4 ms·
"The financial industry" is a very large beast. Even "derivatives" is a very large beast. It makes no sense to go for the industry as a whole when only some sec
by lordnacho 10y ago
"The financial industry" is a very large beast. Even "derivatives" is a very large beast. It makes no sense to go for the industry as a whole when only some section of it was responsible. Mainly mortgage securitisation and distribution. What on earth do guys trading index futures have to do with the crisis? I used to trade listed derivatives, and we never ran into anyone to do with mortgages.
Also, it's worth considering the effects. If you do a FTT, the trading goes elsewhere, or it dies. You won't get nearly as much money as (current size) x (proposed tax rate).
If you want to protect the world from another mortgage meltdown, there are other ways to do that. You could restrict loan-to-value ratios. Or force banks to hold more collateral. These types of things are not unknown.
- conistonwater 10y ago> The European Commission, the EU’s executive arm, first proposed the tax in 2011 to make sure the industry paid its fair share after the costs borne by taxpayers during the financial crisis. This sentence in the article makes it sound like they are not specifically going after the causes of the Great Recession, but the finance industry in general, but I'm not sure. In any case, it doesn't seem to be aimed at mortgages at all. Maybe reducing the amount of trading and finance is the point?
- petre 10y agoThey are going for everything and everyone. The hunt for taxes has begun. Of course it's all being trumpeted as "tax the rich" now, but they will come for you, eventually. In fact they already do with negative interest rates, which are essentialy a tax on money. As the parent points out, capital will just move elsewhere.
- glasz 10y agodon't know why this is downvoted. guess the average 20-sth hn reader hasn't seen the sun yet. i still remember how we've been brainwashed about the greatness of it all in school. wake the fuck up, look around you. learn history, look up precedence. my goodness. any uncommon critique is being downvoted by some stupid pseudo-academic click monkey and their entitlement to whitewash history.
- saiya-jin 10y agowhy the downvotes? this is exactly happening, at least in EU (taxes on anything considered wealth - cars, properties etc. have you ever heard of any tax rate going down or be abolished, for example property inheritance tax? up to 50% in France for example) and to some extent to US (ie FATCA double taxation for US expats that don't live in US for years but still hold the passport)
- Tomte 10y agoJust about every selling or buying of a product or service is taxed. Why should financial products be excluded from that?
- lordnacho 10y agoFinancial firms make profits, which are taxed just like any other firm. Why should they have an extra tax? Optimal taxation suggests we should tax things that won't vanish when we tax them. Land, for instance. The Swedes did an FTT and found it killed the market, and they had to relent. Other reasonable taxes are to do with externalities, but this doesn't seem to apply here.
- Tomte 10y agoA carmaker sells cars and the buyer has to pay turnover tax/VAT/sales tax (depending on locale). And the carmaker still has its profits taxed. Again: Why should the financial industry be better off? The situation is exactly analoguous.
- conistonwater 10y agoIt's not analogous, much of the buying and selling in finance is done for the purpose of the price discovery process, which is to society's benefit, and for which a carmaker analogy doesn't work at all. See any book on market microstructure. If you ignore the price discovery process completely, then, sure, markets become kind of pointless, but that's beside the point. It's not quite like the usual thing of buying or selling a car.
- pyromine 10y agoNot the person you were replying to, but I'm greatly interest in learning more regarding to market microstructure. Have any books you'd recommend?
- conistonwater 10y ago
- Certhas 10y agoWhat is the downside here? I haven't seen any evidence that this type of trading is beneficial to the economy.
- riffraff 10y agoI have no idea if it's true, but the argument about extra trades being beneficial is that they make the market more liquid, thus allowing money to flow better where it's "needed".
- tombone12 10y agoTrying to protect against another mortgage meltdown is just ambulance chasing, at current liquidity markets are inherently unstable and highly sensitive to the number of trades[1]. Since HFT artificially drives up the number of trades, but despite this is orders of magnitude away from providing enough instantaneous liquidity, taxing them to death makes sense. [1] http://video.albanova.se/arc2016_14.html http://video.albanova.se/arc2016_14.html As a side note, after listening to this lecture about the inherent instability of markets, the first guy to ask a question is some sort of trader that wonders if there is any way to make "free money" from the theoretical work presented, shows how social issues is always at the forefront of the financial industry.
- nradov 10y agoWhy should we care whether markets are unstable? Stability isn't necessarily desirable.