8 ms·
European Court Allows Copyright Owners to Demand Open Wifi Networks be Secured
- digi_owl 10y agoWe know the color of the bits, and it is brown...
- fredgrott 10y agohmmm what happens if a EU citizens decides to use a null password?
- ramblenode 10y agoOr any common password shared by "open" networks. If enough APs intentionally adopt the same password then they are effectively open, just with the ritual step of having to enter a password.
- lb1lf 10y agoProbably wouldn't fly in court; the whole idea behind requiring passwords is to be able to tie a person to the device connected to the network. (I think it is a terrible idea to require this; however, chances are any scheme like the one you are proposing will be shot down in flames once the WiFi owner is dragged into court.
- colejohnson66 10y agoHow does requiring passwords tie the user to the device? Sure, in a house for example, you have assurance that the only people connected are your family (or friends). But if you're at, say, Starbucks (and they change the pass every day), the only thing you'll know is that people connected visited that day. If you require a username and password to access, then sure, you could track who is visiting what websites (provided you don't allow guest/guest like my high school did).
- hereonbusiness 10y agoI was in Austria recently, Starbucks there requires you to register an account to use Wi-Fi.
- cynwoody 10y agoIt's not very relevant to the current discussion, but there is a security advantage to requiring a public password vs totally open. For instance, a store could post a sign reading "Welcome to N Guy's Burgers; our WiFi password is 'N'". You see, if the WiFi network is truly open, then client-to-access point traffic is open and can be sniffed by other clients on the network. But if the network is secured, even trivially as above, then each client's connection to the access point is individually encrypted and cannot be sniffed. That means, if you needed any password to join the network, you needn't fear the questionable critter with the MBP in the corner (unless he's hacked the store's ISP or upstream from there).
- MichaelGG 10y agoI don't see how this is possible. With a shared secret, there's no way to authenticate the AP. No auth means no defence against MITM. What am I missing? It might be harder to sniff but it's just a tool away, right?
- icebraining 10y agoNot true, unfortunately. The session key can be obtained as long as the attacker can capture the initial handshake (and they can send deauth packets to force the client and AP to handshake again). Wireshark does this decryption out of the box, just insert the Wifi password: https://wiki.wireshark.org/HowToDecrypt802.11 https://wiki.wireshark.org/HowToDecrypt802.11
- ChoHag 10y agoIf you're trusting your traffic to wifi, authenticated or not, there's no need to fear Mr. Questionable. That horse already bolted.
- mrsteveman1 10y agoAnd what happens if they set a password but make little effort to protect it?
- elcct 10y agoFrom this angle it will be interesting to see why someone should be responsible for protecting someone else property. For example parking owner that is not having security being sued by a stolen (downloaded) car owner.
- ceejayoz 10y agoChances are you might be deemed a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_nuisance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_nuisance
- izacus 10y agoProbably the similar thing that happens to people in USA that ignore DMCA - lawsuit from copyright holders, huge fines, etc. etc.
- icebraining 10y agoSidenote: from what I can tell, this is only about German citizens (who are subject to Störerhaftung), not all EU citizens.
- germanier 10y agoJust a nitpicky detail: This not about citizenship but actions happening in a certain country. A German citizen in, say, Sweden would not be subject to this German law while a Swedish citizen in Germany would.
- jokoon 10y agoOpen wifi networks feel to insecure, I'm sure intelligence agencies have all their fingers on it, or at least the companies leasing those service must make a good feast of snooping on their users. Seeing terms of agreement for a wifi network is a bad enough sign.
- pyvpx 10y agointelligence agencies have their fingers all over landing stations and internet exchange points (IXPs) frankly, they don't need an "open" wifi network to get whatever data they might be interested in.
- danblick 10y agoIf you're relying on your wifi password for security, you're doing it wrong.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- malandrew 10y agojust name the wifi network "password-is-foobar" or something like that.
- elcct 10y agoOne of the few plus sides (debatable) of being governed by morons is that they are not capable of coming up with clever solutions to the problems they make.
- germanier 10y agoEFF's editorialized headline is not meant to be interpreted literally. Quoting directly from the verdict > password-protecting the internet connection, provided that those users are required to reveal their identity in order to obtain the required password and may not therefore act anonymously The whole question by the way was not settled by the court but referred back to lower instances and is not something that will have to be answered uniformly across the EU. The court merely found that such a law would be allowed under EU rules.
- pYQAJ6Zm 10y agoMay there be a loop-hole there? If the requirement is just to have the user reveal their personal identity before using the network, and nothing is said about keeping that info afterwards, then something like this would be possible: ask the user for their personal info, handle them a hash that would work as a password to reconnect to the network within a short time window, and past this time forget said hash and the user info. Could this work? (IANAL.)
- dvh 10y agoMinimal password length for WPA2 wifi is 8 characters, foobar is 6
- j3097736 10y agoModern routers should be powerful enough to create an open network and route all it's traffic trough Tor, maybe with a bit of DNS caching plus hostfile adblocking in the middle.
- m1r3k 10y agoThat is basically freifunk. It is a openwrt router firmware with open wifi and all traffic is routed through VPN outside of Germany to circumvent the legal bullshit.
- dahart 10y ago> Copyright trolling has history in Germany, where lawyers have leveraged the 'formal system of notice' for cease and desist letters (abmahnungen) into a shakedown system against millions for alleged copyright infringement online. Is this true... millions? With only 80 million people in Germany, it seems like if copyright trolls were shaking down millions of people, it would more or less involve every single organization and household in the entire country.
- germanier 10y agoI'm not sure where that number comes from. Every year around a hundred thousand of such letters get sent (with a downward trend and half of that from a single law firm). But I'd say the vast majority of internet users in Germany is aware of their existence. Edit: After looking up some more data, at the peak in 2010 there were estimated around 500k of those letters and the million bar was likely crossed.
- dahart 10y agoCrazy!! So basically it does affect every person in the country. Is the data publicly available?
- DominikR 10y agoNo, not even close to everybody. But most people do know someone who was hit by this.
- germanier 10y agoThese are estimates made by looking at data published by both the law firms that specialize in sending out those letters and those that defend users against them. The latter ones are in a parasitic relationship and also profit from the whole thing. So take this with a grain of salt as both would likely overestimate.
- Udo 10y agoI have no problem believing it's millions. I know many people who got one, some deserved, some not. Last year my mom got one. She died in 2012. It's also worth noting that these letters cost about 1000 Euros each, there is almost nothing you can do about them, and they require not the slightest bit of evidence that you actually did anything wrong.
- DiabloD3 10y agoDear mods, how does story auto-resubmission work?
- DiabloD3 10y agoFor those downvoting, I submitted this 4 days ago, yet was automatically resubmitted after such a long time. Don't downvote if you don't understand the context of a comment.
- kcbanner 10y agoYou provided 0 context in your original comment, and then complain about down voted from people without said context?
- tempestn 10y agoFor future reference, there is a contact link at the bottom of the page if you wanted to ask the mods a question directly. In my experience they're very responsive.
- jakub_h 10y ago"Passport-protected open network"...heh, that reminds of the "anonymous functions" in PHP (the ones documented with the sentence "Creates an anonymous function from the parameters passed, and returns a unique name for it") :D
- Iv 10y agoFrance has passed a law making an open wifi owner responsible of "negligent security", a legal offense. I am not aware of a single ruling about open access wifi. I used to groan and add a password to my open wifi but then I saw one of the MP who actually voted the law who marveled, during a trip in S.Korea that he could connect without hassle to open wifis. "In France we always have to register, what a pain! Why do we make things complicated for ourselves?" Reading that, I decided that open wifi respected the spirit of the law, and that stupid guy (Thierry Mariani, for those interested) could probably quoted before a tribunal to argue exactly that.
- userbinator 10y agoIt reminds me of this: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2008/01/my_open_wireles.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2008/01/my_open_wirel... I wonder if his wifi is still open.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoSo Germany bans WhatsApp from collecting data on its users(whether you agree with this or not, at least WhatsApp provides a service with some utility). Yet, not less than a week later, demands that WiFi operators collect data on its users for the RIAA/MPAA. Don't let the name copyright owners fool you into thinking that this is about actual content creators. The case that in question is Sony vs. Some German Open WiFi operator. Bravo EU! Middle men with sophisticated lobbying experience can get access to user data, but actual content and platform creators can't. It's clear to me that the EU doesn't truly care about user privacy. They just have an irrational bug up their ass when it comes to American tech companies.
- comboy 10y ago> It's clear to me that the EU doesn't truly care about user privacy. They just have an irrational bug up their ass when it comes to American tech companies. I don't think it cares about anything. It's just a huge bureaucracy machine. So huge, that even if all participating agents would be rational (which we are so far away from), just a simple communication lag between people (all organizations in different countries, governments and subdivisions) would make it hard to reach any rational consensus.
- zigzigzag 10y agoIt definitely cares about the propagation of the EU and its associated gravy train. I learned yesterday that the EU has a wine cellar with more than 40,000 bottles of wine in it. Why?!
- mattmanser 10y agoWhat a silly thing to be outraged about, why wouldn't it? It's got to entertain 10,000s of visitors per year, 40,000 sounds a reasonable number. Here's a list of the UK parliament's wine cellar, which has thousands of bottles of wine: https://www.parliament.uk/site-information/foi/foi-and-eir/commons-foi-disclosures/catering-services-retail/content-of-house-of-commons-wine-cellar/ https://www.parliament.uk/site-information/foi/foi-and-eir/c... Are you similarly outraged that the UK own 1128 bottles of coke?
- batrat 10y agoI still don't get it why they did this. So some of the obvious problems: passwords are saved so I can use the wifi anytime, I can tell the password to others, even if they keep track of users with 30 concurrent customers it doesn't matter if they ask for names. IMO this is wrong at so many levels.
- Esau 10y agoI don't understand it either. Europe has some surprisingly bad laws and directives for tech.
- detaro 10y agoThat's something that has been discussed again and again in German politics, but no government clearly wanted to say "Free Internet is worthwhile enough to allow protecting it from 'illegal' activity, even if it can't offer the the log data a traditional ISP can". So now we have a bunch of rules that only apply if you something to stop it, but it doesn't really matter if that is actually effective, and how much that something hurdle is depends on what court or politician you ask. Maximum uncertainty for small operators, so it's mostly a few larger commercial operators and some enthusiasts with VPNs. And a lot of places without wifi that would have it in other countries.
- kuschku 10y agoAnd it’s only an issue with the CDU on federal level prohibiting any move towards it, often with contradictory arguments why. Evil tongues claim that they just want to protect T-Mobile’s business, being corrupt. Luckily, on state level that’s not yet an issue, the parliament of Schleswig-Holstein just approved a test project of running some Freifunk nodes on/in public buildings, and a local company has started putting up free hotspots everywhere in Kiel.
- detaro 10y agoEh, I somehow feel like the federal SPD is just so positive on the topic right now because they know the CDU will work against them anyways. I hope pressure and organization from state or city level will help somewhat. Public organisations can provide similar shields as the commercial providers do right now, and once somebody makes a state look stupid the federal level will have more of an incentive to fix it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jjawssd 10y agoThe disintegration of the European Union needs to accelerate. The non-democratic powerful elite junta known as the EU is increasingly passing policy goals which ultimately serve only the elite minority. Our rights our being eroded, chipped away a little bit at a time like sand being carried away by flowing water. We must resist these policies and rebuild a stronger foundation for our civil liberties, including a truly free Internet. We need to return to stronger local governance and a more decentralised power structure. What we are seeing today is a consolidation of power and the emergence of a singular totalitarian state. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_deficit_in_the_European_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_deficit_in_the_Euro... Disagree with EU policies? Shut up and tolerate it. http://www.europarl.europa.eu/meetdocs/2009_2014/documents/libe/dv/11_revframework_statute_/11_revframework_statute_en.pdf http://www.europarl.europa.eu/meetdocs/2009_2014/documents/l... Arbitrary circuit breakers added to circumvent dissenting opinions. Article 7 TEU. "Far-reaching sanctions" can be exerted, and a country can be stripped of all voting rights in the EU and have funding blocked. In January this year, Frans Timmermans, the first ever unelected Commission "vice president," who is in charge of "human rights," triggered the mechanism for the first time against Poland’s government which came to power in a record-breaking, landslide election in 2015. http://ec.europa.eu/justice/effective-justice/rule-of-law/index_en.htm http://ec.europa.eu/justice/effective-justice/rule-of-law/in... "If freedom of speech is taken away, then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter." ― George Washington. Or more recently, led straight into the gas chambers for a nice "hot shower." We must ask ourselves what is the end game here? Dissenting opinions are now often twisted into being labeled as "hate speech" and "racism." Europe has already experienced the suppression of free thought and expression with the fall of the Roman Empire. What followed was a chilling effect which lasted 1000 years. Do we want to go down this road again?
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoThere are a lot of strong claims in your comment. Could you please back them up with evidence? Like, I don't know, the ruling against Apple and the IE government. Was that in favour of the ruling elite minority? The EU has a lot of problems to fix within itself, but it has a decent track of evidence against your claims (user privacy, antitrust, etc). And you completely lost it when you start mentioning the gas chambers. Dude, I don't know, but you're going too far.
- ultim8k 10y agoFuck EU. Fuck laws and governments. I'm removing my wifi pass now.
- pyronik 10y agoEvery day its looking more and more like Brexit leave was a good decision.