10 ms·
How Bad Off Is Oil-Rich Venezuela? It’s Buying U.S. Oil
- k_sh 10y ago> Oil accounts for half of the Venezuelan government’s revenues ...Who thought that was a good idea?
- pweissbrod 10y agoThose that own the oil fields
- jcoffland 10y agoThe state owns the fields.
- jessaustin 10y agoThen GP's explanation makes even more sense. Why would the state treat all enterprises fairly, when its interests are concentrated in particular industries?
- Analemma_ 10y agoNobody, but the Resource Curse seems to be one of those iron laws that happens inexorably even if people are aware of it (cf. principal-agent problems pushing prices upward), unless very determined action is taken to avoid it (like Norway), and that kind of action wasn't going to happen under Chavez.
- ars 10y ago> unless very determined action is taken to avoid it (like Norway) Norway is not immune. It's the current popular thing to say, but Norway will fall victim to it just like everyone else does. Look at some charts on their exports: 60%+ is energy. Look at their industry: Basically non-existent, except energy. Look at where young people are making their living: Energy. If (when?) the oil runs out (or people stop buying it) their economy will implode - the fund they setup will not last long enough (they have enough for about 10-20 years). No one is developing skills in any other fields, it will take a generation or more to transition, and in the meantime everyone depends on charity (i.e. the fund) - and that's toxic to any economy because people become used to it. So what you wrote about "Iron Law" is correct without the qualifier you added for Norway.
- milcron 10y agoStill, they're certainly doing better than many other oil-rich nations.
- ars 10y agoThat's true, but it's not exactly a high bar. They gets lots of credit for being aware of the problem, but less credit for thinking they are doing better than they actually are. It's too bad oil will be worth less eventually - otherwise they could just force themself to leave it in the ground, but the way things are going they had best convert it to cash as soon as possible. It makes me wonder if it's economically long-term better for them to pretend not to have oil and develop their economy, vs. selling the oil. Long term, which will give them more total cash?
- marcoperaza 10y agoUnder Chavez and his successor Maduro, Venezuela has pursued a socialist policy. I'm talking about straight up nationalization of industries, wealth confiscation, and such. The result was economic catastrophe, capital flight, and brain drain. Venezuela is basically hollowed out. It's not that they aren't taxing everyone else, it's that there is very little profitable industry left but oil. They turned one of the richest countries in the region into a rapidly deteriorating third-world hell hole.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoSocialists. I really was getting tired of hearing from the usual anti-US types on how wonderful Venezuela was back in the early 2000s and how Chavez stands up to the US and such, meanwhile it was led by what was pretty much a strongman with socialist policies and industry nationalization that quickly destroyed their wealthy oil-rich country. Now we're selling them oil so they don't starve in the streets. Curious to see how well Putin, the CCP, Assad, Khomeini, and other heroes of the anti-US left and their respective countries hold up in a decade or two. Considering sites like HN and Reddit are full of the anti-US left, so its almost impossible to have this conversation, but I'm glad to know that Chavez is gone and things are probably going to get fixed there as Maduro loses influence. On top of Cuba slowly drifting away from autocratic authoritarian communism due to normalizing relations with the US. I hope the anti-US left can see some wisdom in getting communists and socialists out of power and putting in a democratic process thats open to all those who want to participate in free markets and protecting property rights, speech, and human rights in those countries. Downvote away.
- tptacek 10y agoEveryone sees their own ideological nemeses in the HN user base, which is both a sign that things are working well, and a reason for us all to avoid ideologically-charged political discussions as much as we can. I promise, the "anti-US left" sees HN as stuffed to the gills full of US apologists as well.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoMy comment is tagged with 'flagged' and set to the lowest score. Obviously these forums lean young and college students which subscribe generally to College identity politics which is very far left. Meanwhile, extremely low effort posts of "Shut up, Socialism works, there's nothing to see here," are voted up uncritically. Tell me again how these forums aren't biased?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- conistonwater 10y ago> Early this year, the United States began shipping more than 50,000 barrels a day of the light crude that Venezuela needs to prepare its own oil for export What does this mean? How does this work? Why do you need oil to make oil?
- tptacek 10y agoThis is addressed in the article: the oil industry in Venezuela is in disarray, so the country can't rely on its own supply. They have enormous reserves, but they can't reliably draw from it or refine it.
- jondubois 10y agoThey should just lease out licenses to allow foreign companies to draw the oil themselves and use the proceeds to fix their own oil infrastructure. They have so many options to chose from to fix their economy. It seems like they don't have the will to fix anything. I wouldn't be surprised if there is some sort of corruption going on. The leaders of the country seem to be intentionally draining the money out of the country (and personally profiting from this).
- PeterisP 10y agoIt's not that easy to motivate foreign companies to invest lots of money, equipment and effort (opportunity cost vs using the same things in other oil fields) after you've recently nationalized their previous investment. Trust is slow to build and fast to lose, they're now facing direct consequences of their earlier actions, and a reversal would likely come only after a regime change.
- tptacek 10y agoVenezuela's oil industry is nationalized.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoI think jondubois's proposal was to de-nationalize it.
- marcoperaza 10y agoThe wonders of socialism.
- danharaj 10y agoWhen people use Venezuela to criticize socialism, they always compare it to the most powerful, developed capitalist countries of the world. Look how poor and dysfunctional the failed state of Venezuela is compared to a capitalist country like the United States! When you compare Venezuela to those of its neighbors who are completely submitted to international capital and empire, capitalism doesn't seem so glamorous either.
- jdminhbg 10y agoIts neighbors seem pretty glamorous to Venezuelans, who pour by the tens of thousands into Colombia to buy basic groceries when the border is opened.
- marketanarchist 10y agoEven in comparison to their neighbors, they are doing poorly no? I think the best indicator would be how people are voting with their feet. Are people fleeing from Venezuela to its neighbors or the other way around?
- santiagogo 10y agoThe frontier was closed off for nearly over a year, but when last reopened nearly 132,000 people crossed on the first day. It's hard to know how many are just crossing over to buy groceries and how many will stay, but I read that the Colombian government estimates that roughly some 500,000 Venezuelans will illegally immigrate to Colombia during the next year, which is a worrisome number. As a Colombian I've personally seen how they've been clearly voting with their feet for the last 10 years, since they have no opportunities and are afraid of protesting against a government that kills and persecutes the opposition. http://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias-america-latina-36817172 http://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias-america-latina-36817172
- 10y ago
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoVenezuela is a failed state at this point. I'm more than happy to personally take them as an example of why spending big on social programs doesn't produce long-lasting social benefits. I understand many people will find a point of disagreement here. This is especially true when corruption is rife. In countries with high corruption, it seems the very best thing to do is to limit as much as possible how much money flows from the top, which is another way of saying limit federal government spending.
- joshred 10y agoYeah, but what about the other states that spend on social programs and ended up successful? This is like throwing out a carton of eggs because one of them broke.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoHaving social programs and being a Socialist government are two very different things. We can have Social Security here in the States and not be Socialist. Nordic "socialism" is just taxing the rich to give to the poor. What Venezuela did was textbook Socialism which, like Communism, is a path to economic, social, and political failure as well as massive human rights violations.
- currysoup_t 10y agoI think you'll find textbook socialism are very different to what you think socialism and communism are. Do the workers in Venezuela own the means of production?
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoI think you'll find it easy to play up No True Scotsman to help with your cognitive dissonance here. The reality is that every practical implementation of socialism uses the government as a proxy of ownership of the means of production. Venezuela is Socialist. Socialists need to own up to it. No more No True Scotsman guys, we've been playing this game since the rise of Communism. Its time to admit that certain economic systems just don't work. How much more historical proof and human suffering can you possibly need? You sound like those people who deny the moon landing. There will never be enough proof for you it seems.
- binarray2000 10y agoWhy can't they just ask other more friendly countries (Russia, Norway, maybe China) for the expertise in exchange for oil? Should be an easy solution, or am I missing something in my oversimplification? (And, please, don't blame it on communism/socialism; people have interests and I believe so do people in Venezuela - including those working in the government.)
- civilian 10y agoI'm gonna blame it on communism. It's not that they don't know how to produce oil. It's that the oil company has been so heavily mismanaged and used for political purposes that it has become extremely inefficient. http://www.economist.com/news/americas/21607824-venezuelas-loss-thousands-oil-workers-has-been-other-countries-gain-brain-haemorrhage http://www.economist.com/news/americas/21607824-venezuelas-l... > IN 2003 Venezuela’s then president, Hugo Chávez, fired more than 18,000 employees, almost half the workforce, of the state-run oil corporation, Petróleos de Venezuela (PDVSA). Their offence was to have taken part in a strike (pictured) called in protest at the politicisation of the company. Their punishment was to be barred from jobs not only in PDVSA itself but also in any company doing business with the oil firm. The axe fell heavily on managers and technicians: around 80% of the staff at Intevep, PDVSA’s research arm, are thought to have joined the strike. At the stroke of a pen, Venezuela lost its oil intelligentsia. Obviously, this wouldn't have happened in a free market. But even other state-run oil companies haven't made this kind of blunder.
- metaphorm 10y agoyour answer is on target but you're wrong to "blame it on communism." that has nothing to do with communism or any other abstract theory of political economy. that is an explicit example of incompetent authoritarian rule by an unhinged despot with no checks on his power.
- zeveb 10y ago> that is an explicit example of incompetent authoritarian rule by an unhinged despot with no checks on his power … Communism!
- tim333 10y agoYou wonder how long Maduro will hang in there. With him gone they could return to somewhat sane economic policies.
- adventured 10y agoI keep wondering if Venezuela won't end up somewhat copying Argentina and politically moving away from the numerous failed policies of the Chavez era.
- iKenshu 10y agoAs Venezuelan I hope no. I think everything that can happen with the opposition can't be worse.
- MrZongle2 10y agoWith him gone they could return to somewhat sane economic policies. Not necessarily. Somewhere there's somebody with some political leverage thinking that the solution is simply more socialism. Not the bad, failed socialism that Maduro ran, but actual socialism, run by smart people! Because this time things will be different!
- cobbzilla 10y agoCurious American asking any Venezuelans out there: how does this situation get any better? What do you look to for hope? I'm not familiar with the Venezuelan media perspective (any non-state-affiliated stations left?), but from here, it seems like there is no serious effort to change course; on the contrary Maduro seems to be driving ahead with the notion that, somehow, more of the poison will cure the patient. When does the change in direction come? What brings it on? Will Maduro step down? Will his successor do any better? Or will his successor be even more dictatorial? It's all very worrisome, my heart goes out to those who live under such incompetent rule.
- rdiddly 10y agoYes, living in the USA does make one sympathetic to other nations living under state-controlled media, with an incompetent government obdurately dragging everyone down a self-destructive and delusional path.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoYes, here in the US we get corporate-controlled media with their own delusional and destructive agendas.
- kilroy123 10y agoNot a Venezuelan, but I've talked to a few Venezuelans in person, recently, about this. (Down in Latin America) They seem to feel very hopeless, and don't expect any change, any time soon. I ask why they don't do anything about it. They seem to think, there is nothing they can do.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThe price of oil increases. Or Venezuela discovers it's sitting on vast undiscovered reserves of Unicorn Poop. What we're seeing is, IMO, far less the Evuls of Socialisum than the end-game of an oil state. There's a similar story playing out through much of the Arab world, as you may have noticed over the past few years.
- jimmywanger 10y agoCurrency controls and price controls and government nationalization have destroyed Venezuela. Currency controls: there's a 1:10 exchange rate, dollars to bolivars, for essential imports, like food, medicine, etc. The black market exchange rate is about 1:1010. To get the good rate, you need connections. But hey, it's a pain in the ass to actually contact suppliers and get goods through customs, and you're capped at what price you can sell goods at, so what you do is actually exchange 10 bolivars for a dollar, and turn around and exchange that dollar for 1000 bolivars on the black market. You keep doing that until either you have way too much money or you lose the preferred exchange rate. Price controls: No country is an island these days. No matter what good it is, you need external imports. For instance, if you're making beer, you might need to import hops or barley (true story, look up Polar in Venezuela). With the currency controls, you can't get hard foreign currency to pay your suppliers. And they sure as heck aren't going to accept your debased currency as payment. So your factories sit idle, because you just can't get supplies for production, and then the government nationalizes your factory because you're "sabotaging production". Government nationalization: The goal of the government is ideological purity. If you're not producing goods for sale at artifically low prices (sometimes the sale price is below the cost of production), the government swoops in, calls you an enemy of the revolution, and replaces all the skilled people who are ideologically impure, such as managers, with party hacks who have no idea what they're doing. That's why Venezuela oil production is in the toilet. The Nordic version of "socialism" simply involves taxing the rich and giving subsidies to the poor. They don't try to dictate prices or control means of production or fiddle with the exchange rate. The authoritarian socialism Venezuela is using right now has failed in every instance it has been tried.
- optimuspaul 10y agoI'm not sure that's how the black market works. I don't think I can exchange dollars for bolivars. That sounds like a losing proposition for the black market.
- jimmywanger 10y agoI'm pretty sure that's how the black market works. Why do you think otherwise? If you were on the black market, you'd LOVE to exchange bolivars for dollars. The inflation rate is over 700% I think this year, and it's only going up. Why wouldn't you want something that's almost guaranteed to be valuable, instead of holding on to a rapidly depreciating asset?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- alphydan 10y agoHow Bad Off Is Oil-Rich USA? It’s Buying oil from all over the world! in 2015, the USA imported 9,400,000 barrels every day from 82 countries (Mostly from Canada, Saudi Arabia and ... surprise, surprise from Venezuela). Now the NYT thinks that Venezuela importing 50,000 barrels of light crude (to dilute their heavy crude) is news? They forgot to mention that last year the US imported 830,000 barrels from Venezuela (the third largest supplier to the US). If you read the actual import/export numbers [0], you will understand that it's just a political submarine article. The reason Venezuelan oil production is declining is a pretty complex phenomenon (driven mostly by Geology and exacerbated by mismanagement, brain drain, corruption, etc). [0] http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=727&t=6 http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=727&t=6
- abysmallyideal 10y agoThe US is hot on the plan to burn all of the world's fossil fuels and natural gasses before anyone else does. Some old strategy from ww2. Edit: my android autocorrect is altering my posts
- alphydan 10y agoI'm afraid there is no such plan. US production has been declining since the 70s in spite of all attempts to keep it going. Only with the >$100/barrel prices from the last few years did fracking become viable and production recover (Tight oil's growth in the US is not expected to last very long though).
- kilroy123 10y agoWhat I don't understand is, how the hell are the leaders still in power? Why aren't people taking drastic action against this failed government? If people are literally not eating food, that's typically when there's a revolution. If I couldn't eat everyday and feed my family, I'd be out in the streets. Why not? You have nothing to lose at that point.
- DefaultUserHN 10y ago>Why aren't people taking drastic action against this failed government? They don't have the 2nd Amendment.
- bpolania 10y agoVenezuela doesn't have a 2nd amendment, but the lack of guns is certainly not the reason, if anything is the excess of guns in the street, what people in America don't understand is that the government will always be better armed than the population, Syria is a good example. What keeps totalitarian governments is will to power, how much os the government willing to risk against the population. Owning a gun is not the same as being willing to die.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThere are some crucial points missing from and/or obscured in this story. Yes, Venezuelay has run some massive social benefit programmes, including subsidising many standard goods, mosts especially fuel and food (both of which, on reflection are fuels), for years. So has virtually every other oil state. The situation in Venezuela devolves in large part, though not entirely exclusively, from: 1. The globally depressed petroleum market. After massive price spikes in the late 2000s, increased extraction, mostly from very highly-financed unconventional wells, and an ongoing global economic recession, have caused oil prices to fall. 2. The highly-financed well operators, much as Venezuela, have the problem of high fixed costs, mostly debts, which must be serviced in order to avoid bankruptcy. This creates a perverse incentive to increase supply as price falls. Since these operators have high marginal costs, their profits are also lower to start with. 3. Venezuela's oil reserves, among the largest in the world, have always been less desireable than West Texas or Persian Gulf oil, both of which are "light sweet crude" -- comprised largely of smaller hydrocarbons, and low in contaminants, especially sulfer. Saudi crude flows like syrup, Venezuelan more like molassas on a cold day. Venezuela previously had more light and medium crude oil, but production of these has fallen by 37% since 2004 (Reuters, below). 4. Much of recent US domestic oil supply has been of NGL (natural gas liquids) and condensate -- very light fractions of hydrocarbons, some of which are only very barely not gaseous at normal temperatures. (This is also, incidentally, why oil train wrecks and fires have been so volatile -- the lighter fractions of oil are exceptionally volatile and burn explosively.) Much of this supply is not suitable for use in transport fuels. You cannot produce petrol, kerosene/jet fuel, or diesel from them, and the US has been (quietly) looking for ways to export this anyway. See this Wall Street Journal article from June, 2014: http://blogs.wsj.com/corporate-intelligence/2014/06/25/what-is-condensate-introducing-americas-new-oil-export/ http://blogs.wsj.com/corporate-intelligence/2014/06/25/what-... Oil industry critics have argued that counting condensate/NGL in US crude oil extraction statistics isn't defensible. http://oilprice.com/Energy/Energy-General/The-Condensate-Con-How-Real-Is-The-Oil-Glut.html http://oilprice.com/Energy/Energy-General/The-Condensate-Con... Exports of condensate began only in 2014 following regulatory rule changes: http://fuelfix.com/blog/2014/06/24/feds-open-door-to-condensate-exports/ http://fuelfix.com/blog/2014/06/24/feds-open-door-to-condens... 5. Venezuela is using the US imports as dilutants for its heavy oil. I suggested this in an earlier reply, and confirmed the fact in a Reuters artice: Each barrel extracted from the Orinoco belt needs some kind of diluent to be transported and exported. Naphtha is typically used to transport crude to the upgraders, but when these facilities are not fully working or are under maintenance lighter crudes are needed to formulate blends for exports. http://www.reuters.com/article/us-oil-venezuela-imports-factbox-idUSKBN0IG17Q20141027 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-oil-venezuela-imports-fact... Venezuela previously imported distillates from Nigeria in the 1990s. 6. As the NY Times article does manage to mention, Venezuela faces large debt and financing obligations to multiple creditors, including China, and several US firms, including Halliburton. As with several previous Venezuela stories on HN, there's been a swarm of comments attacking the Venezuelan government and political systems. At best, those criticisms tell only a part of the story, and quite possibly a minor part.