9 ms·
The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant citing public outcry
- miles 10y agoThe DEA reversing course due to public outcry (and common sense)?! What alternate reality have we slipped into?! Previously: DEA will ban chemicals contained in kratom, a popular herbal supplement https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12410083 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12410083 Call to Action to save Kratom plant from DEA's uninformed Schedule I decision https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12438605 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12438605
- oxide 10y agoIt really isn't a course reversal, the people holding the purse strings seemed to have forced the DEA's hand into extending the period of public comment. IIRC something similar happened with MDMA. Hopefully folks like myself who have used Kratom to alleviate opiate withdrawal to great success will come forward and comment. Anecdotally speaking, there are folks who have used kratom to ween themselves off of maintenance drugs like methadone and suboxone. The withdrawals from long-acting maintenance opiates like these can last months making it nearly impossible to get off of them cold-turkey. Switching to kratom, which has a shorter, more forgiving withdrawal, can be of great benefit to an addict looking to get off of these maintenance drugs. For an addict, kratom stops withdrawals in their tracks. It doesn't get you high, and taking more to get high would be pointless. To an opiate-naive individual kratom will at most give a mild buzz. It's not like taking heroin, hydrocodone, or even codeine. just a mild buzz. Kratom is usually sold as a powdered leaf. You can't overdose on kratom, because if you take too much of the powdered leaf you just throw up, well before you're able to ingest a dangerous amount. It's very self-regulating in that way. You can't smoke or snort the powdered leaf. It is usually swallowed as a powdered leaf with a thick juice or simply brewed into a tea.
- ZoF 10y agoDo you hang out in irc often perchance?
- oxide 10y agoas a matter of fact I just got around to installing an IRC client for the first time in years. sorry about the line breaks.
- ZoF 10y agoHa, funny, different kratom shills I'm thinking of then(I say shill as a joke). Hope you join us on free/quake/ef/rizon. Cheers~ (I'll never forgive you about the line breaks)
- ambicapter 10y agoThe powdered leaf also tastes like ass, and to take enough to feel anything is a bit like doing a saltine challenge, so its also self-regulating in that way :)
- hiisukun 10y agoFor those that may have read this comment and found it strangely familiar, I'll save you the trouble googling. It appears oxide regularly comments on opiate related threads, so his above anecdote isn't a copy of someone else's comment - it is just him re-stating his experiences he has posted before. I mean no criticism of your story oxide; merely commenting for those who thought something might be awry.
- oxide 10y agoI suppose I did start parroting what I said last time I commented here on kratom thread, yeesh. I ought to have qualified it with a disclaimer if I was just going to repeat myself. I feel it's decent basic information on kratom for the uninitiated, but I didn't mean to parrot myself like that. It's been a long week. My apologies, and thank you for clarifying.
- deleted 10y ago
- rosser 10y ago> A group of 51 U.S. representatives wrote to the DEA saying that the DEA's move "threatens the transparency of the scheduling process..." There's transparency in the scheduling process?
- marsrover 10y agoI wonder if we could get weed legalized if we just started calling the DEA about it all the time.
- tracker1 10y agoI'd settle for seeing it off the Schedule 1 list, which would at least allow for more information/research to happen.
- nathancahill 10y agoI read the title as, "The DEA is withdrawing to another planet after the Internet got really mad"
- jessaustin 10y agoClearly, we need to get madder than we are already.
- rosstex 10y agoAny way to bypass the free article limit on Washington Post?
- kabdib 10y agoParanoid speculation: The DEA was given a secret brief to ban a substance that would help addicts withdraw from an addiction. Consider who actually benefits from this ban: Various policing powers, and drug cartels, who depend on addicts staying that way. Having written that, I don't believe it. But on the other hand . . .
- mcguire 10y agoFollowedby another brief indicating such a ban would adversely affect pharmaceutical companies. "Researchers say that their work with kratom could eventually lead to the development of nonaddictive alternatives to powerful opiate painkillers. Placing kratom in schedule 1 would cripple researchers ability to study the drug, they say."
- tracker1 10y agoMore likely the 12-steppers and religious zealots who feel that all recreational drug/alcohol induced highs are wrong, and should be stopped/illegal. There's been a lot of fighting against anything that works to end addiction through medical research/means. In addition to those who think all recreational drugs should be outlawed.
- tormeh 10y agoLike they hate contraception. Party poopers, basically.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoIt's entirely possible for it to be both. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bootleggers_and_Baptists https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bootleggers_and_Baptists
- rms 10y agoI don't think there was a conspiracy here. I think the most likely thing is that DEA is sincerely trying to do something about the opiate epidemic in America, and made a misguided and poorly researched attempt to ban kratom because they thought that would help the opiate epidemic.
- wtbob 10y ago> Unfortunately, in the United States I don't think we have a good regulatory framework for handling this situation Why do we even need a regulatory framework? It's a plant: let people grow it if they want; let them ingest it if they want. Heck, let them crush the eaves and smear them all over their bodies while singing, 'Happy days are here again!' if that's what they want. That's what freedom is about: letting folks do their thing.
- clock_tower 10y agoThe hard drugs have ugly consequences for their users, and for their society as a whole. Look at how the Japanese in WWII legalized all drugs in China, and made heroin, in particular, cheap and easily available; they wanted to corrode the substance of Chinese civil society, and they did.
- tracker1 10y agoOn the flip side, this drug and marajuana have marginal negative affects beyond being reactionally impared, which being very tired can also do. Are they going to outlaw being awake for more than 20 hours next?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mcbits 10y agoMy rule of thumb is, "would I rather be in a room full of people on X (a variable, not the drug) or a room full of people on beer?" If the answer is X, which it almost always is, then I would rather make X more legally and socially acceptable than beer.
- ajmurmann 10y agoPortugal decriminalized all drugs in 2001 and they seem to be doing very well with it and have very few drug overdose related deaths. They have [3 deaths per million citizens](https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/06/05/why-hardly-anyone-dies-from-a-drug-overdose-in-portugal/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/06/05/why-h...). I wouldn't be surprised if we had more drug enforcement related deaths in the US.
- WhitneyLand 10y agoI don't agree with the ban, but it seems like the risks of kratom are not discussed, and in fact even downplayed by saying hey, it's just a plant. To help me be an informed reader I would like WaPo to mention: 1) If you search kratom withdrawal there are a ton of anecdotal reports that sound pretty unpleasant if not debilitating. 2) What is the frequency of severe side effects, as best as can be known? 3) That "natural" substances or "plants" are not always safe. This misconception is so common and dangerous it shouldn't be used to mock the ban (real logic will suffice). https://web.stanford.edu/~jpc/overture.htm https://web.stanford.edu/~jpc/overture.htm There are plenty of valid reasons to argue against a ban. For example the chill on research, the low rate of fatalities, the likelihood it will make use more dangerous, and the probability a ban would have no net benefits.
- cmdrfred 10y agoIn medicine, you have to show a drug is more effective (or as effective) and is as safe as existing drugs for a purpose in order to get FDA approval. Why not take a similar stance on drugs for recreational purposes? If it is as safe or safer than alcohol or tobacco, approve it.
- unethical_ban 10y agoAu contraire, a substance should only be banned from consumption if it is shown to be highly addictive, and life-threatening if overconsumed. Or something like that. I don't believe something should be banned until presumed completely safe.
- slowmovintarget 10y ago>>highly addictive, and life-threatening if overconsumed You mean like caffeine or nicotine?
- unethical_ban 10y agoNo. 1) Addictive as in, one "normal" dose causes high physical addiction. 2) Lethal, more specifically that it is easy to overdose, or that the difference between "normal" and LD50 is low. You don't get hooked on caffeine after one coke, and it's hard to kill yourself drinking too much coffee.
- Bud 10y agoBad edit of the headline; very bad. Makes it appear to mean the opposite of what is intended. Original headline was: "The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant after the Internet got really mad" See the problem?
- btym 10y agoIt's not even grammatically correct. The original headline was fine.
- deathanatos 10y agoI think it's still grammatically correct. "withdraw" can be a verb; in this form it would be interpreted to mean "to leave from a place" (e.g., "the troops are withdrawing"). However, the title, as currently written, certainly doesn't mean what it was intended to mean. I.e., the way I'm parsing it is "(the DEA is leaving/retreating (to where isn't specified); once there, they're going to ban another plant); this occurred after the Internet got mad."
- btym 10y agoOop, you're right. It's awkward but it does technically make sense.
- sctb 10y agoThe article's original title needed editing to fix within the length limits, so the edited title from the submitter was likely just an accident or minor mistake. We've just updated it to clarify.
- riffic 10y agoThe title as given is awful, lacks context towards the plant being banned.
- rms 10y agoIt feels good to still be in business at http://www.getkratom.com http://www.getkratom.com after all these years. There has definitely been a Streisand Effect from all of the DEA's attention but I don't think it was worth the stress. I think I liked this article the most from the wave of press today. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/oct/14/kratom-dea-ban-reversal-culture-shift https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/oct/14/kratom-dea-b... I'm one of the moderators of https://www.reddit.com/r/kratom/ https://www.reddit.com/r/kratom/ , check it out if you want to keep up with news and community sentiment on this topic.
- supernintendo 10y agoThe DEA should be abolished entirely. The War on Drugs has failed and was a naive idea to begin with.
- maxander 10y agoReally the problem is that scheduling a drug makes it illegal (or at least, incredibly difficult) to do research on. I'm not a fan of drug regulation either, but even considering the standpoint of those that are, letting these things be responsibly handled by professional medical development scientists sounds like a win-win situation.
- M_Grey 10y agoThe DEA needs to go away. It's not a useful agency, and does little which other agencies couldn't do to the extent that society actually requires it.
- Veratyr 10y agoI'm not American so forgive me if this is a silly question but isn't/shouldn't the responsibility for evaluating the safety and approval of foods and drugs belong to the FDA? Isn't the DEA being in charge of this like the FBI passing laws? Why does the DEA have this power?
- metaphorm 10y ago> Why does the DEA have this power? Because Richard Nixon hated hippies and wanted to set up a nearly unaccountable police agency to persecute them. I'm not kidding and only exaggerating a little bit.
- ced_vdb 10y agoIs there anything in favor of the war on drugs ? I heard portugal made every drug legal and the amount of addicts has plumeted.
- henriquemaia 10y agoDecriminalized them. They're not _legal_. Still illegal to produce, buy, sell them.
- vt240 10y agoOur law makers have delegated many of their powers, under the constitution, to administrative organizations. There are lots of good arguments for and against this, but it is the primary reason why presidential elections are so important in the USA.
- deathanatos 10y agoRight. And I think the parent asked a really good question: isn't the power of regulating what foods and drugs are safe for the populace to consume a responsibility that was delegated to the USFDA, not the DEA? If the DEA does have this power … isn't there overlap between the FDA and the DEA?
- riffic 10y agoCan we put the subject of the ban (WHICH PLANT) in the title please? HN is a bit more useless than the DEA with these obscure and clickbaity titles.
- BurningFrog 10y agoIf you didn't know it before, this should make it clear these decisions are political, not scientific.
- jknoepfler 10y agoAs with all things in Washington, I'd follow the money. I'd wager someone with a lot of milk to spill lobbied hard to get the scheduling move reversed. I wouldn't buy for a second that the needs of recovering addicts had anything to do with it. The DEA has made it abundantly clear that it gives exactly zero fucks about the facts regarding the narcotics it regulates or the consequences for lay people of their regulation.
- jknoepfler 10y agoAs with all things in Washington, I'd follow the money. I'd wager someone with a lot of milk to spill lobbied hard to get the scheduling move reversed. I wouldn't buy for a second that the needs of recovering addicts had anything to do with it. The DEA has made it abundantly clear that it gives exactly zero fucks about the facts regarding the narcotics that regulate or the consequences for lay people of their regulation.
- nikcub 10y ago> Schedule I substances are those that have the following findings: > 1. The drug or other substance has a high potential for abuse. > 2. The drug or other substance has no currently accepted medical use in treatment in the United States. > 3. There is a lack of accepted safety for use of the drug or other substance under medical supervision Kratom doesn't meet any of those requirements, let alone all three. The scheduling process requires reform, and this impacts a large part of the world since drug scheduling (and patent protection on pharma) are part of American trade agreements. Almost every action the DEA has taken has worsened the opioid epidemic and benefited the Mexican cartels. They didn't require doctor licensing or tracking for lower-level pain medication, they were then slow to crack down on the pill mills - once a large part of the population was addicted, they were then very slow to license more methadone programs and suboxone doctors for the fresh wave of addicts, and now they want to shut down one of the only free and working treatment options (Kratom) The only result you can expect from the DEA's actions are more and more opioid deaths. It is up to 18,000 a year now - over 3x as many Americans who were killed in Iraq in total - so 3 Iraq wars per year. The NYTimes has an excellent series of stories on the opioid epidemic - the video of the woman overdosing in a supermarket while her child attempts to wake her up are shattering: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/28/us/addicted-parents-get-their-fix-even-with-children-watching.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/28/us/addicted-parents-get-th... http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/08/opinion/sunday/how-doctors-helped-drive-the-addiction-crisis.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/08/opinion/sunday/how-doctors... http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/13/well/family/opioids-may-interfere-with-parenting-instincts-study-finds.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/13/well/family/opioids-may-in...
- Fargren 10y ago>>over 3x as many Americans who were killed in Iraq in total - so 3 Iraq wars per year. I know what you mean, but it really bothers me that you are only counting American deaths. The total number of Iraqi deaths arising from the Iraq war is highly disputed, but it seems to be somewhere between 150,000 and a bit over 1,000,000, depending on the survey and whether it only counts direct deaths of combatants vs. surveys that count civilian deaths and indirect effects. In any case, deaths arising from opioids are nowhere near any amount of "Iraq wars per year".
- nerdponx 10y agoThe fact that any federal agency, let alone the DEA, walked back a proposal in the face of public outcry is a real sign that positive change is happening, albeit slowly and subtly. If Obama were white, he would go down in history as one of the great presidents, despite his flaws, which are probably still better than those of other greats like FDR.
- dmix 10y agoIs there any indication that the White House had any influence on this? The last I checked the only places the DEA has stopped their programs is in countries they've been kicked out of for causing more harm than good. Otherwise outside of reducing handpicked domestic crack sentences there hasn't been much revision of drug policy in the last 8 yrs. Look at Colorado or other states which the populace decided to legalize marijuana industry - which were actually big deals. Where has the executive branch stepped in to stop the federal governments intervention in state policy? It's sad when the most minor amount of positive development is rewarded as an drastic evolution in behaviour. Is that the standards that we hold the government up to these days? Kratom is harmless to the average person. Comparable or likely less than marijuana. This was the easiest of choices, especially when considering the complete lack of evidence that it's comparable to the other schedule I drugs.
- cossatot 10y ago> Look at Colorado or other states which the populace decided to legalize marijuana industry - which were actually big deals. Where has the executive branch stepped in to stop the federal governments intervention in state policy? Obama made the decision that the DEA/DOJ would let state legalizations continue[1], at least unless it became clearly problematic. I and many others assume that he's not opposed to legalization and is letting the states be the laboratories for democracy that they should be. I also think this would never have happened in the previous administrations, and Obama is behind more of it than you seem to be giving him credit for. He's just not coming forward as an explicit supporter because it would detract from his support outside of his base supporters. [1] http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2012/12/14/obama-enforcing-pot-laws-in-states-that-have-legalized-it-not-a-top-priority/ http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2012/12/14/obama-enforc...
- patrickaljord 10y agoThe whole concept of banning plants is absurd statism. What are they gonna do? Ban evolution and photosynthesis? Send earth to prison?
- Hydraulix989 10y ago"The DEA is not one to second-guess itself, no matter what the facts are." That's such a sad reflection on American culture. People here value firm, decisive leaders that stick to their principles, even if they're wrong, over people more apt to listen to all sides of the story and re-evaluate their positions over time (because the latter people somehow look "weak" -- even the wording of "second-guess" corroborates this). It's such a detriment to social progress.