10 ms·
Dear Al-Jazeera: thank you for doing the right thing
- oh_sigh 10y agoWas this a marketing win? Scroll telling got their name out there, but al Jazeera response was that they apologized and switched over to the free/open source equivalent to their product.
- evan_ 10y agoSeems like a one-time marketing win in the form of a couple blog posts, and also they chased away what must be one of their largest and most visible users.
- StavrosK 10y ago"Al Jazeera used our code without permission, so we made them switch over to a competitor, showing everyone how trivially interchangeable we are, and we're telling you about it!"
- smacktoward 10y agoIt's marketing pushed so far it becomes its own opposite. Bizarro Marketing. Anti-marketing.
- sparky_ 10y agoStreisand Marketing (TM).
- h1d 10y agoIt's really funny people blame the source of concern if some third party finds about it but laughs at the victim when they make the claim themselves.
- StavrosK 10y agoI'm not blaming scrollytelling for making the claim, I'm blaming them for making Al Jazeera switch to a different tool, rather than asking them for a testimonial and some credit on the article page, which would have been much better marketing. Scrollytelling would have written much the same post, except "AJ was using us in an article without their knowledge, we asked them to credit us, they did, and gave us this awesome testimonial as well".
- sqeaky 10y agoThis alerted to one the existence of one of the companies. This is a data point for good behavior for each company. In the future if I need either of the companies products, I might consider them. I guess that is a win, but then again I am not likely customer in the first place.
- AndyNemmity 10y agoIt wasn't good behavior for each company though. Scrollytelling really rubbed their noses in it, and almost seemed to take some level of joy at repeating back their ethics statements like a college newspaper would. All that tells me is, you can never trust doing business with scrollytelling.
- sqeaky 10y agoPer posts yesterday Scrolly said they tried to notify them by email and were met with silence. This is probably a bad point for AJ, then Scrolly did what they could and published. Per the discussions here yesterday Scrolly hadn't included that in its first draft. Once alerted by this bigger publicity AJ fixed their stuff and responded professionally. There are several faults here, on both sides. But much can be attributed to the simple mistake that people make when trying to get work done. There was clearly no conspiracy, No one intentionally hurt anyone, no one had to take it all the way to way, and I don't remember any unreasonable threats of legal action. This could have been much worse and I have personally dealt with much less reasonable companies trying to screw me harder.
- AndyNemmity 10y agoI don't believe there was a conspiracy, or that anyone was intentionally hurting someone. Scrolly assumed bad faith in their initial post. "In other words, our code had been stolen, by you." Then they got ahold of the person who caused this mess, and he said he would resolve the situation. "We contacted the author of the piece, Hidde Boersma, who told us he sold his piece to you. This is fine. Our source code however was not included in the sale, nor could it have been. Hidde promised to resolve the situation." Then they contacted AJ, who didn't respond back quickly. They had no relationship with Scrolly, and it's not unreasonable that this didn't get taken care of. Hidde was their man. "In order to clarify any potential confusion on your side, here is what we were confronted with." Dramatic language. "In the long run, it’s likely to have been a lot more expensive to have a developer copy our code, copy the assets and put these on a server. The links not only had to have been updated by hand, inside the document, but someone would have had to un-optimize our JavaScript code, and do all the other work that allows the production to be somewhat available. They didn't even do a good job. They did not rip many images, leading to a bad experience for your readers:" Just being dickish, to the party that wasn't aware of Hidde's issue. "To add insult to injury, you didn’t do a great job at ripping the code either." More dickishness. "Al-Jazeera, we know you understand all about journalistic integrity. You have a whole section of your website dedicated to it. The first point states:" This is college newspaper level lame writing. You'd almost expect it to have read, Webster's dictionary defines "ethics" as.... I'll stop now, but I don't see two parties coming out of this looking professional and reasonable, just one.
- hiou 10y agoI certainly wouldn't use a product that could run the risk of having my company publicly attacked by a vendor. I find it hard to believe anyone else is going to take that risk with scrollytelling.io either.
- AndyNemmity 10y agoExactly my feeling, you would never do business with anyone who would act this way in public. The risk is far too great that you trivially upset them, and they go on a similar crusade against you.
- spotman 10y agoWith all the kerfuffle, I would not have imagined it would be so easy to replace. So, after poking around, it looks like pageflow is the actual creators of this stuff, and scrollytelling, has built a business around supporting it and hosting it? While concurrently, it appears pageflow can also be paid to support and host their own product? Weirdly, pageflow appears cheaper too! Am I missing something? Would this be equivalent of someone opening up a competitor to wordpress.com, powered by wordpress?
- PakG1 10y agoI work for an organization that actually purchases a hosted product that fits this exact description literally. Can't stop laughing. :)
- octaveguin 10y agoThere was quite a common scam a while ago about selling open office. It actually was completely legal because they were (in the fine print) selling support - the software was free, of course. A lot of bigger companies sell support for OSS products they don't build. This can be legitimate. It just depends on how forthright you are with who built what.
- lmm 10y agoThey don't have to sell support. One is allowed to sell open-source software. (One of course has to comply with any relevant license requirements when distributing).
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoRight. Copyleft licenses (the GPL and the like) only require you keep software free as in freedom, not as in beer. You can sell the software just fine, so long as you provide the source. And non-copyleft licenses let you do whatever you want. You can take non-copyleft open-source software, add your proprietary junk and sell it at a killing, if you want. You don't even have to provide the source.
- 10y ago
- shortformblog 10y agoThey downplay it, but this situation was exactly what I said it was the other day: AJ syndicated a piece from another outlet with whom they had an agreement, and they understandably thought that the layout was part of the deal. Ultimately, it sounds like someone screwed up and used a tool they shouldn't have to build the layout. (That tool being Scrollytelling.) The lesson here, apparently, is that if you're syndicating content, open-source tools are best.
- frankydp 10y agoYeah this outcome should ensure that no outlet will publish with the proprietary platform again, and that there are controls in place to ensure that it is not available for that to happen. The "guilty" party in this scenario also seems to be EJC for not properly licensing the original content. Edit: It also seem very reasonable to think that AJ thought scrollytelling was simply a host of the opensource resource, and removed all links backs except the CDN file that was obfuscated.
- frankydp 10y agoAfter looking at scrollytelling.io, I am now even more confused about their claim. Their pricing model is based on hosting, with bandwidth and upload limits. Along side that monthly hosting service they offer a one off service for "in-house production" of a story. So. Their model is to collect the production fee for a one off or let the user "produce" the story and profit from the volume savings on hosting. I can not determine how in either model having the story that has already been paid for hosted remotely would be not a good thing, unless there is a license were somehow scrollytelling retains the ownership of the product they were paid to produce. I am not sure why they would want to bare the cost of an AJ level distributed, if they are a hosting company. But, if they are a content creation firm maybe they are not actually creating content for the purchaser, but allowing the purchaser to use scrollytelling content, which the purchaser already owned? Edit: In short I don't understand why the purchaser would not be able to redistribute. Anyways, I have no idea how the model works inside its industry context, and if I am confused even with the current context provided by the OP, I can not imagine that a journalist would not be.
- wfn 10y agoMaybe next time just email them before issuing a DMCA request, and assume charitable behaviour before evidence dictates otherwise? edit I was wrong, see below.
- syntheticnature 10y agoPer the previous article linked at the top, they tried that: https://www.scrollytelling.io/al-jazeera.html https://www.scrollytelling.io/al-jazeera.html "In addition we contacted you directly too. After waiting patiently we received no response. After many tries through your editorial office we got hold of an editor who promised to return our call. This never happened either. As a final measure we sent you a DMCA takedown request and waited patiently. No response."
- wfn 10y agoAh, thanks for that, my bad; you're right. Oh well - glad this ended up being resolved in a friendly fashion, then.
- syntheticnature 10y agoIt did require going one beyond the linked article to be truly sure they had done so, though there was a hint in the mention of "diplomatic solutions."
- oceliker 10y agoThe original version of the article said "Initially we were taken aback and confused. We knew there must be some mistake, so we quickly sent you a DMCA takedown requests and waited patiently." They "clarified" it after a while, but if someone read the original version of the article and did not see the update, it could be easy to miss.
- gknoy 10y ago> [W]e quickly sent you a DMCA takedown requests and waited patiently That makes it sound like the DMCA takedown was the first response -- I'm surprised that a gently worded e-mail wasn't tried first. "Hey guys, it looks like you are using this ... I'm sure it was unintentional, but .... "
- echelon 10y agoThis seems way more embarrassing to storytelling.io. The only take aways I have are how easy it is to switch to a free, open source alternative, and how loudly and publicly storytelling will complain about you. They should have handled this matter in private instead of blogging about it.
- AndyNemmity 10y agoAbsolutely. They handled it like they took joy in catching someone out publicly, and really tried to rub their nose in it. The end result is, I now know there is an open source alternative, and if the need were to arise would use it.
- danso 10y agoThis felt like a completely pyrrhic victory. Not only did they expose how unnecessary their own product was, but they exposed how unprofessional of a shop they were by leveling accusations over Twitter [0]. I'll take scrollytelling at their word that they were doing this to take a stand for software copyright. Sure, I can respect that. But if you're fighting for a world where SaaS/PaaS developers are properly paid and valued, the most convincing victories are when developers (particularly ones that depend on open-source) and such platforms attract loyal, deep-pocketed clients who show everyone else that such a business can be viable. This isn't like the case when The Oatmeal burned the HuffPo [1] for hotlinking. The Oatmeal presumably doesn't survive by syndicating to places like Huffpo. But clients who are somewhat unskilled at web production/hosting are the sole source of potential customers for ScrollyTelling, and ScrollyTelling demonstrated that it would rather burn them than mediate technical fuckups. [0] https://twitter.com/Scrollytellio/status/769971459263459328 https://twitter.com/Scrollytellio/status/769971459263459328 [1] https://www.theguardian.com/media/2015/oct/28/cartoonist-the-oatmeal-trolls-huffpo-over-images-published-sans-permission https://www.theguardian.com/media/2015/oct/28/cartoonist-the... edit: fixed typo in Oatmeal/Huffpo
- pyre 10y ago> ScrollyTelling demonstrated that it would rather burn them than mediate technical fuckups. From what I understand, they tried contacting them directly, but were given lots of promised callbacks / actions that never materialized. Is your opinion that the "professional" way to handle that just to ignore it and move on?
- kofejnik 10y agooh well thanks for telling me about pageflow
- oneloop 10y agoThey even took the motto. Pageflow - Interactive Storytelling
- vachi 10y agoi dont think its fair to accuse and scold scrollytelling. On their homepage they have a tech section where they state: "Our software is built on top of the Open Source version of Pageflow. We are committed to giving back to the community, which is why we are active contributors, and have open sourced our software too." and they have put a lot of their software up on github. Yes, this is very similar to Wordpress companies. However it is still their source code, and scrollytelling's webpages are better... dare i say.
- tilsammans 10y agoThank you! :)
- the_duke 10y agoI don't really understand the negativity towards scrolytelling in other comments here. They are providing a hosting service and product, based on Pageflow. Which is mentioned right on it's homepage! They contacted Al Jazeera directly and were brushed off (can easily happen in a large company, doesn't imply malice). The page would probably never have been taken down without the media coverage. And said coverage might have informed some devs about Pageflow, but it's also good publicity. People often forget that one actually has to make money too. If you do that based on an open source product without violating any licenses, and even contribute back, why not? They have every right to shame companies using their product without paying for it.
- hasenj 10y agoWhen I read their original story about AJ stealing their code, I thought they basically custom built the entire thing. Now I learned it was actually open source, and in my head I'm like .. lol that must be embarrassing!
- tilsammans 10y agoWe're not embarrassed, and the_duke's comment is spot on. It's not a secret we're built on Pageflow and I am the #5 overall contributor to it. We exist thanks to Pageflow and will do everything to promote it. We've referred many leads to pageflow.io. There's plenty of room for both models to happily exist!
- hasenj 10y agoMaybe include this sort of clarification in the blog post?
- bricestacey 10y agoFor anyone else that doesn't know what it means to come in fifth place: 786 commits by the lead developer, then 58, 46, 34, and finally 24 by yours truly. https://github.com/codevise/pageflow/graphs/contributors https://github.com/codevise/pageflow/graphs/contributors
- jimktrains2 10y ago> rewrote the publication in record time using the regular open source Pageflow (on which Scrollytelling is built). I'm lost. Why wouldn't they then take this chance to tell me why I should pay for them if I was in the market for heavy, non-free javascript?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chunkyslink 10y agoAl-Jazeera along with the Guardian are the most honest mainstream news outlets on the planet. Put American journalism to shame.
- pbarnes_1 10y agoI would never use this company's services after this.
- yaur 10y ago> We did notice you took some creative license and manually removed our copyright notices and replaced them with your own looking at the story that was copied[1] I don't see a copyright notice anywhere. What gives? [1] https://verhalen.volkskrant.nl/anti-armoe-aubergine#2220 https://verhalen.volkskrant.nl/anti-armoe-aubergine#2220
- nxzero 10y agoOpen Source Version referenced by AJ: https://github.com/codevise/pageflow https://github.com/codevise/pageflow Given this is in fact the source code that the developer in question has admitted was the basis for their code, it would be interesting to know if they were correctly using the MIT License here: https://github.com/codevise/pageflow/blob/master/MIT-LICENSE https://github.com/codevise/pageflow/blob/master/MIT-LICENSE
- elberto34 10y agomaybe all of this was planned in advance ...maybe just a big PR stunt that worked brilliantly. I hope the NYT steals the code from my website. I could use the pR