13 ms·
Hyperloop One Raises $50M, Hires Former Uber CFO
- brianbreslin 10y agoAm I the only one who gets confused by which hyperloop company is which? What's the difference between the different players?
- charlesdm 10y agoIt's the one that's going to get built. By Dubai no less!
- brianbreslin 10y agowhich one? hyperloopONE?
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoFrom what I can tell, Hyperloop One f/k/a Hyperloop Technologies [1] is a venture-backed company testing at an open-air track in Nevada. They are the ones raising $50MM. (They are also the ones playing the "everyone sues everyone" game.) Hyperloop Transportation Technologies [2] is approaching the problem with crowdfunding and crowd collaboration. Their pictures are quite pretty. [1] https://hyperloop-one.com https://hyperloop-one.com [2] http://hyperlooptransp.com http://hyperlooptransp.com
- blhack 10y agoWhich one has the test track next to SpaceX?
- strictnein 10y agoTo make it more confusing: neither. It's SpaceX's track. http://www.spacex.com/hyperloop http://www.spacex.com/hyperloop > "To support this competition, SpaceX is constructing a test track adjacent to our Hawthorne, California headquarters"
- djsumdog 10y agoThe technology isn't theirs either, or at least not the concept for it. The original idea was proposed years ago and named ETT or Evacuated Tube Transport by a company called ET3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=92dK_yxaKvk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=92dK_yxaKvk
- 1024core 10y agoHyperloop Tranportation hasn't had an update in nearly 2 years: http://hyperlooptransp.com/#!/updates http://hyperlooptransp.com/#!/updates
- imaginenore 10y agoI'm happy for them, but I'm yet to hear for anybody to address the major challenges that many people have raised. The major one being - the sudden pressurization in any point and the consequent shockwave traveling at the speed of sound, exploding the tube, killing everything in its way. Thunderf00t did a good job summarizing the problems: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RNFesa01llk https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RNFesa01llk
- goodcanadian 10y agoJust as aircraft (and I'm sure other pressure vessels) are designed to resist explosive decompression, I am sure any real hyperloop system would be as well. That is not to say that it could never happen, but with proper engineering (and maintenance), we can make it exceedingly unlikely.
- imaginenore 10y agoI'm not talking about the pod depressurization, which is indeed analogous to the plane, but is a separate issue, and is actually much worse than the plane (planes don't fly in near-vacuum, and can descend very quickly). I'm talking about the tube pressurization, which is much much worse.
- goodcanadian 10y agoSo am I. You can still prevent explosive decompression in much the same way. If you provide reinforcing strapping for example, you prevent a minor puncture from turning into a massive tear and explosive decompression [EDIT: perhaps, I should say re-compression]. I.E. if air is leaking in relatively slowly, you will never get the violent pressure wave you are talking about.
- imaginenore 10y agoThat doesn't solve larger tears, like a terrorist shooting an RPG at it, or exploding something underneath, or flying a small plane into it. It's a very large target to secure compared to a plane.
- jlebrech 10y agowill hyperloop be the only martian transportation one day? imagine there being a grid of hyperloop to take all over the planet. it's also free of those pesky seas.
- nicktelford 10y agoSure would be a lot easier/cheaper to maintain a near-vacuum when that is exactly what the atmosphere is!
- m0skit0 10y agoMars atmosphere is far from being near-vacuum. Also if you have to extract air, the difference between how much air you have to extract is pretty much irrelevant.
- lisper 10y agoHyperloop is much more feasible on Mars than on earth because you don't need to maintain a vacuum -- you've already got one. You don't even need a tube, just a U-shaped track.
- ceejayoz 10y agoLet's hope we leave space in future Martian cities for public transportation infrastructure.
- kctess5 10y agoI'm not sure that the ability to make a vacuum is our primary bottleneck to making a Hyperloop on Mars.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y ago> You don't even need a tube, just a U-shaped track. Thus making it a monorail, rather than a Hyperloop.
- lisper 10y ago
- lisper 10y agoOoh, how I wish I could buy put options on the Hyperloop. Because unless they solve the thermal expansion problem -- and there is no feasible solution on the horizon AFAICT -- they will fail.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoNot to mention all of the logistical problems with building and maintaining a low pressure tube. People think high speed rail is expensive? Wait until you see how expensive Hyperloop is going to be per mile. PS - And I haven't even touched on safety/evacuation problems with the concept. That quadupled the cost and size of the Eurotunnel for comparison, how can we assume it won't bloat the Hyperloop's size/cost/complexity?
- komali2 10y agoAnd so it does? However you feel about the executives and history of Hyperloop, I think it's important that companies like this exist and try things like this. You know what's expensive and was once unfeasible? Strapping thousands of tons of fuel to a rocket and launching it into space. And yet...
- masklinn 10y ago> I think it's important that companies like this exist and try things like this. They're not trying anything at this point, they've raised enough money for at most 5km worth of high-speed tracks (proper 350km/h graded tracks) and no rolling stock.
- komali2 10y agoWhat about R&D output? Even if the company goes broke, they / their research can be purchased and used in the future. They might only produce new materials that they sell the patents for upon going bankrupt. Their engineers and scientists will develop and learn, and move on to other firms if Hyperloop becomes insolvement, and take that knowledge with them.
- falsestprophet 10y agoThe funding round was led by DP World, which operates 77 marine terminals around the globe [1] and is interested in using hyperloops to move containers from marine terminals to inland ports. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DP_World https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DP_World
- xseven 10y agoUber had a CFO? That's news to me
- jandrese 10y agoI still can't get past the feeling that this is another Moller Aircar type project. Something to string investors along forever while you bilk them out of money. The proposals aren't even all that similar to the original Hyperloop proposal. Gone is the ducted fan setup and instead they're just building high speed rail in a tube. And the cost estimates still make no sense whatsoever. I will be frankly shocked if any of these companies ever lay anything more than a short test track somewhere.
- Animats 10y agoMost of the workable plans, such as the MIT prototype, are "maglev on a track in a vacuum tube", rather than the original Musk "flies at a 0.5 to 1.3 mm height on aerodynamic lift" plan. That low flying height would require a really smooth tube, with no millimeter-sized sags in the middle of tube sections. Not impossible, just expensive. The whole point of the Hyperloop system is that that the tube is supposed to be cheap. Dubai Ports World might build a system between Abu Dhabi and Dubai. The route is flat and empty. and not too long. Dubai already has two monorail systems and a metro rail system, all beautiful and underutilized.[1] It may cost too much, but that probably won't be a problem. A maglev doesn't need the tube below 200MPH or so. One way to build a useful system might be to run in a vacuum tube for long, straight runs, and switch to open track in congested areas. This would allow bringing the tracks much further into cities. Musk's original plan called for ending the LA-SF system in Fremont, near Tesla's plant. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=615x7e8wXNU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=615x7e8wXNU
- jandrese 10y agoThe idea of creating a miles long pressure vessel "for cheap" always seemed to be the most insane part of the project. It is certainly technically possible to build a structure like that, but I have no idea how they plan to make it affordable.
- Animats 10y agoThat's a classic problem with monorail enthusiasts. Early drawings of proposed monorails used to show single lightweight elevated rails on thin pylons.[1] Pictures of successful operating monorails, such as Tokyo Haneda, show double tracks on heavy pylons.[2] Often there's an emergency walkway alongside. (There are a surprising number of operating monorail systems in the world now. The US is way behind in this. The few in the US are airport systems or tourist attractions, but Japan and China, and now Brazil, have city-sized systems.)
- stcredzero 10y agoI think this needs to be brought to more people's attention, so I'm putting this in a top level comment: Thunderf00t's video: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RNFesa01llk https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RNFesa01llk Debunked: https://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/4udgd2/the_hyperloop_one_busted_by_the_youtube/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/4udgd2/the_hype... Also debunked: https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/4wck43/hi_were_mostly_engineers_here_at_hyperloop_one/ https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/4wck43/hi_were_mostly...
- wtvanhest 10y agoI do not know a lot about the technology, but I remember reading that the hyperloop is not a full vacuum, just a lower pressure environment. That alone means all these videos are bunk themselves.
- Qantourisc 10y agoLow pressure, vacuum, I doubt physics care (not a physicist), it's just a pressure differential, just a bigger or smaller one. So the effects would just be smaller.
- wtvanhest 10y agoRight, but using a true vacuum as your comparable for the construction of a partial vacuum is nonsensical. This structure has a differential closer to an airline, not a space shuttle. Airplanes can handle that pressure differential with a thin layer of aluminum. They can even have windows! Thinking through this a little more. In basic terms, you just need a tunnel big enough combined with low enough pressure that at speed, the train has significantly less air to push out of the way. I'm sure it is some complex math, but someone who understands the math could figure it out.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- Animats 10y agoDubai Ports World invested in this? That's serious. They're owned by the government of Dubai.
- stingraycharles 10y agoWhy is that serious, considering the track record of Dubai investing in silly things ?
- jpatokal 10y agoThe things may be silly, but they still cost serious money. So Hyperloop appears to just gone from "unfunded wacky idea" to "funded wacky idea".
- fudged71 10y agoHyperloop was accepted into the Dubai government accelerator, which is a 3 month program specifically meant to match you up with a government department and sign a contract. The accelerator is overseen by the Sheik's son. There's a lot of money behind this program. Consensys the blockchain company is in the accelerator as well as Sure Chill for cooling medicines, and an augmented reality for education startup, and potentially a concrete 3D printing company as well. There are allegedly 30 companies in the cohort although the list hasn't been made public. I think the program has a huge amount of potential to rapidly scale up these technologies, I just hope that the companies are able to scale with the demand.
- douche 10y agoI'd like to see some venture capitalists put forth some big chunks of money on realistic infrastructure projects using boring, proven technologies. Sure, there's not much chance of ever getting any kind of return on it, but at the end of it, there's still a bridge, or an extra couple transit stops left over when you're done lighting money on fire. Maybe something like imperial Roman conspicuous construction instead of conspicuous consumption. Just for a change.
- eric_h 10y agoI believe we have a presidential candidate quite well versed in conspicuous construction with negligible returns.
- AndrewKemendo 10y ago$50M is peanuts for this scale of a project and the engineering that will need to be done. Seems like this is likely only enough to get to a small scale POC. I think it's a great start, but it's still super early to know if this can even work.
- netule 10y agoHonestly, I'm just glad that the project isn't dead after the recent kerfuffle. Hiring decent people may be a good way to get back on track and attract more investors.
- danbruc 10y ago50 million Dollars will buy you at least 200 man-year of clever people thinking about it, that should be more than enough to realize that this is not an (economically) viable endeavor and render building a prototype mood.
- zootam 10y agobut it will also buy at least 50 'man-year' of clever people thinking about marketing it and how to continue to profit off of it regardless if it is feasible or not
- nihonde 10y agoI'm all for chasing ambitious goals, but America should probably demonstrate some modest capabilities in building and running high speed passenger trains before it disrupts that game. While Americans (and Dubai) chase this hyperloop boondoggle, Japan is rolling out 300kph+ trains from stern (Kyushu) to tip (Hokkaido) in the most inhospitable and earthquake-prone region in the world, with insane population densities in some places, across relatively vast waterways, and with almost zero delays in operating timetables.
- pitaj 10y agoShould America also have upgraded the mail system before telegraph lines were deployed? Should America have also made faster trains before building the interstate system? Innovation and disruption are better than just incremental improvements to make some existing technology fit your bill.
- minikites 10y agoI wonder if they've fixed the basic engineering errors from the first proposal: http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2013/08/hyperloop/ http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2013/08/hyperloop/ > Neither of these is possible for the Hyperloop because the high speed of the capsule zooming along inside it means the pipe curves have to be very gentle. How, I wondered, is Musk going to solve the thermal expansion problem? > The answer turned out to be simple: he didn’t. There’s some hand waving and, possibly, a complete misunderstanding of how thermal expansion acts, but no actual solution. The rest of the article is a deep dive into the problems with the earlier Hyperloop proposal.
- pitaj 10y agoThat appears to be old. The official proposal by his engineers was released, where every criticism I've heard has been addressed. Here's a playlist of videos rebutting some common claims against the hyperloop: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSPi1JFx4_-Gz0Fm0qq2KUz4c22UbZCco https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSPi1JFx4_-Gz0Fm0qq2K...
- minikites 10y agoInteresting, thank you.
- zizzles 10y agoHow resilient will the Hyperloop be against terrorist attacks? It is situated above ground. This means the tubing is exposed to all and everyone. In other words, it is vulnerable to homemade explosives which can perhaps obstruct the path the vessel transverses. Sounds far-fetched, but the lengths extremists go to can not be undermined as we have learned time and time again throughout history. I am interested in the security protocols more so than anything else.
- niftich 10y agoIt's at least equally vulnerable as conventional rail, but more vulnerable than aircraft, which are usually out of reach of improvised weapons and are usually surrounded with some cursory security on the ground.
- the_watcher 10y agoThis is a valid concern, but it's definitely not one that should impede efforts to construct one or prove its viability. For one, hyperloops have a lot of potential value for shipping. For another, most of the designs don't seem to involve a huge number of people in on point at once, and it wouldn't be hijackable in the way than an aircraft is. To be honest, the simplest form of transit to use in terms of ease of access combined with potential destruction is just a car or bus, right?
- wcummings 10y agoHyperloop (and pretty much all "PRT") is a joke and whoever invested in this should be embarrassed. Just get it over with and build high-speed rail.
- Shivetya 10y agobetter yet, don't build any rail for passenger travel. let us instead engineer changes to our roadways to allow for self driving cars to occur sooner and safer. only a few countries in the world have more than 10% of passenger miles by rail. heavy rail is just too damn expensive for what it provides and there are what, two non subsidized systems out there? plus hundreds of billions in backlogged maintenance to many rail systems, not even counting the rail car maintenance that has been put off.
- moultano 10y agoIsn't rail inherently more energy efficient due to the rigid wheels even without the economies of multipassenger vehicles?
- wcummings 10y agoMore space efficient.
- geezerjay 10y agoRail is efficient due to the low slopes that are required by the steel-on-steel friction, required to accelerate/brake through the wheel/rail interaction. And yes, the only mode of transportation that is cheaper than rail with regards to cost per tonnage is sea transport. In passanger transportation, it really depends on the distances and on the speed of transportation. People tend to pay a premium for point-to-point speed, and although airway transportation is unbeatable in that regard the time to get to the nearest airport and required to board end up adding a travel time penalty between 1 and 2 hour. This means that high-speed rail tends to be, by far, the best mode of transportation between destinations that are distanced up to around 400km.
- 10y ago
- kahrkunne 10y agoThe hyperloop - all the dangers of outer space, here on earth. Or: if we can't get SpaceXplode into space, we'll get space down to earth
- tofupup 10y agoneat
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jrockway 10y ago50 million dollars is enough to build 100 feet of subway (in New York).
- KyoChunho 10y agoDoes Elon Musk still have anything to do with any of the Hyperloop companies?
- alberthartman 10y agoHow about dropping the Hyperloop evacuated tube idea and replace it with something more achievable? How about a private roadway that is completely flat and only for specially-equipped electric cars? The cars are completely autonomous and communicate with neighboring cars and a central traffic controller. The cars can tailgate each other in complete safety at 200-250 mph allowing for extremely dense road usage (no 9 car lengths separations). And all the traffic will move at exactly the same super-high speed, carefully servoed. People can just get in using their own privately-owned certified compliant electric cars. And then take a nap as the autonomous driving takes over for safe high-speed travel. No traffic jam slowdowns, no slowpokes in your lane. Road-embedded power can wirelessly beam energy so there is no need for refueling stations. Traffic control manages vehicles entering and leaving the roadway. Read the news or take a nap. SF-to-LA in 2hrs, and you arrive rested and with your car. Not the hyperloop, but drastically cheaper and leveraging technology that's coming anyway. The novelty is drastically higher speeds, bumper to bumper driving, continuous fueling.