8 ms·
"Developer preview of Unity 8 includes desktop, tablet and phone UX convergence" Am I the only one that thinks this is a terrible idea?
by tonyedgecombe 10y ago
"Developer preview of Unity 8 includes desktop, tablet and phone UX convergence"
Am I the only one that thinks this is a terrible idea?
- oblio 10y agoIt depends how it's done. Microsoft's approach was pretty wonky as it basically gutted the desktop. If Ubuntu's one is more respectful for the desktop, why not try it?
- criddell 10y agoI have a feeling that if Microsoft were to design a motorcycle, it would have a steering wheel and gas pedal.
- raverbashing 10y agoMy bet is that it isn't I'm not happy to say this but free software consistently fumbles usability So, no. It's not going to work for all of them
- dijit 10y agoYou're not the only one, but since they're the only company backing unity they're free to explore things. Maybe it's a great idea hidden as a bad one- I'm for exploration as long as they're not dragging software contributed to by others coughgnomecough.
- yulaow 10y agoMeh, let them try! At least on ubuntu we can choose between a lot of DE and WM, and we are not obliged to use unity anyway, so nothing is really forced on us (Still wishing to have a win7 ui on w10)
- theandrewbailey 10y agoThe Aero UI is exactly as pretty as it was 10 years ago, and I think that it all still looks good.
- gertlex 10y agoOn Windows 8 and 10 (Surface Pro and a Desktop respectively), I use Windows7-like UI for most things via Classic Shell.
- reddotX 10y agoeven in the current state Unity 8 is not really that bad to use on desktop https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vaf2LTeLHhQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vaf2LTeLHhQ (it's more or less like unity7 on desktop)
- solaris_7 10y agoI'm always intrigued by this desire for integration. Even if you want to have one device that is mainly a phone but also a PC when you connect it to an external 24" screen and keyboard - why can't it have totally different UX experiences optimized for each state? Is that really so bad? Windows 8 was a UX disaster - so maybe that's just coloring my judgement. I haven't used Ubuntu on mobile yet so guess I need to try it.
- V-2 10y agoThey shouldn't be totally different. Common look and feel is welcome in my opinion. Then obviously they should be customized to adjust for different input devices and screen sizes. It can be done without repeating the Windows 8 fiasco - which seemed to be tailored for touch-input devices, leading to clunky experience on a regular PC. Eg. see Remix OS, or Android for desktop: http://www.jide.com/remixos http://www.jide.com/remixos It's Android, but from the look of it, it's adapted nicely: https://youtu.be/TjAxCWO84L4 https://youtu.be/TjAxCWO84L4 (I admit I haven't used it myself, but even if there are some quirks not visible at first glance, my point is not that Remix OS hit the sweet spot, only that it can be done in principle).
- jug 10y agoYes, I think Windows 10 is a more mature and sane take on this concept, where the "apps" can now run windowed as usual. Makes the transition _much_ less jarring, and is more like how RemixOS also mentioned in the comments here does it with Android.
- davidw 10y agoSeems kind of like aiming for a convergent experience with a pocketknife and a table saw, but hey, maybe my pessimism is unwarranted. I use Xubuntu anyway. I'm extremely grateful for all the effort people have put into Ubuntu over the years.
- yAnonymous 10y agoWorking everywhere with the same tools on one device would be awesome and I can imagine Unity and Linux being much better at this than Microsoft's pathetic attempt.
- 72deluxe 10y agoWhy? Why was Microsoft's attempt pathetic?
- formula1 10y agoI think this is a good thing in the long run. I have no problem being the beta tester for a unifying ui. This can consolidate development focus which arguably will reduce bugs. As people get more tired of one ui, there will likely eventually be enough pushback to cause more custom options. A major difference between ubuntu and every other os is ubuntu is open source with a rich enough history to show it has staying power. Worse comes to worse another fork happens. But the OS UX paradigm has a huge opportunity to evolve with this kind of focus
- satysin 10y agoNope I think it is a horrible idea also. Microsoft showed us that mixing the UX between a 5" screen and a 25" screen sucks. I can't imagine Ubuntu working it out any better. Why the hell do they worry about UX convergence yet I can't put the dock on the right side of the screen?! (and only just got the ability to put it on the bottom earlier this year!)
- superkuh 10y agoIt is a terrible idea. No matter their popularity phones have tiny screens and limited, slow input methods compared to desktop PCs. And mobile OSes have to be provided with special workarounds to deal with the absolutely terrible mobile IP networking that cannot even keep a TCP session open reliably. Convergence to a user interface that provides the crutches for these limits of mobile platforms neccessarily gimps the desktop UI too.
- bandrami 10y agoNo. It's been tried over and over again for a decade now, and keeps running very hard onto the rocks of "users really, really don't want that". I get why devs want it: it's a single codebase for everything. But nobody, and I mean nobody, wants to use a desktop computer the way they use a tablet or a phone. There's a reason people tend to disable computer touchscreens.
- luxpir 10y ago>But nobody, and I mean nobody, wants to use a desktop computer the way they use a tablet or a phone. That's not quite what's on offer. It's more like the ability to plug your phone into a monitor and carry on working. No longer carrying a laptop around (once tablets/phones are at CPU horsepower parity for office work). So yeah, it's not working backwards like you suggest, it's making the phone/tablet more like a desktop (add mice, keyboards, screens etc.) One mobile device is quite likely all we'll need in the near future, not three separates. 2-in-1 laptops are already selling quite well as MS gets its own convergence efforts underway. Apple are actually lagging in this field and kudos to Ubuntu for steering the ship in an innovative/inevitable direction.
- mrighele 10y ago> It's more like the ability to plug your phone into a monitor and carry on working. Do I really need a phone to do this ? As long as I can reach the same data I don't really care if I'm on the same device where I started working on it. In fact the software I want to use when I am in front of a monitor is much different than the one I have on my phone, and I am not talking only about user interface, but also features. Cpu power is getting cheaper and in smaller form factors. I suspect that instead of connecting our phones to the display devices, those devices will be powerful enough that we won't need any integration. And if I really want something portable, I will be able to "add a cpu" with an external stick (like Intel Compute Stick, but cheaper e/o smaller).
- bandrami 10y agoAnd if I really want something portable, I will be able to "add a cpu" with an external stick I'd say it's even more likely that anything computationally expensive won't be done in the same room with you to begin with 10 years from now, but will be done by an anonymous compute node in a datacenter that you're leasing for the 5 seconds you're using it.
- fingar 10y agoBad idea to include the developer preview? You can safely try it out and see whether it works for your hardware.
- Pxtl 10y agoHaving used Windows 10 and the ascendance of responsive webpages, I can see its potential. Obviously Microsoft completely bungled it in Windows 8, but otherwise: This is something that can be done and done well, and if so I'd love to have a phone with the power and software of a full desktop device, expressed in a phone-oriented UI. The trick is that there's a matrix of several features that have to be considered: 1) Tiny screens means that multiple visible applications is not useful, and that all OS UI needs to be auto-hidden (something users want to be able to do anyways). Font sizes may need to be scaled up (that's something you need to be supporting anyways for older folks). 2) Touch means adding new ways to interact with existing widgets (drag scroll, for ex) and buttons need to be scaled up to have a larger hit-area (and you alreayd have to deal with scaling up fonts, so fixed-size UI elements already went out the window). To me, the important thing is that 1 and 2 are not duct-taped together. If I have a phone and a stylus or I plug in a keyboard and mouse, I want 1 but not 2. On the other hand, if I have a 20" touch-screen, I want 2 but not 1.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoUnified UI is a terrible idea: the idea boils down to this: instead of having several UIs that serve the interface they operate on well, have one UI that serves all the interfaces poorly.
- talideon 10y agoThey're not forcing it on anybody any time soon. Until Unity 8 has parity with Unity 7, it's not even going to be considered as the default. Funny thing is, their efforts to avoid the issues with and backlash against the original Unity are the reason Unity 8 has been delayed for so long. Whatever else you might say about Canonical, at least they're doing the whole 'convergence' thing in a pretty open and responsible manner.
- matt4077 10y agoIs there a meaningful difference to responsive websites? Because those have generally evolved to a point where the interfaces work quite well across devices while sharing meaningful amounts of code to make it easier than build x individual UIs.
- e12e 10y agoI'd say it depends. I'm a rather happy owner of a Microsoft Surface 4 Pro - and I do see the need for the ability to switch between modes (and I can't say MS has exactly succeeded here, but also not entirely failed). Granted, I don't really see why I'd want UI/UX adapted to a screen 1/8th the size - but to a certain extent "tablet mode" and "tiny tablet mode" are probably more similar than "tablet mode" and "laptop/desktop" mode. I'd have to test it of course. One thing that MS has not managed is make a UI that works well for high resolution screens (for legacy applications, that is). But I guess one of the reasons I'm positive to the use of "convergence" buzz word, is that it could mean that all GUI-frameworks are expected to scale in a sane manner. I absolutely understand the skepticism that it will end up being "a worst of all worlds" UI.
- tdkl 10y agoNope. I wished Ubuntu used the Windows 8 clusterfuck to gather more ground on desktop, but instead they jumped on mobile/tablet hype rollercoaster.
- krylon 10y agoYou are not. I still remember how well it worked out on Windows 8...
- WayneBro 10y agoYes I remember too and it worked very well. I used it the whole time it was available. It worked well on my Windows tablets (Surface Pro, Surface Pro 3, Dell Venue 8 Pro). It worked well on my gaming PC, my dev workstation and my hyper-v server.
- krylon 10y agoAdmittedly, I have been told by several people that the new interface worked very nicely on tablets. That's what it was made for, after all. On desktops without a touch screen, I found it annoying and still do. Of course, one can still get work done using the new interface, but I still don't understand how they got the crazy idea of throwing out the start menu.
- AgentME 10y agoI love Unity, so hearing that it's getting better on mobile sounds great.
- toxican 10y agoThere's a reason I've not used plain Ubuntu in years, and it's Unity. Pretty much all canonical variations of Ubuntu ship with a better UI than Ubuntu anymore.
- vegabook 10y agoI don't agree with this. I have done Gnome 3.18 for 6 months, did i3 for another 12, and tbh, I found myself with a bog-standard Unity interface on a new machine about 3 months ago and I haven't bothered to change it. Why? Because it doesn't try to be clever, it doesn't get in the way, sure I have to use the mouse a tiny bit more, but it just seems nice and vanilla. It works well by being inconspicuous and straightforward, while not trying extra hard to be boring (Cinnamon). And the fonts look crisp like OS/x which, to my detail-oriented eye, is a big deal. Actually the only UI I consider truly interesting, believe it or not, is e17. That feels like being on a Star Trek transporter beaming onto a Romulan Warbird. Real deal no compromise "this ain't Kansas", if that's your thing. Try Terminology for a taster. All the others (KDE) are trying too hard while simultaneously not being truly interesting. Or they're stultifyingly boring (cinnamon - why?) without being resource cheap. On this front, xfce on armbian is a beaut. Cinnamon without the weight. I also give i3 a big thumbs up btw but I just can't live without the tray icon conveniences for bluetooth, dropbox, power down etc.
- stormbrew 10y ago> I give i3 a big thumbs up btw but I just can't live without the tray icons. What do you mean? i3bar supports tray icons just fine...
- zerognowl 10y agoKeep in mind, iOS apps send your devices' serial number & MAC address via a simple API command, and this can all be done without asking for permission. If you bought an iDevice in a store, you're also on CCTV buying that device and it can absolutely be traced to your canonical name. The idea behind Ubuntu tablets is that it imports the security model of the Debian Linux trust chain to the user, and so worries of serial numbers and the typical 'link-ability' one finds in proprietary iOS devices are vanished.
- gurkendoktor 10y agoI'm not sure if it's a terrible idea in general, but a Ubuntu phone would be many years behind iOS/Android when it comes to apps. I think only Apple and Google have the marketshare to pull off a convergent OS at this point.