35 ms·
Why Your Next iPhone Won't Be Ceramic
- danso 10y agoThe production issues and scaling make sense. But ignoring that, what would be the advantage of a phone made out of ceramics? The OP makes mention of luster and durability...is it lighterweight, too? Less prone to denting? I'm reminded of the way ceramic knives are often sharper than steel, but much more prone to shattering. Edit: re-reading the post, I see that the site has chosen to indicate hyperlinks by coloring them #000 instead of the body text color of #666, so I missed the initial link to Quora, which contains a list of advantages: https://www.quora.com/What-will-the-iPhone-8-be-made-of https://www.quora.com/What-will-the-iPhone-8-be-made-of However, it does acknowledge the brittleness factor. Seeing how phones are prone to being dropped, I'd take a scuff/dent in aluminum over the possibility of a massive crack in my phone's body.
- ianai 10y agoWell definitely if someone throws away a ceramic plate there's less environmental impact and opportunity cost from lost materials.
- chadgeidel 10y agoAluminum is highly recyclable (although energy-intensive). I personally wouldn't assume there's less environmental impact. The structure of a hypothetical ceramic iPhone case would be different enough to make it hard to asses this claim based on materials alone.
- hammock 10y agoYou're assuming someone is recycling their phone...parent comment is talking about throwing it away (landfill/litter)
- ianai 10y agoI prefer to optimize for either the most likely or worst possible outcome...which I'd argue simply throwing a phone away is.
- justinator 10y agoApple does have a recycling program - bring it in, or send it in, http://www.apple.com/recycling/ http://www.apple.com/recycling/
- lostlogin 10y agoThe manufacturing of ceramic seems fairly intensive though.
- blt 10y agoYeah, I understand ceramics to be very hard but brittle. It seems like a ceramic-cased phone would shatter when dropped. I think it's OK for the smaller, lighter watch in the same way that exoskeletons only work for lightweight animals.
- r0m4n0 10y agoAgreed. I can't help but think back to a black ceramic watch I purchased. The metallic black color and finish were pretty amazing (and it didn't really scratch) but it took a whole 2 months until it slid off a table and the entire band shattered on the floor. Some of the links were replaceable but some weren't. I think I still have the leftovers in a shoebox somewhere. I'm not sure I want my phone to be that fragile.
- analog31 10y agoI'm reminded of a quote from Skunk Works, attributed to Soviet engineer Alexander Tupolev: "You Americans build airplanes like a Rolex watch. Knock it off the night table and it stops ticking. We build airplanes like a cheap alarm clock. But knock it off the table and still it wakes you up."
- twblalock 10y agoCeramic kitchen knives aren't a very good idea for the same reason. They are very hard and scratch resistant, which keeps the edge sharp, but they easily shatter when dropped. Given the number of times I've dropped my iPhone, I would probably be unwilling to purchase a ceramic model.
- dTal 10y agoAfter the glass iPhone came out and everyone started complaining about how easily it smashed, I joked that the next iPhone would be made of bone china... looks like I wasn't far off!
- ceejayoz 10y ago> But ignoring that, what would be the advantage of a phone made out of ceramics? It's radio-transparent.
- debt 10y agothis. v high capacity bandwidth devices seems advantageous for the coming video-as-a-platform era.
- jrowley 10y agoInteresting to compare Apple to Telsa, who is having to scale production like crazy and is designing/manufacturing some their manufacturing machines themselves
- jlebrech 10y agoIt'll even more Aluminum/Aluminium because the "glass" will be made of this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_oxynitride https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_oxynitride
- eric_h 10y agoHa! I didn't know that we'd finally invented transparent aluminum. Scotty would be proud.
- thescriptkiddie 10y agoActually, sapphire is already more transparent than window glass and is 100% aluminum oxide. Aluminium oxynitride is a transparent ceramic that has similar properties to sapphire but is not quite as strong or as expensive.
- DannyBee 10y ago+1 I'm weird, but the nicest part of sapphire for me was that it meant i could keep my phone in the shop without worrying about the screen getting scratched from saw blades, chisels, or carbide marking knives i put in my pocket. Of course, i guess i'd have the opposite problem of the phone scratching those things, but ...
- jaggederest 10y agoThat doesn't make sense, tungsten carbide is harder than sapphire. Carbide tools should scratch it no problem.
- DannyBee 10y agoIt varies. You are right that some are harder than pure sapphire, but it depends on the exact grade, etc, and depends on what you do to the sapphire. Suffice to say: I have tested saw blades i have against sapphire screened watches i have. They do not scratch. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- Kenji 10y agoAs pretty as aluminum is, it's way too soft. I have a CNC milled android device and it's got some nasty bumps from me dropping it on the ground. Plastic, while not as shiny and fancy, is much better suited and more resilient if you value material strength and usability over looks. It's cheaper too.
- laurentdc 10y agoThis. Drop a MacBook (or any other aluminum gadget) and it's bent out of shape forever. Good plastic (glass-fiber or carbon-fiber reinforced) is generally... plastic.
- wlesieutre 10y agoIf that's a materials pun, it's actually the opposite. A dent that bounces back to its original shape is elastic. Plastic deformation is the metal phone that stays dented after the force is removed.
- laurentdc 10y agoRight! Took physics way too long ago.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoErr, it seems that the complaint here is that aluminium deforms plastically while plastic deforms elastically. This is why English is fun.
- awqrre 10y agoCouldn't you reinforce aluminum with glass-fiber too (or carbon-fiber)?
- kpil 10y agoI guess you could try to make a composite steel-aluminium material, as the steel has a yield point and will take the load when stretched. But I doubt it will work good for compression.
- Theodores 10y agoThe special properties of ceramics are what? Disc brakes and ball bearings are all I know. In neither of these situations is brittleness a problem. Given brittleness is a problem I cannot see iphones being ceramic any time soon even as a back inlay. However that could be done and the assumptions of this article all wrong. As an inlay the tolerances might be fine, no army of robots needed. The aluminium band holding it together could be an extrusion, hydroformed to have strength.
- xanderstrike 10y ago> Given brittleness is a problem I cannot see iphones being ceramic any time soon even as a back inlay. This is the company that put glass on the back of their phones for aesthetics we're talking about here. Nothing is out of the question.
- alayne 10y agoIt's one company of many. Samsung, Sony, Oppo, Huawei, BLU, and Xiaomi also manufactured glass back phones.
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoCeramics are extremely hard and tolerant of great heat (the latter not being particularly relevant). They can also be lightweight for their strength, at least in compression. They can also have a nice, smooth, cool feel in the hand (partially as a result of their temperature insulation properties). They're also a huge variety of materials, it's like asking why plastic is a good material - do you mean silicone rubber, ABS, or Teflon?
- noir_lord 10y ago> Ceramics are extremely hard and tolerant of great heat (the latter not being particularly relevant). Tell that to samsung, joking aside a ceramic case might be useful if a battery cooks off.
- 10y ago
- xoa 10y agoThe author makes a good argument (and I always love reading about the nitty gritty of Apple's construction and what they not merely do, but do at incredible scale and consistency), and additionally some of the structural tradeoffs involved in ceramics may be unacceptable for general survivability in a phone-sized form factor. But even so I was surprised in his 3 option list he ignored an obvious 4th. He's correct about scaling and switchover challenges, and that at least as of right now Apple doesn't seem to have any major leaps forward in ceramic manufacturing actively deployed in a product, which in turn means iPhone-scale mass manufacturer would be incredibly expensive/difficult, even for Apple. But that's probably part of why Apple doesn't do it in the Watch either. Instead, they have an entire lineup of Watches, and then use a very expensive, niche process only for an ultra premium skin. While I still consider it unlikely (Apple hasn't done this sort of thing in one of its main lines since the TAM in 1997), if they wanted to start the playing with an advanced material they couldn't get to scale quickly one way would be to just port the Apple Watch strategy and make it exclusive to a special high end model, ie., a ceramic "iPhone Edition" for $2-3k or whatever along with the normal color options. The 10th anniversary of the iPhone would be an occasion for that too. That strategy would have the standard advantages in terms of natural market forces: very high pricing simultaneously limits demand and ensures a large margin for R&D, handling issues, and scale out. There are still plenty of downsides and again ZrO2 ceramics may just plain not be appropriate for the future of general Apple products regardless of manufacturing. But if they had a 10 year plan to do a major material shift in their product lines, simply reflecting reality and making the new material premium at launch then moving it down the stack seems like it'd be an option they could now pursue given that they've already gone some distance to getting the public used to the idea of differently priced "skins" on an identical internal hardware platform.
- Animats 10y agoadditionally some of the structural tradeoffs involved in ceramics may be unacceptable for general survivability in a phone-sized form factor. Um, yes. Look how much trouble Apple has with bending. Remember "bendgate". A ceramic will crack, not bend. The other direction, flexible phones, has promise. Flexible printed circuits already exist. Flexible displays exist. Flexible batteries are probably possible. Flexible front transparent cover should be possible. Samsung has tried some things in this space, and has shipped a slightly curved phone. So far, no really flexible phones. The main problem is making it flexible while limiting the amount of bend. Maybe a stiff flat spring...
- lucasarruda 10y agoTo sum up: no one really knows for sure!
- wyager 10y agoI'm always amazed when I talk to mechanical/process engineers or designers about Apple products. They put an insane amount of effort into quality and aesthetics that many users will never notice or appreciate. If only their software had the same quality as their hardware... iOS and macOS have been degrading noticeably over the last few years. Perhaps they ought to use software tech as hard-line as their hardware tech. A device machined to within 10um ought to have a kernel to match.
- snowwrestler 10y agoSoftware, in general, is hundreds to thousands of years behind metalworking as an engineering discipline. Most software is still made like early firearms: each piece uniquely crafted one at a time from scratch. We don't even know how to measure the quality of software, let alone how to systematically improve it. I wish Apple's software was better, but I feel the same way about everyone else's software too.
- chadgeidel 10y agoThis, I feel, is so accurate and is why I bristle when people call me a "software engineer". I do not feel like an engineer as I went to a university with many engineering degrees (my degree was from the mathematics department) and I have friends who are actual engineers (not in the train-sense, in the "constructing things" sense). Very little of what I do in software conforms to what I would consider engineering practice. I'm not suggesting that there aren't software developers who construct software with an engineering mindset. I just see so few of them.
- devonkim 10y agoI went to school for computer engineering with greater emphasis upon hardware and over the years I've tried to approach software the way that I've learned how reliability is increased in hardware and electrical engineering, and the business drivers are nothing alike between the two worlds to me on top of the technical differences in disciplines. When we write ASICs in HDLs, most commercial designs have at least 10 to 100 times as many lines of code for test harnesses compared to the actual design. I've never seen a general commercial software product with anywhere near that much test code in my life (SQlite included perhaps). Furthermore, much of what allows hardware testing is through problem spaces being enumerable (or at least approachable on a statistical basis similar to how memtest works with various bit patterns aimed at different failure modes) and with cross-disciplinary lessons (materials sciences, chemical engineering, etc.). The closest we have in software is the functional programming test ecosystem, especially with Haskell's QuickCheck. But commercial software typically just doesn't care about software reliability to the extent anyone in real world systems does, and there's probably a lot more people pumping out random code now than there are hard sciences engineers thanks to the accessibility of modern software and computers. Combined with software developers as a community being more fashion driven than Milan, London, New York, or Paris we're constantly reinventing the wheel. This is both the blessing and curse of modern software.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoApple and aluminum are design mates big time, I don't see that shift changing, but rather evolving as glass/touch/sizing progress continues. Because I'm an unrepentant geek for the stuff I'm going to want a carbon fiber chassis phone eventually. Mass-production CF still isn't a reality as far as I know, but it's being tested (BMW, golf companies, etc).
- kpwagner 10y agoApple continues to regress, and that's kind of sad. The post-Steve-Jobs Apple has continued to produce superb products. And it has scaled to a truly impressive level while maintaining quality and financial statement success. However, at this point it's an old story to say that Apple has recently failed to capture our imagination and "show us the magic" the way it did throughout the 2000s. I remember being blown away by the early iMacs and Macbooks, the early-gen iPods, iPhone, iPad (don't forget how impressive the iPad was when it first came out), and the Macbook Air. When people speculate that the next generation of Apple products may be ceramic, I think I know why: they want the magic. Ceramic? That's sounds new and interesting. Maybe it's environmentally friendly. Reading Koenig's article, the case seems pretty strong for Apple's disincentive to make such a significant change. It's the same disincentive that all large, successful companies face: they do pretty well with the status quo, so why incur the massive expense to do something new and risky? I can't really blame Apple. But I also can't help but be a little sad. The same way I can't help but be a little sad when a talented movie director goes mainstream. It's a reminder that we all have to face reality and make practical decisions; we all contribute to the massive pile of human ambition and pass our excrement to the level below us; and we all are getting older.
- pjmlp 10y agoI don't know where Apple will go, but those of us that were around can certainly remember how the old Apple without Steve Jobs used to be and I have a feeling that is going on the same direction. However, given the amount of money on the bank they still have lots of time available still, so I still look forward to whatever they might think of doing next.
- dcfun 10y agoThe thing is, it's easy to say this, but doesn't it ignore the fundamentals of what's behind the magic in the first place. All of their major breakthrough products (Mac, iPod, iPhone and iPad) came at a time when the technology that made them possible had just reached maturity. Add on top of that, their undoubted refinement of UI and industrial design and they created some major winners. What I think Apple lacks at the moment, is any new just-mature technology on which to base its 'next big thing'. That's not to say Steve Jobs didn't have a huge roll in making all their previous products a big hit, just that there is nothing new on the scene at the moment with which to craft a break through tech hit.
- LordHumungous 10y agoOne summer in college I interned for a company that was building components of the 787 fuselage. If you want to talk about completely retooling a manufacturing process, imagine going from aluminum riveted aircraft to an entirely unprecedented full composite construction. It was something to behold.
- nik736 10y agoI love my ceramic Mi5 Pro! Feels awesome and I can't imagine something else after using it. Sadly even Xiaomi probably won't build a ceramic phone again because of the manufacturing hassle.
- striking 10y agoRight? I have a black OnePlus One and the first thing anyone says is, "wow, what's this made of?" Sandstone was an awesome choice. At least it's still available as a snap-on case for the OP3.
- joshu 10y agoAnyone know how touch machinable ceramics are? I have a small piece of Macor but I haven't tried milling it yet.
- gak_pdx 10y agoCrazy slow on the feeds and speeds, diamond coated tooling (Harvey is where to go). Macor is highly structurally compromised compared to other ceramics to make it machinable. Typically, production (which is to say, low volume med/aero/optics parts) ceramic machining is limited to cleaning up datum surfaces, walls, mating surfaces, holes and (god forbid) threadmilling tapped holes. It sucks. Totally not capable of meeting iPhone scale at all. (source: author of linked article)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- joshu 10y agoNeat. Are normal ceramics machinable this way?
- guelo 10y ago> patent attempting to lay claim to any electronic gadget with a ceramic enclosure I'm going to get a patent for enclosing electronic gadgets in "fuck you apple" stickers.
- baybal2 10y agoCeramic ifone that shatters 10 times easier than a glass one?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Anjin 10y agoThe author ignored one of the most interesting parts of the Quora post, the patent that Apple filed about a manufacturing process that casts ceramic parts and silicon/rubber parts at the same time to make a single object that has both hard ceramic structure and soft rubber. That would let them unify parts like gaskets and bits that hold other bits into one single process. So maybe even if the ceramic part of the process takes longer, they might be able to make up for lost time but cutting out steps that are further down the assembly process. To quote the patent: "As one specific example, ceramic materials have numerous qualities that make them particularly useful for use in electronic device housings. For example, they may be highly scratch resistant, making them particularly well suited for electronic devices that are frequently subject to bumps, scrapes, and scratches, such as wearable electronic devices (e.g., smart watches, glasses and the like), mechanical watches, and other consumer products (including, but not limited to, media players, mobile computers, tablet computing devices, and so on). As a specific example, the high hardness and optical clarity of sapphire crystal (a crystalline ceramic material) may be very well suited as the cover glass for a touch-screen of a wearable electronic device. Ceramic materials may also be relatively light, making handheld or wearable electronic devices easier to carry, wear, and use. Moreover, ceramic materials may be able to achieve a high degree of surface polish making them particularly aesthetically pleasing. However, ceramic materials typically are more difficult to form into complex geometries than plastics, and, thus, manufacturing housing components from ceramic materials can be more difficult than for other materials. Accordingly, described herein are housing components where a polymer material is co-molded with a ceramic component to form a housing component that includes ceramic and polymer material portions. (As used herein, the terms "polymer" and/or "polymer material" encompass natural and synthetic polymers, plastics, rubbers, and the like.) For example, a ceramic housing portion may be co-molded with a polymer material to form a polymer clip that is directly coupled to the ceramic material and can be used to retain the ceramic component with another housing component. As another example, a polymer material may be co-molded with a ceramic component to form a plastic coating on a portion of the ceramic component As described herein, a polymer material forming a polymer feature may be coupled to a ceramic component by a co-molding process whereby the polymer material is molded against the ceramic component. By co-molding the polymer material directly onto the ceramic component, the polymer feature may be bonded to the ceramic material without the use of an intervening adhesive or other bonding agent between the ceramic and the polymer feature. For example, instead of separately forming the ceramic component and the polymer feature, and then adhering the polymer feature to the ceramic with glue, pressure sensitive adhesive, heat activated films, epoxy, or the like, the polymer may be molded directly against the ceramic material. Thus, parts that include both ceramic and polymer components can be manufactured more quickly and with higher precision than would be achieved if the components had to be manufactured separately and thereafter coupled together with adhesive. In some embodiments, the polymer material is injection molded onto the ceramic component. In some embodiments, the polymer material is molded onto the ceramic component using techniques other than injection molding, such as gravity casting, or any other appropriate co-molding process. Where the present discussion refers to injection molding, it will be understood that other molding techniques may be used in such instances instead of or in addition to injection molding."
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoWhy can't they cast/forge the base shape and mill the features?
- TaylorAlexander 10y agoThis article made me really want to get a manufacturing job at Apple... So I'm applying for one now. I never realized Apple was the world's largest owner of CNC machines.
- tominous 10y agoThe author goes to the trouble of using the phrase "takt time" and linking to its definition but then misuses it. Assuming non-stop operations and 1 million units a day, the takt time (average time between unit starts) is about 85ms, not 3-4 minutes. Assuming a cycle time for interior milling of 240s, the difference is a factor of about 3000, which matches the estimate for the number of milling machines operating in parallel.
- gak_pdx 10y agoYou caught me! Confession? I had a better surrounding blurb explaining takt time, because people who read my (once a year) posts get off on the nerdery, but it was clunky, so I sort of inaccurately dropped it in with a link to the real definition to let people explore the term on their own.
- addicted 10y agoAt this point I suspect ceramics is the new liquid metal or sapphire. Apple could certainly prove me wrong, but I have to see it to believe it.
- brisance 10y agoOr maybe all this is leading to Apple learning how to transition to transparent aluminium. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_oxynitride https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_oxynitride
- smhg 10y agoAs a reminder, on a larger scale: Apple's main focus is on design. Not build quality [0]. This doesn't exclude a unique production process of course. But I think it is important to not mix up both when forming an opinion about them. [0] https://www.quora.com/Why-do-Apples-proprietary-cables-break-so-often-or-so-easily https://www.quora.com/Why-do-Apples-proprietary-cables-break...
- GrumpyNl 10y ago"Numbers sheet busting figures we all expect from the 10th Anniversary model of the world's most successful product in history.", did we forget the lightbulb?