14 ms·
Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel Spolsky
- sotojuan 10y agoIf you search for "open office" on HN there's a thread with a ton of comments in which one person described his ideal office setup as one that has an open/communal area in the middle and individual offices surrounding it in all sides. The commenter said they tried this in real life and it worked well. I'm curious as to why this isn't as popular—it seems so obvious. I'm actually in a program with a similar layout (except there's only individual rooms on two sides) and it works great. I'm skeptical of "serendipity" arguments... Bell Labs had private offices and they did fine.
- biot 10y agoOn Bell Labs and open offices, Richard Hamming (retired Bell Labs scientist) said: "Another trait, it took me a while to notice. I noticed the following facts about people who work with the door open or the door closed. I notice that if you have the door to your office closed, you get more work done today and tomorrow, and you are more productive than most. But 10 years later somehow you don't know quite know what problems are worth working on; all the hard work you do is sort of tangential in importance. He who works with the door open gets all kinds of interruptions, but he also occasionally gets clues as to what the world is and what might be important. Now I cannot prove the cause and effect sequence because you might say, ``The closed door is symbolic of a closed mind.'' I don't know. But I can say there is a pretty good correlation between those who work with the doors open and those who ultimately do important things, although people who work with doors closed often work harder. Somehow they seem to work on slightly the wrong thing - not much, but enough that they miss fame." From http://www.cs.virginia.edu/~robins/YouAndYourResearch.html http://www.cs.virginia.edu/~robins/YouAndYourResearch.html
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- michaelmrose 10y agoI'm sure he did good work but this is the intellectual equivalent to snack food. Its entirely possible to be open to outside influence without giving random coworkers visible permission to interrupt whenever.
- marvy 10y ago> entirely possible But that's his point, isn't it? It sounds like it should be possible, yet he never saw it happen.
- initram 10y agoWell, his definition appears to be that the people with closed doors did it "enough that they miss fame". Who's to say whether those people made extremely good contributions, but since they were introverts didn't seek out fame, or actively ran from it? The whole quote is just anecdotal stuff.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cloudjacker 10y agoBecause any of us here work anywhere for ten years right? We get our cliffs and we get liquidity and none of this workplace nuance matters. Your mere presence is elevated into importance because you got an exit. Being honest.
- reitanqild 10y agoThis get brought up again and again, yet: Those who had their doors open still had offices (and I guess a few of them sometimes closed the doors.) For us who have had to live in open offices where people come in to chat about guns[0] and cutting legs of dogs and daydreaming loudly about things so pervert that anything you have yet heard from big T (yet, at least, I have seen the news) pales and can make even native Norwegians blush... ...for us it is less about where we are in 10 years and more about where we are today. [0]: minor remark: I am as pro-gun as any of the locals it seems, just don't start chatting about them in the open floorplan where I sit to work.
- svjsdjfnskj 10y agoIt's not a binary thing! you can shut the door when you need to concentrate and open it when you want to be sociable. That's how it was in my last job and it worked great. Currently I'm in an open-plan office that's hot and noisy, so I work from home in the mornings when I do work that requires concentration and then I go into the office in the afternoon for easier work and chatting.
- twelve40 10y agoThis can clearly go the other way: people who make an impact are approached so much that it's hard to keep the door closed, doesn't mean it's their natural preference.
- dredmorbius 10y agoJohn Seeley Brown, in The Social Life of Information, has a pair of anecdotes from Xerox's repair staff and either Xerox or Kodak (I think) customer service. The support techs used to have a morning coffee session before heading out into the field on their calls. These turned out to be hugely useful tech transfer opportunities as repairmen would share both their unsolvable problems (machines which had broken and couldn't be fixed) and "This One Weird Trick" solutions. The second anecdote involved customer service operators, who had previously, if I'm remembering this correctly, shared floor space with techs, but had been moved to their own space. Following the move, there were two specific operators who were able to help out customers by not following the specific scripts they'd been provided, but rather by supplying actual useful questions, diagnostics, and suggestions. When studied by management, it it turned out that one was a veteran of the former seating arrangement. The other, however, was a more recent hire. She did, however, sit next to the more senior rep, and had picked up tips listening and talking to the other employee. The lesson I'm drawing is that you don't need people to be interrupted all the time. But you do need them to have some opportunities for a free-wheeling exchange. Finding the right balance point between heads-down work (the Xerox techs, for example, were mostly on the road and at customer sites, so they wouldn't have had input from other techs), and exhange opportunities. In academia, there's the teaching vs. studying/research balance. A few days of lecture and sessions, with other time devoted to actual research, gives that balance of peturbing your own thinking and exposure to new ideas, and focusing on your own work. E.O. Wilson addresses that in his recent book, Letters to a Young Scientist (along with advice to avoid as much teaching and administrative responsibilities as possible).
- taneq 10y agoA company I used to work for had expanded past its available office space, and so they had to rent another office nearby. They moved all the upper management, project managers, and engineers (basically the 'cool kids' / 'important people') over to the new office, leaving some admin staff behind at the main office with the workshop. The resulting loss of communication between workshop and everyone else caused havoc and a bunch of things went wrong.
- 10y ago
- lazyjones 10y agoHe may be right, but as an employer, your aim won't be to make all your programmers famous. The work better done behind closed doors is probably at least as important as that of the visionary with open doors: putting out fires, fixing bugs, meeting deadlines. As an employee, you'll surely want the "open door" work ...
- dwc 10y agoSeveral times over the years I've had an office with a door. Normally I kept the door open, but I would close it if I had work that required extreme (for me) concentration, or if the environment outside was excessively distracting that day, etc. IME, this is quite common for other people as well. Since I have trouble concentrating when people are talking and get quite unhappy about it but managed to keep my door open the vast majority of the time, I have to wonder. Was Bell Labs an excessively noisy place, or were the closed door people there those kind of people?
- badsock 10y agoI've seen this called "cave and commons", and yeah, it seems like a very good setup. I first saw it mentioned in Stewart Brand's (highly recommended) book How Buildings Learn.
- blt 10y agoBecause then it takes even more space than one or the other.
- ams6110 10y agoIt isn't popular because it's more expensive. Cubicles are cheaper than offices, and desks in a row are cheaper than cubicles. It's a beancounter mentality, possibly understandable in a startup with limited funds for offices, but a false economy in the long run.
- abalone 10y agoThis is often repeated on HN threads as a plausible explanation for open plans, always without evidence. But it makes very little sense as a theory. Companies do not have a financial inventive to consciously cripple their very highly paid, very difficult to hire developers' productivity. People are their number one expense and asset, vastly moreso than office space. Far from cutting corners, many open plan companies also spend lavishly on amenities to keep engineers happy. A more plausible explanation is companies do open plan because they believe it will help foster collaboration, culture and team productivity. You may disagree but the "beancounter" theory makes no sense.
- adrianN 10y agoIt's easy to measure the money saved when you go from individual offices to an open plan. It is a lot harder to measure the lost productivity of your programmers.
- abalone 10y agoThat's not really true. You can look at developer velocity and bug fix rates, to name a couple of readily available metrics. It would not be some big mystery if open plan was killing productivity. Also, it does not explain why a "beancounter" mindset about office space would be paired with lavish expenses on free lunches and other de rigueur amenities in said offices, as is typical of open plan startups. Conclusion: it's not a beancounter mentality that drives the decision.
- ZenoArrow 10y ago> "You can look at developer velocity and bug fix rates, to name a couple of readily available metrics." How? If an office starts out open plan (which many of them do), are you going to move to new offices just to test the theory that it'll make your employees more productive? Plus, bug fix rates are a bad metric, bugs are not equal in complexity, and even if you try and guess at the complexity before working on a bug that's only an estimate, and one that doesn't take into account other important factors such as the level of churn in the codebase and the level of familiarity the developer has with the part of the codebase they are asked to fix.
- InclinedPlane 10y agoMoney. Open offices are cheaper. So if you can con your mostly 20-something and 30-something tech staff that it's the best way to go, then you're golden, you save a ton of money and your employees don't even realize they're being ripped off. As for "serendipity" it's the classic post-hoc fallacy problem. People think "oh, there was that one time" where something good happened in an open office, and they think that means nothing good would happen without open offices. Serendipity happens plenty with offices, but it happens amidst a background of much greater productivity and less annoyance at noisy office mates.
- nickthemagicman 10y agoShort term money. If it kills productivity, they lose money in the long run.
- theprotocol 10y agoNearly every company these days falls for this. I suspect suits completely misunderstand the principle of time value of money, as they wrongly conflate "short term money" with "earlier money." And in finance, when it comes to inflows of money, earlier always trumps later (as it's assumed that you can thus will invest that money for longer when you get it earlier).
- InclinedPlane 10y agoThat's true of a lot of practices, but when the feedback loop isn't as tight, it's easy for companies to ignore it. There are countless examples of big companies hemorrhaging talent because of their corporate culture, policies, etc. I've witnessed it many times with my own eyes. But that sort of thing doesn't manifest as the company burning to the ground in the next year and then people going "why did that happen? oh, it's because we lost Jim". Instead it looks like a failure to execute as well on big projects. But because there are always so many things changing from project to project, it's always easy to blame something else. And the management at most big corporations are loathe to blame themselves or their policies, so they always find some other convenient excuse. This is a big reason why companies change character of time and transition from being industry powerhouses to also-rans.
- borplk 10y agoIt's about money. It was always about money, the collaboration thing is just a veil. Companies will always invent "happy vocabulary" to justify whatever it is that is in their interest to do. If they could pack their employees into little cardboard human boxes all separate from each other they would say "Our environment encourages strong focus and solitude." You can put a positive spin on anything.
- BjoernKW 10y agoIt's also about (perceived) control. Otherwise remote work would be pretty much the norm today - at least for software development and similar kinds of knowledge work. Development output isn't easily measurable. What's easily measurable though is people sitting in a chair and pretending to "work".
- Animats 10y agoI've seen the reverse of that at one part of Google - individual desks in the middle, many small glass-walled conference rooms around the perimeter.
- gbin 10y agoGoogle has private offices ? Which building ?
- ap22213 10y agoLet's imagine a universe where research showed that factory workers gained significant productivity when they had private spaces to concentrate. Do you think that the factory owners would suddenly erect partitions? Of course not - at least not until they faced significant competition and were losing market share. Too many people doing software over-inflate their importance to management. The reason why there are few offices at tech companies is simple. Management views software developers as factory workers, and they want to 'see' them working hard for the money that they're spending.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- thesimpsons1022 10y agomicrosoft has that in some teams. one team specifically i knew was transitioned from offices to the open floor plan but their old offices remained empty. this allowed them to have both
- oldprogrammer2 10y agoWhen we moved our dev team to a new area, I chose this style of layout. Each developer has their own small office, which forms an outer perimeter. Each office also has a 4x4 window next to the door to keep the atmosphere open. In the middle is an open kitchen and a standup area, separated by the bathrooms. We have a conference room in the corner. All of this is behind key-access doors, giving the team a sense of sanctuary. Each office, as well as the standup area and the conference room, have a whiteboard wall. I would say that the general idea is that developers come together at standups, and typically plan out the day. If two or more developers determine a discussion is needed, they normally schedule right after the standup. Then the developers depart to their offices, and generally put their heads down and work in quiet. Most leave their doors open throughout the day, and close their doors when they have phone calls or small meetings. The arrangement works well. Adhoc conversations are not discouraged, and occur throughout the day as needed, but the separate offices keep the trivial conversations and disturbances to a minimum. From a cost perspective, this layout requires considerably more space than an open layout. And separate offices require separate HVAC ducts, and walls and doors are (obviously) additional expenses, too. I'm grateful that our team's contributions were recognized by the company (a non-tech company), such that the expense was considered worth it. it's certainly a cornerstone of my sales pitch for recruiting developers.
- JohnBooty 10y agoI'm glad it's working out for you! Our company (also a non-tech company!) is investing in such a space for us and I'm very very excited. Excited and grateful.
- existencebox 10y agoIf it helps, let me put my vote of support for that sales pitch. Literally that fact alone had me going "I wonder where he works", and I'm in quite a good spot right now. I cannot express how much a motivator a sane office space has become for such a silly thing after the last few years of open-sardine-cans. I would love to see more companies recognize that certain acts of consideration to their eng (I don't mean the more transient stuff like "free dinners" "pool table") are a significant differentiator for my strata of less-extroverted devs.
- madmax108 10y agoThis is EXACTLY how we have it at our office (Series D startup). On a daily basis, I pend about half my time in the open area with my team and everyone else dropping by, and the rest in a room where I can be plugged in at peace to get some concentrated coding done. The office rooms range from 1-2 person rooms to 6-10 person rooms, and all of them can be used at any time of day by anyone in office. It's funny how I never have to stretch timelines or have communication issues with this setup. +1, would recommend.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ereyes01 10y agoI've never worked at Microsoft, and I know little about their work environment for developers. Can others here elaborate on why Joel Spolsky has such high praise for them beyond the 12/12 Joel Test score? What lessons can other teams take from Microsoft's mastery of developer work environments? EDIT: I would add that I strongly agree with the need for quiet and concentration as a developer. The worst place I ever worked at had a constant barrage of meetings throughout the workday and a very noisy distraction-heavy open floor plan.
- labrador 10y agoI wasn't an employee, but I worked there for weeks at a time as a contractor. You get your own office and people don't bother you if your door is shut. You are expected to communicate by email or chat. The building is very quiet, and if it's raining outside, which it does often in that area, you can get hours of glorious uninterrupted time to concentrate.
- tempodox 10y agoThat does sound good as a working environment. Strangely, I still hate most of the software they produce and find it a PITA to use.
- labrador 10y agoThat's the fault of product managers and focus group specialists. Programmers don't get much input into the design, at least when I was there. It can be good if you just like to code.
- jhildings 10y agoSounds extremely boring to be honest :p
- labrador 10y agoI'm guessing you're either not a programmer or don't know how to go out and socialize.
- pan69 10y agoI would prefer to work in a private office as well rather than working from home since I like to go into work and hang out with my collages every once in a while. A private office will allow me, as a developer, to choose when "I" want to concentrate, not when the environment just happen to allow me to do my work. Trust me, I will be more productive this way. However, I can also understand that not every business can afford private offices for their developers. But then again, how difficult is it to create a "quiet" and "busy" area? Any company that has the ability to afford more than 2 or 3 devs should be able to do this right?
- true_religion 10y ago> I can also understand that not every business can afford private offices for their developer. I think it's more true that not every business can afford private offices for their developers if they locate their business near the trendiest part of downtown.
- pan69 10y agoUsually the trendiest part of town is also easiest to get to. Also, depending on your business you might want to be where your clients, or potential clients, are. Having at least a quiet and loud space is to me a better compromise than some shitty open plan office, at least I have choice that way.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> Usually the trendiest part of town is also easiest to get to. Not when it's where everyone is trying to go, and where almost none of your developers can afford to live. I like when companies set up shop in a suburban, inexpensive town, and their employees can afford to live 1-5 minutes from work. If you're a startup, you might desperately need the VC networking and signaling value of Silicon Valley. If you're doing a lot of direct B2B sales to Silicon Valley, you might need to have an office there. Otherwise, and especially if you're a company that can set up shop anywhere sensible, be anywhere else high-tech.
- catscratch 10y ago> According to StackOverflow surveys, favorite programming tools currently include Rust, Swift and F#, while those “most dreaded” include Visual Basic, WordPress and Matlab. But Spolsky played down those surveys, saying programmers have “a desire to use the latest, cool new thing” and tend to move on from programming quickly, so that their ranks are filled by “new kids showing up with newfangled things they just invented, usually reinventing the wheel.” F#? I'm pretty sure that was a joke: https://www.google.com/trends/explore?q=%22F%23%22 https://www.google.com/trends/explore?q=%22F%23%22
- tvural 10y agoF# is Microsoft's rendition of OCaml. It's super nice if you're trapped in the .Net world, where the alternatives are C# and Visual Basic. Otherwise it suffers from the same lack of open source infrastructure and good non-Windows support as the rest of the .Net languages. The user base may not be growing quickly, if at all. But it was probably worth the investment for Microsoft, just to have a better language for their employees to use.
- agildehaus 10y agoFavorite and popular are two different things. Here's a link to the stat: http://stackoverflow.com/research/developer-survey-2016#technology-most-loved-dreaded-and-wanted http://stackoverflow.com/research/developer-survey-2016#tech...
- catscratch 10y agoF# was based on OCaml. OCaml was attempted to be promoted several years ago and failed miserably. Yes, there are people interested in it, but not in a really serious way and only in small numbers. I just searched through every article I could find and see that through sites and you would not believe the amount of "how can we evangelize it" sort of things I found- a site dedicated to evangelization, two GitHub PRs for part 1 and part 2 of evangelization. A post about why evangelization isn't working and how to fix that. An article in Code magazine which is controlled by MS. From what I can see in HN comments, there is a minority of people that want to try it but don't use it. Quora has a recent answer about those using F# and mostly it's a short list of companies almost no one's heard of. After all of that, a recent post on HN about F# got ~170 points for front page. It might be a fine language for some, but it's not in the top three. If you don't believe me, just spend some time researching the amount of desperation in the evangelization. I'm not sure how it got all of those points, but it seems like it wasn't purely on merit.
- kyriakos 10y agoAnecdotal but when I was working at a company where I had a private office I was still getting interrupted by phone calls. Calls that would last 10-20 seconds, that type of conversations in an open space wouldn't be as distracting. The fact that I had to hear the ring pick up the phone to talk made it worse. Oh and the phones had no mute setting you could only set them to a low volume. So even private offices can be a problem. What I'm trying to say is that the issue is the office culture and communication policy that makes the difference and not the office layout.
- ams6110 10y agoUnplug the phone when you want to focus.
- kyriakos 10y agoThat really didn't make the bosses happy. I quit for other reasons but looking back to it this could have also been one of them.
- opo 10y ago>...I was still getting interrupted by phone calls. Calls that would last 10-20 seconds, that type of conversations in an open space wouldn't be as distracting. Think about the other people around you. When you are getting phone calls in a private office you are not distracting them from your work - every phone call you get in an open floor plan will be distracting to everyone around you.
- myvirusfiles 10y agoVsh
- jmking 10y agoI have mixed feelings about open concept floor plans. I think they can work - especially if the office is organized such that the work area is separate from areas that could be loud. People who visit our offices are often surprised at how quiet the engineering floor is. There might be the odd conversation, but the tone is kept low, and everyone is issued a pair of noise cancelling headphones. People generally respect the headphone rule and will ping you on Slack instead of shoulder tapping. Basically open concept floor plans can work as long as everyone respects the etiquette that makes it work.
- Camillo 10y agoI don't want to have to wear noise cancelling headphones all day long. If you give them out to everyone, it becomes an excuse to be loud. "Just put on your headphones!" No, you go fucking chitchat somewhere else.
- jmking 10y agoThat's what I mean about etiquette. The headphones aren't an excuse to be loud. Good quality headphones also mean that your neighbour's shitty music isn't leaking noise into the workspace.
- semi-extrinsic 10y ago> Good quality headphones also mean that your neighbour's shitty music isn't leaking noise into the workspace. You don't need anything expensive for that, I have a pair of Sennheiser HD-202 ($25) at work that do it just fine. In fact, they also block most noise from the outside, to the point that I can't hear the person 6ft away who's calling my name.
- crdoconnor 10y ago>People generally respect the headphone rule and will ping you on Slack instead of shoulder tapping. One feature on slack that would help immensely would be an "urgent" signal vs a "if you see this in 2 hours time and respond i'm not that bothered". I'd like to be able to switch off notifications for one and leave them on for the other.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tluyben2 10y agoI have not worked in open offices for a long time but today at our Chinese partner I was in one; I for one get nothing but meetings done there. I am far more productive in my hotel room. Which is why I only go to the office when there is a relevant meeting.
- sztwiorok 10y agothere are pros and cons in every solution. with openoffice barriers between team members are torn down, but it is harder to concentrate, as Joel said. when you work from home it is easier to concentrate (one condition: you are alone in home), but there are much bigger problems in communication beetween project members. I have the impression that the approach to this subject comes full circle. I think you can not find the best solution for all.
- abalone 10y agoInteresting that he cited Microsoft as the canonical example 16 years ago. That example hasn't aged well. In the ensuing years, Microsoft has lost its edge in software innovation. It's not exactly proof positive that everyone working alone in their office or at home is the best way to run a company. I think in those 16 years we have learned that there is personal productivity and there is team productivity. The former is critical for shipping, but the latter is also critical for developing ideas and collaboration. You can't just talk about maximizing one without thinking about the impact on the other.
- tracker1 10y agoI think the work done in VS Code, .Net Core, F#, TypeScript, azure tooling, container support, sql server enhancements etc would counter your assumptions on a lack of innovation... Windows may have stagnated, but ms is still pretty relevant. While I don't do much these days in the MS sphere (other than using VS Code), I think they're far more in touch than most large software companies.
- UK-AL 10y agoMicrosoft probably has the best research division in technology.
- duncanawoods 10y agoJust as a different counter point, I have coded in lots of environments including factory floors full of thundering industrial equipment and in the Gobi desert using a noisy smelly diesel generator as a power source etc. I think I did some of my best work when assigned a desk essentially in a corridor. A constant stream of people behind me, no privacy, noise etc. There was no half-concentration which privacy can encourage e.g. flicking to email/web every 5 mins. It was either get 100% wired in or don't bother trying. Concentration is partly a learned skill and being an environment of disruption is a training ground. Concentration begets concentration - if you have deep focus on a piece of work and made great progress, its much easier to get back to that state than if you have been farting around at the surface. If you have allowed yourself to indulge in "semi-work" then you are not like a rested athlete but an unfit one - you will have to train yourself back up to high-productivity. The really tough environments have been temperature extremes (your mind/body just stops functioning), noise at the truly headache inducing level (sitting 10m away from a drive-train rig the size of an Olympic swimming pool) but the worst of all for me is emotional noise e.g. people bickering. Trapped in a small office with unpleasant people is where I say "never again".
- nzjrs 10y agoGood point. I agree that concentration is a learned skill. We should recognise that the same self discipline stopping oneself from checking reddit every 5 seconds is closely related to the ability to retain concentration.
- richardw 10y agoWhat's possible is that while you were essentially forced to learn to concentrate (and therefore developed the skill), many don't know they have to learn. They're semi-interested in the events around them, don't know it's a problem and don't know the solution is to develop the necessary skills. Chitchat in an open room filled with developers and their challenges is different to the drone of a loud machine, or chatter of factory workers whose interests might not overlap with yours. It's a bit like having the internet at your fingers - far too easy to be distracted by interesting chatter.
- heisenbit 10y ago
- partycoder 10y agoThe most annoying: - finger drummer, tap dancer. - tell me everything about your last and next weekend. - i visited a foreign office and hanged out with all the important people. - i know so much about cars, wines, travel, outdoors. - last night in narcos, game of thrones... S H U T U P
- kelvin0 10y agoTrue Story: I worked a few months programming in an open floor plan (all hardwood floors). My commute from an to work was 3 hours each day. The prog next to me was a Finger drummer + song hummer. There was construction for a new building 20-30 feet from me (next building), and they were driving pillars into the ground for foundations (Booom Boom all day). There was no AC during summer. The washrooms/water would regularly be out of order for several hours ever 1-3 days. All this happened simultaneously over the course of several months. I did finally quit, and I would not wish these conditions on my worse enemy.
- partycoder 10y agoI had a colleague who would be finger drumming and palm drumming and doing something with his feet like pedaling. I sit next to the guy, and it was really annoying to try to concentrate with such guy.
- partycoder 10y agoI sent one of them this link: http://www.somethingawful.com/news/finger-drumming/ http://www.somethingawful.com/news/finger-drumming/ (NOTE: vulgar language)
- chris_7 10y agoThe absolute worst is when someone in management (who generally arrive after me) interrupt me to ask about something irrelevant to the company, like my weekend, sportsball, or whether I watched a TV show. I was focused, hard at work making you money. What are you trying to achieve?
- 10y ago
- Bobblebobble 10y agoI work in an open plan office and find potentially relevant discussions to be the most distracting, so I'm glad that most of these now take place asynchronously over instant messaging. If you've even managed to focus in an airport lounge, or a coffee shop then you know your brain can deal with sounds which are completely irrelevant. Similarly, if it just so happens that people are talking about something directly relevant to your problem, you can join in. The potentially relevant discussions are the most insidious though, because the work of deciding whether they are relevant is sufficient to prevent deep focus.
- tempodox 10y agoThere is another HN post, about a seemingly different topic, that has interesting and disturbingly fitting words about the open-plan office: http://laphamsquarterly.org/flesh/sodom-llc http://laphamsquarterly.org/flesh/sodom-llc
- leksak 10y agoI agree with Joel, I've worked in an open floor- plan, individual offices, shared offices, and even one open floor-plan where part of it was an actual store front. For me, happiness and subsequently long-term productivity has been directly correlated to privacy. While I'd never do anything casually I'm an open floor-plan I got successively drained over the week to the detriment of my nights and my weekends, so in the short run I was more productive but I also left those places.
- a_imho 10y agoSlightly related Why work doesn't happen at work | Jason Fried - 2010 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5XD2kNopsUs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5XD2kNopsUs tldw; M&Ms are bad
- combatentropy 10y ago> “Microsoft figured out a way to create software with a high degree of sanity,” he said. I stopped reading.
- WayneBro 10y agoPffft. OK. So, I take it that you think Microsoft doesn't make high quality software then? I'd love to hear what piece of shit software you think could possibly replace Windows, SQL Server, Exchange and Office in 90% of the world's businesses (small, medium and large).
- ChoHag 10y agoDidn't we agree that 2016 was the year of the Linux Desktop?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- myst 10y agoJoel should shut up indeed
- sctb 10y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly violating the guidelines. If you'd like to be unbanned, please email hn@ycombinator.com. We're happy to unban accounts if we believe you'll post only civilly and substantively in the future.
- hiou 10y agoProgramming is the same as working on an assembly line floor. You are not some fancy white collar worker. Not much difference in type of work(and pay) than an automobile plant. They don't get private offices either.
- walshemj 10y agoWhy do you say that? do you have poor self esteem or are you just trolling.
- hiou 10y agoBecause that's essentially what we do. Assembly and ultimately build products based off a list of specifications. You could say it's more difficult but beyond the fact that more people have degrees I'm not sure how different it really is. An open floor plan doesn't seem all that different than a room full of sewing machines etc. Certainly this doesn't apply to all software development. But for the majority portion the analogy isn't too far off.
- walshemj 10y agoSpefications LOL yes I recall when I was a developer on the management system for SMDS (ake the countrys internet back bone) for the UK the tech was so new we had to keep going back the guys that developed the underlying tech and ITU standards - and this was after 9 months of planning before staring development (which we did in 12 weeks using RAD Agaile paradime)
- jrs235 10y ago"Facebook is paying 40-50 percent more than other places, which is usually a sign developers don’t want to work there." Shots fired! It's an interesting viewpoint. Most say it's because they want and hire the best of the best who command and are worth more but is that true?
- jonaf 10y agoI found this statement intriguing as well. I work at a company where compensation is deliberately above market, if slightly, as a matter of business. It's also an incredible place to work. I don't think it is unilaterally factual that places offering higher salaries than market are horrible work environments; however, it's also not clearly unilaterally false. As such, I'm curious if there's some other factor or set of factors that, in addition to higher salaries, suggests the work environment is poor.
- jrs235 10y agoI would assume high salaries coupled with high turn over would be a strong indicator of a poor environment. But I suppose high turn over regardless of compensation would indicate that. Perhaps when coupled with high salaries it suggests worse conditions than in lower paying places merely because the added pay isn't enough to offset the BS.
- bfrog 10y agoYeah, Joel isn't wrong. Quiet distraction free environments are hard to come by. I do my best work personally when no one is bothering me for about 6 hours at a time. I worked the cube farm before, it was ok when it was quiet. Open spaces are horrendous. You may as well try working at a bar with your friends. It just ain't gonna happen. A private office seems like an unheard of thing these days.
- FollowSteph3 10y agoPersonally I think offices of 2-3 people who are working together on the same thing is ideal. You want some level of communication for immediate stuff but a barrier big enough for non-immediate stuff that others need to actually get up and go to you rather just pop their heads up. As well it allows conversations between interested parties while keeping it quiet for the other groups. I've found this to be the best setup for me personally.
- jonaf 10y agoI really don't understand the sentiment against open floor plans. A little over 4 years ago, I switched from private offices and cubicles to an open floor plan. It's... Just so much better. I'm an introvert. I don't really enjoy small talk. But I really appreciate being informed of what's going on when someone enters my area or someone wants to open up a discussion. Is t an interruption? Possibly. But I consider learning from and teaching others to be part of my job, a career goal, and developing soft skills. It seems like there's a tremendous and dangerous undervaluing of soft skills. I have learned so much and become so much more skilled technically by having these discussions. I'm able to remain in-tune with current project status, etc. this way without having to schedule meetings or get large groups of people together at the same time. I would spend so much more time in meetings if I were in a private office. I'm also completely at liberty to work in kitchenettes, common areas, patios and other places without any resistance. There's plenty of room because everyone's out in the open. We have occasional dividers between teams or different functional groups. But nothing is glued down. Is it really that hard to focus in on some work? If you require complete silence and isolation, I'm afraid you are suffering from the development of certain technical skills at the cost of many other, equally valuable skills. For example, if you ever intend to pursue entrepreneurship or aspire to CTO rank, you can expect to be interrupted often. You will still have to do your work. What will you do then? I see private offices and cubicles as a recipe for limiting your effectiveness outside of a narrow role. I think it hinders a person's career as they are unable to obtain new skills. If you are deliberately avoiding developing these skills, it is your choice, but if management is trying to get you to work in a dark basement, slide a pizza and a deadline under the door from time to time, and expects you to be happy, just remember that they are getting more out of you than you're getting out of your job.
- goalieca 10y agoi'd love an office. I do my best work when i pretend i'm a real functioning engineer. This open-concept agile way of working is very frustrating for me.
- existencebox 10y agoThis is not about soft skills, at least for me. This is about the environment often present with any sufficiently large open office. I have been in offices with 26 people in a space probably meant to hold 20. It speaks to a culture of cost cutting over engineer productivity; when even a low amount of tech discussions at a given time end up with 6~ people talking simultaneously constantly. (see comment re: emotional noise being worse than mechanical noise, in a prior sysadmin job I worked in an office next to a transformer room and would go back to that in an instant because if I really needed to focus at least I could shut the door; and the transformer wasn't going to ignore signs of focus like headphones and being heads down to come over tap me on the shoulder and context switch me to something that really doesn't need to be discussed.) Similarly; not having enough private rooms when they're actually needed for focus work, being placed in rooms with entirely distinct feature teams, and being often shuffled between them. These are all "non soft skilled" environmental factors that have made working in open offices FAR more unpleasant for me than private offices (By private I include up to 1-2~ other people sharing your literal role) Let me address your "at a cto role you must handle distraction" comment as well, since while I agree, we are _not_ at the CTO role, and to pretend the nature of our work is even similar is dishonest. Long-term context dependent thought work has an extremely well documented penalty from context switches. The CTO role, as has been described in recent HN threads and elsewhere, is far more of a salesman/face/public mouthpiece than engineer or even a technical role, and these career skills lend themselves to very different traditional environments.
- bladecatcher 10y agoHacking on noisy trading floors is great fun
- GroSacASacs 10y agoClickbait title with little content in the end. You can read more about Joel and his opinion on how software development should be here: http://joelonsoftware.com/ http://joelonsoftware.com/
- markbnj 10y ago>> But Spolsky played down those surveys, saying programmers have “a desire to use the latest, cool new thing” and tend to move on from programming quickly, so that their ranks are filled by “new kids showing up with newfangled things they just invented, usually reinventing the wheel.” Odd and sad, and I think mostly true. As a 55 year-old working engineer I consider software my trade, and it's given me a life most people around the world would envy. I think how strange it would be to say "most carpenters quickly move on from woodworking," or "most architects quickly give up designing structures."
- pasbesoin 10y agoI did very good work. Work people would repeatedly be amazed at. So, I proved myself, in that regard. Yet, when I would ask for a quiet, distraction-free workplace, I would receive incredulity. Impossibility. Lack of regard. The resources were readily available. But the disconnect between what I was doing, and the control of those resources, was apparently too great to bridge. And sometimes -- not infrequently -- the direct reports I was so helping out, were not willing to go to bat on this. Rock the boat -- me, or them on behalf of me -- and you're out. For me, human noise is the worst. I can tune out a storm, or a significant degree of mechanical noise if it is regular, not too extreme, and not indicative of risk. But nature or nurture has left me highly sensitive to the human activity around me. Headphones don't help; music is as distracting as the rest. All I asked for, was that my circumstances be acknowledged and respected and that a reasonable amount of readily available resources be devoted to matching them. You either trust and believe your employees, or you don't. My output was already exceptional; further, my employer could have measured whether that continued or improved after choosing to "believe me". Unfortunately, my environmental needs were discounted and I was coerced and semi-brainwashed to try to make "open", "collaborative" spaces work, from the time I was a kid. To my great distress. For a time, youth and cortisol and all that carried me through. But I eventually built into and hit a severe level of burn-out, including physical. These days, I'm not even that sharp, any more. You can, indeed, really get "used up". So... I don't care HOW MANY words, slogans, nor how much rhetoric is thrown at this topic. You either respect the people you work with. Believe them. Give them what they ask for, and see whether it works. Or you don't. Most of the people talking, don't. Look for actions, not words. P.S. Likewise for people who say they like different environments. If open-space works for you, fine. Or whatever else. I'll respect that. As long as your performance matches. Just, respect me. Don't force your noise on me. You like what I create and contribute? Then give me the tools I ask for, to better do so.