5 ms·
That's not revolutionary at all, despite what the New York Times claims. This was done, long, long ago already by Henry Ford (double the going wage for his work
by ekianjo 10y ago
That's not revolutionary at all, despite what the New York Times claims. This was done, long, long ago already by Henry Ford (double the going wage for his workers):
http://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/2014/01/03/history/post-perspective/ford-doubles-minimum-wage.html http://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/2014/01/03/history/post-p...
- dilemma 10y agoNot revolutionary but definitely radical in today's environment.
- Zhenya 10y agoNot at all. Costco is a place that leaps to my mind. Also all the large tech players have done this to a large degree compared to non-tech who hire IT folks.
- maxerickson 10y agoCostco and Walmart aren't really comparable. Costco stocks about 4000 usually larger, higher margin items in each of their stores. Walmart stocks more than 100,000 items in their stores, many of them with very low margins.
- Zhenya 10y agoI was not comparing Costco v Walmart. I was responding to companies paying high wages in "today's environment"
- maxerickson 10y agoRight, but it isn't really clear that Costco pay's particularly high wages for the business it is operating.
- Zhenya 10y agoIt's absolutely clear. Their workers are retail employees who provide near substitutive type of labor as wal-mart employees. They consciously raise wages to retain employees. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-06-06/costco-ceo-craig-jelinek-leads-the-cheapest-happiest-company-in-the-world http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-06-06/costco-ceo...
- nickff 10y agoThat's what Costco says, but I'd be willing to bet that Costco and Walmart employees are quite different. I would bet that Costco employees had more years of education, and more successful (i.e. years not fired for cause) work experience. When you are willing to pay more, you can purchase higher quality; this is as true for labor as software or electronics.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago" I would bet that Costco employees had more years of education, and more successful (i.e. years not fired for cause) work experience." You'd loose money. I've met many Costco employees. Most were either high-school students or older people without degrees who simply applied for the job or were referred then got through an interview. They care more about whether you'll work hard than anything else. Then they tend to stick around longer since they get paid and treated really well so long as they work hard. Lots of retail workers would like a job at Costco or a similar place but there's just few openings since people don't quit often.
- nickff 10y agoNeither Costco nor Walmart will have anything near the average level of education of the average HN commenter, but I maintain that there is almost certainly a difference
- nickpsecurity 10y ago
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThen compare Walmart to Kroger and Publix. Publix charges around 10% more than Walmart per Walmart's ads in exchange for more variety, fast checkout, and high service. Kroger charges a mix of that and Walmart prices on things to attract basically every demographic with similar benefits offered to customers. Both pay workers well with benefits with Publix treating them well. The result is the two collectively sucked $135 billion a year out of Walmart's potential revenue. So, the highest profit and customer satisfaction companies in Walmart's model & market get there by providing decent pay, benefits, and job security to workers plus treating them better in Publix case. Same pattern emerges in lots of other industries. Probably better than what Walmart was doing. That Walmart keeps copying Kroger and Aldi, but not Publix which is employee-focused ;), shows they know those methods are better. Their management greed and control-freak nature makes them adopt more selectively and slowly.
- maxerickson 10y agoKroger and Publix both seem to offer ~50,000 items in their larger stores. They don't have a full department store and will thus likely have a greater variety of groceries than the Walmart, but they don't have greater variety overall. I would argue that they are a 3rd variety of big box (along with mega stores and club stores), not the same as Walmart.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoGrester variety in food. I should've specified that. Also a lot of higher-quality stuff or at least branded as such. Edit: It should be noted that Kroger is moving that direction with its Fred Meyer-style stores. They're more like Walmarts and Targets. Walmart even converted a failed store into a Walmart once although Im not sure the size of that one. Kroger is opening a Fred-style store close to me with descriptions that sounded like a Walmart. Will be interesting to see if these work and what effect they'll have on profit. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Meyer https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Meyer
- will_brown 10y ago>Also all the large tech players have done this to a large degree Didn't all the big tech players recently get sued in a class action for colluding to stifle worker's wages specifically by agreeing not to poach each others employees?
- ekianjo 10y agoThat's not because they decided to get together to stop inflating waves that it means the waves were not high in the first place.
- jnbiche 10y agoYes, but the fact that they were found guilty of suppressing wages does mean without question that they weren't attempting to consciously pay above market wages to gain some Ford-like benefit as with efficiency wages.
- xenadu02 10y agoDon't forget: Facebook capitalized on the scheme by offering above-market wagesa and refusing to participate. They poached a lot of good engineers that way.
- code_sardaukar 10y agoThere's a difference between efficiency wages and paying market rate for a group with specialized skills. Efficiency wages means paying more than market rate in order to get some other benefit such as reduced turnover. In my opinion, tech companies pay market wages for a rare skill (being good at programming). Some will say this is arrogant, but it's just my honest opinion given my knowledge.
- crdoconnor 10y ago>Also all the large tech players have done this to a large degree Not through choice. They are trying their hardest to bring down tech wages by: * lobbying for more immigrants * funding programs to bring more girls into computer science * lobbying to put computer science on school curriculums. * engaging in illegal no-poach agreements. They are pretty damned determined.
- tunap 10y agoBut Costco is a bit radical. I recall several times in the past decade+ reading on Forbes or Bloomberg about their 'less-than favorable'(according to Wall Street) employee compensation practices. This is a big reason why I shop there, my money is my vote. *I have tried tipping the guys in the garage for tire services & have yet to get anyone to accept, they tell me they are paid well enough and it's against policy, etc... they say that even out at the smoking area, away from the cameras, too.
- ekianjo 10y ago> Not revolutionary but definitely radical in today's environment. not even. There are many companies that pay higher-than-category wages just because they want to get the best employees possible. Look at what's happening in the Valley for the more popular companies. They pay more than average and give you tons of benefits on top.
- dilemma 10y agoFacebook and Google are not comparable to Walmart. Don't even pretend they are. They supposedly do knowledge work, Walmart relies on unskilled labor - there's not much latitude in stocking shelves, goes traditional wisdom. Challenging that is radical.
- bobajeff 10y agoAhh a fellow smartphone user! I can tell you've been sabatoged by the autocorrect gremlin. (waves = wages)
- pyb 10y agoI think we'll keep forgetting, and rediscovering Fordism for many years to come, unfortunately.
- calinet6 10y agoSame with Drucker, Deming, and other great management thinkers of the 20th century who repeated similar mantras: respect your people, build good systems, and you have a better chance of succeeding. We're doomed to repeat ourselves, as understanding complexity is not an easy thing to do, and it takes significant time, experience, and effort to unlearn your assumptions and learn to get closer to reality.
- icebraining 10y agorespect your people Ford created a morality department and forced their workers to follow his views of respectability (eg. prevent their wives from working), and to ask for permission before making large purchases, using investigators which would show up unannounced at their home to check up on their personal life.
- givinguflac 10y agoSource?
- girkcknrndnf 10y agoThat's some nice cherrypicking, but the morality department also prevented domestic violence and supported youth education. Not only that, but after receiving some criticism on the issue, Ford realized his mistake and closed down the department saying that it wasn't his job to intervene in the lives of workers.
- icebraining 10y agoCherry-picking is the constant reference to the higher wages, without mentioning the heavy strings that came attached. That it also had some positive effects doesn't diminish my point. Also, from what I can tell, when the department was winded down the salaries weren't higher than the market average. There's also the lovely Ford Hunger March: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Hunger_March https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Hunger_March
- will_brown 10y agowhile increased wages were fine, Ford also attempted selling automobiles at a loss to the company in order to proliferate the number of Ford's on the road. Ford was sued by his shareholder's, Ford lost having been in breach of his duty to the shareholders. Specifically, "the Michigan Supreme Court held that Henry Ford had to operate the Ford Motor Company in the interests of its shareholders, rather than in a charitable manner for the benefit of his employees or customers."
- coredog64 10y agoLet us not muddy the waters with "Dodge vs. Ford" nonsense. Not only was a fair chunk of the original decision reversed on appeal, but it's also fairly well known in business law that "Dodge vs. Ford" is an aberration and not solid precedent.
- will_brown 10y agoThe law has certainly evolved over time into the business judgment rule...but that only muddys the waters more than the maximization rule from dodge v ford. We see new types of cases from shareholders against boards/officers all the time, including, but not limited to political donations; increasing corporate expensive for more environmentally friendly supply chains; and similar issues of selling product for loss. These shareholders would likely win all the time under dodge v ford, but now they win some and lose some under business judgment rule based on the taste of the jurisdiction/jury. The reality is case law provides only some clues and the waters are muddy until a given set of facts is tested, and I'm not saying I like the shareholder maximization rule over business judgment but I do prefer bright line rules over balancing acts.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coredog64 10y agoThis is known as the "Efficiency wage" theory. Megan McArdle has written a number of posts about where it does and does not make sense. Her conclusion (and I agree) is that generally speaking, "WalMart worker"* isn't beholden to efficiency wages. It's also worth mentioning that a side effect of efficiency wages is more unemployment. Paying more results in a better class of applicant, meaning that people who would normally use WalMart as the bottom rung of their career ladder are shut out. *Yes, Costco can do it, but Costco also has a very different business model.
- gerbal 10y ago> It's also worth mentioning that a side effect of efficiency wages is more unemployment. Paying more results in a better class of applicant, meaning that people who would normally use WalMart as the bottom rung of their career ladder are shut out. This assumes that workers are of a fixed quality. I know I worked harder for $10/hour than I did for $7.25. Higher pay means stronger incentives to do well and less stress from poverty.
- winstonewert 10y agoCertainly, people will work harder if you pay them more, you won't just get better people. However: Employers will have to hire fewer workers because their workers are more productive More people will be interested in the jobs, increasing employee competition Since people vary, some people's increase in productivity will be insufficient to cover the increase of wages The end result it seems is that getting a job is made harder. This is not to say that increased wages are bad, they are great.
- gohrt 10y ago"getting a job is made harder" isn't a problem, when the the people are getting better at getting a job. "increase in productivity will be insufficient to cover the increase of wages" is only true if the company isn't turning a profit or paying high salary to managers. This is relevant for some small businesses and bankruptcy-threatened large business, but not for the largest players in the economy, like Walmart.
- imsofuture 10y agoIt's really saddening that thinking beyond first order direct effects of something is considered rare or revolutionary.
- oldmanjay 10y agoIt's not. Modern journalists report everything breathlessly because buzzfeed ruined the craft in exchange for clicks
- jbuzbee 10y agoFrom the article: "Higher wages were necessary, Ford realized, to retain workers who could handle the pressure and the monotony of his assembly line." So in Ford's case, he was simply paying the going rate. Supply and demand. The lower wage wasn't enough to keep the workers he needed in his revolutionary assembly line. People spin this all the time to say things like: "He increased the wage so his workers could afford to buy his cars" But if it were as simple as that, he could have tripled or quadrupled their wages so they would buy even more or at a quicker rate.
- mabbo 10y agoNot quite. What Ford realized was that workers were not simply replaceable cogs, but that each was on a spectrum of skills, experience, etc. He could have, like his competitors, continued to pay very little and gotten mostly the low-end quality workers. He'd have continued to make cars, but probably of lesser quality. He chose to pay the going rate for high quality workers.
- marincounty 10y agoPlus, he wanted his employees to be able to afford one of his vechicles. He wanted a consumer base. With Globilization--they can build it in the cheapest country, and ship it to anyone around the world. What bothers me with American entrepreneurs who follow this business methodology is they took advantage of our school system, relatively safe neighborhoods, relatively fair legal system, and they turn around and build their widget in the cheapest chit hole country that pops up. And when things don't go their way they use our legal system/government to work out their dilemmas. And of course, they would never live in the country that makes their product? Except for tax purposes? At least have the decency to move to that country you make your widget in? I don't want people like you as my neighbor. It took a few moral/hard working generations to make a culture that could coddle entrepreneurs. Let's just see how long it will take for the system to break down/tarnish, and we turn into just another chit hole country? A country with desperate citizens. A country where people will do anything to make a buck. A county with no morals/ethics. I really find them disgusting. Sorry. I just do. I won't be back for the MBA's rebuttal. (Remember who paid for that line of thinking. Remember the generations before that sacrificed for your current theories. Remember that father with the good union job that is now pretty much gone. Argue with your kind.)