14 ms·
So in Germany, the interest on a mortgage is non tax deductible. The article doesn't mention it but I understand that property owners are also liable for capita
by cm2187 10y ago
So in Germany, the interest on a mortgage is non tax deductible. The article doesn't mention it but I understand that property owners are also liable for capital gain tax if they hold the property less than 10 years.
I think that makes sense. There is no reason to favor individuals investing into an unproductive investment (property) over productive investments (stocks and bonds, which enable companies to raise money to start new projects, create jobs, etc). Over-borrowing to bid the maximum amount one can to buy a nineteenth century house doesn't create any job for anyone, it just transfers wealth to the hands of the seller.
- camiller 10y agoBuying stock on the open market also doesn't create any job for anyone, it just transfers wealth to the hands of the seller. Basically, unless you are investing in an IPO, the company doesn't see a dime from the ongoing trading of it's stock. So the vast majority of investors are not creating jobs by buying stock. Similarly, most bond investors are not buying new issue bonds, they are buying bonds from the current owner of the bond.
- cm2187 10y agoI am not sure that is true as even for stocks, on the other side you have asset managers, hedge funds or insurance companies who participate both in the primary and secondary markets. Of course, you will have similar bubbles forming in stocks than you have in property. But overall it is a way more productive investment. Bonds barely trade on the secondary markets. When you invest into a fund that buys bond, it's pretty much 100% primary market (i.e. new issuances).
- camiller 10y agoFor property you still have ongoing maintenance to pay for, and real estate agents, and the title company, etc. so there are jobs created due to the buying, selling, and ownership of property. If I by 100 shares of IBM in my self-directed account at Charles Schwab there likely isn't a single human being involved in that transaction after I click the buy button. Granted, somebody wrote the code that drives all of that.
- cm2187 10y agoBut this maintenance would happen anyway whether you own or rent.
- alistairSH 10y agoAt a much slower rate. If the paint in my personal home starts peeling, my incentive to fix it is higher - I don't want to walk down the hall and see peeling paint. If the paint in a corporate-owned tenement starts leaking, what incentive does the corporation have to repair it? They will do the bare minimum to prevent me suing them for breach of contract. A tenant is unlikely to sue over peeling paint. And they actively discouraged from re-painting, as they will likely lose their security deposit should they paint in any color other than generic off-white.
- AjithAntony 10y ago> If the paint in my personal home starts peeling, my incentive to fix it is higher - I don't want to walk down the hall and see peeling paint. > If the paint in a corporate-owned tenement starts leaking LOL. It's the opposite effect. If I own the place, and The paint is peeling, and I have to fix it... then maybe I'll just live with it until it gets worse, or I plan to sell. If it was a rental, then I complain to the landlord to fix.
- alistairSH 10y agoAre you married? Own a house? ;) What incentive does the landlord have to fix minor problems? It costs you more to move/sue than it costs him to sit on the problem.
- AjithAntony 10y agoYeah, not married, so there is not that particular stakeholder motivating cosmetic repairs. As a landlord I want my current and future tenants to respect the valuable asset I have entrusted to them and maintain a good relationship. Fixing the little things is important in a "broken windows theory" way. "the cobbler's children have no shoes"
- philipodonnell 10y agoIn isolation, sure. In aggregate though, increasing demand raises the value of stock, which reduces borrowing costs and encourages companies to expand, which can sometimes create jobs. Not just stock: companies are constantly comparing alternative sources of capital. Any increase in demand from investors for any particular source of capital (bonds, stocks, loans, etc...) will tend to make that capital available at a lower cost to the company. I have not thought about whether aggregate increases in the demand for housing have the same positive effect on firms, though you could argue that increasing housing values creates home equity and the mortgage interest deduction encourages homeowners to borrow against that new equity and invest the proceeds in ways that will generate a higher return than the interest rate - marginal tax rate, such as stocks. But that happens a lot in economics, many seemingly conflicting forces can lead to the same effect.
- tw04 10y agoHow do you figure the value of stock increasing reduces borrowing costs? I don't know of ANY financial institution that bases the interest rate of a loan on the value of a company's stock. It is, in every case I've seen, based on their credit rating. You could have a stock that's through the roof, but if you don't pay your bills on time that means absolutely nothing to me as a financial institution. On the flip side your stock could be in the gutter, but if you are financially viable and pay your bills on time, I couldn't care less. Generally speaking there is a correlation between stock price and "health of the company", but not always. Finally - stock price increasing creates jobs???? Source? I have never, in my life, heard of a company of any size hiring people because their stock went up. That's the most ludicrous thing I've ever heard.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- linkregister 10y agoCompanies often issue common stock long after IPO. Tesla famously did this earlier this year in order to finance an accelerated release schedule for the Model 3. Companies undergoing temporary financial trouble also issue common stock. The major banks issued large amounts of common stock during the 2008 financial crisis. Most have not yet repurchased the issued stock. Technically and in the extremely specific case, yes, buying stock on the market doesn't create jobs for anyone. However, the liquidity of stock in the aggregate is one part of the confidence of the financial system. Upon IPO, buyers of the stock need to know they can sell their stock on the market after it fulfills their objectives.
- camiller 10y agoYeah, I purposely ignored the edge cases of selling treasury stock or existing companies making new issues. An existing company making a new issue is kind of unusual because it dilutes the value of existing shares which is harmful to existing shareholders. generally a bad thing. Selling Treasury stock does get new cash in the hands of the company, but usually that was because at some point the company had excess cash and invested it in it's own shares in the form of a buyback, less often the company is still holding shares from it's own IPO. It later needs the cash and re-sells the stock, hopefully at a better price. I would argue though that the day to day trading of common stock on the open market is the more general rule not a "extremely specific case". Normally, if I go to make a trade in my account, it is not a new issue and would be a coincidence if it was at the time a company was selling treasury stock. no argument in stock liquidity being a measure of confidence, but not really to the point I was addressing.
- linkregister 10y agoI agree with everything you said. I wanted to mention liquidity because I (wrongfully) thought your post implied it wasn't particularly important; is indeed paramount for the stock market to work at all.
- blibble 10y agoif there was no secondary market people likely wouldn't buy into the IPO, as there would be no way to get rid of the stock later so it clearly adds value to the original seller
- camiller 10y agoYes, but that wasn't the point.
- tcbawo 10y agoI had heard that the mortgage deduction was designed to incentivize the population to settle down. A population that is settled is more invested in the community, less likely to cause trouble, and more likely to pay taxes. Although, in today's workforce, lack of mobility can be a liability.
- vilhelm_s 10y agoAccording to Priceonomics, > the deduction began as an unplanned technicality. When the federal government first levied income taxes in 1913, Congress allowed Americans to deduct from their taxes the cost of all interest payments. This is standard policy for corporations: the government only wants to tax profits—not money spent on loans for tractors or a new office. In 1913, the government allowed deductions on all interest—probably because all interest payments were business-related. No one took out car loans in 1913 or paid interest on credit card debt, and the majority of mortgages were for farms. https://priceonomics.com/the-case-against-everyones-favorite-tax-break-the/ https://priceonomics.com/the-case-against-everyones-favorite...
- Spooky23 10y agoThat's not really accurate, you could deduct interest and leases for a very long time. Pretty sure that went away as Vietnam war spending ramped up.
- maxerickson 10y agoMost of the benefit goes to the wealthy (at least, the portion of the population with the highest incomes; I'm not interested in arguing about whether households earning $200,000+ in high expense areas are wealthy or not). http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/model-estimates/individual-income-tax-expenditures/tax-benefit-deduction-home-mortgage-interest-1 http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/model-estimates/individual-in... For someone earning $500,000 a year, a $5,000 tax break is a $5,000 tax break, it isn't going to do much of anything to their behavior. Considering that mortgages usually require a down payment, you could also make the argument that the benefit overwhelmingly accrues to the financially stable. People that can't get the down payment together aren't going to be stabilized by a benefit they can't access.
- randiantech 10y agoSo are you recommending to invest savings on stocks and bonds rather than a house? I mean, I wont argue / refute you reasoning, I just simply dont have the knowledge to do a proper analysis. Ill just say that my 78 years old parents, that not even finished high school, always told me to first buy a house, then think about the rest. Being an owner feels like the best decision Ive ever made. If something happens to me, I have the safety that my family have a place to live in.
- cm2187 10y agoYou could have savings and investment you could use to cover a lower rent the rainy days. House prices are only high because everyone is over-bidding to buy them. And that's driving rents up. Now this is different to the question of whether you should individually follow the crowd in a country where everyone over-bids on property. If you don't, you still pay a high rent to repay the massive mortgage of the guy who bought the property. And in a country like the UK, there is a massive moral hazard: because so many voters are all-in into property, politicians will do anything it takes to ensure prices never go down, even if that means printing massive amounts of money, robbing savers from their investments, having negative interest rates, etc. In that world, it probably doesn't make sense to bet against the central bank. But as a society I think it is a bad allocation of resources.
- standel 10y agoso as a society, it would be better to have a handful of house owners collecting the rent of everyone else? Is that a good allocation to you?
- aianus 10y agoYes. Owning your own home is like cooking your own food. It might be cheaper but only if you don't value your own time or have anything better to do. There's a reason why even rich, successful businesses rent office space instead of buying. They just can't manage a property as efficiently as the companies that focus on that.
- Hermel 10y agoIn Switzerland, this is even more extreme and there are even fewer home-owners. The Swiss can deduct their mortgage payments from their income, but you are taxed the virtual income of renting your house to yourself. Furthermore, the capital gains tax on real estate is up to 40% on short-term transactions (less than two years) and there is no capital gains tax on stocks. Furthermore, there's a wealth tax disincentivizing you from holding low-return assets such as real estate. And returns on real estate are very low (like 3% or so), mostly because it is seen as a safe investment by pension funds. All these factors add up.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- riprowan 10y ago> There is no reason to favor individuals investing into an unproductive investment (property) over productive investments (stocks and bonds). I beg to differ. I think that real estate, like farming, has critical societal benefits that are worthwhile to develop and maintain. Namely, it is very difficult to raise a family of four in a mutual fund. Investing in a home may is absolutely "productive." See, there are significant societal benefits to home ownership that you are not considering. For example: 1. A paid off home is a social safety net against homelessness for an entire family and many of their social circles. Even if all of them are unemployed, all of them have a roof over their heads. 2. A paid-off home frees up cash flow. It allows the owner to divert his earnings into other activities or investments or reduce the amount he has to earn monthly. 3. Real estate can be borrowed against. Try that with stocks. If you are an entrepreneur, your home is likely the asset you will use to acquire bank financing for your business. 4. With unskilled / low-skilled jobs vanishing left and right, homebuilding is one of the few markets which still relies entirely on a giant low-skilled workforce. It's one of the few sectors that can keep a lot of people productively employed. I think there are valid arguments against stimulating homebuilding to reduce unemployment among low-skill workers, but there is nevertheless a societal logic here. 5. In a time when wealth is centralizing as never before, investments in real estate distributes wealth locally. I think there are valid arguments against public policy to distribute wealth, but there is a societal logic here. 6. Finally: taxing a home is very counterproductive to the well-being of the middle class and the poor. I'm sure in Germany the interest on a mortgage isn't tax deductible as you say, but I'd also guess that steps are taken to refund the property taxes for the lower classes. Otherwise you simply tax the poor out of their homes - a form of confiscation. I think there's a lot of sense in NOT taxing one's first home, at least not if it's below a certain reasonably high value. All things considered, home ownership is empowering. A second home or income-generating rental property is a different story, but one's domicile should be unconfiscatable by the state.
- cm2187 10y ago> Namely, it is very difficult to raise a family of four in a mutual fund. It is difficult to ski without skis. But most people don't buy skis, they rent them. Renting skis do not mean that no skis will be manufactured. There is a need for house, houses will be constructed, irrespective of whether people will over-bid on them or not. > A paid off home is a social safety net against homelessness Stocks and savings are equally a safety net against loss of primary income. > Real estate can be borrowed against Borrowing against your home to finance your business is no different than selling some stocks to invest into your business. In both cases you are using previous savings. > I think there's a lot of sense in NOT taxing one's first home Why? Again you are assuming that the alternative to owning a home is renting one and having no savings. The cost of housing (renting) would be much lower in a country without massive over-bidding on property. There is no reason to give a tax benefit to this particular type of investment (property) over any other types of investment.
- Spooky23 10y agoThat's a ridiculous position. My ownership of my home provides a lot of active investment activity that wouldn't happen otherwise: Examples: - the local nursery benefits from the plants and growing materials that we buy - investments in home improvements generate contractor man-hours and local material purchases - as an active participant in stakeholder in the community, I contribute to the governance of the community - single family homes are valued at a premium to multi family, so I contribute more to local school and municipal services.
- codemac 10y agoOnly the home improvements is unique to home ownership, the rest happen whether or not you're renting or owning.
- mason240 10y agoWhen I was renting, I had a 30-day investment in the neighborhood/city. Now that I own my house, I have a 150k investment in the neighborhood/city.
- hx87 10y agoEven improvements aren't unique; the last time I moved into an apartment I replaced the wall-to-wall carpet with pine boards, replaced the 50+ year old electric receptacles with GFCI outlets and stripped off the old paint and put on a new coat of primer and paint.
- sosuke 10y agoWoah your renting experience sounds like home ownership to me. I've never heard of that in the US that is a lot to put into a place! The max lease allowed by my last complex was 13 months.
- kgermino 10y agoHow does anything on your list stem from owning vs renting? Presumably if you were renting - you would still garden and you or your landlord would still maintain the lawn - your landlord would still maintain the house - you would still be living in the community and therefore motivated to participate in it's government - I don't understand this one at all. Why would a second family suddenly move in if the house was rented?
- MarkMc 10y ago> an unproductive investment (property) Why is property unproductive? It produces accommodation, doesn't it?
- closeparen 10y agoInvesting in land doesn't make more land. Rising land values don't even produce taller buildings, since zoning and neighbors work to preserve the character of neighborhoods. Investing in manufacturing companies makes more factories.
- Sargos 10y agoRaising land values does in fact produce taller buildings. HIgh land value means land is either scarce or very attractive. With high land value it makes more sense to make a two story building on one plot of land rather than a one story building on two plots of land. That's even in the face of NIMBY neighbors since builders must deal with that no matter what.
- bufordsharkley 10y agoRising land values don't produce taller buildings when landowners don't feel the pain of rising land values (see: Prop 13). A very efficient tax is the land value tax: by untaxing the improvements on land and taxing the land values more heavily, you incentivize efficiency.
- eloisant 10y agoWell rent doesn't create any wealth either, you're just paying monthly a landlord so he doesn't have to work. If you want to create value, you should make sure that housing prices (both renting and buying) stay low. This way not only wealth can go to other investments, but more people can take the risk to start a business if they don't have the risk to be unable to pay their rent or mortgage.
- cesarbs 10y ago> paying monthly a landlord so he doesn't have to work. Try telling that to a landlord. Being one is a job in itself - or you have to pay someone else a good chunk of money to do the work for you.
- justincormack 10y agoThat's because it is an amateur business with people doing it in a way that does not scale. Large scale renting is vastly more efficient.
- oldmanjay 10y agoI suppose that it's emotionally satisfying to denigrate people for having something you want, but does it truly make a useful contribution?
- ythl 10y agoBeing a landlord sucks, you don't know what you are talking about. Tenants are terrible for wear and tear on your house. Since they don't own the house they don't treat it with care. Lots of maintenance and tenant problems that need solving.
- Grishnakh 10y agoThat's one good thing about large-scale home-ownership: people tend to take better care of things they own, so overall costs to society for housing may be lower that way. It also makes people more invested in their communities, in theory. I was a landlord for a while during the realty boom. It really did suck. However, it varied wildly by tenant: some tenants took good care of the place, others didn't. So when a tenant left and I had to get a house ready to re-rent, some were a relative cakewalk, while others required a ton of work (like one idiot who drilled a bunch of giant holes in the walls for cables for their A/V equipment). The worst part about it was being on the hook for major repairs, and having them happen at unpredictable times.
- zavandor 10y ago>So in Germany, the interest on a mortgage is non tax deductible Wrong reasoning. It's tax deductable in Switzerland and they rent even way more than the germans
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoBut then you are also taxed on the imputed rent for the property, i.e. you have to pay taxes as if you are renting the property from yourself and the rent that you are paying yourself is taxable income. That greatly outweighs the effect of the mortgage tax deduction.
- bzbarsky 10y agoThe thing is, interest on loans is tax-deductible for businesses (in the US, but I expect more broadly too), like any other business expense. So people may just set up shell corporations to buy the house and get the deduction anyway. Of course then the capital gains tax treatment would be rather different.
- DocTomoe 10y ago> (stocks and bonds, which enable companies to raise money to start new projects, create jobs, etc). Interestingly, us Germans do not like those much either - mostly because of the associated risks and the Notion that "the small guy" cannot win that lind of game. There was ... some enthusiasm about the stockmarket in the 1990s, but after the Dotcom-Crash and many people who invested in "save, large, local businesses" like the postal service or the Telekom losing a lot of money, that has waned.
- tdullien 10y agoIn which way is paying returns on the investment to build housing unproductive, but buying Disney stock is productive? I think you are measuring with unequal yardsticks here.
- codebeaker 10y agosomewhat arbitrarily choosing your comment to reply to, I noticed you're picking on the idea of buying a house being an investment, rather than a simple alternative to rent. For me, the motivation for owning a house isn't so much an investment as it is that renting and owning cost virtually the same, given that one has the means to get on the ladder. I bought my first house (I'm 30) in north Germany about 18 months ago, we paid 515k and it was recently valued at 700k due to large improvements to the area, and the renovation of an old hospital site which is now luxury flats and houses, the mortgage (2.5% fixed-for-25-years) costs us about the same as renting a flat (100sqm) in the city, and we now have 200sqm of living space and 250 of garden to ourselves, we also now own, rather than rent a parking space (which always annoyed me more than it perhaps should have) The capital gains tax is an interesting point, given the rent we were previously paying at 1800/month (warm == includes some bills) we'd have been over 20k/year out of pocket just by maintaining the renting status-quo. My wife and I discussed whether it was the perfect house for us, whether we wanted to take a risk on living 20min north (metro) of the city, rather than 5 minutes to the west, and whether waiting 2/3 years was justifiable, we poured about 70k of our savings into legal fees, ground-tax and the deposit for the property, we figured that sitting on our hands for 2-3 years could cost us essentially the same. Naturally one can't write-off the convenience of renting and being able to terminate a contract and simply move, but I have almost the same freedom to rent out my house should I choose not to live there anymore, although the rental market for houses ~20 min north of the city will make it tricky to cover the cost, then keeping the house turns into a question of eating the capital gains tax, or paying out of pocket a few hundred euros per month to make the difference. I also don't have to pay €4k for a "Markler" to help me find a flat, and fax me a contract, a rather shameful act that persists in Germany, even if you do all the work yourself, the Marker can still get their commission, legally speaking, they often do deals to prevent you pushing the issue to the courts. Given the duration of my mortgage, the low (fixed) rate, I can look forward to the last 15 years of my useful working career being rent and mortgage free, which might be a bit too late to build a nest-egg, but it's certainly better than being at the mercy of ever-increasing rental rates in an ever-expanding city. (in my opinion) I think it might be fair to close by saying that Germans are typically fiscally risk-averse, and huge debt, variable rate mortgages, and the uncertainness about maintenance and insurance might be as big a driver as anything else. There's also the cultural shift away from generational houses (think "Home Alone") where many generations live together longer term, I think this is significant.