10 ms·
Wonder if the attention put on YouTube here will inspire Google to fix the financial and political 'infringement' takedowns. Eg, during the takedown process, h
by nailer 10y ago
Wonder if the attention put on YouTube here will inspire Google to fix the financial and political 'infringement' takedowns.
Eg, during the takedown process, have something like:
> [ ] I understand that satire and political commentary does not in itself consititute copyright infringement, and that I am not filing this notice on the basis of the video satirizing or making commentary on my copywritten content.
> [ ] I understand that incorrectly flagging satirical or commentary videos that mention my trademarks but do not infringe upon my trademark rights may delay response to future infringement filings.
Or something similar. IANAL. Complainants must tick the boxes to be able to submit.
- dragonwriter 10y agoHas it changed the financial incentives? If not, why would it change the results?
- nailer 10y agoThat's why we have 'I understand incorrectly flagging may delay response' which would change the financial incentives. If Samsung waste Google's time with false takedowns of satirical content, Google won't be able to respond to, eg, companies marketing fake Galaxy phones or similar as fast as they would otherwise. Likewise if trolls incorrectly flag videos critiquing them Google won't be able to respond as quickly to someone just pirating their material.
- cortesoft 10y agoI think the person you are responding to's point is what does Google gain by changing its takedown procedure? Does Google really care if they take down some non-infringing content? Is it going to hurt their traffic that much?
- emp_zealoth 10y agoGoogle is working hard to make content creators quit. Lack of real recourse against false flagging and takedowns, new "advertiser friendly" rules, the new hero system (top 10 or so most downvoted video on youtube, absolutely the worst ratio If they really start pushing on enforcement of this bullshit there will be nothing for me to watch there, just shitty non-content nonsense. AvE is not PC, EEVBlog also is not PC, Louis Rossman swears in his videos, singsing streams are full of racial jokes, stereotypes and the like.
- milankragujevic 10y agoYes unfortunately copyright trolls will complain about that because "It's not fair" and "dem pirates took our jobs"... They want to be able to use the DMCA to flag anything their employer doesn't like, whether it's actual copyright infringement, criticism under the fair use, or criticism without even using their content... Sad truth about the freedom on the Internet and the DMCA.
- akerro 10y ago>Warner Bros. flags own site for piracy, orders Google to censor pages http://arstechnica.co.uk/tech-policy/2016/09/warner-bros-flags-own-site-for-piracy-dmca-google/ http://arstechnica.co.uk/tech-policy/2016/09/warner-bros-fla...
- colejohnson66 10y agoIt would've been hilarious if Google actually blocked those pages out of spite
- mhurron 10y ago> Wonder if the attention put on YouTube here will inspire Google to fix the financial and political 'infringement' takedowns. Man that's funny. Ya, THIS TIME Google's going to care.
- Kenji 10y agoThat doesn't change anything. The algorithms are broken and they will always be without general AI. Either you have a human inspecting it and seeing that Samsung are trying to be fascists about it, or you use an algorithm and stuff like that happens.
- jhasse 10y agoHow about an alternative to YouTube? It's such a pity that online videos have become so centralized ...
- mountaineer22 10y agoIt is a money-losing game (free video hosting/streaming), unless you re-appropriate user provided content to extort ad revenue (a la Content ID)? UPDATE: Let me add, if somebody would be willing to subsidize such a service (large co, or gov), it would be possible to compete (market share, not ad revenue obviously).
- pooper 10y ago> Let me add, if somebody would be willing to subsidize such a service (large co, or gov) Except that such a large co or gov would probably not allow certain videos against itself. Can I force them to host it against their wishes? I don't mean to add this link sarcastically: https://youtu.be/8CMxDNuuAiQ https://youtu.be/8CMxDNuuAiQ Maybe we have hope with ipfs? It looks promising to me https://www.reddit.com/r/ipfs/comments/4eyc3v/ipfstube_a_player_for_videos_stored_in_ipfs/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ipfs/comments/4eyc3v/ipfstube_a_pla... Edit: obligatory sample video https://ipfstube.erindachtler.me/v/QmPCTWTWqrDqRpquM4rqAmgBNL94m5UaWNFbz8HNeR49j2 https://ipfstube.erindachtler.me/v/QmPCTWTWqrDqRpquM4rqAmgBN...
- mountaineer22 10y agoNo, I understood you. Benevolent 501c3, maybe? Really, the answer would be in symmetric last-mile internet connections, no? Having the ability to host and distribute/stream video would change many things in these industries.
- kijin 10y agoIt will have to be P2P of some sort. Even with full-duplex gagabit fiber, there's no way for one person to stream HD video to thousands of viewers simultaneously on a home or office connection,
- 0xcde4c3db 10y agoTwo things (IANAL too, this applies to US only, etc.): 1) As I understand it, parody is not inherently non-infringing, it's just one factor that weighs in favor of a judge finding that a use is non-infringing. 2) I doubt that the DMCA allows a provider to punish copyright owners in this way (though this might be applied to YouTube's mechanisms that go beyond DMCA requirements). The law requires that "the service provider responds expeditiously to remove, or disable access to, the material that is claimed to be infringing". Intentionally delaying processing is pretty much the exact opposite of "acting expeditiously".
- revelation 10y agoBut that's the whole point, this probably wasn't a DMCA complaint. Google and YouTube on the pressure of rights holders have put in place a completely parallel system that offers the accused no legal recourse. They just need to go back to all DMCA. Then at least someone with pockets deep enough can challenge these fraudulent requests.
- parent5446 10y agoIn this case the article clearly says the uploader can submit a counter-notice to reinstate the video, so it sounds exactly like a standard DMCA notice to me.
- jimktrains2 10y agoJust because it sounds like it doesn't mean it is. http://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2013/12/19/the-injustice-of-the-youtube-content-id-crackdown-reveals-googles-dark-side http://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2013/12/19/the-injust...
- parent5446 10y agoNot sure how that article is relevant. As I just said, you can submit a counter-notice. Sure the ContentID system might have flaws, but (as the article says) you can still dispute it.
- mountaineer22 10y agoHow is Google's behavior even covered under the DMCA (safe harbor - not very hands off)? Because 'algorithm'?
- edsouza 10y agoMost likely Samsung used the Youtube's "Content ID" system. DMCA is not necessary in that case.
- luso_brazilian 10y agoYour presupposition is that it is in Google's (and Youtube's) best interest to guarantee that videos are correctly allowed or denied based on the balance of copyright, trademark and fair use. It could very well be that their best interest is in satisfying their big customers, the companies that invest massive amounts of money in advertising, publishing and divulging their products and services through Google platforms. Hence the existence of Content ID as a tool for takedown as opposed to rely simply the existing tools like DMCA takedown notices. The later is, in theory, fair as it gives the accused a clear remedy for false accusations (demand reinstatement of the video and wait for the court battle with the video in place) while the former is a process completely in control by Google and it is up to their discretion to fix the situation.
- bisby 10y agoIt's amazing how people act like they have the "right" to post some content anywhere. Youtube, facebook, reddit, hacker news are all private organizations. They are not legally obligated to host your content (in some cases, like copyright infringement, they are legally obligated to NOT host your content). The only thing that keeps these sites from arbitrarily censoring their users is money. If facebook deleted every article that zuckerberg disagreed with, people would eventually stop using facebook (there might be some speculation about how their "top stories" algorithm "filters" stuff out). Less users means less ad revenue. But on the flip side, if samsung accounts for a noticeable chunk of ad revenue and that becomes at risk, less ad revenue means less ad revenue too. If blindly DMCA'ing videos yields a loss of 2% of users, but keeping the video up yields a loss of 5% of ad revenue (from samsung's share), then I imagine they will always prefer to side with samsung. This isn't illegal, this is just one of the truths about capitalism. If a company exists to make money, it will side with money. if a company exists to provide a quality service, it will side with quality service. Quality service often doesn't have the marketing team though.
- YCode 10y agoFunny how people tend to view things like malls and social media as public places. It's a mass illusion we all place on what is inevitably a biased corporate product fully intended to make money. It would be interesting to see what a municipal social media platform would look like.
- stonemetal 10y agoFair use is an affirmative defense, not a get out of trouble free card. The process is right and correct for the rules as written. The rules may be bullshit but that is a different problem, and one that isn't going to be solved by feel good measures.
- delinka 10y agonit: ...copyrighted content. "Copywrite" and "copyright" are not synonymous.
- illumin8 10y agoYoutube really has terrible discretion here. The optics of banning a cancer patient's channel and sole source of income are not great... "It's going to take three months to get the strike removed from my channel... I got my live stream taken away," he said in a video. "If I submit a counter-notification to say 'sue me', I wonder what they will do. Will they sue me, the kid that has cancer and just makes money off YouTube playing a video game?" "It really sucks, because I really worked hard on this channel." edit: spelling
- joesmo 10y agoHow about huge monetary penalties enforced on these companies by law, instead of hoping that the industry police itself? There is no way anything else is going to work and hell will freeze over before abuses stop voluntarily.