8 ms·
Apple removes Scratch from iPad/iPhone/iTouch
- cesare 17y agoIMHO, this should cause more outrage than all the developer related policies. Apple has always been a world apart, with a strong philosophy and its own priorities. But the culture around its products was all about fostering creativity. I used to say to friends: get a Mac if you want an hassle-free computer to make things (music, graphics design and even programming. Does anyone remember HyperCard, which at one point was bundled with every mac?). The argument that the iPad/iPhone/iPodTouch is not a computer is really myopic. It's the culture that has changed.
- lallysingh 17y agoYeah, that's linux now, and only for software dev creativity.
- api 17y agoUnfortunately, it is only for software dev creativity. Nobody else can really use Linux. (I say that as a long time Linux user... I would never give Linux to a non-techie.)
- hoggle 17y agoWith all due respect but I would encourage you to try exactly this with a recent version of a major distribution like ubuntu. It is so much easier for non technical people to install applications with all those comfortable package management frontends alone. I recently have successfully "deployed" such an environment on an absolute beginner's PC. I would clearly say that everybody who was able to use WinXP is easily able to use a modern major Linux distribution. I have been an enthusiastic osx user for many years now but then again I originally came from BSD world and I am somewhat married to my workflow now. IMHO Linux is a great option - certainly for casual users and programmers.
- aristoxenus 17y agoI agree that it should cause more concern -- but how about more "reflection and rethinking" than "outrage". The kids with the most to gain from an encouraging tool like Scratch can't afford iPods anyway.
- bad_user 17y ago> The kids with the most to gain from an encouraging tool like Scratch can't afford iPods anyway. That's why they have parents.
- raganwald 17y agoBuild for free software platforms like Linux or the Web and these issues go away. Being outraged at Apple policies when the web is free is like being outraged at your employer when you are free to start your own business.
- angumagu 17y ago"Free" is a term that always benefits from definition. How free am I to start my own business? Well, that depends on relative power, and how precarious my financial situation is, my debt load, my family responsibilities, and other things. It's not just a simple question of "is it physically possible?" I'm not sure how directly applicable that critique is to the analogy, except to say that I am well within my rights to be outraged at my own employer for many reasons, whether or not I have the opportunity to start my own business. "Love it or leave it" is generally a cheap argument for dismissing folks who are pushing for progressive change in a system.
- raganwald 17y ago> Build for free software platforms like Linux or the Web and these issues go away. Is this statement true or false? > Being outraged at Apple policies when the web is free is like being outraged at your employer when you are free to start your own business. Does this statement say you are not entitled to be outraged at Apple or at your employer? Or does it merely say that being outraged at Apple when you have alternative target platforms is like being outraged at your employer when you can start your own business? Making money from the web appears to be more difficult that making money from iPhone software. Starting your own business appears to be more difficult than working for yourself. Don't these statements support the simile? I support your choice to push Apple for "progressive change." But just as you may choose to push them to change, I choose to push developers to change. I hope you accept the direct comparison I am drawing.
- angumagu 17y agoExcellent rejoinders. They do support the simile. I think I did jump to reading it as a "love it or leave it" argument, though recognizing you are more on the "come and join us on the outside". But maybe you can see it was easy to ready it as "it's a waste to get riled up about this". Anyway, I'm quite sympathetic to the build-alternative-institutions as opposed to work-within-the-system approach. I rewrote this response a dozen times and then realized I hadn't figured out what really rankles me about this whole conversation (the larger one). I think it's that Apple makes really good stuff, when so often it's the people making marginal or crappy stuff that are making regressive moves like these. So I get torn, because there are real efforts being made on their part to make technology human, to meet people where they are, efforts that have gone further than a lot of others. And I can't see any basic link between the closed approach and that success.
- joe_the_user 17y agoI certainly hope that this will cause more outrage than there's been so far but this action is a completely consistent application of Apple's draconian tools policy and that is a natural result of the walled-garden model. see: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html Sorry if it's been seen before...
- aphistic 17y agoFrom the article: "Why? Discussion on the Scratch forums suggests that it’s because Apple wants to focus on consuming media using these devices, not producing media. Want to be truly computing literate, where you write as well as read? There’s no app for that." No, it's because (as far as I can tell) the Scratch iPhone app was acting as a Scratch interpreter which is explicitly not allowed on the App Store to begin with. The authors of the iPhone app (http://www.mobilewikiserver.com/Scratch.html http://www.mobilewikiserver.com/Scratch.html) made a nice post in the developer forums (https://devforums.apple.com/thread/46425 https://devforums.apple.com/thread/46425) pleading their case for any you with access to the forum and an interest in digging deeper.
- aristoxenus 17y agoThat post really puts the "C/C++/Obj-C" thing into much starker relief than the "wish I could use lisp" discussion. Geeks can get around 3.3.1 if they're clever enough; replacing a democratizing technology like Scratch, on the other hand, may be impossible. That said, if their app really was an interpreter, I'm surprised it made it into the store in the first place. And if anything, the typical Scratch output of a crayon-drawn animation designed by a 13-year-old only bolsters Jobs' point about cross-compilers bringing down the average app quality. But I'm very impressed that they had Scratch working on the platform and I hope Apple can find a way to incorporate that educational mission into their world-domination strategy...
- stcredzero 17y agoThey built it on top of Squeak. That thing is one of the most straightforward VMs to port. The runtimes execute bit-identical. Years ago they were on 40 different platforms, and I've lost track. It's an incredibly elegant architecture.
- aristoxenus 17y agoThat's cool. Should have said "happy" instead of "impressed" -- knowing nothing about the technical side, I was imagining the impact of letting kids program ipods/iphones. They must have loved that.
- malkia 17y agoIt's out only from the store. There are other ways to install it! Legal ways.
- malkia 17y agoWhy am I getting downvoted? If you want Scratch for your students, you can use ad-hoc install for them? Buy a $99 dollar account, sponsored by the school, and install it for them? What is the problem? I understand, and I wish Apple did not put such restrictions, but they've put them. Yet, still there is a way. It's not like with Sony and the latest Ps3 firmware, where even if you want to pay (And I've already paid $69 for YellowDog support) I can no longer get it, or I can't use the Sony Service...
- cschep 17y agoIs the code freely available to use to install it? If it's not, then this won't work.
- malkia 17y agohttp://info.scratch.mit.edu/Source_Code http://info.scratch.mit.edu/Source_Code
- jonknee 17y agoUnless you have more than 100 students. Or don't have a Mac. Or think it's ridiculous to have to pay $99 every year to run your own app.
- fierarul 17y agoNext up "Etch A Sketch"-like iApps will be banned since the viewers will interpret de data from the server and display other users' sketches. God forbid you use JSON to communicate with the server in your app and parse it yourself, that's too close to Javascript-parsing and you can only use the approved Javascript interpreter for that. It's starting to look a bit like a joke. Yeah, of course, typing this on my MacBook Pro... It's a weird love-hate thing with Apple these days.
- abstractbill 17y agoIt just occurred to me you officially cannot make an iPhone app that displays PDF documents - because rendering a PDF involves interpreting a program written in the PostScript programming language (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PostScript#The_language http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PostScript#The_language).
- acon 17y agoNo. PDFs only uses the PostScript imaging model, not the PostScript programming language.
- abstractbill 17y agoAh, interesting - I always though PDF was just a superset of PostScript, but it looks like you are correct: http://www.adobe.com/print/features/psvspdf/ http://www.adobe.com/print/features/psvspdf/
- fierarul 17y agoYeah, but you won't see a TeX editor very soon.
- bad_user 17y agoPDFs generated by Adobe Acrobat have Javascript in them (for forms mostly). You are free to not interpret it though.
- naz 17y ago
- cpr 17y agoNow THIS really got my attention. I was holding my nose lightly through all the flap so far, and I'm quite sympathetic to Apple's desire to keep Flash off the platform, but disallowing educational software just because it's running a Smalltalk interpreter? A polite but forceful email to Jobs is on the way...
- nearestneighbor 17y agoI'd hate Apple more if they published a policy, and then cherry-picked when to enforce it for their best PR benefit.
- jamesbritt 17y agoDidn't they do essentially that by allowing apps for magazines from larger publishers (Sports Illustrated, Playboy, for example) that contained certain content while nixing other apps on the grounds they had exactly that sort of content? http://www.cooltechzone.com/2010/02/23/apple-loves-playboy-sports-illustrated-hates-other-sexual-apps/ http://www.cooltechzone.com/2010/02/23/apple-loves-playboy-s...
- jamesbritt 17y agohttp://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2010/04/16/cartoonist-apple-backs-down-after-denying-iphone-app/ http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2010/04/16/cartoonist-apple-back... Don't be playa hater. :)
- dejb 17y agoWhy does it have to take a specific concrete example like this to make you sit up and take notice? This is the sort of slow and lazy thinking allows despots of all kinds to take control. I can imagine in nazi Germany 'holding your nose lightly through all the flap about persecution of jews' and then being surprised when they take your neighbor away.
- ANH 17y agoI'm guessing you're doing self-parody. If not, see Godwin's Law: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law
- anonjon 17y agoI find this very interesting because (as mentioned in one of the comments) it seems that running anything with saved data on a computer could potentially constitute 'running interpreted code'. And that is really the thing that has bothered me about the whole fiasco. The policy seems to come from a fundamental misunderstanding of how computers actually work. Normally we think of there being a huge difference between code and data... psychologically we categorize notepad.exe and a .txt file differently from a scheme interpreter and a .scm file. But really, at a macroscopic level, they operate in a very similar way. If I open a text file in notepad, notepad reads the binary data in the file, and interprets it as ASCII or Unicode, and then prints it to the monitor. And the same process takes place in a scheme interpreter. I open the file, binary is read and interpreted as scheme code, and the results of interpretation are printed to the monitor. (This is even more obvious with something like html). You could easily think of different file formats as different programming languages, and different programs for opening them as interpreters for said language (what is MS Word but an interpreter for .doc codes?) Every time I save a file, I am having the computer generate a little interpretable program. (A continuation?) But when you realize this, it seems like any policy banning interpreters logically collapses. If I can't have an interpreter, I can't save files, if I can't save files, what is the point? So you could look at scratch as something that allows you to save scratch files, or you could look at scratch as something that allows you to interpret scratch code... it doesn't really matter. Saving and compiling are the same thing, reading and interpreting are the same thing. Correct me if I'm wrong, but this would mean that between their rules, they can (theoretically) outlaw any program that does much more than cause the device to become warm. Granted, they won't, because they have a certain notion of 'how computers work', which is generally shared, but it isn't particularly true..
- endergen 17y agoThis is not exactly what Alan Kay hoped for when he talked about the iPhone foreshadowing the iPad: "When the Mac first came out, Newsweek asked me what I [thought] of it. I said: Well, it’s the first personal computer worth criticizing. So at the end of the presentation, Steve came up to me and said: Is the iPhone worth criticizing? And I said: Make the screen five inches by eight inches, and you’ll rule the world." Source: http://gigaom.com/2010/01/26/alan-kay-with-the-tablet-apple-will-rule-the-world/ http://gigaom.com/2010/01/26/alan-kay-with-the-tablet-apple-... The iPad is no Dynabook: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynabook http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynabook. Perhaps a better name would have been: -UndynamicBook -iStade (See: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/stade http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/stade )
- vtail 17y agoCould you please elaborate on what is exactly 'disrespectful to history'? Dynabook concept was out there since 1968, not patented as far as I know - anyone could have 'borrowed' it and reaped the benefits. The fact that Apple has provided a particular implementation of the concept, even with all the software restrictions etc., is a step in right direction. Competition will certainly follow.
- endergen 17y agoThe last paragraph came across much stronger than I intended. I've removed it for now until I articulate what I intended better(or never).
- endergen 17y agoI agree in general with what I take to be your stance, that people who actually get it out there into the mainstream and do it well should be rewarded. And that open markets will always create competition so therefore some strict control is ok if it gets us there. To clarify, I wouldn't expect an academic to patent his work. He wants his works to be freely available to everyone. It's Steve Job's/Apple's right ethically and legally to leverage that. I meant it more lightly that it felt disrespectful that years later Jobs isn't paying homage to the source of inspirations. I love Apple, they are killing it out there. I don't take nearly as much issue as everyone else does with most of their controlling terms. I come from the game's industry where Apple seems like the most gracious host compared to Nintendo/Sony/Microsoft and their approval process. But as a Tools/Interface developer it's so frustrating to not be allowed to commercialize say an IDE that utilizes multi-touch to make software editing/navigation more efficient or enjoyable.
- javanix 17y agoWant to be truly computing literate, where you write as well as read? There’s no app for that. On some level, the iPad isn't really a Turing Machine.
- locopati 17y agoSo again the question arises - why would you develop for a platform where the rules can change arbitrarily in a way that invalidates your work and possibly cuts into your income stream?
- viraptor 17y agoBecause you get money while it lasts. If you're fully aware of problem and its consequences - why not just stop worrying and love the bo^W appstore. I'm not sure why would any hobby developer do that though...
- adamc 17y agoKept waiting to hear this was a joke, but apparently not. Depressing.
- shaunxcode 17y agoMy first problem with scratch was that it was client based and the "player" is java based. It absolutely needs to be web (not flash or java) based. I actually had a good portion of a jquery/drag and drop code editor written a few years ago when I was stuck at a 9-5 programming gig. I am going to dig it back up as the time seems right to move forward with it.
- misuba 17y agoPlease do!
- binspace 17y ago> Of course, they can take all the hate from developers because the mindless Apple legions will still love them. So true.