10 ms·
Yeah, but I'm kind of tired of having to fight my own government every step of the way. I'd prefer a political solution at this point.
by StavrosK 10y ago
Yeah, but I'm kind of tired of having to fight my own government every step of the way. I'd prefer a political solution at this point.
- TaylorAlexander 10y agoI trust a well designed protocol over some murky promise not to collect data on me. They collected data when they weren't supposed to before...
- dredmorbius 10y agoThe best protections would come from both. A strong political regime and support for privacy. Strong technical tools for enforcing those political goals.
- zeveb 10y agoPolitical solutions change as politics change: I think it's better to be mathematically secure than politically secure, since the one is forever and the other only sure until the next election.
- fweespeech 10y agoThey can just make it illegal to own a mathematically secure piece of software without a license.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- marketanarchist 10y agoThat would backfire economically and politically I think, especially long term. Let them ban it if they are so foolish.
- fweespeech 10y agoThey license it to businesses that cooperate with the government. It wouldn't backfire, honestly. The fact no one has done anything major about any of the other surveillance state BS is proof enough of that.
- marketanarchist 10y agoWell, one could argue that rise of Trump, Bernie, backlash against mainstream media etc are partially due to the surveillance state BS. In any case, there are still the negative economic consequence which important alone, but also affect politics.
- fweespeech 10y ago> Well, one could argue that rise of Trump, Bernie, backlash against mainstream media etc are partially due to the surveillance state BS. http://www.cnn.com/2016/06/15/politics/donald-trump-muslims-mosque-surveillance/ http://www.cnn.com/2016/06/15/politics/donald-trump-muslims-... > Trump doubles down on calls for mosque surveillance http://thehill.com/blogs/ballot-box/presidential-races/261673-trump-sides-with-rubio-over-cruz-in-nsa-surveillance http://thehill.com/blogs/ballot-box/presidential-races/26167... > Trump said Tuesday that he would be "fine" with restoring provisions of the Patriot Act to allow for the bulk data collection, something candidates such as former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush have also called for that was banned with the passage of the USA Freedom Act, which Cruz supported. Well I don't think I'm going to agree given the only person who made it to the GE is a guy who supports surveillance.
- Kadin 10y agoThey wouldn't need to outlaw or ban all cryptography, only the particular communication systems that don't have "lawful intercept" capability. There are already laws for this on the books, although they've generally been interpreted in such a way so as not to apply to non-telephony products so far. TBH it probably wouldn't require that much Orwellian apparatus; you just make the software slightly harder to use than it already is today, and network effects basically ensure that only people who are really interested in communications without government interception (who the government is presumably interested in) are using it. Then you can start doing endpoint attacks, deanonymization via compromised downloads, etc. The government's -- and I don't mean just the U.S.'s, but most large governments', I think -- ideal for Internet communications is something similar to the telephone network circa 1975. They're fine with privacy between one individual and another (i.e. keeping your conversations private from your neighbors), but they aren't going to be satisfied with any technology that prevents wiretaps by state-controlled apparatus. I am not exactly bullish on the ability of technology or technologists to resist this, over the long run. Unless there is a widespread and overwhelming realization on the part of individuals that governments shouldn't have this ability, and I don't think that consensus exists even in the liberal West if you frame the question even moderately advantageously to the government, then they will get it. There will always be pockets of noncompliance, and an ensuing cat-and-mouse game, but the steady state will likely be one that deters mainstream usage. And if we really are seeing the end of Anglo-American geopolitical dominance in favor of countries whose political systems emphasize stability and harmony over individual rights and dissent, then it becomes very difficult to see that consensus ever manifesting itself at a meaningful global level.
- the_watcher 10y agoEx post facto laws are unconstitutional, and something like this (where millions would instantly be in violation) would absolutely, 100% end up in front of the Supreme Court.
- andars 10y agoExcept for when they aren't. There are several examples of ex post facto laws that have been upheld. The Supreme Court would definitely get involved.
- fweespeech 10y agoIt isn't ex post facto if it has an effective date of 1/1/2017, regardless of what came before.
- cderwin 10y agoBut they can instead make it illegal to use such software, which would not be an ex post facto law (it would only apply to uses of said software after the law was enacted). IANAL though, so I digress.
- cloudjacker 10y agoSome examples of when a law can be retroactively applied: When the Securities Exchange Commission decides that something is a security, it retroactively applies the civil and criminal compliance back to 1934 because it was always a security. I mean, you can argue it in front of a judge if you want, but thats how they established jurisdiction. Same goes for discretionary tax law at the IRS or any regulatory agency I agree its a problem, but if you live your life under your version of reality it is easy to get railroaded in the dragnet
- zeveb 10y agoThat just goes to show that the Constitution, while imperfect, is better than what we have now.
- cloudjacker 10y ago
- mirimir 10y agoWell, it was illegal to smoke marijuana everywhere in the US for several decades. That didn't stop people from doing it. And now it's becoming legal.
- fweespeech 10y agoYes. However, that doesn't change the fact casual users that are largely harmless ended up losing years of their lives and had their ability to earn a good living to support themselves casually destroyed in the process.
- mirimir 10y agoTrue, sadly enough. But my point is that the Drug War didn't stop people from doing what they wanted to do. Unjust laws tend to get ignored.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoIt already is for exports unless you get license. They probably approve it but they left high-assurance security + a bunch of other stuff classified as munitions. The "victory" of the Crypto Wars was for mass market stuff that's basically insecure. Detailed analysis with appropriate links: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/11/the_return_of_c.html#c6682917 https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/11/the_return_of... Note: I could be really misreading the material due to not being a lawyer or pouring through regs all the time. I think it says all this stuff is still 5A002 (munition) outside the exemptions they compromised on.
- marketanarchist 10y agoSpot on, that's the idea behind bitcoin as well.
- ptero 10y agoA political decision to stop sabotaging technological solutions would be a good starting point. Even if changed later, all the technologies already developed would still be available. Being provably secure is great, but this is a tall order -- there are always conditions to satisfy (solution is secure if A, B and C and governments and other attackers might invalidate those by a tap point, decree, a court action, etc.).
- zeveb 10y ago> A political decision to stop sabotaging technological solutions would be a good starting point. In America, we have had those, and it hasn't helped. We have a First Amendment and a Second Amendment, and yet we have campaign-finance restrictions and gun control. Political decisions simply don't stand. It's terribly sad.
- mikepurvis 10y agoInteresting perspective. I think the majority of the rest of the world is in awe that those two specific restrictions (such as they are today) are so inadequate at protecting anybody (from the rich and crazy people with guns, respectively).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nickff 10y agoThe Bill of Rights was never intended to protect citizens from each other, the intent was very clearly to protect citizens and states against the federal government. Even with this limited scope, political pressures have overcome those two amendments (and most of the others). The parent is very right to point out that it is hard to restrain the majority, even with the constitution (and/or law) on your side.
- burkaman 10y agoI don't think it's sad, politics are supposed to change. Obviously you can be sad at specific changes, but the idea that political decisions in general can change is a good thing.
- Lagged2Death 10y agoPolitical solutions change as politics change... "Mathematical security" can be politically banned, is banned in many parts of the world. You only have the option to use mathematical security because other people have been doing the politics for you.
- codedokode 10y agoYou cannot protect your privacy with just mathematics. It won't help against government tracking your cell phone location or looking into your bank account.
- mcbits 10y agoThere are plausible solutions for both of those, or at least a clear direction to look for solutions. Unfortunately, there tends to be a critical mass that decentralized systems need to reach in terms of adoption before they become truly feasible. Consumers aren't interested in buying a "UWB mesh hub" or some such, which wouldn't appear to do anything but drain batteries. But they might, for example, buy a car stereo or security system that uses a wireless device to deliver specific features, and which also happens to help saturate the city with a p2p mesh network. Likewise with cryptocurrency, most people are not interested in the hassle for some intangible privacy benefit. But a lot of people might be interested in a crypto video game currency that can be easily traded, even between games. Or perhaps a currency-like mechanism to implement quotas on the mesh.
- CaptSpify 10y agoWhy not both?
- Bartweiss 10y agoTo me, the big question is what a trustworthy political solution would look like. I see this desire raised a lot, in contexts from HN to Valley-mocking pieces on how encryption is no substitute for advocacy. I completely understand the instinct, but every incarnation of it seems to struggle with the same question. Namely: how do you know when you've won? Restrictions against collecting data on US citizens didn't produce the expected results. Testimony to Congress didn't accurately depict what's collected, even in secret. In the early days, the existence of these agencies was classified to help go around restrictions on existing agencies. Years ago, back in the Puzzle Palace days, the DoJ cited systematic criminality but concluded that they were unable to prosecute it. So... what does winning look like? What regulation, what testimony, what promise could possibly convince people that a solution had been reached, even for the moment?
- zigzigzag 10y agoGenuine accountability. Rules that are enforced against the elites.
- lerpa 10y agoThat would not happen with anything short of a revolution, and I don't mean that as a figure of speech.
- ryandrake 10y agoYou never win. To use a controversial example: Who thinks abortion rights people "won" with Roe v Wade? Their opponents have been relentlessly chipping away at that "victory" ever since. When you make something a political issue, you are guaranteeing that it cannot be won with any kind of finality.
- rhizome 10y agoAfter Roe, antiabortion strategies had to change. You can say that this was a weakness of Roe, but I think it's complex enough of a situation not to attribute it to a root cause. I prefer to think of this in terms of the Red Queen Syndrome[1]: solving problems reveals new ones. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Queen_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Queen_hypothesis
- Esau 10y agoThere is too much fear, and too many people trying to take advantage of that fear, for there to be a political solution.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y agoI don't think there is. Think democracy. We have to fight for democracy over and over, and we have a technical solution in the form of an election process that's designed to make tampering hard and in the form of institutions controlling each other for a good reason. There is no political solution to the risk of putting all your trust in a single person, aka a dictatorship, there is only a technical solution, and that is democracy: A system of government that avoids the single point of failure at great cost.
- icelancer 10y agoSuch a thing isn't coming. The population at large doesn't care, so no major party candidate will ever fall on this line. We have to fight using technology until it becomes a politically relevant issue (which may never happen).
- kybernetyk 10y agoInteresting. You're (correctly) identifying the government as the problem and the solution you come up with is more government?
- marcoperaza 10y agoYou want the government to give up the right to access communications that it has the ability to access? You're talking about a fundamental weakening of government greater than has ever been attempted. Governments have always had the power to access your mail and papers and such, the only changes over time is the legal hurdles they must use to exercise that power.
- Floegipoky 10y agoThis may seem like a small nitpick to some, but I think it's extremely important that people remember that, at least in the US, rights are reserved for The People; the government, by definition, does not have rights, only authority (explicit and implicit).
- marcoperaza 10y agoIt's not even a nitpick as much as a distraction from what's being talked about. In the sense that I used the word "right", it can be exchanged for the word "power" and have the exact same meaning. In fact, I make that exchange in my comment. What exactly is your point?
- Floegipoky 10y agoMy point is that terms like 'right', 'power', and 'authority' are not interchangeable, they mean different things. There are other tangential points, but this entire thread is essentially about people objecting to government exercising power without authority in a way that violates rights. I hope that illustrates both the differences between these terms and why it's important to use the correct language in this discussion.
- faktorialas 10y agoThe problem is, I don't think you can say that it's a form of a giving up, or a fundemental weakening of power. We are creating absurd amounts of information compared to before. Just because US Gov could access the measly amount of info that was generated before doesn't mean that they should be able to access the crazy amounts created now. It is from a very narrow perspective that anyone can call this a "fundemental weakening of government". Compared to before the internet, they're still drowning in insane amounts of data. We can also add that if they can access some things, they will manipulate their way into accessing more things. Which means that reducing privacy and security is just optimization for them. And that will have costs beyond the US Government's own doing. Sure, the current law climate seems to be that they can access it. But that climate was created with pushes from LE agencies and ignorant politicians. You may argue that that has always been the case, but clearly there's increasing demand for this to be decided democratically. So US Gov "giving up" this "right" might be the thing that democracy wants.
- atmosx 10y agoTo be honest, that's the only thing that makes sense in the long run.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 10y agoI'm also kind of tired of having to fight my own government every step of the way. My conclusion is different though: I'm no longer interested in fighting for political solution that will be overturned the next time we turn our backs, meaning constant fighting and more time where shitty laws apply than not. Hence, I prefer a technical solution.
- mbrock 10y agoMaybe the pirates win the upcoming Icelandic election. They give asylum to Snowden and decide to become kind of like the Estonia of online privacy. Maybe they invest public funds in accelerators and scholarships etc. With a political climate like that, Icelandic businesses could make stronger claims about protecting data, making that a point of global competition. And then maybe the US politics could slowly start to change.