6 ms·
> would you use a Chinese email provider? Chinese Facebook clone? Chinese Twitter clone? I'd use it more readily than I'd use the american counterpart. I have
by StavrosK 10y ago
> would you use a Chinese email provider? Chinese Facebook clone? Chinese Twitter clone?
I'd use it more readily than I'd use the american counterpart. I have to travel to the US sometimes, but not so much in China, so China knowing things about me affects me much less.
> I don't know about you, but I'd think twice before feeding my child Chinese formula or taking a flight in a Chinese made airplane.
As others said, yeah, you're already doing those things. Everything is made in China.
> China's reach is China.
That's why you never see "made in China" stickers on anything.
> They may have a billion person market but last I checked that was only 1/7th the world.
That's also the largest country in the world, and it's the only market you can say that for. The US is 1/20th of the world.
- endisukaj 10y ago> I'd use it more readily than I'd use the american counterpart. I have to travel to the US sometimes, but not so much in China, so China knowing things about me affects me much less. Why does traveling in the US and the US knowing things about you affect you? > As others said, yeah, you're already doing those things. Everything is made in China. Not by Chinese companies though. Individual parts are made there, but they are designed by non-Chinese companies and the manufacturing process is overseen by these companies. > That's why you never see "made in China" stickers on anything. See my last point. > That's also the largest country in the world, and it's the only market you can say that for. The US is 1/20th of the world. Last time I checked, Facebook, Twitter and Instagram (not to mention Apple products and Google) were used outside the US as well. I don't think anyone in Europe uses a Chinese Facebook clone or Twitter clone.
- StavrosK 10y ago> Why does traveling in the US and the US knowing things about you affect you? Because I can be detained by a country (or denied entry) much more easily when I am in the country than when I am not. > Not by Chinese companies though. Individual parts are made there, but they are designed by non-Chinese companies and the manufacturing process is overseen by these companies. I don't believe that "Chinese company" automatically equals "crap". Xiaomi makes some of the best products I've ever used (and they definitely have the best quality to price ratio of anyone), my Huawei phone is amazing, everything I bought from Ali has been good, etc. > Last time I checked, Facebook, Twitter and Instagram (not to mention Apple products and Google) were used outside the US as well. I don't think anyone in Europe uses a Chinese Facebook clone or Twitter clone. The western world uses those products. I would be surprised if nobody outside China uses them. Maybe they don't, I don't know the WeChat penetration numbers for countries outside China...
- triplesec 10y agoYou are taking a very short sighted view here, because if Chinese social media became practical monopolies you would be much more worried than if an American company did, because the Chinese government is so much more repressive
- dragonbonheur 10y agoPlease clarify what you mean by "repressive". The USA still imprisons more people and have much more people on parole or under some kind of judicial oversight than a lot of much more populated countries.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoComparing Chinese repression to American repression and saying they are similar is like comparing North Korea repression to Chinese. Yes there is an element of truth, but the scales and natures are completely different.
- dragonbonheur 10y agoThe stripping of freedom, interaction with the rest of society, the effects on the imprisoned individual's family and their finances are the same. Would you dare say that if the USA droned an innocent person based on signature data in Afghanistan his death would be of a higher quality than the Talib killing him? If you do not want to make such comparisons then answer one question: Which country's actions in recent history ( <30 years ) were more beneficial to improving trade, alleviation of poverty and development of poor countries across the world - the USA or China?
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoChina's PLA has a great track record of winning battles....in China. Ya, the USA military is focused outward, but they aren't killing a bunch of people in their own country. When you are looking for a country to live in, that is important. You can tell what people think by the immigration rates between the USA and china.
- adventured 10y ago> Everything is made in China. Well then allow me to introduce you to the fun fact of the day: were US manufacturing output a stand-alone economy, it would nearly be the size of the entire French economy. As the #2 manufacturer - only overtaken by China in 2011 - the US is twice the size of the #3 manufacturer. US manufacturing output has also doubled since the early 1990s and is now greater than the #3 (Japan) + #4 (Germany) + #5 (S.Korea) manufacturing nations combined.
- zmh 10y ago> so China knowing things about me affects me much less. Not if you have a few experiences when a recipient or sender verified with you that his/her/your email had disappeared. When that happened, we keep wondering did who say what which angered the email provider or hit the censor black list. Such things never happened with email provider from other countries. The same emails finally got through when we switched to gmail or alike.