22 ms·
Is developer compensation becoming bimodal?
- ffjffsfr 10y agoMajority of new IT grads earning 150k? This can't be representative sample for US. > this is from about 100 data points, members of the “Hackathon Hackers” Facebook group, in 2015. What's the point of analyzing data from such narrow and unusual sample? RE: how to get data about programmers salaries, I'd say try to check job postings, they usually say how much company offers.
- narrator 10y agoGlassdoor.Com is a pretty good source for salary information.
- asdf742 10y agoI just peeked and even Google and Apple don't come close in similarity to the data presented in the article.
- ffjffsfr 10y agoit's really difficult to get good salary information. glassdoor.com is nice but getting data from them will be pain (you probably cant crawl them). I was thinking about writing some spider parsing Stack Overflow careers or "who is hiring" HN threads. But if you get data in this way you only get salaries offered and not salaries actually paid. I guess salaries paid might differ from what is offered. There was a spreadsheet so maybe OP could check this https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1a1Df6dg2Pby1UoNlZU2l0FEykKsQKttu7O6q7iQd2bU/edit#gid=1023506792 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1a1Df6dg2Pby1UoNlZU2l... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11331223 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11331223 I wonder if this will confirm ideas about bimodality.
- personjerry 10y agoDoes 150k include bonuses and stock? In my experience, 150k base pay sounds awfully high
- base698 10y agoIt's about average for LA at the moment. Not new grads mind you but 5+ years experience.
- flareback 10y ago> What's the point of analyzing data from such narrow and unusual sample? I have to agree. It seems like a really small sample.
- dkopi 10y agoThe most important thing to remember about developer compensation, especially when comparing to more "traditional" roles, is scale. A programmer working at a large internet company may be impacting millions upon millions of people. Building a feature that lets you collect (or save) a penny from a user every month is worth $240K a year when spread out over 2 million users. $120M when spread out over 1 billion users. That's really my answer to the common question at the end of the post: "I don’t understand this at all and would love to hear a compelling theory for why programming “should” pay more than other similar fields, or why it should pay as much as fields that have much higher barriers to entry."
- NhanH 10y agoI was thinking along that line too. In traditional more "human" field, a good lawyer/ doctor can just do that much, regardless of how good you would be. It would be interesting to compare revenue or profit per employee for tech company, comparing to law firms and the like. Another thing is that we believe (ie. The Mythical Man Month) in software, there is a limit of programmers per task before you just can't throw any more body into it anymore. Is this true (or still true), and does this apply to other fields of comparison? Immigration could likely be a bigger factor than we thought. How long has developer compensation been skyrocketing? The immigration situation to the US has only been getting shittier for the past 5-7 years mostly (although it wasn't flower and pleasant before that, if you wanted to do startup or worked in the US with a job offer, it's several folds easier back then). And seeing that it takes like 5-7 years for a startup to mature, even longer for immigration "market" to catch up with reality (it takes a long time for people to decide or to immigrate in general), it wouldn't be a surprised that compensation is still lopsided for the US.
- work4beer 10y agoHow about tri-modal, or even quad. Problem with coding is that there are 1st,2nd,3rd, and 4th level programmers. 1st level A star guys/gals from big-name cs school like CMU, ... having been pulling in good money since the 1960's upon grad, 2nd tier engineers are the self-trained guys who get lucky, and secure an engineer job after a few years working, they usually don't have degrees and nearly always face a glass-sealing 3rd tier are the hackers, they might get lucky maybe not, 4th tier would be those that never get beyond script, say html, but consider themselves coders. Teir 1 can develop a system, from scratch, and understand the math,physics, ... Tier 2 really don't understand but by hard-work, and smart enough to hire tier one's they might climb 3/4 are usually called 'techs', never even have clue what's going on, they make < $10k/year ... In all cases if you want the big bucks you have to start your own company, where you have a chance to scrape 50% of the GROSS, or even sell out and clear millions or billions. Graduating from a big-name school and getting a +200K job at google, is a lot like being pro-ball, it happens, but luck and family mean more. The real money is like bill gates, zucker, any of these, which usually means you steal somebody elses software, and you market it as yours, mitch kapor used to say, you only be need to be 1st, best, or fastest to win the MILLION DOLLAR pot. All great fortunes are made on THEFT, you study oracle, microsoft, google, ... et-all you will find the common pattern, Small fortunes like millions can be had by delivering a good product, and enjoying it life cycle 5-7 years, keeping the cash, and retiring young. Rock Star's in BIG companys, unless you the owner isn't that big of a deal, talk to any big GOOGLER and they'll tell you that meaningful contribution of an ordinary mortal is impossible. It's a lot like INTEL, there are a lot of MILLIONAIRES ( which is not a lot of money in silicon valley/beach/forest ), but there are also a lot of very unhappy bored middle age millionaires rotting their lives in shitty jobs. Then there is the issue that after 40 you can't get hired unless your connected, again this pay's to have been an entrepreneur when young, and keep re-inventing yourself, I see O'Reilly is still around to name one. IMHO the happiest people are those like Andreesen who are rich and stay to play VC, then their are those who love power like ORACLE boss, and just stay, but most of the happy people retire when they're 35+ and get the hell out of tech and do something else, Those that stay post 50+ in any big company can't compete with the YOUNG, I have old friends still at fortune 500, and they are miserable, and of course the companys long ago broke all social contract like med insurance for life, pension, ... In summary start your own biz, be an owner, put in your 5-15 years, and buy all the real-estate you can so when your done you have hard assets and not just stock or smoke-mirrors to show for your work. For the most part TECH is no fun for old folks, I see it different as a scientist you can still play to you die, ...but for TECH it means nothing after a few years what software you may have been an expert at yesterday, working for somebody else has always been a bad bet, entrepreneur is fairly certain, unless you ain't wired such, to become a successful $500k/year over-paid partner employee you got to be connected, you to to go to the right school and network the right people, .... for most mortals we are not born so lucky. It's good to work for a big company when young and learn as much as you can about all, then break away and start your own small company and fill a niche you know that has a real need, so long as your the real owner, you can always pull +50%/year off the table, a good CPA can avoid taxes along the way by deferral, Best book I ever saw or had was "What ever happened to the wooly mamoth", a book about starting your own company, told the real truth. Once you have a company and it good, you will have a dozen competitors in 3 years, and you can't drop the ball for a moment, good luck, most people get out 10-15 years or burn out and die, few people are wired to do this stuff after they're say 40, ... I think its best to have a goal to retire at 35, that was my goal at 15, and certainly by 25 I couldn't work for another person, or company. After 40 unless your an executive and highly tightly wired in to the VC community getting a job is hard, The main thing is that if your say 20-25 you start your own biz, by the time your 30 you retire and can spend the rest of your life doing what you want, be that investing in start-ups, or sailing, or living as a hermit in the another country.
- antocv 10y agoYou can find salaries data by looking at Swedish IRS, the numbers are public, but may not be in digital form/easy API yet. But you can order a catalogue from a redistributor, containing every persons income from work and income from capital and taxes payed, for previous year. Would not take much to scan it and analyze.
- pathy 10y agoHere is a quick Google Sheets with most "Developer employee codes" that are reported to the tax authority/Statistics Sweden. Salaries listed per Quartile, in SEK. The categories are quite broad. There is a listing per decile but I could not find it right now. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1yPjcXoKuwq8SBngQ2-G97dxalLT1PqelSM8VXcdDLaY/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1yPjcXoKuwq8SBngQ2-G9... http://SCB.se http://SCB.se is the source.
- antocv 10y agoThis is nice, and should give a good picture of the industry as a whole. The data probably masks those who are self-employed subcontractors and take a lower salary in order to lower taxes at profit time, which should effectivly double or tripple the reported salary. Ofcourse, it does get a bit difficult to compare this data vs USA, because we have social necessities already payed for by the high tax of the collective workforce, such as health care, pensions, safety, and many other insurances. So, say average is 42 000sek per month, that gives about 59 000USD per year salary. Which may seem low compared to USA, but behind those 59 000USD, is 31.49% in taxes for things we enjoy.
- pathy 10y agoYep all very true. I believe the salary listed here is pre-tax so the take home pay (for someone living in Stockholm) would be 30 330 Kr/m or $42.5k/yr. This number excludes social costs; the total cost per month for the employer is just over 55 000 SEK/m.
- pathy 10y agoCannot edit the original post anymore. I have added new statistics at the bottom, including 10th and 90th percentile. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1yPjcXoKuwq8SBngQ2-G97dxalLT1PqelSM8VXcdDLaY/edit#gid=0 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1yPjcXoKuwq8SBngQ2-G9...
- jasode 10y agoIf there's a pronounced bimodal distribution, it seems like the biggest driver of it would be the lumping of various programmer specialties into one giant bucket. It seems like the 2 sub-buckets would be: 1) $100k or less: backoffice programmers where software itself is not the product sold. Also known as enterprisey/LOB/CRUD developers working outside Silicon Valley. (E.g. programmer working on mortgage servicing software for a bank in Kansas earning $80k salary.) 2) $150k or greater: programmers for a "tech" company in Silicon Valley. (e.g. the programmers at Apple/Facebook/Google earning $150k+) If you combine those 2 groups nationwide, you'd end up with 2 humps in your graph.
- wodenokoto 10y agoCan't you arguably make similar groupings within lawyers?
- ghaff 10y agoI suspect even more so. Top school, law review, good federal clerkship, white shoe New York firm and everyone else. (Of course, that's a gross oversimplification. There are lots of lawyers with, e.g. solid in-house corporate counsel jobs. But the overall "commodity" market for lawyers isn't great these days.)
- warfangle 10y agoAnd there are many lawyers who work on social issues like tenant advocacy that make a whooole lot less than, say, an M&A lawyer.
- mafribe 10y agoI teach computer science at a well-known, large and mediocre university. I see bimodal grade distributions all the time. The more technical a subject, the more bimodal the grades. In fluff subjects like software engineering where grading relates to essay writing and group projects, grade distribution tends to be gaussian. OTOH in technical subjects where I grade by automated test suits, basically students fail almost all tests or pass almost all tests. These grade distributions have been constant, regardless of university, regardless of who teaches the course. There really is a sharp threshold that separates those who get programming from those who don't. And those who get programming really are a lot more productive than those who don't get it. Moreover, once you get it, learning further parts of CS (e.g. new algorithms, new programming languages, new OSes etc) is much easier then if you don't get it, and learning new things makes you even more powerful. The mastery of doing great things is joyful and makes you want to learn more. The frustration of failure drives you away from the subject. I find it plausible that grade distributions turn into similar income distributions later in life.
- meric 10y agoI have a theory where the bimodal distributions comes from two sets of people: one set focused only passing the course/assignment/test, the other set focused on actually knowing the content. Appearance and substance.
- mafribe 10y agoInteresting theory. I have a different one, derived from teaching 1000s of students over 2 decades. the bimodal distributions comes from two sets of people: one set working hard and putting the hours in until the master the subject, the other set being lazy, cheating, and don't put the hours in, so they never achieve mastery. Appearance and substance.
- kgwgk 10y agoHow is it different?
- asdf742 10y agoDoes anybody else think the salaries are a little high? Perhaps the sample size is skewed? I'm somewhat senior in software engineering, but I literally don't know a single person making over 200k. Nada. Not one. I also don't know any college grads who started making 150k. That seems absurd, unless you're only looking at certain companies and top performers or something.
- surfmike 10y agoWhere do you live? The numbers you are mentioning sound sound very realistic in the Bay Area, if you are talking about total compensation (salary + bonus + equity).
- humanrebar 10y ago200k isn't that rare for senior engineers in large firms in NYC or the bay area.
- lallysingh 10y agoNot even senior.
- curryhoward 10y ago> Does anybody else think the salaries are a little high? The numbers for programmers are total compensation, not just salary. The lawyer figures are actually salaries though.
- Bahamut 10y agoI know plenty of people making over $200k in the Bay Area, some over $300k. I think that is the point of the article commenting on the bimodal distribution of salaries.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoDepends on where you are. High numbers like that are pretty normal to be tossed about in the bay area, and probably also NYC/Seattle.
- 10y ago
- syllogism 10y agoDeveloper compensation is high because developers produce more valuable work, and in the short term the labor market isn't that efficient. People don't make very efficient initial choices of career, and their initial choices are fairly sticky. In the middle of a gold rush, how does it happen that people change their plans, and go out and mine the gold, sell the pick-axes etc? Dropping your plans generally sucks. All else being equal, you'd rather not. And you probably know less about the opportunity than the one you're pursuing. Because not everyone is going to drop everything and go mine gold, if the gold mining is profitable, the people who do pursue the opportunity are going to do very well. And that'll continue to be true for a long time — because people just don't respond to these opportunities that efficiently. As a comparison: in Australia during the mining boom, the salaries available for work in the mining industry compared very favourably to other industries. And yet I knew lots of smart high-school grads starting degrees in fields like chemical engineering, aerospace engineering, computer engineering...Smart kids would eagerly enroll to study fields where there was no industry to speak of in Australia; even though a lot of them weren't planning to move overseas. In the meantime, salaries for mining-related fields were sky high. My hand-wavey, empathic read on this is that following price signals into a field you don't have a particular affinity for feels somehow wrong. I think smart kids are very vulnerable to this sensation. They feel like simply going into the high-paying field is somehow too "obvious". It's an affront to their sense of individuality. I think the small/large company thing is in part a similar effect.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoIt's say it's the "smart but not intelligent" kids that are vulnerable to that. The "smart kids" ride the wave to get their foot in the door and pivot into something more stable. Being the local subject matter expert on a relevant topic or straddling the management/technical line goes a long way. Look at what happened in the defense industry in the 1990s and tech in the 2000s. Being able to code well and having domain specific knowledge is more valuable than just being able to be a rock-star. When times get tight companies shed weight (people) and carrying around a splitting maul is a better deal than a sledge and wedge because it even if it's a little less powerful overall.
- syllogism 10y agoDeveloper compensation is high because developers produce more valuable work, and in the short term the labor market isn't that efficient. People don't make very efficient initial choices of career, and their initial choices are fairly sticky. In the middle of a gold rush, how does it happen that people change their plans, and go out and mine the gold, sell the pick-axes etc? Dropping your plans generally sucks. All else being equal, you'd rather not. And you probably know less about the opportunity than the one you're pursuing. Because not everyone is going to drop everything and go mine gold, if the gold mining is profitable, the people who do pursue the opportunity are going to do very well. And that'll continue to be true for a long time — because people just don't respond to these opportunities that efficiently. As a comparison: in Australia during the mining boom, the salaries available for work in the mining industry compared very favourably to other industries. And yet I knew lots of smart high-school grads starting degrees in fields like chemical engineering, aerospace engineering, computer engineering...Smart kids would eagerly enroll to study fields where there was no industry to speak of in Australia; even though a lot of them weren't planning to move overseas. In the meantime, salaries for mining-related fields were sky high. My hand-wavey, empathic read on this is that following price signals into a field you don't have a particular affinity for feels somehow wrong. I think smart kids are very vulnerable to this sensation. They feel like simply going into the high-paying field is somehow too "obvious". It's an affront to their sense of individuality. I think the small/large company thing is in part a similar effect.
- rajeshp1986 10y agoFunny thing that I was having a discussion with one of my friend who is in the middle of salary negotiation. The company is pushing him hard to accept the offer well below than his expectations and he was expecting more hike as he was relocating to bay area. He was quite disappointed that he didn't get the salary figure he was expecting but still wanted to accept the offer as he didn't want to loose the opportunity. We discussed at length about how the salaries in software ended up like this. Why are they not transparent like finance guys, lawyers, doctors etc. This is also the standard structure across the world for all software industries irrespective of the country. The salaries are not transparent and the developers are kept in dark. How did we end up like this? Is it not a bad thing for the company that employees are demotivated when their pay sucks? I feel it is a very basic thing. To make more profits you need to build better products and sell better. How much can you save on operating costs by paying employees less? I feel the companies & HR needs to modernize itself. There was a time, you could get away by paying a particular employee less and he may never find out. This is an Information age!! Information freely flows. There are many sites like Glassdoor, Paysa where people can go and find out more about salaries that you are paying to your employees. It is no longer a well kept secret. What is required here is that companies and HR's understand this and make salaries open and relevant to the value produced/added to the company. Since the early managers probably didn't understand the dynamics they went with what they could do best at their time. I feel this model of negotiating a salary based on previous salary should be deprecated. It should be replaced with a more open model. It doesn't hurt much to know that the next guy is getting paid more than me, if that guy truly deserves it and produces much better code or is adding more value to the company than me. What hurts more is that to know that the company values the other guy more and pays him more just because he is straight out of college or gets lucky at salary negotiation. I think it is time Developers & Engineers talk more freely about their salary.
- kgwgk 10y ago> Why are they not transparent like finance guys, lawyers, doctors etc. What makes you think that the situation in other fields is any different?
- 10y ago
- joeblau 10y ago> Programming also doesn’t have a licensing body limiting the number of programers, > nor is there the same prestige filter where you have to go to a top school to > get a well paying job. This is my favorite quote from this article. I went to a great school and even though it wasn't Berkley, Stanford, MIT, or CMU, that qualification has never limited my ability to get great opportunities.
- phd514 10y agoWhile it's true that a prestigious degree is not strictly necessary for obtaining a good job, in my experience, it helps a lot in getting your resume nearer the top of the stack for those job openings.
- gaius 10y agoIt matters alot in the first 5 years of your career. Consider tho' that a developer with say Google on their CV has the "prestige" that once would only have been conveyed by a university.
- codingvelocity 10y agoMy experience so far is, i've made more opportunities for myself going to the bar/pub/coffee shop after a meet up to shoot the shit with my peers than anything i've ever put on my resume. Your degree is largely just a way to break the ice with some companies, hiring manager x went to school y so he knows that you must be as good as him. Simplified greatly obviously (you still have to know your stuff), but networking is hugely important
- geebee 10y agoI agree, and this is a good thing. However, there are reasons for this. It's quite difficult to gain admission to a top law school, but the people who apply tend to come from very low attrition majors like history or literature. Furthermore, attrition rates from elite law schools are vanishingly low - less than one half of one percent. Lastly, interviews in law firms are actually interviews, not a series of oral exams. You don't need a degree to be a programmer, but it helps. Think about what you had to go through to get that degree. The curriculum is relatively standard and is highly rigorous at all "reputable" schools - and by that, I don't mean elite, I just mean real CS departments. Attrition rates for CS majors is very high. At the graduate level, attrition rates remain quite high - PhD programs have an attrition rate of 35%-50%, depending on the field - and that is true of elite programs. Athough MS attrition rates are lower and I've found less data on them, what I did find suggested about 30% - and keep in mind, you have to make it through a high attrition major to apply. On to interviews. I actually did go to Berkeley for an MS, though not in CS (I did the MS in IEOR and as a cs-ish math major for undergrad), and maybe that was instrumental in getting an interview at Google, but it sure didn't exempt me from the same technical grilling everyone else goes through! It was about 5 hours of what I considered to be genuinely difficult whiteboard exams. I actually felt OK (not great) about my performance, though it was ultimately a no-hire. This is why I don't agree that programming has a low barrier of entry, especially if we're going to talk about a bimodal distribution. Where you went to school is less important, but that's because getting through is so difficult - we don't have these vanishingly low attrition rates in our field, even at elite programs. And the interview process is very, very difficult. Great analysis from this post, and very interesting data, but I think it does miss the mark when discussing why programmers are well paid at the elite level. The claim that "U.S. immigration laws act as a protectionistic barrier to prop up programmer compensation" is indisputably true, but I don't think it explains much - if this is true for programmers in the US, it's just as true for every other field. In fact, it may be the reverse - programming does have the H1B visa, so if anything I'd say programming is subjected to a higher level of international competition for jobs located in the US than other fields that require "current right to live and work in the US". Ultimately, I think people confuse the absence of formal barriers backed with the force of law with the absence of barriers in general. Considering what I went through to get my degrees (in high attrition rate fields), and the kind of problem solving, math, programming chops, poise under pressure, and presentation ability it takes to get through google-style interviews - you know, I really don't think we face considerably lower barriers to entry than law. Different, more porous in many ways, more fluid. In law, you must (in general) attend a law school, whereas in programming, there are multiple paths toward getting that knowledge and those top jobs. But it's actually not at all easy to break into the elite level of this field. I'd say barriers to entry are actually quite high.
- kriro 10y agoMy working hypothesis is that there's more programmers in the "very good" bucket that don't care all that much about monetary compensation than in other domains. As long as a certain X that is deemed fair is reached they are way more interested in interesting problems/an opportunity to learn new things/access to hardware or data they couldn't otherwise get etc. Or in other words, (good) programmers care a lot more about motivating factors than hygiene factors than other employees. I have no data to back this up, only a gut feeling.
- collyw 10y agoI think this is true to at least some degree. I have noticed that the better paying jobs here are Java or Microsoft stacks, probably more corporate style jobs. Personally I prefer working in a smaller place in Python, and feeling genuinely valuable to the company, having done some corporate stints earlier in my career.
- alecco 10y agoI'd like to see that adjusted to cost of living where the job is. I bet is not bimodal anymore.
- geodel 10y agoI do not have US data but in India a few friends and relatives living in same city have 5:1 ratio in compensation for same no of years as experience. The lower ones are in traditional IT job others in mobile app / big data. I think in US it will be same cutting edge skill vs traditional skills.
- alecco 10y agoRatio of highest/lowest doesn't have much to do with distributions. This is about having blocks of people paid more than others.
- rayiner 10y agoI suspect the bimodal distribution for programming and law have the same explanation: a group of highly profitable firms targeting a subset of the overall industry have imposed a de facto hiring floor that limits supply, raising wages.[1] Why is Cravath raising salaries while 85% of legal grads are taking jobs making half or less of its old salary scale? Because it has a hiring floor. It won't hire lawyers that aren't at least one standard deviation, if not more, from the mean.[2] Their demand is high--each lawyer generates on average $1.3 million in revenue--and supply is limited to the 10-15% of the market that meets the hiring filter. I suspect the same is true in the tech industry. Google, Facebook, etc. don't hire candidates who can "do the job." Like in law, there is this idea that it's important not just to have competent programmers, but programmers who are smarter than your competitors' programmers. These firms limit their pool of hires to those who, by their metrics, are one or even two standard deviations away from the mean.[3] Meanwhile, everyone else is willing to hire the median programmer. They can do the job, and there isn't the same idea in that segment that it's worth paying much more to have people who can not only do the job, but do it faster/better than your competition. [1] How this group of highly profitable firms continues to exist despite market competition is outside the scope of this post. [2] Cravath measures that as a function of law school rank and class rank. No comment on the validity of this model. [3] Again, no comment on whether going to CMU and acing interview puzzles makes you a top programmer. What matters is that these firms think it does.
- daxfohl 10y agoMost of the comments seem to be focusing on the supply side. I agree the demand side is probably the greater factor.
- vc4devil 10y agoThe focus is also similar to sports. There are very few 100 million dollar players, and there are very few high school kids that even become $1,000 players. While the story's about Google/Apple programmer's getting $150k are well and good, most hungry un-employed 40% unemployment under 25 world-wide kids these days, would be glad to get an indoor job for $10/hour. The sport analogy is excellent. Let's look at the hood, the ghetto kid tosses balls in the hoop from 6-14, with dreams of NBA, then one day he realizes the odd's are not in his favor, he see's his destiny at flipping burgers at micky-d, or hustling drugs, the drug dealers have the best women, best cars, ... and the micky guys are a joke, by 16 most ghetto kids know that nobody becomes an NBA, but it rather easy to go be a drug dealer, with micky-d always waiting. Our little nerd is much the same, he gets his computer, and maybe codes in high-school, but if he doesn't get accepted into Harvard at 14 years old like Bill Gates, then most likely by 16 he knows that he's never going be a Zuckerberg, he looks around see's everybody around him working in high-tech as fat, miserable, and bald. The only people having fun are doctors, and lawyers, and financial guys. People who like math, and physics, and make it to college, and along the way take to coding go on to be excellent teir-1 programmers. Most people that get into IT, just know enough to get an interview, and most of the time its 'who you know'. Even 50+ years ago in man-month-metholgoy of Brooks, it was noted that most developers ranged by an order of magnitude in ability. In all organizations it usually one guy that does the work of 100, and what do the other 99 do? Mostly meetings and bullshit, eventually the golden-boy bails and starts his own company.
- SloopJon 10y ago> Developer compensation has skyrocketed since the demise > of the Google et al. wage-suppressing no-hire agreement Is this true? This seems like a bold claim, given that most of the post is about how little data there is on programmer compensation.
- chrisdbaldwin 10y agoYes, it happened. Thanks Steve!
- tboyd47 10y agoThe discussion about bimodal pay distribution is interesting, but I think there's a much more parsimonious explanation to it. Most of the companies that are going to be paying software developers $150k+ are based in or around SV, where rent is abnormally high. But what's even more interesting to me is another question the author discusses halfway through the article: > How is it possible that programmers are paid so well without these other barriers to entry that similarly remunerative fields have? The author posits three hypotheses: 1) supply of programmers is naturally low, 2) immigration laws keep the supply artificially low, and 3) the overall relative efficiency of American companies create a productivity force multiplier for everyone at the company, including programmers. I want to introduce a fourth hypothesis, which is that programming skills are highly commoditized, which causes demand for those skills to increase. If I work for OmniCorp using 100% proprietary OmniCorp technologies, they have no reason to pay me more than the bare minimum because I'm effectively married to them. If I work for OpenCorp on a 100% open-source stack, then the buzzwords listed on my resume prove I can be productive at thousands of other companies, giving them all incentive to compete for me.
- city41 10y agoBut isn't OmniCorp married to their devs too? Those devs probably took a while to get up to speed on the proprietary stack, and outside devs would have a ramp up time. Not to mention outside devs would be hesitant to take the job seeing as they'd get stuck learning proprietary technology making them less mobile.
- tboyd47 10y agoTrue, but you can't re-negotiate your salary once you're in the job. So OmniCorp has all the leverage there.
- city41 10y agoDo they? If you're the one developer in the world keeping their tech going, and the nearest next developer is 6 months of ramp up time away (plus the time for the hiring process), you'd have some leverage.
- MollyR 10y agoI just assumed its becoming bimodal due to silicon valley rents being so high.
- markbnj 10y agoBeing a physician or attorney confers additional compensation in the form of social status and prestige which I think it's fair to say we don't get by virtue of working on code. I also think that as a general rule there is a fairly small percentage of people who like programming, and can sit in front of a computer and focus on code for hours at a time and consider that a fulfilling way to make a living. I doubt that percentage is ever going to be much higher than it is now.
- morenoh149 10y agoSocial status and prestige is all in our minds. You can code and be very respected in society if you act that way. The problem is that the type of work attracts (filters?) for introverted behavior. The folks that aren't going out and being flashy.
- ryuker16 10y agoI beg to differ....nobody thinks programmers are slouches in the pay and intelligence area. Plenty of broke ass lawyers running around like Better Call Saul.
- hibikir 10y agoThe assortive matching is very real, but whether that's related to salaries is another matter. I live in a far smaller tech market than the valley, and it's plain as day. We might have about 20 large employers that use the JVM. Out of those, it's so easy to see the good from the bad that many of the good places are skeptical about even giving an interview to someone working in one of the bad ones without a reference. Interestingly, places can transform by altering the way they hire and who they retain: I have worked for a place that was known as a terrible place to be, and changed their fate by building a very good interview process and laying off the weakest side of their staff. I remember doing the climb from the bottom myself: Few places hired new grads, but the ones that did hired pretty much everyone. it only took a few weeks for teams to realize who knew how to program and who didn't: inter team communication quickly became a network of the people that could get things done. Eventually, as people came in and left, the high performers started taking other high performers with them to better companies, where similar sorting happened again, but with a higher floor. What I have seen instead of big salary differences is that the best firms have better management and treat developers better: Given that outside of consulting, the market has relatively well defined maximums, the good developers congregate in places where the work is more rewarding and doesn't put high tolls on peoples' lives. In the valley there are companies that get so much more value out of developers that they can pay more, but even that has a ceiling, and when we get to that ceiling, being good companies to work for becomes the next differentiatior.
- yibg 10y agoHaving been in the hiring and compensation path at a few companies both north and south of the boarder, this seems to only apply to the US, and in particular silicon valley. Up in Canada, the compensation seems to be more of a normal distribution.
- AStellersSeaCow 10y agoFTA: "One possibility is that we have a shortage of programmers. If that’s the case, you’d expect more programmers to enter the field, bringing down compensation." This is imo a big part of why high-end salaries have skyrocketed, but the author's reasoning is total "let them eat cake." It's not that there's a shortage of programmers overall. There are lots of programmers working non-industry jobs for relatively piddly salaries who would leap at the opportunity to double or triple their compensation at a big name tech company - if they were qualified to do so. The problem is that there's a shortage of people who have the aptitude and skills to work in a big tech company with very high expectations for even their entry-level engineers. I don't doubt that there are intangibles at play: soft skills, "cultural fit" biases, to a lesser extent academic pedigree, but none of that trumps needing to be an actual honest-to-goodness engineer, rather than a "programmer". Plenty of other pieces (citation needed) have been written about the growing chasm between the two classifications of development jobs - engineers who can create software, vs. programmers who can write code - and I think the salary differences are just an aspect of that.
- projektir 10y agoI'm trying to figure out how most of this thread meshes with, say, the growth mindset.
- faddat 10y agoYes. Tier 1: Those who solely re-implement. You can do a lot copying and pasting. It's just not worth as much money. Tier 2: Those who re-implement while creating anew, typically in specialized areas or occasionally very well over a wide range of tasks. Note the importance of re-implementation to both job tiers.
- faddat 10y agoYes. Tier 1: Those who solely re-implement. You can do a lot copying and pasting. It's just not worth as much money. Tier 2: Those who re-implement while creating anew, typically in specialized areas or occasionally very well over a wide range of tasks. Note the importance of re-implementation to both job tiers.
- sev 10y agoJust bimodal? I work for a large, well-known tech company and they just re-titled all of their front-end engineers to "Software Engineer" (probably to stop creating a pay divide between front-end and back-end engineers). If you have a "Software Engineer" doing basic wordpress stuff, another "Software Engineer" doing PHP/Zend framework stuff, another doing pure JS/React/Angular stuff, and another doing backend services (concurrency/spring boot/API, etc) - the pay scales of all these "Software Engineers" should be different. I'm surprised it's not trimodal.