19 ms·
A Brief History of Who Ruined Burning Man
- Chathamization 10y agoI first became aware of Burning Man in the late 90's. It sounded interesting, but a lot of people said it wasn't worth going to anymore because all the new people had ruined it and it was nothing like it used to be. The argument doesn't seem to have changed much since then - "it's gone downhill over the last few years and is nothing like it was 8-9 years ago when I first went." It wouldn't surprise me if in 2026 people are talking about how terrible Burning Man has become and how it's nothing like the wonderful Burning Man of 2016.
- Paul-ish 10y agoThat doesn't make them wrong though. It may truly be mostly different people every 10 years.
- cloudjacker 10y agoturn down for what? because you're 38 and reminiscing about how unappealing burning is compared to when you were 25
- marssaxman 10y agoI also first heard about Burning Man in the mid '90s, but didn't actually attend until 2001. I was worried that I was going to be seeing the decrepit, watered-down remnants of something that had once been wild and wonderful. Well... I'm here to tell you that it has certainly changed over the last fifteen years, but it is still wild and it is still wonderful. I think that this pattern exists in part because you can't really have the same mind-blowing experience twice. You can keep going back to the playa, and the event will keep offering you new experiences and even some surprises, but you do get accustomed to it. I suspect that many people claiming it is not as good as it used to be are failing to distinguish their reaction to the novelty of the experience from the nature of the event itself. It is very common for people to go every year for 3-5 years, then move on - not because Burning Man has gone downhill somehow, but because they have gotten all they need out of it and are now ready to spend their summers doing something else.
- lintiness 10y agothose sound like the same people who ruined my indy band.
- refurb 10y agoThis t-shirt always made me laugh... http://mentalfloss.com/sites/default/legacy/wp-content/uploads/2008/02/435VennTshirt.png http://mentalfloss.com/sites/default/legacy/wp-content/uploa...
- FireBeyond 10y agoThe New Radicals said it well (http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/newradicals/jehovahmadethiswholejointforyou.html http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/newradicals/jehovahmadethiswh...): "So original in her black lipstick Listening to some obscure band But isn't she pissed at all the other non-conformists who listen to that same obscure band"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- projektfu 10y agoAs soon as I heard about burning man, back in 1996, it had definitely jumped the shark. If this guy knows about it, it's no longer hip.
- hammock 10y ago2016: OP's blog post ruined Burning Man.
- pacofvf 10y agoI think we can agree that the guy at 2016 IAC ruined BM this year.
- cobookman 10y agoLol its like usenet. The first rule is there is no usenet.
- vt240 10y agoI've never encountered this sentiment regarding usenet. Or maybe I'm misinterpreting your comment? Do you mean that knowledge of, and participation on usenet is elite/special? I find it fascinating if that is what you mean. I was born in the 80s and never really had that feeling from anyone in my circle of friends; more like, "Hello! What is wrong with you? We have forums on the web now."
- oldmanjay 10y agoAround the time of fight club being popular, usenet was the place to find pirated media and software. The inspired formulation of the "rule" gathered steam because it seemed no one in authority noticed this while they freaked out about napster and descendants.
- vt240 10y agoHaha, got it, that makes sense.
- op00to 10y agoThe way this relates to FOSS communities and the culture that surrounds them is really interesting.
- heartsucker 10y agoI feel like this takes the term "ruining" too literally. Yes, clearly nothing was completely ruined with each subsequent change, but the current incantation is certainly not the same as the first, and people are right to criticize the change (just as people are right to defend it). No one change might have been the death, but all together, it is very understandable that some people might call it "dead" and have moved on.
- ben174 10y agoI think that's the joke.
- heartsucker 10y agoThe post seemed to claim that because each small change didn't ruin it, it's not ruined. I'm saying that it's ruined to some because it's no longer the thing they fell in love with.
- HCIdivision17 10y agoHuh, you know, I've never really noticed it as Xeno's Paradox applied that way before. I'll have to keep an eye out for it, since it can lead to such a different conclusion with the same information.
- lfowles 10y agoZeno's paradox or Ship of Theseus?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- FireBeyond 10y agoThere's a song that has the lyrics, about a drunk Irishman singing of home: "He sings his songs of Ireland far away, and of how he's going back to Dublin one fine day." but carries on: "And the Ireland of his heart's recall, If it ever did exist at all, Now only lives and wistfully moves, Through Paddy's dreams." So many of our memories are very... rose-tinted.
- droopyEyelids 10y agoBut each time, what it "was" did get "ruined" ... at least enough to change it into something different. It's like the old koan about a radio: if you replace the speakers, then the housing, then the circuitry, then the controls, is it the same radio?
- thoth 10y agoKoan about the radio?! Try nearly 2000 years old, also known as the Ship of Theseus (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus).
- wlesieutre 10y agoOr the older version about a ship: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus
- jseliger 10y agoThere is an intriguing consilience between this post and sama's "We're in a Bubble" (http://blog.samaltman.com/were-in-a-bubble http://blog.samaltman.com/were-in-a-bubble).
- FreakyT 10y agoI love this breakdown; it really demonstrates how the "ruining" of Burning Man is no different than the sort of aversion to change that occurs with basically anything that people are enthusiastic about. * Bands? "They used be all about the music, then they went mainstream" * Video games? "Now they just cater to beginners; they don't care about real gamers anymore" * Movies? "They're so focused on the special effects, they don't even bother with the story" ...and the list goes on. Name just about anything that people enjoy, and you'll find a vocal contingent complaining about how recent changes have "ruined" it.
- heartsucker 10y agoThose seem to be legitimate complaints that seem to be "take something specialized that caters to a small crowd, then water it down so it appeals to everyone." That said, sometimes such complaints are clearly a bit whiny, but then again, sometimes they are warranted critiques.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoI don't think Burning Man could yet be called "appeals to everyone". Got a ways to go? There's still a core of weirdness that proves its still got something going on.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoIt appeals to a certain kind of everyone. But this always happens in anything that starts out as counter-culture. Always. First the freaks and the true believers invent something that appeals to other freaks and true believers. Then it gets bigger and becomes a mainstream business. Then eventually it crashes as it starts to feel sterile and commoditised, and it becomes more about management and money than expression. Then the cycle starts again elsewhere - sometimes with the same people. (Any similarity to software is intended. Although sadly I think we have too few real freaks and true believers in software. Certainly not too many.)
- 10y ago
- donmb 10y agoSwap [Burning Man] with any modern or long lasting festival. Here in Germany it would be "Rock am Ring" or "Southside". Very well written. We all will sooner or later act like our grandparents and say "in the past everything was better". If we are honest, it wasn't.
- lucozade 10y ago> "in the past everything was better". If we are honest, it wasn't. According to Socrates it was [0] [0] http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/63219-the-children-now-love-luxury-they-have-bad-manners-contempt http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/63219-the-children-now-love-...
- tashoecraft 10y agoNot Socrates [0][1] [0]http://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/01/misbehaving-children-in-ancient-times/ http://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/01/misbehaving-children... [1]https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Youth https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Youth (bottom)
- delegate 10y ago> Swap [Burning Man] with any modern or long lasting festival You can't really do that. Burning man is different from a normal music festival. I've never been to Burning Man, but I've been to other similar week-long psychedelic festivals, like Boom in Portugal and it's definitely not your 'normal' rock music festival. First there's the 'non-commercial' side - no companies or logos or other publicity displayed anywhere, then there's the international aspect - literally, it's a gathering of people from all over the world. Then there are the drugs, the virtual lack of alcohol, the psychedelia and the 'unsanity' that people experience for a week, which manifests as all kinds of forms of art, music, yoga, martial arts, shamanic rituals and so on. 'Leave no trace' means people are conscious and careful about the place, so the festival ground is always clean. People change, they become non-competitive, extremely nice and generous to each other - sort of like a sect, but in a good way :)). So the festival is not just a great amount of fun and suffering from weather extremes, but also a very 'spiritual' and introspective experience - in which I personally regain hope in humanity.. Boom Festival is always a powerful experience, but 'burners' who've been at both claim Burning Man is even more powerful. Of course as these events gain popularity, more and more people are going to be attracted to them and inevitably that's going to change the 'old spirit' of the festival. But this is the rule of life - old gives way to new and it's been like this since the beginning of time, right ? :).
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThe most powerful line is the last one: "The 10 Principles are at their most powerful when given to strangers." So quit resenting new folks joining; that's kind of the point of the whole thing.
- pweissbrod 10y agoAll the true scotsmen joined burning man 10 years ago!
- protomyth 10y agoI am impressed, this was a really good article that I thought was just another rant going in. The universal rule of groups: its always the next guy who ruins the coolness of a group As to Burning Man itself, it always felt like one of those events that I was not cool enough to go to. Camping in the desert would be interesting, and probably a lot less stressful than some of the camping I did during high school.
- jcbrand 10y ago> As to Burning Man itself, it always felt like one of those events that I was not cool enough to go to. So you're playing your own gatekeeper? If you wanted to go, just go, you might just learn a thing or two about coolness, yourself and other people. Coolness is largely an illusion. In any case, isn't being uncool the coolest thing nowadays? At least that's the impression I get when I look at hipsters. 20 years ago, no-one would be caught dead looking like they do, it would have been totally uncool. Now it's cool (perhaps not for long anymore). In my opinion, there's no substitute for authenticity, and anything that's considered cool or fashionable is merely an imitation of real authenticity (see e.g. late-stage hipsterism).
- protomyth 10y ago> So you're playing your own gatekeeper? If you wanted to go, just go, you might just learn a thing or two about coolness, yourself and other people. I think it has more to do with the expected enjoyment value. I really didn't get into frat parties in college, and Burning Man seems to be the art scene version of a frat party. So, I think it would be interesting, but I really don't have the friends that would make the trip worthwhile. > In any case, isn't being uncool the coolest thing nowadays? Not if reality TV is to be believed. > In my opinion, there's no substitute for authenticity, and anything that's considered cool or fashionable is merely an imitation of real authenticity (see e.g. late-stage hipsterism). Looking around, that doesn't seem to be the majority view. I think authenticity is dead. The majority of the people want their opinion reinforced and not contradicted.
- 10y ago
- wpietri 10y agoI would like this article a lot better if they included some of the legitimate criticism about what Burning Man has become. The number one "ruined" point I hear about from early attendees is when it went from a volunteer effort to something with a year-round staff. Seeing a small band in a pub is different than a giant, commercialized stadium show. Neither is wrong, but nobody is served by pretending that they're the same. As most developers know, things change when you go from "I do this for the love" to "this is my job". I don't think Burning Man was "ruined" by that transition, but I don't like how this article mocks the whole notion that something might have been lost along the way. Of course, it was written by somebody whose job is Burning Man, and as Upton Sinclair says, "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it."
- FreakyT 10y agoThe article's main point is simply that change is not necessarily bad. You assert that transitioning from a volunteer effort to something with a year-round staff is a "legitimate criticism", but to others that is just part of the natural evolution of the event.
- wpietri 10y agoThe article's main point is that none of the changes Burning Man has made have been bad, although somebody always thought so at the time. But it ignores one of the biggest changes. To decide whether change is bad or not, we first have to honestly look at the change, at what has been gained and lost.
- burningman_rant 10y agoYou are right its become a "corporation" of its own. I know a company/app that was shutdown by Burning Man lawyers this year because that company had an app named "Burningman" that was about burning calories. Completely unrelated. They spent good part of last year fighting their lawyers but in the end gave in.
- lawpoop 10y agoI don't think it mocks the notion that something has been lost along the way. Instead, it seems to say that there are many ideas of what the "one true essence" of Burning Man is, and each of those "essences" have been lost, often times more than once in a single event. So if one points to a single event that "ruined" burning man, you're picking out one thing that was its True Essence, inadvertently putting yourself at odds with all the other people who thought that something else was the True Essence of Burning Man. All in all, perhaps the essence of Burning Man is more resilient than we think.
- acomjean 10y agoI know a someone that goes to burning man a lot (they call themselves "burners"). I asked how it was this year and was told one of the best years ever. Last year wasn't so go according to this person. Its probably who you are and what you're looking for. For her, its all about the art installations. The logistics and planning of getting everything out to the dessert from the east coast was more significant than I had imagined. I borrowed her popup tent that was covered in burning man dust, its weird gray and alkali. Its remarkable that burning man actually happens.
- alexandersingh 10y agoIncidentally, last year had the worst weather in many, many years. Frequent sandstorms and freezing temperatures at night.
- amdlla 10y agoSo what is the newer untainted version?
- ryan42 10y agoI've never been to BM, but I think there are many art/music festivals which you could go to that are more accessible and very similar themes and things happening burning man has, but on a smaller scale. I just attended my first "art/music" focused festival a few weeks ago. It had meditation/yoga/various educational workshops, artists displaying all different kinds of wares for sale, people trading and giving small things freely (think shared water, wristbands, food, trinket). There was a rock that had a sign, purposed to "give something, take something". The downsides were there too. Lots of people just there for the music/drugs/party aspect or whatever. There are probably 100's of alternatives to burning man - regional burns and music/art festivals, that are much more accessible to get to and experience. Most are 2-3 days long, and that is more like prepping for a regular camping trip than something the scale of burning man.
- bsder 10y agoYour question is too vague. What's important to you? Is it the culture of being totally present, here and now? Well, then you need to find something that without cell phones, computers, etc. Is it the culture of sharing? Then you should find something that tries to run itself without money. Is it the art and the spectacle? Find your local arts community. That's probably the easiest. Find something doing stuff you like to do, go in and participate--even if you are an introvert. There is something very different about standing on the stage than standing behind or beside it.
- mseebach 10y agoTwo semi-random thoughts that struck me when reading this: First, this Douglas Adams quote: I've come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies: - Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. - Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. - Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natural order of things. The second was this very insightful article on the dynamics of the evolution of sub-cultures: https://meaningness.com/metablog/geeks-mops-sociopaths https://meaningness.com/metablog/geeks-mops-sociopaths For the record, I've never been to Burning Man, nor seriously tempted to change that.
- lawpoop 10y ago> The mops, when properly squeezed, produce liquid capital, i.e. money. "liquid capital" -- such a sublime, apt description/definition of money. Surprised I've never encountered it before, in awe of its simplicity and insightfulness. So obvious I should have thought of it myself.
- mjlee 10y agoI'm slightly worried that I might be taking your comment too literally, but it's a very commonly used term: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_capital https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_capital
- brianolson 10y agopfft. It was better next year.
- akiselev 10y agoI've been to Burning Man several times and this article is spot on. No matter which year I go, there is always some new group "ruining" the event according to the "true" burners (and since BM is all about inclusivity, this group seems to grow exponentially). The first few years I came, the moaning was about "sparkle poanies", people in their 20s who came to party for a week with drugs, costumes, and glitter... without bringing a weeks worth of food or water and no tent or shade structure. This evolution is inevitable and it doesn't change the fact that there is no event like Burning Man on the planet. Standing in the middle of a dessert as a city as vibrant and alive as the Vegas strip pops up around you is an experience I'd recommend for anyone. In my opinion, the only group that is on the path to actually "ruining" BM is the organization itself. From the rapid price hikes to the parking passes to general incompetence running infrastructure for such a large popup event to clashing egos, every time I talk to a current or former employee I get the sense that BM is run by children, half of whom want to run it like it's the 90s when the event was a tenth of the size it is today. The worst part has been the antagonism between the BM org and the BLM/local law enforcement. Every move the org makes seems to make life harder for attendees (although the cops seem to have stopped arresting for drugs, giving out heavy fines to recoup lawsuit costs instead, so I guess that's a plus).
- hashkb 10y ago> no event like burning man on the planet Check out regional burns. They're smaller, but many are not ruined yet.
- bluejekyll 10y agoYou just ruined them. ;)
- akiselev 10y agoI've been to a few of those and while they're fun, they're only like the modern Burning Man because of association ans they don't have the same scale or funding. Burning Flipside, in Texas, was really really fun though. For those on the west coast, Fourth of Juplaya is the big gathering of Burners early in the summer but there isn't really a sense of community and everyone is really spread out.
- rburhum 10y agoHuh... and here I was thinking that Burning Man was ruined when they decided to run their infrastructure on Oracle and Salesforce
- engx 10y agoThere's some interesting parallels between Burning Man and the Cremation of Care. The latter started at the Bohemian Grove in 1881- https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cremation_of_Care https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cremation_of_Care
- SeanDav 10y agoI predict overseas tourists will ruin Burning Man soon™
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- njharman 10y agoTime aka change ruins everything. Every wave of people, SF residents, phone phreakers, immigrants, every generatuin; bemoans the next wave of people are ruining it.
- beatpanda 10y agoGod, I know, it was so much better next year
- davesque 10y agoI guess this must be true of any strong subculture. Subcultures are, by definition, "sub" or differentiated from some other mainstream culture. So the subculture's very existence is based on this boundary between itself and the mainstream culture. Participants in the subculture are obviously concerned with who is closer to or further away from this boundary.
- gwbas1c 10y agoI went to Burning Man twice. What I found the last time was that it was so biiiiig that it was hard for me to have fun. Large traffic jams getting into and out of an event just aren't my cup of tea. I also stayed for a very long time in a tent; if I were to go back for longer than a 2-3 days, I'd need to stay in an RV. What I did realize, though, is that in order to really get the most out of Burning Man, I'd need to really get into the culture. People get into Burning Man like they get into their churches, where there are lots of social events. Ultimately, the groups that enjoy Burning Man the most are large groups of extended friends that like can be found in a small church. The hardest thing with Burning Man, IMO, is the participatory prep. Meaning, the easy part of the prep is like planning for a long camping trip. What ultimately is required for me to be more than a tourist is much more than what I was able to do as an introverted person who just doesn't like to make artwork or run games for other people.
- vhost- 10y agoI grew up in Nevada along a main highway that people take to burning man. I really wish "leave no trace" included places outside blackrock. People would also routinely leave their playa covered and broken down vans, RVs and cars in my neighborhood. In the desert by my parent's house we would find numerous trailers abandoned full of trash, empty water bottles and old clothes. You knew it was from burning man because the stuff was covered in playa dust.
- marssaxman 10y agoWhen was this? I lived in Reno for a while, and I remember having a similarly disgusted response to the trash strewn along the road when I happened to pass by shortly after the burn in 1998. My understanding is that the org has tried hard to deal with that problem since - there is certainly a lot of messaging before the event about where you can and cannot dump water or trash, and how not to be a dick to the locals, generally. I didn't start going to Burning Man until after I moved to Seattle, so I haven't actually seen what the fernley-wadsworth road looks like post-event these days, but my impression of Hwy 447 going northwest is that it generally stays clean.
- vhost- 10y agoLast time I saw it was probably 2005-ish. It was along 445 near Spanish Springs.
- pasbesoin 10y agoThe same people who ruined the Internet and every other unconventional new thing.
- bertiewhykovich 10y agoBurning Man is an enabler of some of Silicon Valley's deepest pathologies and I'd prefer to never hear about it ever again.
- vegabook 10y agoOoh the delicious irony... The very demographic (overpaid valley types) who ruined burning man now upvotes a story about Who Ruined Burning Man.
- sixQuarks 10y agoI've been to burning man 8 times, first was 2001, most recent was this year (hadn't been in 7 years). the shark has definitely jumped higher since the last time I went. Hardly saw any naked people this year. There were lots more "coachella" types - doing a lot of instagramming, but the worst for me was that there really wasn't a lot of room to be by yourself out on the playa. There were always people around. In past years, I could be out there by myself if I went out far enough. That being said, BM is still incredible and I'm not against it evolving. The spirit is still alive and well.
- mgce 10y agoI do wish there was some way to ban cell phones out there. You may have noticed there's even reception now - this started in 2015 and, to my knowledge, isn't BM's fault - one of the cell companies decided to put up a tower nearby. That change saddens me. That said, in the end I basically adopt your last sentence as my ethos. Change is inevitable and the saddest thing of all is to miss what's still great because you're too focused on what's lost.
- scelerat 10y ago"Nobody goes there anymore. It's too crowded"
- whybroke 10y agoThe confusion stems from the idea that Burning Man is still a cultural phenomenon rather than just entertainment/art installation. An erroneous belief that the promoters seem to have internalized to their own confusion. Indeed, part of the entertainment value is the perception that just showing up in costume means you are engaged in significant culture production. So easy! Disappointment stems from attendees expecting a cultural phenomenon and getting a show; the expectation that Burning Man is still important but finding it's just a show. You don't get this problem at Disneyland because and talk of 'Disney spirit' is tongue in cheek. Here are some more substantial questions than the sort of feel good straw-man in the article. What new ideas have come out of it in the last 15 years? How do you create culture by showing up for a weekend to a catered camp ground and show? Is there any overlap at all to what attendees think about the meaning/point of Burning Man? So if you come west just add it to the Vegas-Disneyland circuit because that is all it is now. Indeed there is one advantage to Vegas and Disney, the cops don't shamelessly hassle gay people.
- mgce 10y agoBurning Man is fundamentally different than Disneyland and is still pumping out extremely strong culture. 99% of the disappointment people have at Burning Man is precisely because of that - expecting a "show", or something that's going to be on display to entertain them, then feeling bored / disillusioned / shunned when the reality that they have to do real work to connect into it sets (or doesn't set) in. Your interpretation sounds excessively jaded to me and irreconcilable with the communities I know that continue to nurture and grow from BM. I notice in particular your comment about coming to catered camps. That's precisely what Burning Man's community is pushing back hardest against, because the community wants to avoid the exact degeneration into vapid entertainment that you're claiming it's become. It's deeply deceptive to suggest this is a lost battle, or that the heart that makes this community something more isn't still strong and fighting very hard for the good fight. Edit: I didn't notice your comment about gay people. What are you trying to express there? Black Rock City has to be one of the most gay-friendly places on earth. Where are you getting these ideas?
- whybroke 10y ago
- jokoon 10y agoI have not yet planned to go to burning man, lack of fund or motivation, and I don't plan to. Am I too ruining Burning Man ?
- computerwizard 10y agoBurning man was pretty awesome this year. Can't wait for next year :D
- computerwizard 10y agoBurning man was pretty awesome this year. Can't wait for next year :D
- bdrool 10y agoThe very first thing I ever heard about Burning Man was how it wasn't cool any more. This was in the 1990s. I've come to believe that the real purpose of Burning Man is to have these kinds of meta-discussions. The actual gathering in the desert is nothing but a side effect.
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoFat people do make it unpleasant. Fat frat boys and fat women.
- Semiapies 10y agoNo mention of This Is Burning Man and other media coverage in the early 90s? I'm vaguely surprised.
- swayvil 10y agoHe could have simply summed his "who ruined it" assertions. He could have said "Allowing an uncontrolled influx of new participants ruined burning man". And that is precisely right. Some clubs should be exclusive.
- thomasmarriott 10y ago'Next year you'll say last year was so much better.'
- frik 10y agoNext years headline, "HN post ruined Burning Man" ;)
- d--b 10y agoThis guy just ruined burning man...
- IsaacL 10y agoI've never been to Burning Man but for a few years I was heavily into meditation, dabbled in psychadelics, and was reading Timothy Leary, Robert Anton Wilson, and any other mind-expanding literature I could get my hands on. I get the sense Burning Man used to attract people like my younger self. From my Facebook and Instagram feeds, I now see many startup scenesters I know attending. If I want know, I feel I'd have to be much more careful to suppress my "weird" side. I can understand why the original attendees feel the event has become too diluted to be appealing. Not having been, I don't know, but from a distance it looks like a pattern I've seen play out in other communities. One thing I've noticed is that many people who are genuinely cool, interesting, curious, adventurous and so on, don't see themselves that way at all - and many people who see themselves as cool and creative are in reality vapid and shallow.
- kpennell 10y agoThis is a great little comment/insight