10 ms·
For a long time, I've wondered what would finally be the Securitypocalypse, the thing that finally caused our industry as a whole to take security seriously. Th
by jerf 10y ago
For a long time, I've wondered what would finally be the Securitypocalypse, the thing that finally caused our industry as a whole to take security seriously. These IoT DDoS attacks are as good a candidate as any I've seen in a long time. They are fundamentally very difficult to fix in light of the non-updateability of many of these devices, and this is only the beginning, because the IoT has hardly begun to develop. And in the short-term, I'm not sure I see any hope, because the forces that make people throw out cheap devices with broken firmwares with no update capability aren't going away.
If we could somehow mandate that these devices were supported with firmware updates for the indefinite future, that would simply destroy the entire market. And you can't do that, because even the devices created by an entity that no longer exists and didn't sell its IP to anybody else will eventually be enough to do these DDoSes, if they aren't already.
- seanp2k2 10y agoYep, and manufacturers have not much incentive to update firmware for a device which is not their latest greatest or update firmware while not adding more features to help them sell more. Security isn't a feature that the vast majority of consumers would pay extra for or know how to verify anyway. There was plenty of demand for that one "unhackable" android phone, but I'd be blown away if it wasn't 100% snake oil. My prediction is that it'll get worse before it gets better and that these type of botnets will be around for at least 5 years. Look at what happened to unsecured-by-default routers, android phones, Windows PCs, cars...the way consumers will get more secure stuff is by manufacturers being publicly embarrassed / sued over problems until caring about security makes business sense, then they'll have it in their hands when their old insecure gadgets die. My cynical side side thinks this will be a problem until all the old endpoints supporting these insecure things are shut down eventually in 5-10 years.
- Angostura 10y agoThis isn't just small manufacturers either. I bought a new Samsung tablet for my kid two weeks ago. It is running a three year old version of Android with no updates available. Pretty shocking.
- JoelBennett 10y agoThere'd be something ironic about a manufacturer's website being made unavailable because of a DDoS caused by their own poorly secured devices.
- NKCSS 10y agoIt's easy to fix; back in the day when a machine was infected; an ISP would just block outgoing traffic, contact line owner and re-enable when the issue is resolved.
- gaius 10y agoIf the "machine" in question is my ADSL router as supplied by my ISP, I will be deeply unimpressed if they block me due to their own negligence in updating it!
- Jtsummers 10y agoSimilarly, a single bad device on my network would block the whole of my network from the internet. It's another sort of denial of service attack. We need IPv6 and have devices either access the internet with their own IP address or not access it at all. This solution, then, would only impact bad actor devices, not your other (non-compromised) devices. Still, not easy.
- cpncrunch 10y agoI think it's fair to block the entire network. It is then up to the network administrator to fix the problematic device.
- Jtsummers 10y agoWhile technically accurate to describe them as such, the vast majority of consumers (and internet service subscribers) lack the actual technical expertise to be network administrators. Where these devices are being attacked inside, ostensibly, professional organizations (companies, schools, government buildings), I agree. But there you have, again ostensibly, an actual network administrator capable of dealing with the issue (and paid to do so).
- matthewmacleod 10y agoI think that's okay. We don't expect all homeowners to be, say, experts in electrical wiring, or gas supply, plumbing, drainage, or waste management. But all of these things—if they are poorly modified, managed, or maintained—can cause impacts on third parties. In the case of networked devices, the possible impact on third parties is even greater. We also enforce strong regulation on these systems – defining what may and may not be legally connected to public utility networks, for example. We would probably expect a homeowner to hire a tradesperson to maintain these services, and in some cases it's legally mandated that only a qualified person may install or modify these systems. Is it then unreasonable to kick consumers off of the Internet when they install poorly-maintained devices, and require them to resolve the problem – perhaps by hiring the networking equivalent of a qualified plumber?
- gtrubetskoy 10y agoThese attacks are mostly possible because of the complacency of operators at many sites and companies. This is not a new problem and many of RFC's talk about methods for preventing and mitigating them, but most people don't care and prefer to just outsource everything to a single provider, which becomes the weakest link. The Internet wasn't envisioned with a single email provider, single DNS provider, single app container provider. (Ok, for most of these you have two, sometimes three choices, but still, that is too few). The centralization makes everything very vulnerable - imagine what would happen when Gmail is knocked out for a day.
- supergeek133 10y agoThe problem with these devices in particular is the weak point is the user. As is the case in most attacks. Your average user says "Sure I can setup cameras" then sees "remote access" in the menu, sets it up, maybe it has some UPNP to the router and BOOM. Magic remote login without any type of mitigation.
- cmdrfred 10y agoExactly, I have tons of IOT devices. I put them on a separate subnet that does not have a gateway to the internet then I VPN into that network to access them. Perhaps a product that makes that a simple process will solve the problem?
- RickS 10y agoFWIW, I would definitely be interested in paying for a service like this. I'm technical enough to care about this, but not technical enough to solve it myself. Similar to where I was before dropbox.
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoMy comment here might be relevant to your interests: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12765051 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12765051 It could suit your needs or we can help with custom deployments. In any case I'd like to learn more about your needs and your expectations. Can I drop you an email?
- HipHopHacker 10y ago> For a long time, I've wondered what would finally be the Securitypocalypse, the thing that finally caused our industry as a whole to take security seriously. Nothing. If the economic system revolves around capital's valorization of itself, security is a distraction from that. I have to spend five seconds typing my password in every time I sit at my desk? I can't just easily e-mail this executable file to my co-worker and have them run it? My desktop is locked down by the desktop admins to prevent me being able to do this, and many other things? Every implementation of security costs money for the personnel to do it and possibly the product cost. Plus any lost productivity it might cause (15 seconds to type in a password each time one sits at their desk, compounded). Donn Parker wrote one of the first books on computer security in 1976, Crime by Computer. The opening words are as apt for corporate security now as it was then. The #1 fear for the corporate manager are the employees of that company. They are the ones with the greatest control over the means of production, so to speak, even more than the managers themselves who are de jure in charge, but are de facto one step away from actual control. Look at how much access someone like Snowden had at Booz Allen. Obviously, if all products have wide open holes, script kiddies will be able to get control. Some minimal security will always be done to stop this sort of thing. On the other hand, one (or better yet, several) dedicated people who want to get past some security arrangement can almost always get in. Even if the firewall is supposedly impenetrable, the wifi or the building security or the social engineering credulity of employees or something will be there. There will be some weak link in the chain. Especially for a company that needs to make a profit. The real security is that semi-intelligent, persistent agents that seek to access and control systems without authorization are lacking. Things depend on the conditions that cause this to rise or diminish. Because once it rises, there is little that can be done. I forget who said that the czar's Russian Okhrana was one of the largest, most extensive security forces that existed. That meant little when Russia began collapsing in 1916 though - all it meant was that they were even more aware that virtually everyone in the country was becoming the czar's enemy. Securitypocalypse events due result in business and government putting more focus on security for a while, but time moves on, and attention drifts back to the main focus. These things go in waves, and total security is never something of the highest priority.
- trhway 10y ago>They are fundamentally very difficult to fix in light of the non-updateability of many of these devices as you proved, fixing the situation by fixing the devices wouldn't be a feasible approach. The traffic from those devices is carried by ISPs and this is there this traffic should be stopped. To me the situation reminds about email spam. We didn't get rid of spammers, instead the email traffic is analyzed and dealt with accordingly. I'm sure that ISPs easily see the patterns of such massive DDoS attacks and could just drop (or throttle down into oblivion, like 100s times down) the participating traffic.