16 ms·
Let me do a mini-askHN: I'm thinking of joining Twitter to work on their anti-abuse efforts. What factors should I consider in my decision? At first considerat
by wpietri 10y ago
Let me do a mini-askHN: I'm thinking of joining Twitter to work on their anti-abuse efforts. What factors should I consider in my decision?
At first consideration, this news doesn't worry me a ton. They provide a product that provides a lot of user value, just to a smaller user base than they/investors hoped. They've found a reasonable way to monetize it, with $2b+/year in revenue. Their expenses are too high for that, but not egregiously so, with previously committed stock compensation being a big chunk of things. There's still a lot they can do with the product. And they've got a unique value that's hard for other people to replicate: it's the place for public figures (public figures at all scales) to interact.
Am I crazy here? I know I'm taking a risk, but I'm not seeing more risk than, say, joining a Series A startup, which I've happily done before.
- harryh 10y agoIt seems like you are in the stage of your career where you are mostly making decisions based on who you want to work with and what interests you. So, if this meets those criteria, you should do it. That being said: A) I think you underestimate how out of wack their expenses are. There is a decent chance that larger cuts will come in the next 12 months. B) Additional cuts, along with internal management turmoil, are likely to effect your day to day job there to some degree. Are you comfortable with your manager changing? With the composition of your team changing? Are you the kind of person that just rolls with this sort of thing or will you find it frustrating as it impedes your ability to plan and execute? If I were you, I'd be asking myself these sorts of questions.
- wpietri 10y agoHi, Harry! (We met at a Scala unconference a while back.) You are a person who knows from turmoil, so I take this advice seriously. You're correct about my motivations; this is a problem I want to work on. After a career in startups I'm more comfortable with turmoil than most, but you're right ability to keep delivering user improvements is very important to me. I suppose the question I have to struggle with is how much this crunch will force positive change versus pathological contraction-cycle chaos. I've seen organizations do both, and from the outside it's hard to guess which one will win out.
- raywu 10y agoHow Twitter handled Greg Gopman's press situation seemed alarming to me. I wonder how much of it is PR vs cost cutting.
- harryh 10y ago(Yes I remember meeting you. I hope you're doing well!) I agree that it's hard to guess how things will go. Predictions are hard, especially about the future. Overall I think that if you go into it with open eyes and are comfortable with the fact that things might not work out the way you hope (but they might!) then it's probably the right thing to do for you. I think you'll get to work on pretty interesting stuff that's very important to the company right now. And if things get too weird/annoying you can always go work somewhere else.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoRe-orgs happen on a yearly basis even in big companies that are stable.
- jamesroseman 10y agoTwitter employee here. Admittedly I work in a remote office and not in HQ, but I've noticed NO day-to-day changes. The work, the management, the atmosphere have all been remarkably consistent despite wild rumors and general craziness. I can't speak to the financials, but this... > Additional cuts, along with internal management turmoil, are likely to effect your day to day job there to some degree. ...is false (in my, and every employee I've spoken to about this, opinion). I'm not saying you shouldn't consider these points, but if you turn down Twitter expressly because you imagine the madhouse inside, I'm here to report no such thing.
- harryh 10y agoYou are a frog in a slowly boiling pot of water. I see that you are a very young employee in a remote office. As such you are more likely than average to be cut in future layoffs. Depending on your financial situation you should possibly be looking for a new job already. You should definitely start looking for a new job when you hit your year cliff next March. It would be a significant career mistake not to.
- aswanson 10y agoGreat objective perspective and advice.
- empath75 10y agoIt takes a few years, but once you're no longer a growth company and the lay offs start up, the company because a less interesting, more stressful place to work. And the best people stop wanting to work there. (See Yahoo, Aol, etc). What's going to happen now is twitter is going to try and trim down their own projects to siphon as much profit as they can from them, and then try to grow by acquisition instead of innovation...
- zump 10y agoSo what? This is happened to every successful startup in existence. A company can't be a startup forever. What it needs to find is a niche which can continue churning out successful products even when the majority of employees are concentrated in the range of 35-50. This is what Microsoft, Intel and Qualcomm do and they're still largely profitable companies.
- kylebgorman 10y agoThat's an interesting problem. But I'm not seeing much upside for you and there's a high chance of being laid off before you get situated.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoYes, cutting jobs is one way to "eye on 2017 profitability" (yeah, right...).
- wpietri 10y agoThe upside for me is mainly personal. I believe Twitter to be an important platform; it's basically become our global public square. But abuse is limiting the depth and richness of the conversation by suppressing speech and driving people off of Twitter. I did anti-abuse work in the early days of web communities and it's something I care about a lot. So the upside for me is the possibility that I can look back in 3-5 years and say, "Wow, our team made a big difference to a lot of Twitter users. They are now participating in ways that weren't safe for them before." I expect that would also have significant positive impact on Twitter as a business. More users and more conversation benefit them, as does maintaining their position as a unique medium for connection. But personally, I'm mainly motivated by impact. As Tron says, "I fight for the users."
- josh2600 10y agoLayoffs hit engineering last in most tech companies but when layoffs happen it's usually last in-first out.
- chiph 10y agoThis is indeed a general rule, but there are oddball cases, like when the firm I was at was acquired and the new owners kept all the back-office staff, but laid-off the developers (the acquisition was for the customer base, not the technology).
- josh2600 10y agoThat's an orthogonal point to working at Twitter :/. Even if Twitter were acquired, there's basically zero chance they'd fire all the engineers.
- chiph 10y agoWhich raises an interesting question - what's the valuable parts of Twitter? Customer base, for sure. Architecture for scalable messaging, absolutely. The rest of it? Not sure.
- josh2600 10y agoThey are able to operate a company at that scale. I think your comment dismisses a lot of very functional people within their organization.
- chiph 10y agoLayoffs/mergers are an unpleasant subject. Someone is always going to lose their job. I've been through it twice now - once survived, once not.
- snowwrestler 10y agoI'd argue that Twitter's brand is among its most valuable assets. It's globally known. Used and promoted by influencers like celebrities, artists, politicians, media, business leaders, activists. It's all over music, TV, media of all types. Heck, an entire movie was made about it. That sort of broad public awareness is very hard for any company to get.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoThis press release seems like damage control/propaganda to me. The company internally is still very much in the shitter, from what I've heard. I'd be cautious. The recruiter you're talking to is probably presenting a "unicorns and sunshine" version of the story.
- insickness 10y agoIt's ridiculous that you are getting downvoted. All news today is talking about how much trouble twitter is in. They are cutting 9% of its workforce.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoThanks for that counter-upvote. Probably remaining Twitter employees at work; in the past, it's been pretty obvious on here that some of my posts have gotten mass downvoted by specific cohorts. The smartest friends that I have that (used to) work there have all already left and moved onto other unicorns. That's generally a bad sign, whenever all the smart people leave.
- jerf 10y agoIn addition to the other fine points, I'd point out that "anti-abuse" is going to be "not revenue generating". I wouldn't expect that team to be very stable. The temptation is probably to try to rationalize how obviously important it is, but that's true of everything in the business so it carries no weight. It's not revenue generating. You don't need to convince me it's revenue generating, you need to convince management, who will be looking at a revenue sheet at the time and seeing negative numbers from that department. It may be shortsighted but companies looking at significant chances of failure in the short term get shortsighted. They have to. That said, as you suggest, the worst case scenario is that you join and then you lose the job, and then you're back to not having a job. If you can tolerate that financially, then it may still be a good risk. But please be sure you can tolerate that financially.
- hyperpape 10y agoI think that depends. Abuse and harassment was mentioned as a major factor that kept the company from selling in the past several months. If upper management isn't willing to give up the possibility of selling, fighting abuse would be an important goal, whether or not it's a cost center. That's not a given, and I agree with braythwayt above that assessing the company's commitment is the most important consideration, but there are strategic reasons they could prioritize it.
- jerf 10y agoSorry, but... yes, that's a great example of the sort of rationalization one is tempted to do. Here's the business reality: On the balance sheet for the abuse team, there are only expenditures. The benefits don't show up on the balance sheet there; there are diffuse, spread throughout the company, and often future-biased (the abuse shut down today may prevent people from leaving next month). It's the same for IT at a bank, customer support staff anywhere, or accountants. No matter how important it may be, it's not revenue generating. And that makes a huge difference in future career prospects. Things that may impact revenue in a year is not important to a company becoming concerned it may not make it to that year. (In Twitter's case, while there will probably be a business entity called Twitter in a year, the thing that might not make it to next year is Twitter-the-unicorn-dream. Going into maintenance mode or being acquired at unfavorable terms, while better than going out of business entirely, is still a failure for the Twitter of today.) I say this as someone who is not really directly revenue generating myself; I'm moving ever more into risk mitigation and management. But the company I'm doing it in is not currently contracting and laying off, but growing. I've got my eye on my own situation, too.
- criddell 10y agoI'd do it. For one, if you can help fix the abuse problem, you would be helping out a lot of people. It sounds like interesting work, I know there are lots of great people at Twitter and if you think you can grow there, I see little downside. At the same time, I wouldn't get too comfortable...
- arethuza 10y agoThe only bit I'd be worried about (and I am prone to these kind of worries, not claiming this is particularly rational) is that "anti-abuse" might not sound revenue generating to a senior manager with a bean-counting perspective.
- lordnacho 10y agoI'd be worried if it was a part of Twitter that wasn't the main product. There's a whole load of things they're doing that don't seem related, and that's probably where the cuts are going to be. Your thing seems safe enough. In any case, you'll be in SF, so not a huge problem finding other work if it goes sour.
- erjjones 10y ago> I'm thinking of joining Twitter to work on their anti-abuse efforts. The abuse issue on their platform is the main issue with most potential buyers. I would imagine by now they have their core services running on auto pilot (minus SAN failures). http://www.businessinsider.com/disney-twitter-acquisition-trolls-abuse-harassment-report-2016-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/disney-twitter-acquisition-tr...
- emodendroket 10y agoI wonder how much that's an honest explanation and how much it's the financials
- zellyn 10y agoI spent five years on the YouTube anti-abuse team. You should also apply there. And where I am now, Square. And Stripe, and Facebook… there are lots of good anti-abuse teams in the industry.
- braythwayt 10y agoIf you are sincerely interested in quashing abuse, and if the risk of being laid off does not frighten you, forget about the numbers and let’s talk about quashing abuse. Twitter gets extremely mixed reviews from people who are the targets of abuse, and I believe I am putting that conservatively. So, what I would ask is not whether they are going to lay me off because they run out of money, but whether I am going to quit because when I get inside, I discover that they are not going to actually do much about it. If Twitter has had a come-to-jesus moment about abuse, and there are no structural obstacles to doing something about abuse, this could be a job where you will one day look back and say, “I was part of the team that turned the corner on Twitter’s biggest problem. I made a difference.” On the other hand, if Twitter doesn’t have quashing abuse in its cultural DNA, or if there are deep structural obstacles to quashing abuse, then you may discover that you cannot actually make a difference. That can be soul-crushing if you are passionate about the work. I am not making a claim one way or the other about where Twitter is with this, I’m just suggesting that if you are motivated by making a difference, the biggest thing to figure out is whether you will actually be able to make a difference. IMO, this matters more than the financial risk.
- grus 10y agoWhat are we even talking about here - "quashing abuse"? Are we talking about going to work deleting spam, statementless insults, etc., literally combating people abusing the platform? Or is it about stopping people abusing other people, deleting hateful comments, and maybe censoring certain ideologies (nazis, etc.)? I'm just wondering what abuse is, and what a twitter moderator's job description even is.
- snowwrestler 10y agoWell that's part of the challenge, isn't it? What constitutes abuse? The GP doesn't say that they're going to be a moderator, BTW. They might be a developer who would be building features that would allow each user to better determine for themselves how to manage abuse. Or tooling that would allow moderators to do a better job of managing abuse complaints. The native feature set is pretty simple right now. A lot of people use Tweetbot for its temporary mute feature, which is not native to Twitter.
- gadders 10y agoAnti-abuse is one thing Twitter does terribly. It would be great if they could have a more politically even-handed approach. // Downvotes - apparently people want Twitter anti-abuse to be less politically impartial.
- Naritai 10y agoMy guess is, your down votes relate to your implicit equation of abuse to politics - as though saying statements that politically disagree with you are abuse.
- bisRepetita 10y agoI find quite interesting that before receiving/taking an offer, you ask such a question in a very public forum, under your real name. I have no idea whether it is good or bad for you, but I am surprised by such a high level of transparency.
- kristianc 10y agoIf Twitter's approach was to can him for asking reasonable questions (even on a public forum) before taking the job, that would be a signal that the opportunity wasn't worth pursuing for me.
- wpietri 10y agoThat did cross my mind, but I couldn't really ask it anonymously. Indeed, 20 minutes after posting, I got a kind and funny Twitter DM from the hiring manager offering to discuss any concerns people here raised. Based on my experience with the people there, I figured they wouldn't mind. You can't really work at Twitter without believing deeply in honest public dialog as a way to solve problems. Indeed, I heard about the job through a retweet and I responded publicly, so for me this has always been public. And it's provided some unexpected benefits. I've already received some great emails from people, including encouraging ones from within Twitter and from people I respect who might want to join me in solving the problem.
- bisRepetita 10y agoThanks for the feedback and closing the loop. +1 for transparency, congrats!
- codezero 10y agoSomewhat unrelated but if you're looking to generalize the stopping abuse problem you may want to check out Smyte: https://www.smyte.com/ https://www.smyte.com/
- snowwrestler 10y agoFrom my perspective it doesn't seem like much of a risk--no more than any other job, and probably less than most. Even if Twitter flames out and gets sold, it's a highly recognizable name, and will be from a long time. It's a name that jumps off the page of a resume. It will help you get through HR filters for a long time to come. And particularly in the anti-abuse space, going to work at Twitter has to be like going to play in the major leagues.
- clydethefrog 10y agoAs long as Twitter's business model is based on revenue growth, you will be interfered whenever your anti-abuse efforts mean interrupting the user growth. All those alt-right bots that popped up during the US election add up nicely to the amount of active users, which result in more advertising revenue. Take that in account and check if your ethics align with that.
- sjreese 10y agoI would say be very worried about layoffs .. Your job will be to program a spell-checker for bad words - At which time your usefulness has ended. Mr. Snowden shows the government is very interested in collecting information on posters. Therefore your next assignment would be identify and write an exit routine to report them. End the end you will be found useless. Because powerful interests like abuse - so the spell-checker dies and the exit grows in very direction.
- nl 10y agoAre they actually serious about doing anything at all about abuse? There's a lot of low-hanging fruit, and it is completely unclear Twitter has attempted to do anything at all about it. If they are serious, then great - you should join. It's a pretty important platform, and it would be great to see it improved.
- h4nkoslo 10y ago"Anti-abuse" in practice is revenue-negative; regardless of whether you think it's a good moral position, kicking people with tons of followers off the platform for starting inter-celebrity drama (or sometimes for no clear reason at all) reduces platform engagement. If they really wanted to, they could provide cost-free tooling that would let people prevent seeing "abusive" tweets (email spam prevention is a solved problem after all), but putting humans in the loop is done so they can decide at a whim the spectrum of acceptable opinion (try merely insulting a Saudi-affiliated account & see how quickly you get banned, now that the KSA owns more of them than Jack does). So given that they're losing money & the position is revenue-negative, the scenarios are: - Bought by Google or somesuch, which has their own robust content filtering teams, making you redundant - Bought by hedge fund as a moneymaking venture, making you redundant I would not sign up.
- wpietri 10y agoThanks everybody for your advice. I've carefully read all of it. And since no less than three people have privately cautioned me about taking advice from HN, let me just say that one of the things I love/hate about HN is that we here are very good at poking holes in ideas. As somebody who has been a daily Twitter user for years, and as somebody who worked on anti-abuse stuff in the early days of web community sites, I'm super excited about possibly helping solve Twitter's abuse problem. Twitter is the closest thing we have to a global public square, and I truly believe that dialog is necessary for us to solve our biggest problems. I would love to make Twitter a hospitable place for many more voices. But I remind myself of the engineer in the classic joke about the guillotine. I worry that my love of solving problems might be causing me to ignore personal risks: http://sethf.com/freespeech/memoirs/humor/guillotine.php http://sethf.com/freespeech/memoirs/humor/guillotine.php So my goal here was not to take the median HN position as gospel, but just to see what concerns people raised. (I could also have asked on Twitter, but there's a bit of selection bias there.) And indeed, many useful concerns were mentioned. So thanks, all!
- throwaway4123 10y agoas a former employee who had the opportunity to sit across the table from some of the execs you read about in the newspapers, let me give you my admittedly skewed perspective. cop catches thieves.But it is not in the interest of cops if they catch ALL thieves. This is not a vaccination program, where if you eliminate polio across the nation, doctors will rejoice because they can now focus on malaria. If there are no thieves at all, the funding for cops will simply drop drastically & cops will be laid off. So cops must catch thieves, and always "appear" to catch even more, but never actually catch all of them. If you had a 100% sanitized feed with no trolls and no spam and no abuse, it would become a plain old communication utility, like a letters to the newspaper column, or weather channel or stock ticker driven finance channel etc. Even in those mediums, the channel programmers throw in sordid details like "most disastrous tornado", "worst all-time hurricane", "sleaziest hedge fund manager" etc. They do that because otherwise it gets too boring and viewership drops. it is very much in the interest of twitter to "appear" to be actively engaged in combating trolls and abuse. but part of its newsworthiness and charm is all this frenzied action around policing abuse and suspending high profile trolls. these things keep the company hip and happening. if you solve the problem for good, there wouldn't be much to cheer about - users may temporarily cheer, but then they'd notice nothing much happening, no controversy, no abuse, no trolls, everything too polite, and soon users will switch to the next racy medium.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- LordHumungous 10y agoYeah. Abuse is a problem for high profile people for the most part, who are an infinitesimal fraction of the user base. For the average Joe with a few hundred followers it really isn't much of an issue. And for the most part public figures continue to use Twitter, despite their grumbling.
- wpietri 10y agoThanks for the comment. The notion that Twitter needs drama about Twitter is interesting, but at first blush I don't think I agree. Most of the drama I see in my feed is about everything else in the world, from global events to small, individual actions. If abuse ends, people will still have plenty to be dramatic about. If Twitter is a reliable communication channel, that strikes me as very good for business. For years, the telephone was an extremely reliable communication channel, so much so that we still talk about "dialtone" as a metaphor for something that just works. But it was insanely profitable. People fell in love and ranted about things via their perfectly boring Western Electric phones and were happy to have them just work. I also don't think "reliable" has much to do with "polite". People can be rude without being abusive, and vice versa. Some of my favorite people are shockingly, colorfully rude, but they are never vicious. Think of a good stand-up act as an example: many comedians get a lot of emotional power from being impolite. But that's very different than, say, picking on an audience member in an attempt to drive them out of the theater. So in this case, I think Twitter and its users all benefit from energetically reducing harassment, death threats, etc. One way to look at it is the venue for a party. At a party, humans provide plenty of entertainment on their own; you don't need a kitchen fire to have a lively and exciting time.
- jwtadvice 10y agoKeep your eye out for abuse from intelligence operations and the State Department. Twitter has been waging a 'battle' against National Security folks for some time with regard to giving them carte blanche ability to pull censorship triggers. I guess to distill that down: if you care about that sort of thing, also consider the ethical quandries your career may put you in.