6 ms·
Aren't CP laws set so that it doesn't really matter if you did it, the possession by itself is a crime, no need to prove intent?
by PeterisP 10y ago
Aren't CP laws set so that it doesn't really matter if you did it, the possession by itself is a crime, no need to prove intent?
- Arnt 10y agoThere are 50-60 parents in any given class. A fair number of them can be expected to make trouble no matter what the police does.
- toomanybeersies 10y agoYes, and every image is a separate charge. Because think of the children. Possession and distribution of child pornography is perfectly legal if you're the FBI though.
- jsjohnst 10y agoThere's a further nuance there as well. Say you work for a site that accepts UGC images (like a major social network for example). It's required that you have a team who works with law enforcement to handle investigations / takedown / preservation. Anyone who works for said team unfortunately thus has to see those images and have them, at least temporarily, on their machine, but there is zero legal precedent to protect them. It's a legal grey area and thus I have and continue to recommend anyone in such position to refuse to risk it.
- wbl 10y agoYou have the defense of "we are specifically required by law enforcement to do this" which is pretty strong. It's no different from a locksmith being asked by a cop to break into someplace the cop needs to be.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoI think the psychological trauma would be a much bigger concern for most than some vague legal threat.
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoThis was my thinking as well. On a huge social networking site I would imagine this comes up an awful lot and to have to see those types of images along with other abuses has got to be difficult. I'm also curious if you see enough of them how it changes your mind and if there have been any studies on it. Fortunately I know you can integrate with that hashing project (I forget what it's called) where they generate a hash for known images of child porn so those can at least be removed automatically but I don't know how much of a percentage that catches.
- jsjohnst 10y agoIt's called PhotoDNA.
- omginternets 10y ago>Yes, and every image is a separate charge. Each video frame is a separate charge...
- thecatspaw 10y agoHang on, just to clarify: if someone else puts a file on my PC without my knowledge, without me ever having seen or opened it, he could call the police on me, and it would get me convicted?
- lutusp 10y ago> Hang on, just to clarify: if someone else puts a file on my PC without my knowledge, without me ever having seen or opened it, he could call the police on me, and it would get me convicted? Yes. In such a case, a presumption of innocence would be true in theory but of no value at all in practice. Such an attack could even be carried out remotely -- an attacker could compromise a machine remotely, then plant incriminating evidence on the compromised machine (i.e. child porn, terrorist literature, drug-dealing evidence, etc.), then alert the authorities. This plausible scenario is another reason to vigorously protect one's computer against external attacks.
- ErrantX 10y agoI won't say that it doesn't happen (bad outliers always exist); however it would be very unlikely you'd be convicted for it. A few years ago when I worked in computer forensics there was this big myth that if you went on porn websites and one of the images was underage you'd get done for it. However intent is a big part of law and so there would always have to be something along with "just an image" showing some intent to have obtained and viewed it.
- nikanj 10y agoThere was a person in Finland mass scraping the alt. newsgroups for porn, and they got some cp on their machine inadvertently. Conviction, publicity and a ruined life promptly followed.
- grecy 10y agoIf someone else put 10 kilograms of cocaine in your house without your knowledge, without you ever having seeing or opened it, he could call the police on you and you would get convicted.
- 10y ago
- gadders 10y agoIn the UK, possession of Child Porn is a strict liability offence: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strict_liability_(criminal) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strict_liability_(criminal)
- DanBC 10y agoIs it? http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1978/37 http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1978/37 > 1 Indecent photographs of children. > (1)[F1Subject to sections 1A and 1B,] it is an offence for a person— > (a)to take, or permit to be taken [F2or to make], any indecent photograph [F2or pseudo-photograph] of a child F3. . .; or > (b)to distribute or show such indecent photographs [F4or pseudo-photographs]; or > (c)to have in his possession such indecent photographs [F4or pseudo-photographs], with a view to their being distributed or shown by himself or others; or > (d)to publish or cause to be published any advertisement likely to be understood as conveying that the advertiser distributes or shows such indecent photographs [F4or pseudo-photographs], or intends to do so. [...] > 4)Where a person is charged with an offence under subsection (1)(b) or (c), it shall be a defence for him to prove— > (a)that he had a legitimate reason for distributing or showing the photographs [F6or pseudo-photographs] or (as the case may be) having them in his possession; or > (b)that he had not himself seen the photographs [F6or pseudo-photographs] and did not know, nor had any cause to suspect, them to be indecent. There are some amendments in the Sexual Offences Act 2003, but I don't think they turn it into a strict liability offence.
- ErrantX 10y agoThat's not true. The wording of the act's relevant to CP specifically say things like "knowingly" which is well-ruled to mean Mens Rea is required. Real-life sexual offences, as in actually attacking a child, is strict liability.
- gadders 10y agoI stand corrected.
- Iv 10y agoCP laws in most countries are insane, because every politician knows what it would take to defend against reinforcing the anti-CP arsenal.