12 ms·
Dropbox Hasn't Learned Their Lesson
- ummjackson 10y agoThis is just blatantly false... the setting to disable the feature works after you've restarted Dropbox, just as the UI tells you to. Proof: https://twitter.com/ummjackson/status/782387668713771008/photo/1 https://twitter.com/ummjackson/status/782387668713771008/pho... I'm toolbar free and it was a very minor inconvenience - not worth a rant-filled blog post like this.
- eridius 10y agoBefore you even posted this comment he already replied saying restarting Dropbox didn't work. https://twitter.com/sethvargo/status/782387877321867264 https://twitter.com/sethvargo/status/782387877321867264
- ummjackson 10y agoIt's obviously a bug in his environment... this is a beta feature they're testing and hence not perfect. I've tried on multiple machines and it's working. Perhaps he should try a reinstall. Agreed it's annoying, but worthy of an entire blog post? Eh, not really.
- Zekio 10y agoThis is just like stuff that adds itself to right click menu in windows without asking during install
- Mister_Snuggles 10y agoAt least the Windows right-click menu doesn't obscure the main UI and is actually designed for third-parties to plug into. I agree that you should be able to turn it off, but adding something to the context menu is completely different than adding a large UI element over the main view of a Finder window.
- vram22 10y agoI think I've seen a few of those, but what are your examples? Interested to know. I normally check carefully for cases where the software tells you its an option (adding itself to right click menu, or to startup menu). But don't remember coming across one where it does it silently. Would like to know of those.
- jodrellblank 10y agoDoes AMD Catalyst Control Center count? Not sure if it prompts, but I usually untick optional things, and I still have that when right clicking on the desktop.
- vram22 10y agoI guess yes. Any that meet the criteria.
- IMcD23 10y agoI see in the screenshot of the settings at the bottom "Finder Toolbar" set to On. Is that not how you disable this?
- yborg 10y agoThat wasn't present in 11.4, so that seems like a good bet. Still seems like a useless feature.
- sethvargo 10y agoUnfortunately that doesn't disable it. I've updated the post to make that point clearer. It seems like that option was added, but doesn't actually control anything. Maybe that UI option was never actually wired into the functionality /shrug.
- immigrantsheep 10y agodisable and restart finder. works here...
- stevenringo 10y agoThat refers to the native toolbar.
- hendzen 10y agoNext up - Dropbox starts conditionally disabling features if it detects that the user is a developer (i.e. XCode is installed or Terminal.app is in the list of running processes).
- xxpor 10y ago>If you were any other company, you would be liable for a lawsuit for hacking. Please stop using your position as a company to hack our systems. This post is full of ridiculous hyperbole, and it really detracts from the actual message.
- petters 10y agoAgreed. The relevant part of the post seems to be the UX issues.
- paulcole 10y ago"Your honor, the defendant installed a hacky UI overlay element on my system." stunned silence in the courtroom
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sethvargo 10y agoThanks for the feedback. I've removed the rants about Dropbox the company to focus on the UX and lack of disabling issues.
- davidu 10y agoDon't you think it's possible that it is just a bug that "enable finder integration" being unchecked doesn't disable this by greying out "finder toolbar" and disabling it?
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoYou're using a beta version of Dropbox, right? I haven't seen this behaviour on the regular non-beta version I'm running. You'd expect bugs in beta.
- SilasX 10y agoBugs, yes. Blatant disregard of user-specified OS-level permissions and inability to access your own files when there are more than fifteen in a folder, no.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoDropbox will never learn their lesson if it's not in their interest (cf. Upton Sinclair). For instance, client side encryption? Mwahahaha. Studiously ignoring that for the better part of a decade, why change now? Valuation is OK, ain't it? Doing fine, then.
- wilmo 10y agoThis is it in a nutshell, Dropbox won't care what the noise about this is because it won't be heard by the vast majority of their users.
- benologist 10y agoSame company that endlessly lies about getting unlimited space for an extra $2.50/month.
- ethanbond 10y agoIt's remarkable that they have such a stellar product design team but push out stuff like this.
- bogomipz 10y ago"The only way to disable this this is to completely quit Dropbox" I went ahead and disabled it a few months ago.
- peterbsmith 10y agoJust putting this here so that the Dropbox employees who inevitably read this can be aware: I've used dropbox for 5+ years, and as a paid user at that. Today I deleted dropbox because of the recent shenanigans and bad press as well as because there is a lot of high quality competition in the synced file storage space that I can turn to.
- creshal 10y agoOut of curiosity, what did you switch to?
- copperx 10y agoNot op, but SeaFile looks nice.
- trextrex 10y agoWith a brief look at the alternatives, Tresorit [1] looks quite nice with their encryption features. [1] https://tresorit.com https://tresorit.com
- copperx 10y agoIt doesn't look like you can install Tresorit on your own webserver.
- raphman_ 10y agoit's also quite stable. We never had an issue in ~ 2 years with ~ 20 users.
- compuguy 10y agoNextcloud is decent as well.
- Mister_Snuggles 10y agoWhat solution did you turn to, if any?
- fixmycode 10y agoWe're still waiting on an answer of how does Dropbox do this without Accessibility. What happens when every other service wants to start putting toolbars on my finder?
- saynsedit 10y agoDropbox has been modifying the Finder since 2008, nothing new here.
- xenadu02 10y agoDropbox still refuses to answer why their client takes up a ton of CPU anytime there is IO on the system. It seems like they are monitoring ALL filesystem activity, not just the Dropbox folder. What they are doing with that data I have no idea. They prompt continuously for access to Accessibility and the "control other applications" permission, no matter how many times you deny it. As soon as I finish this project (where I need access to Dropbox) I'm uninstalling it.
- ben_jones 10y ago"Don't attribute to malice what could equally be explained by ignorance" is one of my favorite sayings and though I would hesitate to attribute ignorance to Dropbox I do feel some empathy when it comes to dealing with multi-platform file-system permission settings. I think it's completely reasonable to suspect at least some of Dropbox to be old code pushed quickly into production and caste almost instantly into legacy-matenence-mode that can not be easily refactored or iterated upon ("move fast and break things har har"). While this is almost inexcusable for an established and well-funded company that does not have a shortage of resources to fix the problem, I find it significantly more likely then some 5-eyes-esque surveillance or data mining strategy as you allude to.
- eknkc 10y agoI uninstalled it a while ago. It was like one of the first things I'd install on a new OS but all these weird ass hacks and stuff irks me. Losing trust of their users is not good for a cloud storage company.
- mcarrano 10y agoI have not had dropbox installed on any of my devices for a few years now. I still have files in dropbox but that is mostly files from when I was in college.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- laurentdc 10y agoI'm not sure why people still use Dropbox besides inertia. I mean, it's not even competitive on the pricing. 1 TB @ 9.99$/mo while Microsoft gives you the whole Office suite plus 1TB of OneDrive at less than that.
- ericmason 10y agoMy company pays for both and I had the same thought recently, but the consensus from the web seems to be that the Mac OneDrive client doesn't work very well.
- KallDrexx 10y agoI switched from Onedrive to Dropbox about 3-4 months ago for several reasons. 1) I have zero usage for MS office, and if I did I could just use my wife's version she got for being a student. So this isn't a value add for me. 2) I find the web interface and the windows integration much better on the dropbox side 3) Most importantly, Onedrive has zero support for tracking versions of non-document files. Since I have the extreme need to quickly exchange files between my several computers the last thing I need is for some ransomeware to get activated by some 0-day and compromise my primary backup. Yes I have secondary backups but it is not nearly as easily as rolling back files in dropbox. 4) I REALLY did not like how integrated windows is with OneDrive, going as far as making it a royal PITA to not make it the default save location for new files, and the complication of now having 2 "My Documents" folders. There were other misc issues that I had with Onedrive that I can't remember at this point in time but I really did not like one drive as a whole and have been happy since moving to Dropbox.
- encoderer 10y agoPrice sensitivity to consumer SaaS always catches me by surprise. Ten dollars a month is a rounding error in most budgets, a single grocery store impulse buy.
- laurentdc 10y agoIt's more about paying for something you're likely not going use or need. They only offer the 1 TB tier which sounds great, but I wouldn't be surprised if most people used at best 5-6 GB. Enough to fill the 2 GB free plan, not enough to justify the 1 TB, but there's nothing in the middle. Also, subscriptions add up quickly. One less is always better.
- MitchellCash 10y agoIf not Dropbox, what solution are others turning to? I recently signed up for Sync.com, due to their prioritisation of security features and they seem like a good company. I have come across some minor bugs, but I sent these onto their customer support who were reasonably responsive. Even with these minor bugs I'm still happy with the trade-off to move off Dropbox. I must admit the most difficult part was definitely the services I used that directly integrate with Dropbox, like 1Password syncing. So I also had to find solutions to not just Dropbox, but also third-party services that integrated. For 1Password, I signed up for their Account option where they handle the syncing for you at a cost of $2.99 per month. Again, another trade-off I was happy to make.
- danieldk 10y agoIf not Dropbox, what solution are others turning to? I mostly use Resilio Sync besides Dropbox. It works really great: fast syncing, nice user interface, etc. What keeps me from fully switching is that I hit some nasty bugs in the past (e.g. all folders suddenly getting disconnected, etc.). I recently signed up for Sync.com, due to their prioritisation of security features and they seem like a good company. I also tried sync.com recently. Unfortunately, the client did not look very native on macOS (poking around revealed a lot of .exe files, so I guess they are using Mono). Besides that sync was quite slow compared to Dropbox.
- MitchellCash 10y ago...the client did not look very native on macOS (poking around revealed a lot of .exe files... I also noticed this. But I have the mind frame that they are still a fairly "new" company, 3 years old, compared to Dropbox, 9 years old, and their growth and features continue to improve. In saying that, I would definitely prefer a more native look on macOS. Besides that sync was quite slow compared to Dropbox. I'm from a place in Australia with a generally slow Internet speed, especially upload speed, and may not have noticed this pitfall as much as others might.
- joshmanders 10y agoDang, I've always been a fan of Dropbox, but after upgrading from El Capitan to Sierra I opted to completely cut Dropbox out of my tools used, as I only ever used it hold an archive of documents I wanted to keep but don't interact with often (Such as license files for software and online receipts for things like tickets bought and stuff) and opted for using iCloud Desktop & Documents.
- m_mueller 10y agoSiracusa probably knows what he's talking about when he tells you to run, not walk, away from this feature. Backup everything before you disable it too.
- joshmanders 10y agoI'm unaware of what you're talking about..
- bartvk 10y agoIn the latest episode of the ATP.fm podcast, one of the hosts (John Siracusa) expressed his doubts about iCloud Desktop & Documents: http://atp.fm/episodes/189 http://atp.fm/episodes/189
- newscracker 10y agoHere's an article that has a review of the feature pointing out UX issues and recommends avoiding it. [1] [1]: https://derflounder.wordpress.com/2016/09/23/icloud-desktop-and-documents-in-macos-sierra-the-good-the-bad-and-the-ugly/ https://derflounder.wordpress.com/2016/09/23/icloud-desktop-...
- joshmanders 10y agoInteresting article, but none of it really matters to me. The only thing that seems bad is moving of files after turning it off, but I have no intentions of turning it off. Space isn't an issue. I pay $0.99/mo for 50GB of space in iCloud, that's about 5x as much space as I need currently, including all the photos I have stored in it. And in the event that I do manage to use that 50GB up, $9.99/mo for what 500GB? is again well worth it. I'm well invested into the Apple ecosystem and that does not bother me. I have 3 MacBook Pro's, an iMac, an iPad, 5 iPhones and an iPod Mini. The benefits of removing yet another app that just sits there taking up resources, and utilizing the ecosystem to handle something I've always done, is value enough for me. I appreciate the concerns, but like I said, none of it is an issue to me.
- duncan_bayne 10y agoI'm using SyncThing ( https://syncthing.net/ https://syncthing.net/) to synchronise files between my systems (Linux and Android) and it's great. No complaints so far.
- newhouseb 10y agoHi folks, Ben from Dropbox on the desktop client team -- This is an experiment that is being tested with a fraction of users primarily on beta releases (which Seth is on, as evidenced by the version number in his screenshots). We haven’t shipped it to everyone so that we can continue to iterate and incorporate feedback. I checked with the team about the “Finder Toolbar” drop down and it looks like it requires a restart of the Dropbox client in order to take affect — let us know if that doesn’t work.
- sethvargo 10y agoI have restarted both the client and my computer. No results.
- newhouseb 10y agoThanks, circling back with the team... Edit: if you'd be willing to file a ticket here: https://www.dropbox.com/support/s/219/5481540/c/219 https://www.dropbox.com/support/s/219/5481540/c/219 with "att. Of Luke" in the subject it'd really help us get to the bottom of this.
- nl 10y agoWhy didn't you post that you were on a beta version branch? Choosing to use beta software and then posting rants about something you don't like is a pretty shitty thing to do, especially without disclosing you are using a beta.
- moefogs 10y agoBecause he hadn't selected early access, dropbox just opted a few regular users into this. It's a pretty shitty thing to be mean to somebody for that, even if you'd been right; but it's atrociously shitty when you were wrong. And you were wrong. But don't worry, DropBox makes pg rich, and HN loves assholes, so you'll get upvoted for your unwarranted personal attack.
- nl 10y ago@moefogs - your reply is dead so I can't reply directly. You are wrong though: you choose a beta build via this: https://www.dropboxforum.com/hc/en-us/community/topics/200210355-Desktop-Client-Builds https://www.dropboxforum.com/hc/en-us/community/topics/20021... Edit: Also the language I used was a reference to the language in the authors post. I agree somewhat that was unnecessary, and I accept that I could have said the same thing different ways.
- bandali 10y agoFor folks looking for a Dropbox alternative, I recommend Syncthing [0]. Syncthing is a free software (MPL-2.0) cross-platform [1] and decentralized peer-to-peer file synchronization utility with end-to-end encryption, and with support for relaying [2]. Check out their getting started guide [3]. [0]: https://syncthing.net https://syncthing.net [1]: https://docs.syncthing.net/users/contrib.html https://docs.syncthing.net/users/contrib.html [2]: https://docs.syncthing.net/users/relaying.html https://docs.syncthing.net/users/relaying.html [3]: https://docs.syncthing.net/intro/getting-started.html https://docs.syncthing.net/intro/getting-started.html
- mixedCase 10y agoHave they solved their discoverability issues? I haven't used it in a looong time but too often it would fail to sync two computers in the same LAN unless the daemon was restarted several times until they saw each other. Could I rely on this just like I would rely on Dropbox to instantly get my files synced or do I still need a centralized option for that?
- deagle50 10y agoI have relay disabled so I can only comment on the LAN experience. Been using Syncthing for about 6 months on Mac, Windows and Linux with great success and no discovery issue.
- aban 10y agoThis was actually the question I had when I decided to try Syncthing again a few months ago. I've been using it for a while now, and though I feel there's room for improvement, it's definitely much more reliable than it used to be before and I haven't had to restart the daemon multiple times. As for your second question about instant syncing, there's syncthing-inotify [0] which detects file changes immediately (instead of 60 second rescan interval), but I haven't tried it yet. For syncing outside your local network, Syncthing supports relaying, which I linked in my previous comment. [0]: https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing-inotify https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing-inotify
- immigrantsheep 10y agoListening to these comments one would think Dropbox is the worse company in the universe and we have a thousand alternatives. But then time goes by and people are still using dropbox and nobody talks about the alternatives. Another point is, you're using someone else's drive somewhere in the cloud and storing there (more or less) sensitive files and you're talking about privacy and security? Gimme a break. Third and last, if you're that unhappy with a piece of software that's for the most part free, go ahead and pick something else. Nobody's forcing you. Same goes for Windows, Office, Gmail and whatnot.
- foolfoolz 10y agoyou are allowed to complain about free software
- immigrantsheep 10y agothis is not complaining. this is villagers with torches and pitchforks at the gate
- wruza 10y agoDo you have any footage from the gate cam?
- daenney 10y agoThat little overlay on the site that tells you how many minutes of reading you still have left I find infuriating. It disappears the second I stop moving and gets right in the way when I start scrolling. Especially when you increase the font a bit b/c eyes and it's no longer confined to an empty column on the right of your screen.
- lolahaha 10y agoThis is more of a design problem than an engineering problem. Dear Dropbox Design Team, please get your shit together.
- Exuma 10y agoDid they literally just remove it as fast as they added it? I have 11.4.21 and it's not there, and it also has no 'finder toolbar' in settings.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- peternicky 10y agoAfter learning about their mac client backdoor, I removed all their software from my devices and stopped using the service. I'd suggest everyone do the same and use the web interface if you absolutely need to consume or share with other parties who still use them.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoI haven't used Dropbox in forever. If you really need sync, SyncThing's your best bet, but all I really needed was access to all my files from anywhere. SSH and Git work pretty well for that. I'll take a trusted piece of open source sofware with strong security running on my own server (openSSH) over a magic pocket any day.
- brian-armstrong 10y agoEven if you can remove the overlay somehow, you still can't remove Condoleezza Rice from Dropbox's board, which should be plenty of reason to avoid it entirely.
- ryanmccullagh 10y agoQuestion about Dropbox. Since their product uses open source software, that means they use non GPL licensed open source software, correct?
- Sphax 10y agoProbably, lots of non GPL software out there.
- gcr 10y agoDoes the author not see the "Finder toolbar: On" option in their own screenshot? And they claim it can't be disabled?
- rovr138 10y ago> Update: As some folks have pointed out, there is a "Finder toolbar" option that is enabled. Toggling that yields no results, although maybe it will work in the future. It's there in the article
- rovr138 10y agoAccording to this, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12620632 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12620632 It seems to work, but you need to restart... /shrug
- iamleppert 10y agoI use sshfs (FUSE on mac) with a mount point on a small instance that has mounted my S3 bucket. Files get transferred to the server and eventually make it to s3. If you have a little time, you don't need Dropbox at all. And you can't get much cheaper than raw S3.
- bbarn 10y agoI gave up on drop box long ago, but someone in my company uses a paid version of it for some reason still, and group policy means it's on my windows machine. I made the mistake of plugging my phone into my work PC to charge it recently and got a lovely little attempt to get me to back up my photos from my phone - so I don't lose my memories! which caused me to promptly circumvent corporate policy via my buddy working in helpdesk and uninstall it. I don't understand why, once already installed, they are trying to get me to use it more. They won't make more money will they? Are they using this as a way to get me to get close to a limit and upgrade?
- viraptor 10y agoYou may know it's possible, others on HN may know it's possible. But if you release Dropbox for Joe Random on the internet, it actually makes sense to notify him that he can backup his photos from the phone when you discover the phone is being connected. It's helping feature discovery, not pushing addons - as you say - they don't explicitly make more money from this.
- bbarn 10y agoI gave up on drop box long ago, but someone in my company uses a paid version of it for some reason still, and group policy means it's on my windows machine. I made the mistake of plugging my phone into my work PC to charge it recently and got a lovely little attempt to get me to back up my photos from my phone - so I don't lose my memories! which caused me to promptly circumvent corporate policy via my buddy working in helpdesk and uninstall it. I don't understand why, once already installed, they are trying to get me to use it more. They won't make more money will they? Are they using this as a way to get me to get close to a limit and upgrade?
- Grom_PE 10y agoI removed Dropbox from my Windows computer as soon as they started to include a minifilter driver with new versions. https://www.dropbox.com/en/help/9249 https://www.dropbox.com/en/help/9249 I don't believe a program needs to integrate so deeply into the system just to sync the files.
- rincebrain 10y agoFWIW, I would presume the reason that was added would be some shortcoming(s) in [1], since I doubt they wrote a minifilter driver just for kicks. (It might have been that some programs were doing IO that avoided triggering the change notification, and a sufficiently large {number of customers,customer} complained about it.) I don't work for Dropbox, and I haven't used the API, but as I said, I really doubt they added a (signed) driver requirement lightly. [1] - https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa364417%28VS.85%29.aspx https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa364417%28VS.85%29...
- Grom_PE 10y agoThey made it primarily to support the functionality called "Project Infinite": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11571813 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11571813
- chtfn 10y agoHmm I wonder what the author means by: "Aside from the fact that this banner looks like something free software would install as a toolbar, [...]" As alternives, depending on your requirements, I recommend SpiderOak, SyncThing, or a third-party offering / your self-hosted Nextcloud.
- tdkl 10y agoTo sum the post up to avoid this in the future : - OP needed to state he used the beta release, which are prone to be in an unfinished state, - Dropbox needs to be more transparent about their releases, with including proper changelogs (they're only stating "bug fixes and optimisations" in the Dropbox forum). If you're adding/changing the UX in some way, document it. If you want a feature to be developed discretely, make a private beta, but still - document it. It's an opportunity to learn something from this.
- zwetan 10y agoI completely uninstalled dropbox desktop client and replaced it with expandrive [0] which I was already using for mounting drives trough SSH [0]: http://www.expandrive.com http://www.expandrive.com
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- apatters 10y agoAnother area where Dropbox seems to be slipping is customer support. DB stopped working on one of my machines after an unscheduled shutdown. Submitted a ticket along with a thorough description of the problem and error log, and after nearly a week the only response I've had was an automated reply that I should disable antivirus programs. This being an Ubuntu desktop, I don't have any AV installed. This company gets $120/yr from me and they can't answer a support ticket? There have many competitors who charge less and I bet some of those competitors actually support their paying customers. You are looking at one soon-to-be-ex-customer unless DB pulls a rabbit out of their hat very soon.
- new299 10y agoI said this last time but it bares reiterating: Dropbox circumventing security restrictions is particularly worrying because they have board members who support warrentless surveillance. In my mind Dropbox became a company not worth supporting when Rice joined Dropbox's board (http://www.drop-dropbox.com/ http://www.drop-dropbox.com/). Personally, with a board member who advocates warrentless surveillance it seems unlikely that we share similar views on the security of my data, and I wont be using their service.
- NumberCruncher 10y agoI remember the last time I used dropbox on my laptop. I tried to open a random file outside my dropbox folder and I got the error message that I can not open it because it is used by dropbox at this moment. I deleted the desktop app at that moment. I am not an OS hacker but as a user I am pretty sure the desktop app should not access files outside my dropbox folder. The excuse of "testing some desktop features" is pretty lame. If you catch your housemaid sniffling your panties it is simply not an effing feature, even if your panties are clean and sexy! And this is not part of the mass surveillance...
- TeMPOraL 10y agoKill the messenger, eh? If Dropbox really, to quote 'SilasX, "broke the entire permission model, where I can no longer trust the sandbox boundaries" - well, the cat's out of the bag, Apple's sandbox model sucks. You should bring it up with Apple so that they fix it (either allow proper extensions or just patch up the hole and brick Dropbox in the process).
- HaoZeke 10y agoI say people haven't learnt their lesson of they're still on macs.