7 ms·
The oldest computer in use by the U.S. government
- jmbwell 10y agoThere is a lot to be said for systems that do their jobs despite their age, and which have been validated and refined over the course of decades. In many ways, I'd rather maintain an old, well tested system than a modern system with widely available exploits, conflicting commercial interests, and rapid obsolescence.
- cmdrfred 10y agoAn abacus has an exceptionally small attack surface when you think about it.
- paulddraper 10y agoAmen. The principle of least power: use the least amount that you need. If an abacus suffices, you will reap the reliability and security rewards.
- jeff_marshall 10y agoToo true - both the negative (who wants to program an abacus), and the positive (there is no magic in this program/device). I feel like developers tend to favor the magic, due to the burden it relieves, without having to consider the negatives due to the way the business of software works.
- userbinator 10y agoNot all developers, but I'd say that certainly the majority seem easily entranced by the "latest and greatest" especially in some areas of software; web development is the most prominent example to come to mind.
- sotojuan 10y agoMaybe it's because most of the apps or programs web developers make don't last more than a few years.
- Yxven 10y agoWeb development has the most innovation because it is the least entrenched. It is not hard to write a bare-bones web application that produces output that can be read on browsers everywhere. Compare that to the difficulty of writing a cross-platform GUI framework. It's not even easy to write bindings for existing GUIs because it's hard to wrap C++ in a way that doesn't have you manually managing memory or discarding other language features and philosophies. This is why we're seeing the Electron approach to GUI apps grow. It's easier to write bindings for chromium and feed it HTML.
- ianamartin 10y agoOh god, this. So much this. I'm dealing with it right now in a hardware migration. Local iron to AWS. There's so much magic that we can't effectively debug errors. The new system is extremely vanilla and it throws errors where you would want them to. The old system silently swallows them and creates invalid data. I'm not even talking about php or mysql. Magic is bad when it comes to replicability. I wish more people would take that into consideration when writing software. Your convenience for today is your headache for tomorrow. Be lazy. It's a good trait. But not too lazy.
- triplesec 10y agoReminds me of Arthur C Clarke's Into the Comet. Warning: Wiki article is mostly plot spoiler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Into_the_Comet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Into_the_Comet
- Someone 10y agoRemotely: zero Locally: if you distract the person making the calculations for a second, it's easy to move a bead or two. Insider: easier than a computerized system for individual computations. Imagine how easy it is to move a few beads incorrectly when computing taxes on your own income statement and how much work it would be to detect that.
- justanother 10y agoThis happens a lot more commonly than people might think. Not sure if this is still the case, but Florida DHSMV (motor vehicles department) used a Honeywell mainframe as recently as a few years ago, and the word around Disney World Ride & Show was that the parades in Magic Kingdom ran on a DEC PDP-10 as recently as the late 1990s and early 2000s. Both of these may no longer be true, but I haven't checked in awhile. Both of them might still be true...
- fma 10y agoThe only reason I do it is job security. I prefer to know a version of something inside and out, all the strengths and weaknesses. I don't want to spend the time to learn something new if the current tech stack suffices - it's a risk. I'd rather spend that time building something. But if I don't upgrade/rewrite every few years, and I need to find a new job, the interviewees will look at it and think I'm a dinosaur - despite the fact I follow the latest trends through blog's and podcasts. My company is slowly upgrading all our application servers because what we were running is way past EOL. The ops team bitches and moans because the newer one is more unstable. Go figure.
- sotojuan 10y agoYep. In a lot of parts of the industry, old and stable is seen as a negative by many. Maybe that's why people don't consider programming "engineering".
- kochthesecond 10y agoYeah, well. A lot of those systems does it's job very well. But now they want to access it's data and calculations on an iOS and browser app. Suddenly it becomes unusable or blocks productivity.
- intrasight 10y agoThere's plenty of work available in wrapping legacy systems with modern APIs
- kensai 10y agoThey are also probably unhackable by modern means.
- s_q_b 10y agoIn many ways, I'd rather eat a flaming ball of excrement than work with 1960s technology again, especially when the code was written by programmers in the USG. These systems are horrible kludges. They're like the crumbling ruins of an ancient Roman city beneath a metropolis, beautiful only for their history. It's a nice place to visit. But you wouldn't want to live there.
- Overtonwindow 10y agoHa! Bravo! That is some old software! This hunt has reminded me of The Cuckoos Egg by Clifford Stoll.
- chris_wot 10y agoOh, fantastic read. It read it again the other day and I suspect that Stohl got mixed up with the NSA but didn't enjoy it too much.
- contingencies 10y agoWhy?
- chris_wot 10y agoThey gave him short shrift, and he was a Berkeley man who was more at home at a Grateful Dead concert than tracking down overseas hackers. He only discovered the issue because he was trying to teach himself how to program, and decided to chase down a problem with a discrepancy on the timeshared server that was causing it to be out of balance by about 5 cents.
- Overtonwindow 10y agoCorrection: 75 cents ;-)
- chris_wot 10y agoI stand corrected :-)
- apaprocki 10y agoThe IRS itself goes into detail: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pia/imf_pia.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pia/imf_pia.pdf "IMF is located at the Enterprise Computing Center – Martinsburg (ECC-MTB) and resides on the MITS-21 GSS. IMF is written in Assembler Language Code (ALC). There are no direct users of IMF. IMF receives data from an array of systems and then sends data to several systems as well." MITS-21 GSS == "Modernized Information Technology Services (MITS)- 21, IBM Master File General Support System (GSS)" https://www.treasury.gov/tigta/auditreports/2011reports/201120074fr.pdf https://www.treasury.gov/tigta/auditreports/2011reports/2011... There are two mainframe systems, Unisys and IBM: "The Unisys mainframe at the Martinsburg Computing Center processes all of the centralized Individual Taxpayer Information File workload for the 10 IRS campuses. The Unisys mainframe at the Memphis Computing Center processes all of the centralized Business Taxpayer Information File workload for the 10 campuses. The Unisys mainframe at the Martinsburg Computing Center is configured to run with 950 MIPS for normal weekday processing. For weekend processing, the Unisys mainframe at the Martinsburg Computing Center borrows MIPS from the development and test environments to increase capacity to 1,200 MIPS for managing the increased workload. The borrowed MIPS are returned to their respective systems on Monday mornings to support weekday processing. The Unisys mainframe at the Memphis Computing Center is configured to run with 675 MIPS for normal weekday processing." "In October 2010, the IRS upgraded its Martinsburg Computing Center mainframe computers from the IBM z/9-series mainframes to the IBM z/196-series mainframes." The report even provides nice utilization graphs.. Your government at work. edit: The type of Unisys systems "The IRS Unisys mainframe environment contains two Dorado 280 mainframe computers, with one located at the Martinsburg Computing Center and one at the Memphis Computing Center. Because vendor hardware support will be discontinued as of December 31, 2011, the IRS has decided to upgrade the Dorado 280s to Dorado 780s during Fiscal Year 2011."
- quasse 10y agoFor anyone else who was curious, an Intel i5 2500k runs at about 83,000 MIPS compared to the 1,200 of the entire IRS Mainframe.
- microcolonel 10y ago
- unsignedqword 10y agoThe article mentions that the oldest actual computer in use by the government regards nuclear strike operations, and that it's actually being upgraded sometimes next year. I find this...concerning? Says they're upgrading terminals and data storage, which seems pretty harmless, but I feel like in terms of nuke-launching tech, "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" is a pretty good philosophy to live by.
- KC8ZKF 10y agoHow do you know it ain't broke?
- unsignedqword 10y agoTrue, but I'd at least regard such a system as likely fairly fault tolerant, considering its been in use for 50+ years.
- subway 10y agoI'm sure plenty of replacement parts of EOL by decades. Heck, the terminal upgrades alone are likely necessitated by the fact CRTs are no longer manufactured in quantity.
- omegaham 10y agoI was running into this doing requisitions for a precision approach radar that was commissioned in the late 60s. By this point, all of the part suppliers had long since moved on to other things or gone out of business, and the usual avenue became "Order the part, and wait for enough air stations to also need the same part. Then, and only then, will the government commission a custom fabrication job to manufacture the parts needed for an obscene amount of money." Two results happened. First, we ended up paying $15k for parts that were worth $500 because that's what it costs to set up a fabrication job when you only want 50 circuit boards. Second, we did whatever the hell we could to avoid having to spend $15k on a $500 part, and the radar was therefore held together with gummy bears, duct tape, and black magic. It was a clusterfuck, and we were always putting out fires with that thing, sometimes literally. Horrifyingly, the military has never been able to create a better PAR, which is why it's been around for so damn long. I got out in 2014, and last I've heard, they just re-extended the EOL for the radar to 2025. They'll probably be sending out lance corporals with binoculars and walkie-talkies to yell "TOO HIGH" and "TOO LOW" by then.
- valleyer 10y agoThe DOD one ("Strategic Automated Command and Control System") claims to be 53 years old and run on a Series/1. But Series/1 first came out in 1976, 40 years ago. Anyone understand the discrepancy?
- steanne 10y ago"We did indeed find the oldest computer in government, but it’s not really a computer at all; it’s computer software."
- valleyer 10y agoExcept... I read that sentence as referring to the IRS systems, not the DOD system. Am I wrong? It's confusingly written.
- walrus01 10y agoIBM mainframes have virtualized their predecessor hardware for a long time for backwards compatibility with locked in enterprise customers. It might be something 53 years old running on hardware from 1977.
- emersonrsantos 10y agoIt's not difficult to find those systems in the government and some big companies. Adding logic to some some source code that was last modified in 1985 and recompile it 30 years later is magical.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoIndeed. The Norwegian IRS equivalent still publishes updated Cobol programs that businesses can use to calculate employee taxes: http://www.skatteetaten.no/en/Bedrift-og-organisasjon/Drive-bedrift/Arbeidsgiver/employers-order-electronic-tax-deduction-cards/Documentation-and-program-for-calculating-prepayment-deductions-2014-and-2015-income-years/ http://www.skatteetaten.no/en/Bedrift-og-organisasjon/Drive-...
- chris_wot 10y agoSounds like the cheapest way of upgrading hardware for the IRS is to write an emulator that can understand IMF assembler and stick it in a virtualised environment. Given the server it is running on is now underpowered, a medium sized server could handle what it does at a fraction of the cost.
- kalleboo 10y agoThe article says it's already running on modern IBM mainframes. > "While they’ve upgraded the hardware to more modern IBM mainframes, those mainframes are still running vintage assembly." This is one reason IBM is still popular - their modern mainframes are backwards-compatible with 50-year old software. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_System_z https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_System_z > The System z family maintains full backward compatibility. In effect, current systems are the direct, lineal descendants of System/360, announced in 1964, and the System/370 from the 1970s. Many applications written for these systems can still run unmodified on the newest System z over five decades later
- Spooky23 10y agoIts all about cost and rish. These are bespoke systems that were written decades ago -- the entire operations of the agencies were organized around the abilities of the system. In the 60s, there was a clear ROI, the money spent zapped an army of clerks. Standing up a new system is high cost, high risk, and brings low measurable benefit.
- musgrove 10y agoAnd they're still using it with admin as the username and password as the password.
- ComputerGuru 10y ago*that we know of. (So this isn't a garbage comment: I imagine somewhere deep in Mt Cheyenne and elsewhere there are some even older milspec machines that have been running archaic code since mainframes were first invented.)
- dendory 10y agoIn the short term, there's always a lot more risks in scraping an old system and spinning up a new one, especially in large complex organizations. However, in the long term you're really better off with modern systems. So it really is a difficult trade off.
- amelius 10y agoHow does this machine compare to a modern cellphone?
- soneil 10y agoThat's actually a very difficult comparison to make, because your expectations of them are so entirely different. Will your phone: * Still be useful in 5 years * Still be functioning in 10 years * Still be receiving vendor support in 50 years The actual "wow, my phone is faster than a 5-year-old desktop" makes fun headlines, but is entirely irrelevant.
- amelius 10y agoIf governments insisted that all hardware should come with a spec that runs on a universal virtual machine, then today I could probably run the old machine on my phone. But alas, thanks again to an unvisionary government, we're stuck with old hardware.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoIBM i software was compiled as platform independent binary and converted into machine specific code by the operating system. Ok, it's a propietary spec far from being open etc, but the tech is there and even better than a vm (in certain aspects)
- peter303 10y agoProbably why the core IRS systems have not been hacked yet because few hackers know IBM 360, COBOL and 9 track tapes. New peripheral systems like the transcript request system have been hacked.
- teh_klev 10y agoPrevious similar discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11772966 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11772966
- dahart 10y ago> We did indeed find the oldest computer in government, but it’s not really a computer at all; it’s computer software. What a complete disappointment! I was hoping to read about some crazy legacy hardware they were still using. Software?! Yeah... no, that does not count as the oldest computer in government. In general, does a software's age alone really give any cause for concern? In my book, software that survives 56 years is proved solid. Software that is new is guaranteed to have bugs. > I’m starting to have a lot of questions about this tax software and the management around it. This does seem like muck-raking by a non-expert with little to no real context... Is that what Muckrock does? This software was audited, presumably by experts, and people looking directly at it acknowledge it's hard to maintain and still conclude there's no immediate need to replace it. What evidence is there that this conclusion is in dire need of re-examination?