know it.
- cairo_x 10y agoDo you prefer non-fiction to fiction? I find non-fiction way easier to read without a voice, and certain kinds of fiction require a voice (somewhat).
- Filligree 10y agoFiction. And yes, when reading fiction I can generally hear the characters' voices when they're speaking; this is somewhat deliberate, as I find it improves immersion. But I don't really have one of my own.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoIt happens - though it is hard for me to imagine. Mine is pretty active - I think in words, and can get into an inner monologue that is basically narrating what I do. But my spouse doesn't have that - it seems to be a foreign concept to him. I think some folks think more in pictures or sounds and other such things.
- StavrosK 10y agoI can get into an inner monologue too, but, more often than not, I realize that it's going on, think "this is useless, I already know what I'm thinking" (wordlessly) and stop it.
- dmd 10y agoYeah. I have a lot of trouble imagining what it would be like to have what they're describing.
- gm-conspiracy 10y agoCan you speed read?
- StavrosK 10y agoI used to have one when I was younger, it's just like talking to yourself all the time, only inside your head.
- praveer13 10y agoSame here, I think I had it too when I was a kid..I wonder if my excessive internet use drowned my internal voice or something else.
- ourmandave 10y agoWhat I wouldn't give for a Mute button some days. You know that Good Will Hunting scene, "It's not your fault"? I wake up to my inner voice saying, "It's all your fault. It's all your fault."
- bbctol 10y agoI don't think in words that often, but when I do, it's usually just the word "Stupid." on repeat.
- gm-conspiracy 10y agoCan you speed read?
- StavrosK 10y agoYes, but that's a bit orthogonal (I don't think it has to do with not having/using an inner voice). I could since I was young, which made the teachers irritatedly think I was joking when I was done before the rest of the class were a third of the way into the text.
- GrinningFool 10y agoWhich inevitably leads to additional questions probing your actual comprehension. Fortunately, after a few weeks in each grade, I found that teachers did tend to accept it. After sufficient probing attempts that felt like they were trying publicly disgrace me for claiming to have read the material but not actually doing so...
- gm-conspiracy 10y agoSo, how did you learn to read or sight words?
- GrinningFool 10y agoSight words were a new concept to me when I saw that's what they were using to teach my son, so I have to assume it was standard reading. I don't have a clear memory one way or the other though, so I can't be sure.
- StavrosK 10y agoWith me, they wouldn't even bother, they'd just say "stop joking around and read", so I just re-read the whole thing, more slowly.
- lostcolony 10y agoThat...is a fascinating question. Usually when dealing with verbal thought, it turns into voices in my head, unlike the OP. That might be why while I can read pretty fast, I still can only do so about carnival barker or auctioneer speed, rather than faster than speech. I could be automatically limited in my rate of comprehension due to how it's being processed, still as a 'voice', rather than visuals that map directly to concepts. I would -love- to see survey results on that, whether people had tried to speed read, if, having tried, they succeeded, and whether they tend to/ever have an 'internal voice' in their minds when thinking
- TeMPOraL 10y agoGet a wireless camera, wireless headset, big powerbank and even bigger data plan, and I'll happily narrate your life for you ;).
- StavrosK 10y agoHaha, I might just take you up on that. I've always wanted a narrator, he wrote in the comment box.
- c3534l 10y agoHave you tried drinking way too much coffee?
- joeldg 10y agoWhen I found out people to talk to themselves in their thoughts I was blown away. I absolutely do not understand it.