10 ms·
I always feel like it is unfair how we place different European nations in same category as the US in these rankings or whatever, and for the US, we average ove
by noobermin 10y ago
I always feel like it is unfair how we place different European nations in same category as the US in these rankings or whatever, and for the US, we average over all the states in the US. As homogenous the US is, different states have different economies, different laws, in some cases, some slight but important cultural differences. Is it really fair to say have the US compete on terms of "competitiveness" or in other cases, happiness, education standards, with Netherlands, Switzerland, Sweden, or is it more fair to have them compete with California, Texas, New York, etc.
- erichocean 10y ago> different states have different economies Eh, not really. Central bank-controlled states are a reasonable grouping measure, which is why it's the US, EU, Switzerland, the UK, etc. that people compare (even though the UK is part of the EU, and Switzerland has signed on to most economic measures the EU mandates).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- humanrebar 10y agoIt's different enough. They are notable enough for their own wiki pages. Analysts spend their careers studying individual states. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Texas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Texas Maybe 'central bank control' is a reasonable grouping measure, but 'size of economy' is also reasonable. There is certainly more nuance than a simple ranking can model. And the 'central bank' argument is muddied by the existence of the Euro and the particular economic struggles of countries like Greece.
- noobermin 10y agoA central bank (and thus a state that can perform monetary policy) is important, but in many of these reports and rankings they do cut across the Eurozone. For example, this competitiveness report places Eurozone nations against one another in the ranking (see page 15 for the ranking, US is #3 behind Singapore and Switzerland).
- Swizec 10y agoIn that regard, is it really fair that the US has a single Olympics team? Or a single world-level anything team?
- noobermin 10y agoVery good point! I'd say that in one case, you are dealing with averages over a population, and averages definitely wash out differences which I think are important. An Olympics team is a different statistic, the max of the distribution, the cream of the crop. One is a sports competition and another are a set of rankings that give us insight into a population and how their culture and laws affect the performance of said population. But I'm afraid I have no retort to the Olympic question other than that is it a completely different ranking of the best of each population rather than the average, so different rules apply? I'm not sure that is a good argument against your sentiment, though.
- bbctol 10y agoIf anything, population size matters way more when picking out the cream of the crop than the averages. I think the point being made is less about the Olympics specifically and more that it makes little sense to divide up the US economy by state when the US is very clearly one single country.
- humanrebar 10y agoThere are completely different purposes for the Olympic games and a ranking of economies. We-have-a-different-flag is perfectly fine for the purposes of friendly competition. Something with more justification is appropriate for discussing economies, especially since the boundaries of 'an economy' are naturally nebulous.
- Swizec 10y ago> There are completely different purposes for the Olympic games and a ranking of economies. Isn't success at international competition largely a factor of financial investment into a particular sport? Arguably the US being the world's biggest economy, would also give them the world's best trained athletes, the best trainers, the best training facilities and so on. Many (most?) sports have specific checks and guards in place to minimize the effect of money on team success, but that only goes so far.
- finid 10y agoUntil California, Texas, New York, etc become independent countries, the comparison will always be made against the US. I'm sure some folks in Texas are itching to secede, but until that happens, we compare other countries with the US, not California, Texas, or New York.
- maxerickson 10y agoWhat are you gonna do about it if someone makes a comparison of the economies of US states to the economies of countries? Like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_between_U.S._states_and_countries_by_GDP_(nominal) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_between_U.S._states... for instance. Your phrasing is as if the popularity of the per country comparison makes it impossible to discuss any other comparison. But that's not the case.
- bmm6o 10y agoStating that it's what will always be done really dodges the question of it's what should be done.
- vidarh 10y agoComparing European countries to California is actually fairly common. We like comparing ourselves to California in particular, apparently - it's rarer to see comparisons to other states.
- slantedview 10y agoWhether talking about the US as a whole or any particular state, we don't compare to the modern European countries. One important way we don't compare is that healthcare and retirement costs are a massive drag on our economy. Just an hour ago I received an e-mail from my employer letting me know that their 401k matching is decreasing 1% next year, but that they're cool with it because it's still "competitive". The reality is that many Americans working today will never afford to retire. And at some point in the future they will not be able to afford their healthcare either. How can we talk about productivity and competitiveness when we can't even afford to keep ourselves alive and healthy? TL;DR; American competitiveness is a joke.
- davidw 10y ago> American competitiveness is a joke. Not really. "It's complicated" and there are many aspects to it. US health care is terrible, for instance, in terms of costs/benefits. The startup I worked for in Italy dedicated all of 0 person-hours to health care or health insurance stuff because it's none of their business. Big advantage. OTOH, the public pension system in Italy is pretty creaky and I would not trust it a lot. There are a bunch of people who got to retire at like 55 or 60, which is pretty early for a country where many people live quite long lives, and are no longer doing hard manual labor. "At will" employment in the US is way, way more flexible than the kind of system they have in Italy where you'd pretty much have to murder someone while on the clock to get fired. Definitely a win for business. There are all kinds of things to compare countries on, and it's not simple.
- slantedview 10y agoNot sure if you confused my comment with someone else's. I never said it wasn't complicated, I said it's a joke, for exactly the reasons you mention among others.
- davidw 10y agoIt's not "a joke", though: it's a very competitive country in many ways. Facile comparisons of one or two aspects don't do the subject justice.
- brotherjerky 10y agoDoes that mean you should breakout London from the rest of the UK? Frankfurt from Germany?
- oh_sigh 10y agoMaybe, since NY state has 3x the area, 2.5x the population as Switzerland. It seems crazy to lump Mississippi and North Dakota in the same basket as NYC
- oblio 10y agoBy the same criteria we shouldn't talk about Russia but about Moscow or Sankt Petersburg or not about China but about Beijing or Shanghai. Every countries has regions which are less well off. But most comparisons lump everything up. Otherwise madness ensues trying to create "proper" economic divisions...
- whybroke 10y agoThose negative cultural attitudes that can hold back a vast country packed with resource that has oceans separating it form two world wars maybe should be fixed. Otherwise one must wonder what is the point in remaining a single nation if the end result is always less happiness, education and "competitiveness".
- linksnapzz 10y agoThere is no point. Or rather, as originally established, the Federalist intent was to allow states significantly more freedom to direct their own affairs. Sadly, this is no longer the case. The point of keeping the US as a single nation is to further the interests of those who are aligned with FEDGOV, not for the education or happiness or prosperity of ordinary people.
- whybroke 10y agoWith no historic federal interference, Mississippi would out do Switzerland in happiness, education, prosperity and general liberty? Somehow I doubt that. If anything, the Federal government is overly distracted bringing the slow parts of the country kicking and screaming into the 21st century and by those same parts randomly derailing it. But anyone ever want to secede again, I won't object.
- linksnapzz 10y agoOh, a person with a little imagination might think of many ways MS could do better with less federal interference... As to not complaining about a possible future secession... You also think it's a federal obligation to bring the "slow parts" of the country "into the 21st century". I'll venture that anyone who makes that sort of mental investment in pharisaic priggishness has more to lose, ego-wise, if the "slow parts" do better outside the union than inside.
- whybroke 10y agoMy imagination isn't that good but I'm more than willing to take the risk of an ego bruise if seceding states wanted to go. In fact, I'd be willing to pay for them to leave. Even willing to fund a wall on the Mason-Dixon line if they wanted one when the got independence. And the first world part of the country wouldn't have to do such 'priggish' things as ending Jim Crow or endlessly fighting disenfranchisement. And those who feel oppressed by such outrageous intrusions as teaching evolution in schools, would have their own country to move to. Why they could have their war with Iran and a president who's testosterone levels are announced on the Dr Oz show while the rest of the country could move on. Everyone wins!
- kukx 10y agoThe states in the US may vary, but so do regions in Spain and other countries. And the differences are often way bigger than between any pair of states. It would be more unfair to compare separate US states with European countries. While US states share a common fate, the same can't be said about say Germany and Greece even though they are both in the EU.
- duaneb 10y ago> The states in the US may vary, but so do regions in Spain and other countries. From whose perspective? A us state, Spain, or a third party?
- angry-hacker 10y agoProbably he referred to Spain's situation where several regions want independence and they also happen to be wealthiest - Basque country and Catalunya. They have their own culture and own language. That happens inside (!!! ) a country in Europe .
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoNo, it's more about the GDP per capita difference between Matadepera (58k EUR) and Montefrío (9k EUR), both Spanish towns. Source: http://www.lavanguardia.com/vangdata/20150520/54431341415/ranking-municipios-ricos-pobres-espana.html http://www.lavanguardia.com/vangdata/20150520/54431341415/ra...
- acchow 10y ago> While US states share a common fate Can you elaborate on what you mean by this? Individual US states are pretty close to sovereign. Other than ability to tax and a few other things, the US federal government doesn't have much power.
- kukx 10y ago> Individual US states are pretty close to sovereign. Other than ability to tax and a few other things, the US federal government doesn't have much power. But the idea of the geographical transfer of resources is there. While Texas may not want to refinance american banks, the FED doesn't care. Germany may not want to refinance Greece, and the European Central Bank can't enforce it. [0] >> While US states share a common fate > Can you elaborate on what you mean by this? It's a great question. You can get the best answer from the following article: https://www.stratfor.com/weekly/20100510_europe_nationalism_and_shared_fate https://www.stratfor.com/weekly/20100510_europe_nationalism_... [0]: https://geopoliticalfutures.com/lehman-brothers-and-germany-an-opera-in-two-acts/ https://geopoliticalfutures.com/lehman-brothers-and-germany-...
- honkhonkpants 10y agoYeah this always drives me crazy. You will often see stories about how successful is the school system of, say, Finland, compared with the USA. Well Finland has about as many school children as the Bronx has, so it's kind of an odd comparison. If you threw in Estonia and Romania and enough other European countries to make an equipopulous comparison, then it would make sense.
- corybrown 10y agoBy that logic, you would have to throw all of north and south america's population combined in order to compare anything with China or India in order to get close to an equipopulous comparison.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoI try to be fair. It also drives me crazy when people compare USA or EU with much larger countries like China or India. Also driven nuts by "Chinese food". FYI.
- heydenberk 10y agoI was making this point a few weeks ago and after looking into it more, I still think it's a valuable point to raise, but the truth is more nuanced than I expected. States in the US vary in nominal GSP per capita by only 2x — from Mississippi at $35K to Delaware at $70K. In the EU, it ranges from Bulgaria at €6K to Ireland at €55K. (This excludes DC and Luxembourg, which are outliers in many ways.) In fact, even Mississippi, the poorest US state, is wealthier than the EU average (€28K, about $31K)! Only the wealthiest EU countries are wealthier than Mississippi: Luxembourg, Ireland, Denmark, Sweden, Netherlands, United Kingdom, Austria, Finland, German, Belgium, France. And of those, only Luxembourg and Ireland have a higher GDP per capita than the US average. So the EU member states vary economically far more than the states in the US do, and the US is more easily characterized as a uniformly "high income" region than the EU is. Mississippi's GDP per capita being similar to that of France, Italy or Spain is really hard to reconcile with the fact that many of us would love to live in the latter countries and couldn't be paid to move to Mississippi.
- raphaelj 10y agoI think you forgot to take into account the fact that that Europeans don't work as much as North Americans: https://data.oecd.org/emp/hours-worked.htm https://data.oecd.org/emp/hours-worked.htm That doesn't entirely explain why revenues in the US are that much higher than revenues in Europe however. The fact that the current trade value of the € against the $ is significantly lower to what it was ten years ago (European debt crisis) also partially explain the different revenues between the two continents.
- vidarh 10y agoIndeed, working hours explain surprisingly little: France usually has a higher GDP per capita than the UK despite far shorter working hours. They also move pretty much in sync.
- grecy 10y ago> Mississippi's GDP per capita being similar to that of France, Italy or Spain And that's why GDP per capita is so useless. You have a few multi billionaires running your country, and you have tens of millions of people in abject poverty, tens of millions with no health insurance, etc. Don't look at GDP per capita, it tells you noting about life for the average person.
- WhoBeI 10y agoIf we were to create a new category including only nations of a certain area size or population then the US would probably get a high or at the top ranking. However, if the US seeks to become ever greater they, and all other nations for that matter, should aspire to rise above all nations and not seek to change the system in order to shield themselves from the truth of their issues.
- wobbleblob 10y agoIf you want to take that approach, then why not compare Skåne to Staten Island, Zuid-Holland to Manhattan etc. These European countries aren't homogeneous blobs either. You shouldn't feel competitive (pun intended) about this kind of lists anyway, it's just a score on criteria some organization called "WEF" values for reasons that are their own. You don't have to 'win' every ranking, if you "win" one, you're going to lose another that uses different criteria.
- tete 10y agoIt's kind of hard to do that, because it really depends. You could also go down to city levels, which again would change a lot of things. For really big cities you could probably even see the district level. Yes, there are slightly different laws and politicians, but also different infrastructure in different districts. The are multiple political, cultural and so on levels. Countries and states inside countries often don't work the same and the hierarchical structures might be different. Taking only EU and US already shows the huge difference. Take really banal things. The countries in the EU are also all part of the Council of Europe, which doesn't have a lot to do with the EU other than the geographic location. But they create certain rules, such as a common view against capital punishment (they actually caused that in some countries). On the other hand in the US you have very different views. It's not easy to compare complex political, cultural structures and economic competitiveness in itself is kind of a weird thing to measure, cause there are so many layers of that term itself. Now while it is clear that this isn't meant think about all kinds of movements, be it for money less societies, be it people that want gold or resources. Describing economies can include only the monetary part, but might include goods, infrastructure, even health. And for such a report one can come up with kind of arbitrary ways of measuring things, giving them a value. Now, I think many here know how hard it can be to measure non-complex things, how hard it can be to get the KPIs right and for how a startup those can be different and how those KPIs can change from one day to another (and that might or might not make sense). Now comparing countries and economies is a wholly different thing. Also I am not saying that what was done is bad or whatever. It certainly is not. I just think that people often interpret too much in those things. Taking different, equally qualified people to create such a report could result in rather big differences, because what makes sense to put in there is rather subjective and for example influenced by culture.