9 ms·
Germany Says No Bailouts for Deutsche Bank or Any Other Struggling Lenders
- superplussed 10y agoThis might be a silly question, but as a customer of Deutsche Bank what would the likely outcome be to your money and account if the bank is allowed to fail? Is it just that another bank takes over the account?
- JacobH 10y agoYou lose all of the money over the amount that isn't insured. If the bank even has insurance.
- gnud 10y agoAll banks in EU are insured, but the max amount and percentage varies. The amount/percentage for Germany is 100% of up to EUR 100.000, according to Wikipedia.
- mrweasel 10y agoWhat I find interesting is that you lose all money over the insurance amount, but you're guaranteed that someone will buy up any debt you may have, regardless of the amount. While I understand why that is, it hardly seems fair that the customers can only lose money.
- mathiasrw 10y agoIts working as designed. "Fair" was never part of the plan...
- asciihacker 10y agoYes, a bank is a business not a charity. Customer service is important but saving their own skin appears to matter more.
- mtmail 10y agoOn default your savings are insured up to 100.000 Euro. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deposit_insurance#European_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deposit_insurance#European_Uni... The security measure only really works if one bank fails, not if suddenly many fail. You probably won't have access to your money for months.
- lordnacho 10y agoMove your money to another account. You don't want to get all sweaty when the news starts coming in about the final death throes. Even if there's a guarantee (and there are in many countries), I would imagine there would be a period of limbo where it's very hard to get a hold of people who can assure you. Meanwhile, there's plenty of other banks who seem a lot less likely to fail.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIf everyone would be to follow your advice, wouldn't that pretty much seal the fate of Deutschne Bank?
- lordnacho 10y agoYep. So if they do, you want to be early. If it's just cash, it's pretty damned easy to just go into your online banking and send it to another account.
- CaptSpify 10y agoAnd that's how business works. Sucks for Deutschne, but I wouldn't want to have my money reliant on a system that needs a bailout. If they can't do business right, they need to fail.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoSure, but isn't that also the mechanism that can lead to the next bank collapsing, and then the next... Like with bubbles, individually beneficial action will result in doom if done by everyone at the same time.
- pmorici 10y agoIf you have an account with a US branch and the amounts are under the FDIC insurance limit the process of transitioning people's accounts from the failing bank to a new bank is usually pretty efficient. It seems to happen overnight in most cases. Failed banks are much more common than people realize but they are usually smaller and don't have national or international presence so you don't hear about them as much. https://www.fdic.gov/bank/individual/failed/banklist.html https://www.fdic.gov/bank/individual/failed/banklist.html
- tcoppi 10y agoHistorically in the 20th century, it is not that common for a bank to fail. Since 2008 bank failures have accelerated greatly. I also could tell a story about people losing access to their money for weeks, waiting on the FDIC, when IndyMac failed at the start of the recession. But it is not my story to tell as it did not affect me, and it was also one of the largest bank failures in US history, at a time when the FDIC was already undergoing stress, so I doubt it was malice. I just wouldn't count on FDIC insurance to save you in the short-term if shit starts to hit the fan. Have a cash reserve. Edit: Here's an interesting graph to ponder https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/BKFTTLA641N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/BKFTTLA641N The first major cluster of failures actually preceded a crisis(the S&L crisis) and fell off rapidly after, whereas in 2008 the cluster was timed with the recession and had a longer tail of failures afterwards that continues to this day.
- infinite8s 10y agoWhere would you keep that short term reserve? Cash under your mattress?
- tcoppi 10y agoWherever you want. I'd recommend a firesafe bolted to your foundation slab, but that's just me. I'm not saying to keep a lot your short-term reserves in cash, or even necessarily more than just enough to buy yourself food for a day or two, but you also shouldn't rely on always being able to get money out of an ATM or that the global payment remittance systems will work in a true emergency, either.
- andylynchnz 10y agoIf you're in the EU, your deposit is insured up to 100,000 EUR, and you must be paid out within 20 days under EU Law (Seven in Germany). http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/banking-union/single-rulebook/deposit-guarantee-schemes/ http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/banking-union/sin... Specific info for Deutsche Bank customers in Germany is available at http://www.edb-banken.de/en/banks/abfrage-deutsche-bank-ag/ http://www.edb-banken.de/en/banks/abfrage-deutsche-bank-ag/
- mrweasel 10y agoWhile I understand why have Deutsche Bank fail could be a huge issue, I also believe it's necessary to show that banks are responsible for their own bad decisions. In at least the US and Denmark we have the concept of systemically important banks. Bank that are to big to fail. These banks will, currently always be bailed out by the tax payers. So far it seems to have worked out for the benefit of the tax payers, because the governments have managed to make money on bailing out these banks. What I however don't understand is why governments allow "to big to fail" banks to exist. The Danish government have actively encouraged people to choose bigger banks, arguing that there are to many banks in the country. It seems like what they should do is break up banks that are large enough to harm the nations economy, should they fail.
- dogma1138 10y agoWhen banks are held responsible its the people who end up losing money. You can't just let them be when they struggle because you'll end up paying double. It doesn't mean that banks don't end up "paying" especially if there was misconduct but it's not as simple as just giving them a cold shoulder.
- camperman 10y ago"When banks are held responsible its the people who end up losing money." If a bank is insolvent, as it looks like Deutsche Bank is, you've _already_ lost your money. "You can't just let them be when they struggle because you'll end up paying double." Bailing them out means paying double if they lose your money making stupid loans or ridiculous bets and then they get bailed out with taxpayers' money. They were already in deep trouble eight years ago and were bailed out. What did they do with that lifeline? Placed even more ridiculous bets with it, bringing in the bonuses but expanding the bank's debt to a whopping $42 trillion. Besides, banks aren't special. They're businesses like any other. They need to go bankrupt if they make stupid business decisions. "It doesn't mean that banks don't end up "paying" especially if there was misconduct but it's not as simple as just giving them a cold shoulder." No of Wall Street executives prosecuted for the financial crisis of 2008: 0.
- dogma1138 10y agoWhile Germany might not step up now, the ECB will not let DB fail, it would send a shock wave through the euro block that can cause it to implode. This is especially important now when countries like Poland have the Euro hanging over their heads.
- jpfr 10y agoDifferent from 2008, we now know the ramifications of a failing bank pretty well. The EU is conducting yearly stress tests to that effect. [1] We now see the effect of this new knowledge about a previously opaque sector. Politicians and buraucrats are not as afraid any more. So banks cannot get away by having the tax-payer carry their risk. [1] http://www.eba.europa.eu/risk-analysis-and-data/eu-wide-stress-testing/2016 http://www.eba.europa.eu/risk-analysis-and-data/eu-wide-stre...
- dogma1138 10y agoYou should read the results of the stress test, also a hint it wasn't about "can the EU deal with one of the world's largest banks collapsing" but what can be done to prevent collapse, and what is the overall risk. http://www.eba.europa.eu/documents/10180/1532819/2016-EU-wide-stress-test-Results.pdf http://www.eba.europa.eu/documents/10180/1532819/2016-EU-wid... DB is also not lehman brothers, so the 2008 analogy isn't exactly on the money.
- yulaow 10y agoGermany, imho, is doing whatever it can to avoid to put money in a failing institution because they promoted so much the "be responsible, no buyouts" in the whole EU area. Now that they are in trouble if they go for a buyout there will be _a_lot_ of states who will ask to definitely stop all the austerity measures they so hard promoted [and that, honestly, never worked for any south-west country in EU, they just worsen the situation].
- hvidgaard 10y agoIt will not be allowed to fail. Period. It would send EU and probably the world into yet another financial crisis. They're likely to keep it floating, take control of it, and demand that it is split into smaller pieces. Anything else would be completely irresponsible, especially if it's because of pride.
- neximo64 10y agoIts worth pointing out banks in the EU haven't yet deleveraged like the banks in the UK and US. Deutsche bank falls under this list of being too leveraged.
- cies 10y agoWe should all learn from how Iceland did it. Take the power back.
- AnthonBerg 10y agoIcelander here. The popular story is very inaccurate. However: I encourage everyone to do like the popular story of how Iceland says we did :)
- cies 10y agoPlease explain, or link to an article that you believe show the more accurate story. For all I know: Iceland let its banks fail and jailed some high-ups in said banks, while bankers worldwide said Iceland was going to have an endless recession because of it, which did not happen.
- coredog64 10y agoIcelandic banks were in the business of promising huge returns to foreigners. When those banks failed, the hardest hit were people who didn't live or vote in Iceland. It's pretty much a no brainer that Iceland isn't going to do squat to help them.
- AnthonBerg 10y agoPlease link to a story which you based your original words on so I may try to offer a POV which seems more correct seen from the ground here?
- kafkaesq 10y agoDon't know what the original commenter had in mind, but the vague, popular impression seems to be, in so many words: "The brave people of Iceland decided they had enough, and formed a lynch mob and put a few dozen perpetrators in a real, actual jail. Which didn't reverse the damage caused, by any stretch, but at least they got sliver of self respect back after being taken for a ride by these assholes." Not sure how accurate that is, but any qualification (or just any articles at all you feel give a more grounded summary of events) would be very helpful.
- lordnacho 10y agoThe only meaning of such a statement is to say that DB is in deep trouble. It's just like when there's a big company meeting and the boss tells everyone you're going through hard times but everyone's job is safe. Or that the last round of redundancies was the final one. Whether the government does bail them out can only be tested in one way.
- jbmorgado 10y ago"Germany Says No Bailouts for Deutsche Bank" These are basically the famous last words before any bank goes bankrupt and consistently get's a government bailout in Europe.
- cs702 10y agoI'm all for wiping out bank shareholders to zero and sending corrupt executives to jail... but if the financial system and the public lose confidence in Deutsche Bank, one of the world's largest banks, we could end up with another global financial panic like the one we saw in 2008. By many accounts, the second leg of the Great Depression of the 1930's started with the failure of an Austrian bank, Creditanstalt, in 1931, triggering financial panic and a wave of bank failures that ultimately affected everyone. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creditanstalt#First_Republic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creditanstalt#First_Republic , http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2011-04-20/lessons-from-the-credit-anstalt-collapse http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2011-04-20/lessons-fr... and http://www.cambridge.org/catalogue/catalogue.asp?isbn=0521030293 http://www.cambridge.org/catalogue/catalogue.asp?isbn=052103... , for example. The world cannot afford to have another global financial panic. The outcome could be catastrophic. Lenders, including depositors like your Aunt Tilly and Jack the plumber, should not have to worry about the safety and liquidity of their money. The financial system is infrastructure -- like the electricity grid and the Internet. We cannot afford to have this infrastructure come to a halt due to the fear or stupidity of greedy executives. Businesses and consumers depend on this infrastructure every day.
- ethanbond 10y agoSo how about we bail out the institutions and throw the executives in jail? That seems like a good compromise.
- atmosx 10y agoAmen. Bringing accountability in the banking sector? That's a refreshing thought and a decisive step forward to save, whatever can be saved from the EU.
- pizza234 10y agoAFAIK, in case of criminal charges, the bank license could be revoked as consequence; that would match the fact that [AFAIR] there are often N zillions of dollars in fines, but never charges against the executives.
- 10y ago
- f_allwein 10y agoIt is important to remember that the reason many countries are out our cash/ deep in debt is because so much money has been spent on bailing out banks. E.g. in the UK, this was more than a trillion pounds at the peak of the crisis. https://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2011/nov/12/bank-bailouts-uk-credit-crunch https://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2011/nov/12/bank-b...
- hs77812871 10y agoIt could be an attempt to put pressure on the U.S. to reduce the fine. I'm sure DB will be bailed out if the situation is there.
- slv77 10y agoThe challenge in 2008 with the Lehman collapse and AIG's later struggles is that there was no method to wind down non-bank financial institutions except through the bankruptcy courts. After the financial crisis regulators were given authority to take over non-bank financial institutions and also created the concept of bail-in where a large bank or financial institution that was in financial trouble could raise equity over night through forced conversion of some of its bonds to equity. This would of course dilute existing shareholders and result in potential losses for bond holders but the bank continues to function which removes the systematic risk. As part of the reform the banks were also required to hold more liquid capital to reduce the risk of runs and to go through stress tests to validate that bail-in capital was adequate. The politics are that in Italy the banks bonds that would be subject to bail-in are held mostly be retail investors (granny and grandpa) and a bail in would be politically costly and they want to bailout banks using tax-payer funds. At the end of the day losses due to bad loans have to be allocated. Those losses can be allocated to bank equity and bond holders through bail-in; depositors through bail-in or lower interest rates; tax holders through bail-outs; or to savers through Central Bank inflation and fiscal stimulus. Each one of those scenarios creates winners and losers with vested interests. There is also strong cultural memory with Germany looking back to the hyperinflation of the 30's that gave rise to the Nazi Party and the US looking back to the 30's and the Great Depression when losses were allocated to banks and depositors. The alternative is extend and pretend which is to ignore bad debt and because in the future "we're all dead." This was used in Japan after its financial crisis and creates and interlocking group of zombie companies and banks which seem to feed on the rising generation. Pick your poison I guess.
- kukx 10y agoSays who? - "a senior lawmaker in Chancellor Angela Merkel’s conservative bloc". Germany will do what it has to do to keep its economy afloat. If they have to bail out their banks, my bet is they will.
- JMCQ87 10y agoMichelbach is not even well-known, actually.