12 ms·
The $50,000 San Francisco Home
- powera 10y agoBy "home", the author apparently means "120 square foot studio apartment". And by San Francisco, the author apparently means "somewhere near San Francisco, except the zoning laws don't allow this anywhere near SF right now".
- subway 10y agoI live in a 140sqft unit, and am quite happy. If anything, even at 140, I still have too much space for junk to accumulate.
- davidw 10y agoThere are plenty of people who would happily live in those, if the choice were available to them: http://www.sightline.org/2016/09/06/how-seattle-killed-micro-housing/ http://www.sightline.org/2016/09/06/how-seattle-killed-micro...
- powera 10y agoI don't buy the math in that article one bit for why they can't build more houses. I also don't buy the premise that building as many SRO-style apartments as possible is a good thing.
- BryantD 10y agoHe discusses both the feasibility of living in a 120 sq. ft. apartment and SF zoning laws in the article.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mankash666 10y agoThing about dense housing is that one or two streets lead in/out of a community of 1000 cars. When everyone wants to leave at 8:30 AM and get back at 6 PM, this often ends in traffic tragedy
- geogra4 10y agoStrange that places like Manhattan and Paris have a solution to this issue
- mankash666 10y agowhich is?
- malyk 10y agopublic transportation.
- throwaway2016a 10y ago> With all due respect, I live in a dense community in the bay area with the aforementioned problem. Public transit isn't in sight for miles! Did you mean to say "without"? Because your statement doesn't disprove what he is saying at all. The argument is that public transportation would fix it and if there is no public transportation for miles than it means the system is clearly inadequate.
- mankash666 10y agoI'm unsure about the grammar. All I know from my own experience living in the bay for 10 years, is that if your home and workplace are within walking distance of BART, public transit is an viable option. Else, unless you're in the city, cars are the only way to get about. Also, living is getting denser due to obvious reasons, while the roads aren't getting wider - and I'm not even talking about the highways.
- malyk 10y agoOf course, then it would just get "flipped" back on the market for $500k because that's what people are willing to pay.
- davidw 10y agoThe laws of supply and demand hold true for housing too. Add enough supply, and those prices start to drop.
- oxide 10y agoI'm fairly ignorant of the housing market in general, but from what I understand the problem in SF has more than one layer: the local government won't allow new housing to be built, the NIMBY crowd wants a one-story skyline across the entire bay, etc. what is to be done to introduce new supply? the whole thing seems like a hell of a headache, I feel for folks trying to live in that area.
- davidw 10y agoYes, the problem is an entirely artificial, political lack of supply. I mean, at a certain point, you get so dense that only building way, way up (skyscrapers) works to add new housing, and those are expensive. But SF is a long ways from there.
- oxide 10y agoIf the problem is a political one, is the only solution to fight fire with fire? Politics is a slow turning ship, so I can't imagine the problem getting better any time soon for folks who's lives are affected most. I'd probably just settle for a much longer commute if push came to shove, but I imagine that's not an option for everyone.
- davidw 10y agoYes: http://www.sfyimby.org/ http://www.sfyimby.org/
- douche 10y agoI'm a little surprised that the Googles and Apples of the valley aren't trying to build company housing on their campuses. It's not without its own problems, as the history of "company towns" shows, but something has got to give.
- lallysingh 10y agoLots of zoning problems over there. They'd probably do anything they could (e.g., finance a builder) to get stuff constructed out there.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoGoogle has proposed more than once building housing at their North Bayshore (HQ) site but the "city" of Mountain View is having none of it.
- Fricken 10y agoGoogle has been struggling with Mountain View city council to get housing built in North Bayshore for about a decade. It got approved this spring: http://www.mv-voice.com/news/2016/03/03/council-oks-plans-for-dense-housing-in-north-bayshore http://www.mv-voice.com/news/2016/03/03/council-oks-plans-fo...
- Psyonic 10y agoThey are: http://www.wsj.com/articles/facebooks-answer-to-silicon-valley-housing-crunch-build-apartments-1469534402 http://www.wsj.com/articles/facebooks-answer-to-silicon-vall...
- dclowd9901 10y agoI find it so strange that experts center their goals around how to fit as many people as possible into these cities, rather than figuring out how to scale what makes places like the Bay Area desirable out to other regions...
- davidw 10y agoIt's possible to do both. It's a lot easier to figure out how to allow people to live in cities though, because the technology has existed for 100's of years. Figuring out how to "replicate Silicon Valley" is something everyone would love to do, but very few places have come close.
- jdmichal 10y agoSilicon Valley as a phenomenon is about network effects, so of course it's extremely difficult to reproduce. How do you reproduce the mid-century hacker culture leading to technical giants leading to VC money attraction leading to startup culture? VC money moving to the Midwest will maybe change where future startups happen, but there's still a lot of networking power centralized to Silicon Valley that will take time to match. And in the meantime, those other places are at a disadvantage in that respect.
- idbehold 10y agoIf someone finds a way to scale nice weather to other parts of the world, I'm all ears.
- leakybit 10y agoThe Bay Area is so desirable because it where all the tech companies are located and the tech companies are there because it were all the tech workers are. It's an unbreakable cycle.
- raldi 10y agoFor others (including me) high density is itself one of the key attractors. I enjoy the big city lifestyle, with subways and museums and economies of scale and millions of potential new friends.
- tjpaudio 10y agoI think the real tl:dr of this article is: making affordable living spaces is easy if the laws and NIMBYs allow it. But they don't. So it's not.
- oxide 10y agoThe more I learn about this situation the more surprised I am. George Carlin had a great bit about NIMBY-types, but in that bit the NIMBY-types, who don't want a prison built near them, have a "logical" viewpoint that he deconstructs: criminals don't hang around outside of a prison. Inmates who escape want to get as far away from the prison as possible, that's the point of escaping, after all. From what I can tell, the NIMBY-types in SF only have...aesthetic concerns? is that really what is keeping housing from being built? concerns over an eyesore? I don't see the "logical" viewpoint that can be deconstructed here, no wonder it's such a headache.
- aji 10y agoas I understand it, the argument is that "bad" construction will make the neighborhood less desirable and cause the value of their property to drop
- ng12 10y agoIt all comes back to money. People who've seen 20x returns on their property value want to keep the money, people who've spent $5m on a small house want to justify that investment, and landlords want to keep renting their shoebox studio for $3k/mo. Arguments about neighborhood character are just trying to obscure the obvious greed.
- EduardoBautista 10y agoJust a random opinion from someone who doesn't live in SF: I like to visit SF because of the architecture. It really is what makes it unique in the United States. It would be a shame to lose that.
- 10y ago
- ComteDeLaFere 10y agoI like this, although one thing that I've recently learned is that Silicon Valley has a number of large trailer parks, and you can often purchase a home in one of them for about $70-90K. Many of the trailers are actually quite retro cool. I believe Tony Hsieh still lives in a trailer, in Vegas. http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/191-E-El-Camino-Real-SPC-284-Mountain-View-CA-94040/2097442737_zpid/ http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/191-E-El-Camino-Real-SPC-2... http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/2150-Almaden-Rd-SPC-125-San-Jose-CA-95125/2097418932_zpid/ http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/2150-Almaden-Rd-SPC-125-Sa...
- ZanyProgrammer 10y agoWhich is nice right up until the trailer park gets sold for condos.
- Someone1234 10y agoI feel obliged to point something important out about trailer park homes (and other temporary dwellings)... They're a financial trap. So MOST people buy a home with finance, it might be a bank, credit union, or whatever but ultimately these loans are backed by larger organisations in the background that set the rules. One thing you may not be aware of is that once a trailer park home is 15+ years old a LOT of companies won't loan against it. Even for a new dwelling of that type it can be hard to get finance, but as they grow older loan providers vanish. There's a whole host of reasons for this (e.g. the type of people that live there are "high risk," the home can literally be stolen, there's less standardisation for home inspection, the land is low value since it is often in the middle of a trailer park (i.e. has no general purpose value)). I call this a "trap" because you'll buy the trailer park home, then at some stage in the future you'll want to resell it; when that occurs you may suddenly find that while there are a lot of interested buyers none of them can get finance(!) to buy your home. This has nothing to do with a buyer's credit score by the way. It is the property itself that won't be loaned against (since when you mortgage the property itself is normally collateral in case you don't pay, in this case they cannot determine that the property is worth as much as the loan you're asking for). I know someone who's been trying to sell their trailer park home for a year. Lot's of interested buyers, all with good jobs and solid credit scores, but none of them can get finance because the property is too old, and none have the cash. They're tried dozens of financial institutions.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoThe article has a picture of a "typical" san francisco street that doesn't represent most of the city. Maybe weighted by population the photo from chinatown is typical, but weighted by land use this photo is more typical: https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7432808,-122.4896485,3a,75y,358.24h,84.24t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sZGoGAvwrztEtEGSlevEvgw!2e0!6s%2F%2Fgeo0.ggpht.com%2Fcbk%3Fpanoid%3DZGoGAvwrztEtEGSlevEvgw%26output%3Dthumbnail%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26thumb%3D2%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D136.28094%26pitch%3D0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7432808,-122.4896485,3a,75y,...
- wott 10y agoThis 3rd world cabling...
- imaginenore 10y agoI wonder if one could create some sort of a floating platform and build housing on it.
- BlickSilly 10y agojust use a cruise ship to bring cheap labor 5 miles off shore ala http://www.sea-code.com/ http://www.sea-code.com/
- imaginenore 10y agoMost cruise ship cabins aren't exactly comfortable. Plus cruise ships are really shitty in storms. I'm thinking of a much wider structure.
- internaut 10y agoYou haven't heard of seasteading?
- wrong_variable 10y agoBesides NIMBYism, a drop in home equity will be extremely bad for the economy due to how much of debt is linked to mortgage debt, so I do not expect to see a drop in price anytime soon.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agorent-extractors going bankrupt is a net-positive for the economy. There will be losers, sure, but we're better off overall if the Bay Area has three times as many people at the current levels of productivity/salary.
- tsunamifury 10y agoI currently live in a new 330 sqft microhouse in Berkeley. Its not a solution at all. You can't have a family and you don't gain enough value to buy an actual livable size home. The only use it has is to rent to others on your backlot to help pay for your $1.2m two bedroom home's constant renovation needs. Its like living in too small of a pot, you either end up with a tiny plant (your life) or a dead one.
- stickfigure 10y agoAccording to the 2010 census (via wikipedia), in SF "There were 345,811 households, out of which 63,577 (18.4%) had children under the age of 18 living in them." It seems highly likely that much of the other 81.6% might be willing to sacrifice some space in order to spend less on housing. But it's not an option. Instead we either overpay or have roommates - often both - and rent rather than buy.
- Dylan16807 10y agoThe article isn't really about how big your home needs to be. If you want a multiple of that many square feet, you pay a multiple of $50k. You're talking about a budget of $1.2m. Let's spend half of that with the article's math. $600k gets you 3000 square feet of low-rise, or 1500 square feet of mid-rise right at the center of downtown. That's enough for a pretty big family.
- chupasaurus 10y agoFYI: In Soviet Russia in the early 80's, there were 161,5sqft of house space per each resident. The most common accomodation was single-room apartment 351sqft sized.
- tsunamifury 10y agoYou just cited a nation who has been in a population decline.
- chupasaurus 10y agoUSSR's population had grown up since WWII to the end. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_Soviet_Union#Population_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_Soviet_Uni...
- bcheung 10y agoEven if they do make houses for $50K, there is a huge demand so prices will still rise well above those prices. Both government and local home owners don't want more housing. Nobody who already owns a home wants more built because it would mean their home goes down in value. Also, it means it would be more crowded and more traffic. It's a crappy situation all around. That aside, I wish we could get some better 100% telecommuting / remote jobs.
- wrong_variable 10y ago> here is a huge demand so prices will still rise well above those prices. That is not supply and demand works, price will fall. It might pick up again due to increased economical activity driven by population growth, but that is a second order concern. At some point housing itself will not be a limiting factor to the growth of the economy, however SF is far being Manhattan, London, Paris.. It might take 10 years to get there. Once SF increases its population by 7-8x a simple investment in underground metro would undo the effect of congestion. That is where technology is right now, Greater Tokyo supports 40 million people ! and the city is an economical powerhouse. It allows cool stuff like trains that travel at the speed of a bullet.
- bcheung 10y agoI should have clarified. Yes, increasing supply satisfies some demand and brings down prices. My point was that demand is so much higher than supply that the market value is still much higher than the intrinsic value. Saying you can build a home for $50K doesn't mean it will cost that. Regulatory concerns are a large part why homes so much more expensive. I built a 2 story, 4 room structure inside of a friend's warehouse for $3,800 total. I got a book on framing and just bought a bunch of lumber and drywall from Home Depot and built it myself with the help of a friend. It wasn't legal of course. If I actually followed the law I couldn't have afforded a place to live and would have been homeless. I agree that technology follows an exponential curve and will bring construction costs down, but gov't and society in general doesn't move at that speed and so I don't anticipate homes being much cheaper. That and inflation.
- 10y ago
- jbpetersen 10y ago$10,000 profit and $40,000 expenses is not a 20% profit margin, it's a 25% profit margin. Is it just me or has there been a recent uptick in miscalculations like this on the part of professional journalists?
- jeffem 10y agoYou sure about that? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Profit_margin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Profit_margin
- jbpetersen 10y agoApparently I've been mistaking profit percentage for profit margin all along. Thanks for setting me straight.
- makomk 10y agoWait, they're proposing four story, wooden multiple-occupancy buildings? Would those meet fire safety standards anywhere in the developed world? I doubt their example photo (sheltered accommodation for the elderly in the UK) is wood, since we don't generally build that way, and from what I can tell it cost substantially more than their budget despite being built somewhere with low land costs. I also notice that their photos of how six-story buildings would look are actually mostly four stories or less - and even at that height, they're starting to look pretty crowded in and dark. That's the trouble with dense high-rise buildings - you rapidly run out of light and privacy. This has two nasty effects on their proposals: it limits the density at which you can manage to cram them in and puts a lower cap on the minimum size.
- blackguardx 10y agoIn the US, home construction is almost entirely wood. Masonry is usually reserved for commercial buildings. Really large apartment buildings are often made with concrete and steel. Using wood isn't unusual at all for a project like this. There was even some large apartment buildings going up in SF last year between the Potrero and SOMA neighborhoods that were entirely of wood.
- spc476 10y agoIt really depends upon where you are in the US. Here in South Florida, most homes are built out of concrete block, due to expense (it's cheap) and building codes (for hurricanes). Yes, there are a few wood homes but you have to go out of your way to find them. Brick houses are very rare, as it costs a ton to ship the bricks in (we lack the resources to make bricks, but not concrete blocks).
- noxryan 10y agoWooden multi-story building are standard in the US, at least in the midwest. Many new apartment buildings less than 7 stories are constructed with wood. I actually live in a 6 story wooden building with about 300 housing units. Also, stepping back higher stories is commonly done to help deal with shadows. http://www.woodworks.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/Paper_383.pdf http://www.woodworks.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/Paper_38...
- munificent 10y agoTL;DR: It's the size of a postage stamp.
- iav 10y ago1) construction costs don't scale down linearly with square footage. Every home needs a kitchen, a heater, a bathroom, a foundation. This makes micro homes much more expensive on per foot basis 2) using construction costs from rural areas with low cost labor. Majority of home construction is labor with materials and overhead the rest. Contractors in SF are highly sought after due to hyper demand and charge double the figures here 3) seismic reinforcement in SF significantly increase construction costs 4) the cheapest anyone ever built anything in dense urban areas is $250/sq ft. My architect here says $350/ft is a challenge in SF for 2000 sq ft build. Good luck!
- johan_larson 10y agoI wonder what people would be willing to pay for 200 sq ft apartments in, say, San Mateo if the units could be rented at market. Could you get $1000 per unit per month?
- dismantlethesun 10y agoI did the math and it checks out. $500,000 for 1200sq is essentially DC prices for a condo in 12-16 story buildings. Our land values aren't that high though, so there's definitely some money being put into the luxury of the building and grounds.