12 ms·
The Rise of Hypersonic Weapons
- adrianN 10y agoThis reminds me of Project Thor [1]. The idea was to drop tungsten rods from orbit on the target. It would also be a weapon that is very hard to defend against with similar implications to these hypersonic missiles. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_bombardment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_bombardment
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoIt's not really "dropping" them - they're in orbit and already not falling. You'd need to fire them backwards with a rocket engine (or railgun?) to deorbit. At that point, why not just fire them as a ballistic missile?
- azernik 10y agoFaster reaction time, less obvious launch, and ability to attack from any direction (not just the direction that your bases and submarines happen to be in). There were also proposals to just launch nuclear warheads into orbit, for deorbiting in case of war, but they were banned by treaty because they were considered too destabilizing - as were partial orbital weapons, which just went into orbit for long enough to attack from unusual directions.
- lmm 10y agoThey're not vulnerable to boost-phase intercept. And potentially more deniable at least historically (with a ballistic launch any radar track will point you to the launch site, whereas to detect the origin of kinetic bombardment you'd have to be continuously tracking everything in orbit back to its original launch nation).
- arethuza 10y agoWhat about the Sprint ABM - 0 to Mach 10 in 5 seconds! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprint_(missile) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprint_(missile)
- simonh 10y agoI'm surprised the wikipedia page doesn't discuss the technical problems. Accurate guidance proved to be surprisingly hard and the heat of atmospheric re-entry both blocks targeting sensors and also interferes with targeting signals from a ground spotter.Also it turns out terminal velocity for such a device isn't really all that high, relatively speaking. It's also prohibitively expensive. So it sounds good, but isn't really practical. Shame, I was a big Jerry Pournelle fan back in the day.
- throwanem 10y agoI'm not sure these are as destabilizing as the article makes them sound. If Russia and China didn't already have the capability of destroying US carrier battle groups, I could see the sense in the argument, but Moskits are cheap, capable of Mach 3, and easily able to swamp antimissile defenses when launched en masse. (And they can carry a nuclear payload, too, not that it's likely they would in such a scenario, nor would they need to.)
- nprecup 10y agoA hypersonic vehicle can travel much faster than that. We're talking about the ability to strike targets anywhere on the globe in minutes. That IS destabilizing. The example of striking carrier groups in the pacific is only the tip of the iceberg. This race amounts to a global game of chicken, and the stakes of a mistake are world war. Let's hope cooler heads prevail. On the other hand, there are some pretty amazing applications of air breathing hypersonic technology. You could use it to launch equipment, satellites and people into space much more efficiently (air breathing means you don't need to carry an oxidizer!). Or imagine being able to fly from NY to Hong Kong in an hour! This kind of tech is not as imminant as the article is implying. We've only barely demonstrated small air breathing hypersonic vehicles as feasible (see X-51 and X-43). The X-43 was a crude initial test that demonstrated flights of only up to 12 seconds. The X-51 managed to go for 6 minutes. Scaling this up to a transportation vehicle will pose a significant engineering challenge.
- 3pt14159 10y agoNot if you run the simulations. A city or three might get nuked in a tit-tat-tit exchange, but total war isn't currently likely. During the 60s and 70s there was the _chance_ we could just nuke all their nukes at once and maybe they'd get London, NY, or Washington, but we'd survive. A total strike is no longer even a first reach option because even if they level us and somehow cripple our nukes or kentic weapons we can just unleash a bioweapon on everyone and it's payback game over. I look at these weapons in the same way. There might be a couple dozen million deaths from an exchange that starts with them, but after some tense phone calls things will deescalate. What I worry about is actors smaller than a well funded nation state getting weapons like these, and for that we need intelligence.
- ewr24 10y ago> However, hypersonic weapons do not need to be nuclear in order to be disruptive, as demonstrated by the United States’ focus on conventional hypersonic weapons. Does China and Russia believe that? It takes a few minutes to swap conventional and nuclear warheads. If anything US is the leader in this new cold war.
- credit_guy 10y agoIt's very difficult to see a scenario where it makes sense to put a nuclear warhead on a hypersonic missile. The fact is, hypersonic missiles are dog slow compared to ICBMs. ICBMs though suffer from the tyranny of the rocket equation (most of the fuel they burn is used to push the rest of the fuel), so the mass of the warhead is a small fraction of the total mass of the rocket (for Trident 2 it's about 7%). The main problem is that ICBM's have to carry their own oxydizer, which is heavy. Cruise missiles get oxygen from the air, and this is a big deal. For a Tomahawk the warhead is 35% of the total mass of the missile. Now when you deliver a nuclear warhead (or a bunch), you don't care that much about the ratio warhead/total mass, since nuclear carries a lot of punch in a small package. And if you plan to start WW3, you might as well do it quick, no reason to use a (relatively) slow delivery vehicle, like a hypersonic one, when you can use an ICBM. It's when you want to deliver conventional explosives that you care about how big your rocket is. It's one thing for the rocket to be 3 times as big as the warhead (Tomahawk) and another to be 15 times as big (Trident 2). The Tomahawk is really slow though, so the idea of the hypersonic is to be faster, at the cost of having a smaller delivery ratio. The fastest current cruise missile, the Russian-Indian Brahmos has a 12% ratio of warhead to total mass (if launched from an airplane, less if launched from the ground), and a speed of about Mach 3. What would be the ratio for a hypersonic weapon? It shouldn't be less than 7% (otherwise you keep it "simple" and use the Trident 2 design) and it's unlikely it will be higher than the 12% of the Mach3 Brahmos-A missile. It will be somewhere in between, and most likely not that disruptive after all.
- ewr24 10y agoVery informative. However my impression is that US version is ballistic missile with highly maneuverable shuttle as a payload. Article mentions it will be capable to hit anywhere on earth within 30 minutes. It seems like very very expensive way of bombing terrorists.
- Cozumel 10y agoThere's nothing 'hypothetical' about them like the article says, both Russia ( http://www.ibtimes.com/russias-secret-hypersonic-nuclear-missile-yu-71-can-breach-existing-missile-defense-1987590 http://www.ibtimes.com/russias-secret-hypersonic-nuclear-mis... ) and China ( http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/china-successfully-tests-7000-mph-df-2f-hypersonic-missile-says-pentagon-source-1557121 http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/china-successfully-tests-7000-mph-d... ) have operational hypersonic missiles. Whether they would use them when conventional weapons work just as well and are cheaper is debatable but they already have them.
- dfsegoat 10y agoThe article you cite for the PLAN system states that it completed it's 7th test flight. This is not operational. For instance the F-35 only recently became "operationally capable" - but it has been flying since 2006.
- paulmd 10y agoAnd on the flip side, the P-51 Mustang took 149 days from placement of the order to the flight of the first prototypes (and the near-immediate order of a run of 300 further aircraft for evaluation). I'm not disagreeing with you that a test firing is vastly different from serial production, but the F-35 is the poster child for an unreasonably protracted and dysfunctional development process. It's a massively complex system with a dozen different major players all trying to pull it in conflicting directions with dozens of contractors all trying to make sure they diffuse the project across all 435 Congressional districts. The overall implication that because the F-35 is a trainwreck that it's not possible to ever develop a weapons system on a fast timeframe - that I disagree with. The fact that we are dysfunctional does not make everyone else so.
- dfsegoat 10y agoOh for sure - F-35 is a dog and I could have picked a better example, and I would even support your point to the extreme with: http://breakingdefense.com/2016/10/holy-smoke-gm-army-turn-out-new-hydrogen-car-in-9-months/ http://breakingdefense.com/2016/10/holy-smoke-gm-army-turn-o... They went from rfp => selection => 1st prototype in 9 months. Obviously, a car is a bit different than a 5th gen fighter. But still.
- ethagknight 10y agoThe article frequently mentions the agility of these hypersonics. Doesn't 'flies super fast' usually require 'flies in a straight line'? Do we have suitable materials for control surfaces that can withstand the drag/heat/pressure of an evasive, quick turn at Mach 5?
- CapitalistCartr 10y agoThe SR-71 did it fine slightly above Mach 4. If you call taking a few states to make a turn evasive.
- reubenswartz 10y agoWell, the SR-71 could go over Mach 3 at 85,000 ft. If you could have somehow pushed it to that speed at sea level, you would have had even worse heat problems.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ethagknight 10y agoRequiring a few states to hang a left makes it difficult to both evade and defense hit a target, right?
- dredmorbius 10y agoYour attacker is going to have roughly the same problem turning as you do. Though an unmanned attack vehicle (missile, drone) isn't limited by physiological g-force limitations. At some point though your airframe becomes airframes and flight dynamics change considerably.
- zevets 10y agomy understanding is that maneuverability is thought of in Gs - so even though the turn radius is enormous, the acceleration is high, and it's the acceleration that prevents defensive interceptors from getting hits
- LoSboccacc 10y agoI think this article conveniently forgets to mention nothing hypersonic of sort will outrun lasers. lasers can't track of course and range is limited by factor like atmosphere and earth curve, but still, thinking about an hypothetical future scenario hypersonic weapons would just get lasered down by automated point defences all the same as conventional speed ordinance.
- CapitalistCartr 10y agoTo shoot down a missile with a laser, you need a segment of light about 30-50 cm long, so the target doesn't move too much whilst burning a hole in it. In that little segment has to be the energy of at least a .50 BMG, so 20k joules of energy. In a portable form that can fire repeately, reliably. That's doable, but not easily.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThat's about one nanosecond of light. E.g. travelling 1000mph is about a foot per millisecond. I think your light could be 1000 times that long and still hit essentially the same point on the target?
- CapitalistCartr 10y agoTravelling 1000mph is about mach 1.3. Hypersonic is mach 5 to perhaps mach 15, if our space launch research goes well. The target has to travel less than about 5 mm in that time. A foot would schmear the light too far. [Edit] OK, I've done a bit of calculating, and I think you're right. The laser pulse could be a maximum of about 175 meters long.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoA foot of light is necessary if you focus on a millionth of a foot of target. A longer bolt is acceptable if tolerances are looser than that. And they probably are. 5mm is about 1000X larger than that.
- 10y ago
- CapitalistCartr 10y agoI think tying aerospace advances/research to only the military potential, and thereby banning it all, would be stupidly counter-productive, and ineffective. If we want spaceplanes, supersonic intercontinental flights, etc. this is where the rubber meets the road. A test ban treaty would be as wise, effective, and narrowly-focused as DRM is at preventing IP-violating file sharing.
- ekianjo 10y ago> would be able to knock out a target’s nuclear capabilities fast enough and thoroughly enough to pre-empt any attempt at a retaliatory strike. Did the author completely forget about nuclear subs?
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoOr nuclear tipped cruise missiles on ships or in-air bombers. The nuclear triad is still unbeatable. The article is pretty terrible in general. Hypersonics won't change the balance of anything, especially considering what a decent sized one can do. If you're delivering nuclear-levels of destruction with hypersonics then your opponent will retaliate with nuclear weapons. There will be no exception for "Oh, you used hypersonics on us, that's cool." If anything, hypersonics make the nuclear option more likely and nation states will be wary on ever using them on another nuclear power. The article does play up a 'Russia/China will soon dominate the US' nonsense that gets ad impressions, but if these weapons ever hit a US carrier or city, then a nuclear response will be the most likely scenario. The development of these weapons has been pretty slow and no one is sabre-rattling with them for a reason. They'll fall under the category of weapons of mass destruction, which is probably what all the major powers want because the alternative is yet another arms race, on top of the low simmering nuclear arms race that exists today.
- jessriedel 10y ago> or in-air bombers. It's no longer the case that the US and Russia maintain nuclear bombers in air continuous.
- mikeash 10y agoIt hasn't been for a long time, too. The US discontinued continuous air alert in 1968, when it became apparent that it was just too risky (planes kept crashing with live weapons on board) and ICBMs and SLBMs made it unnecessary. I'm sure it could be restarted now if it looked to be necessary, but it doesn't seem to be.
- upofadown 10y agoOnce you get to the point that you can explode anything you want anywhere on the planet it doesn't make much difference if you can do it somewhat faster. ... and it is getting pretty obvious that being able to blow things up doesn't make much difference anyway in a political sense. Simple terror doesn't work anymore to bring people around to your way of thinking. All the people that can be simply coerced are gone now.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ufmace 10y agoI'm also skeptical about the targeting side of these "wonder-weapons". Going really fast against, say, an aircraft carrier, is almost more of a liability if you don't already know exactly where it is and how fast it's going pretty much before you launch at all - you don't have much time to detect it and change course to actually hit it, plus reduced ability to detect things through all of the air resistance heat you're generating.
- djyaz1200 10y agoSeems like we might want to address this and other threats by putting "dial a yield" nuclear devices on our missile defense weapons?
- ryanmarsh 10y agoThis got me wondering, how low would the cost to reach LEO have to get for it to start making sense to use Falcon 9 + Dragon to deliver an SF team (e.g. commanders in-extremis force) to an objective? Then that got me thinking about the reality of drop ships. Isn't that the next logical progression? I mean, currently we can put a battalion of paratroopers anywhere in the world with 48 hours notice. We can put a Ranger company anywhere in the world with 24 hours notice.
- vilhelm_s 10y agohttp://www.realcleardefense.com/articles/2015/03/23/the_ultimate_cold_war_weapon_fantasy_ballistic_troop_transports.html http://www.realcleardefense.com/articles/2015/03/23/the_ulti...
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoHow would one defend and/or re-configure carrier strike groups in a world filled with hypersonic missiles?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]