22 ms·
Western Digital unveiled its SanDisk 1TB SDXC card prototype
- overcast 10y agoI'm looking forward to the stories of people actually filling these things, and then losing/corrupting them. I think that is waaaaay too large for the size/speed of SD.
- gmazza 10y agoDesigned-for use-case for an SD card is a buffer where a photo/video camera will save footage sequentially, then you copy everything to your PC/laptop and reformat the card. When used as a generic storage with a complex write/delete/overwrite pattern, most card would start corrupting data fairly quickly.
- overcast 10y agoI understand its use case. Now imagine you're on location shooting, and you're fumbling around with tiny SD cards. It wouldn't be the first time I've dropped one. Even compact flash I try not to put TOO much work on one before I switch them over. To say that every consumer is going to use it only as a temporary medium, I think is overly optimistic.
- cptskippy 10y agoI think part of the appeal of high capacity cards is that you spend less time fumbling with cards. A 1TB card would probably last an entire day of shooting HD video. As an amateur photographer, I generally keep 2 extra SD cards on hand but they're backups and not used. I don't think I've ever filled up the 64GB card that I shoot with and at the end of the day I move off what was shot. If I'm shooting on vacation I'll generally leave a copy of the images on the card so that I have 2 copies floating around but I've yet to fill up the card. This card probably isn't targeting the consumer market. I think smartphone cameras have cannibalized much of the Point-and-Shoot camera and PVR market. That being said, I think most consumers purchase one SD card when they buy their camera and it's the only card that camera ever sees.
- eropple 10y agoI get what you're saying, and it is a concern, but there is a decent argument (to me, anyway) that with 1TB you probably won't be taking the card out to be fumbling with it in the first place. Even with on-location shooting, "I filled up a 1TB card, I need to archive it" is probably a good reason for a lunch break.
- overcast 10y agoNo one in their right mind would fill a 1TB card before swapping. That's an insane amount of potential lost. I could see it as a secondary backup disk in DSLR about it.
- colejohnson66 10y agoNot that you're wrong, but [citation needed]. Mainly because you use a microSD card to boot the Raspberry Pi. Also, in my Yearbook class in high school, we almost never formatted(?) our cards. Granted, they were only 32 GB or less to avoid SDXC, but still.
- cptskippy 10y agoWhy were you avoiding SDXC? Was it a technical deficiency in SDXC or limitation in your hhardware?
- rocky1138 10y agoI'm not the parent, but SDXC on my Raspberry Pi causes kernel panics after ~6 hours of operation. It's entirely annoying.
- colejohnson66 10y agoAre you formatted as exFAT? Because it's my understanding that Windows will refuse to format an SDXC as anything but.
- rocky1138 10y agoI believe it was ext3 or ext4, but I'd have to look.
- colejohnson66 10y agoWe did have a few cameras that supported SDXC, but the majority didnt. It was easier to just use SDHC and not have to worry about what card works in what camera. Besides, 32 GB was plenty because we almost never shot in RAW (high schoolers aren't professionals); I think only me and 3 others knew about working with RAW. So to answer your question, space wasn't a premium, and because of the technical and human limitations of SDHC vs SDXC. I'm sure some of those cameras had firmware updates that would add SDXC support, but we didn't need it.
- 10y ago
- throwaway7767 10y agoI'm excited about this to upgrade my old hard-drive iPod. Replacing the hard drive with an SD card should increase battery life considerably, and this is more than 8x larger than the hard drive it came with. If it dies, I lose no data since it's just a copy of my music library. And the speed doesn't matter since I only need to sync things once and from there it's just incremental additions. The reason I consider this is that there don't seem to be any decent music players with large capacity, as everyone moved their music playing to their phones.
- pronoiac 10y agoI've delved into flash on iPods, though I haven't taken the plunge yet. You might want to look at https://www.iflash.xyz https://www.iflash.xyz - there are adapters for multiple sd and micro sd cards, resulting in ridiculously large volumes. I think RAM limits the total number of songs supported, is the next bottleneck.
- throwaway7767 10y agoI've seen those adapters, but I'd prefer to use only one SD card and a simple (read: less likely to have weird edge-cases) adapter. But I haven't taken the plunge myself either, mainly because high-capacity SD cards are still pretty expensive. I think RAM will be less of an issue for me since I run Rockbox[0] on the iPod. No need to keep the whole database in memory there. I like everything about the iPod except the software (pretty much the same as other apple products :) [0] http://www.rockbox.org/ http://www.rockbox.org/
- imaginenore 10y agoThat's why many professional (and some prosumer) cameras have dual slots and allow you to write to both.
- overcast 10y agoCorrect, and expecting most people to actually do that. Not happening.
- soylentcola 10y agoYep. My several-years-old prosumer Nikon (D7000) has two slots and I can configure them either as mirrored for redundancy, overflow in case I misjudge how much storage I need, or I can use one for RAW and one for JPEG in case I need to show a preview before I get a chance to process the RAWs. Typically I just have it set as mirrored since I only shoot occasionally as a hobbyist and a corrupted card is the most likely "fail state" I'd encounter.
- penguat 10y agoI use my second slot for JPG, reasoning that I can get good enough results out of a JPG if I desperately need it - and the cheaper, slower, bigger card I put in the backup slot will hold a couple of days' shooting as JPG and not slow the camera down.
- rocky1138 10y agoWith HD video capture and other such uses, sure. But what about when we're capturing 8K video in a few years?
- gmazza 10y agoI wonder how well would it perform when used in place of laptop's system disk (i.e. with tons of small files and very random read/write access patterns).
- mkj 10y agoAbysmally
- throwaway7767 10y agoUnfortunately, this has been my experience with all SD cards I've tried. Even ones sold as high-performance are just annoyingly slow to use as a root FS. They also seem to be extremely unreliable when used with even a modest write load, often failing within a year.
- eropple 10y agoAs a root FS, agreed. As an expansion, I have had really good luck with the 256GB microSD card in a low-profile SD adapter on my MBP. When I'm doing screencasts or whatever, I happily dump my recordings out to it and, as silly as it is, it's one of my favorite pieces of tech right now.
- T0T0R0 10y agoOn the other hand, what if you paired it with an Apple Watch running Windows 95?
- agumonkey 10y agoWhat's the seek time ? I use tiny usb keys as live image source, even as stateful system half the time, and it's a bit touchy. When the cache gets full, the kernel will get stuck in very long syncing mode, so much systemd starts to complain. On non recent (say 2013) usb keys, it will even trigger kernel error messages and lockups.
- throwaway7767 10y agoFTA: > The 1TB card is certain to be prohibitively expensive, and at such a large capacity, read and write speeds are going to be comparatively slow Why would a larger card be slower? Wouldn't it be faster since it can write more flash cells in parallel? Larger SSDs are usually a bit faster due to this.
- jshevek 10y agoI didn't take the quoted text as a suggestion that the drive would be slower in any absolute terms. 'Comparatively' can be an ambiguous term - compared to what?
- throwaway7767 10y agoI read it to mean compared to smaller SD cards, which is also the only reasonable comparison here. I just re-read it and I actually can't see what else it could be referring to.
- fencepost 10y agoAnother poster referred to this, but the most obvious reason for slow speed is intentional throttling due to thermal concerns. It might actually have to be simply capped at an "always-safe" write speed due to limitations on the circuitry - is there room in an SD card format for adequate thermal sensors and the logic to limit write speed as the card heats up?
- T0T0R0 10y agoOh god, we're talking about overclocking SD cards? I can't wait to see experimental results not only in general, but also in edge case scenarios like when encountering counterfeit hardware.
- fencepost 10y agoDiscussion doesn't seem to be really widespread, but particularly with the M.2 / PCIe SSDs you actually do get some thermal throttling. Here's a review of the Samsung SM951 where in just over 2 minutes of sequential write testing the card reached a throttle temperature of 82C and throughput dropped from 1500MB/s to 70MB/s (http://www.legitreviews.com/samsung-sm951-512gb-m-2-pcie-ssd-review_161689/3 http://www.legitreviews.com/samsung-sm951-512gb-m-2-pcie-ssd...). I'd call that a noticeable dropoff in speed. Yes, I realize that article is talking about SSDs not SD cards. The relevant difference here is that the SSD is substantially larger with likely better heat dissipation. Of course, the maximum bus speed of SD cards right now (including the UHS-II hardware change to add additional contacts) is only ~300MB/s, with a more practical top speed of ~150MB/s to allow both reading and writing. Maximum power consumption of UHS-II SDXC cards is 2.88W, which is actually fairly significant when you consider the volume of the cards - it's not a lot of power, but it's also not a lot of thermal mass.
- Ezhik 10y agoBut it doesn't.. https://i.imgur.com/XlcJYf2.png https://i.imgur.com/XlcJYf2.png
- jacquesm 10y agoActually, it does. 1TB > 250G in that particular case. This is one of the reasons I opted for a slower but much larger drive in my day-to-day work laptop.
- Jedd 10y agoNot really. One of the nice things about the Inspiron 3800 (and doubtless a few other models) is physical capacity for both a 2.5" SSD and an mSATA ... so you really can wander around with 2TB internal non-spinning disk. (Good for bragging rights, but an expensive option.)
- Ezhik 10y agoDefinitely, that's why I love my T420 (got OS X on that). A nice SSD for the OS and other important stuff + a big HDD to put all the data on is still the best option, in my opinion.
- kabdib 10y agoIts performance is going to be glacial. Example: I have a 1.2 TB Fusion I/O flash drive on my workstation; it gets about 2 GByte / second sustained, and it has heat sinks and extra power connectors for a reason. Extrapolate down to a dinky piece of plastic that has about the same amount of storage; trade-offs were made. And you should look really, really hard at retention when it is not powered (do the bits leak away, past recovery by ECC, when it's been on the shelf for six months?) Also look at reliability (transaction-nature) when it experiences unplanned ejects or power loss.
- gambiting 10y agoSDXC U3 cards can easily write at 90MB/s, which is obviously nowhere near 2GB/s of a fusion drive, but it's definitely good enough for recording 4K video and taking large pictures - which is what this card is going to be used for. No one expects it to replace your SSD.
- hengheng 10y agoWorth noting that rarely any 2.5" HDD is faster than 100 MByte/s at 100 iops. This SD card could well come near that.
- cm2187 10y agoI wish but I am yet to see an SD card exceeding 10MB/s in practice.
- gambiting 10y agoKingston UHS3 gets over 90MB/s in sequential read/write, and over 10MB/s in random read/write: http://www.storagereview.com/kingston_sdhc_sdxc_uhsi_u3_review http://www.storagereview.com/kingston_sdhc_sdxc_uhsi_u3_revi...
- bluedino 10y agoWhat device and card are you using? The MacBook Pro will do 90/40 http://images.anandtech.com/reviews/mac/retinaMacBookPro/quickbenchrMBP.jpg http://images.anandtech.com/reviews/mac/retinaMacBookPro/qui...
- andrewclunn 10y agoWith portable storage like that, I really could use a computer sans the internal disk.
- agumonkey 10y agoWith on the fly encrypted rolling core OS fetched from the network.
- pmontra 10y agoEvery single SD card I plugged into my laptop was slow, even the cat 10 ones. They also tend to fail faster than the HDDs (per hour of usage) so I'm not sure that I want to put all my eggs into a 1 TB SD basket. However 1 TB is plenty of recording time: it should be OK if you can back it up regularly. By the way, my laptop has a 1TB Samsung EVO 850 now, plus the original 750 GB HDD and its 32 GB SSD cache, which I keep shut down. They contain the OS (SSD) and data (HDD) prior to the upgrade. I should format and reuse them. The HDD could be handy for seldom used files and given the amount of RAM (16 GB) wasn't that slow. Or I just buy another TB SSD, handy for working with docker containers, VMs and the like, and leaving overprovisioned space on the SSD.
- frou_dh 10y ago> Every single SD card I plugged into my laptop was slow, even the cat 10 ones. Could be that the interfacing chip in the computer is low-end and bottlenecks them. That has been my experience with some ThinkPads.
- cloudjacker 10y agoEggs in the basket? How do you guys use sd cards? I never keep anything on them for long, I can imagine folks that only have a tablet might neglect moving photos off their cameras
- flukus 10y ago16GB Should be enough for anybody - Google Nexus Team.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoExcept that the Nexus 6P came in 32/64/128 GB configurations and the Nexus 5P came in 16/32 GB configurations.
- flukus 10y agoIt took them until late 2013, and they still don't allow SD cards do they? They also don't allow their apps to be moved to SD, which is especially aggravating for the crappy apps you can't uninstall on phones with small built in drives.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoAnd it's now almost 2017 when Apple just made 32GB the minimum storage for their iPhone 7.
- xbmcuser 10y agoAnd google is going to announce its new phones on 4th oct. If they are still 16gb then you have a point. With the new android update system where the phone has 2 system partitions and load the updated version on rebooting the phone means they will need more space anyway.
- Dylan16807 10y ago2GB is more than enough for a system partition. You can fit two into a 16GB phone. The only real consideration is app and media size, and google's historically been on the low end of that.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- peterburkimsher 10y agoI think that this is the first storage device to use the 10nm silicon process. The same dies will be used to make 512GB microSD cards. Perhaps someone from SanDisk can confirm?
- mrb 10y agoAFAIK there are zero sources reporting SanDisk uses 10nm for this SD card.
- voltagex_ 10y agoHas anyone got any info on the long term reliability of SD cards? Could they be used for archival for 10+ years? What about 100?
- tw04 10y agoFlash storage in general is very poor for long-term storage. Current leakage occurs and if they're just sitting on a shelf there's no way for them to self-correct. Your best bet is still tape or optical (think bluray) media.
- ekianjo 10y agoany recommendation for tape recording devices these days, that will be still supported 10 years from now ?
- taeric 10y agoI would think you could get basic support for any device from Linux. Question is really, why not offshore the device support to someone else entirely? Hosted backups are likely at least as reliable as anything you can do. Right?
- apaprocki 10y agoI restored my 22 year old BBS off Colorado QIC tapes by jury rigging an old mini-ATX board with a floppy tape drive and installing Win98 on it. They read perfectly. Of course you can always pay someone to dump the data for you, but where's the fun in that?! I think any off the shelf modern tape will be just fine in 10 years.
- agumonkey 10y agoHa, just tried to read a Colorado tape backup from 98 (tape might be from 96 even, HP T1000 drive) and it ran like a charm. I didn't even realize it was an 18 yo storage until reading your comment. Even at floppy speed, copying the 400MB wasn't that long, and it's lovely to hear the cute drive noise (for retro lovers).
- gruez 10y agoSerious question: why is this considered innovative? 256 GB micro sd cards are widely available[1], and are less than a quarter of the size of sd cards (by area). Surely they can take a 256GB micro sd card's die, copy paste it 4 times, and end up with a 1 TB SD card? [1] https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01G7L03OS https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01G7L03OS
- jl6 10y agoInnovation doesn't mean breakthrough. Also, innovation isn't just having the idea. Innovation is actually doing it.
- jomohke 10y agoI think it's being treated as noteworthy due to reaching a milestone. It doesn't feel very long ago that we hit 1GB. Edit: after a quick Google search: "Jan 29, 2004 - Sandisk ships world's first production 1GB SD card"
- feelix 10y agoYou generally can't just stick separate chunks of flash memory together to make one big one, because the controller is the limiting factor. Having a chip being able to manage large amounts of flash memory (having to have its own memory for the allocation tables, wear leveling, and so forth) is where it gets tricky.
- creshal 10y agoBut we've had 1+ TB flash controllers in SSDs for several years, too.
- feelix 10y agoYes, and they're disproportionately more expensive (ie more than twice the price of 2 500GB's) because of the aforementioned issues. It's also the bottleneck in having say 5TB SSD's that are just 20 smaller ones stuck together, because you could cram them into a 3.5 inch enclosure.
- dang 10y agoUrl changed from http://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2016/9/20/12986234/biggest-sd-card-1-terabyte-sandisk http://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2016/9/20/12986234/bi..., which points to this. None of the tech website articles on the story seem to add any info over the press release, so we might as well link to that. This topic excited a lot of interest earlier today and set off HN's flamewar detector (more like an overheated discussion detector). That was too bad, so we've rolled back the clock on the original post and merged in the comments that were posted to a duplicate thread.
- a3n 10y ago> SanDisk's 1TB SD card has more storage than your laptop If you take the HDD out of your laptop, the HDD has more storage than your laptop. If you put it back in and use it, then it doesn't have more storage than your laptop. If you put a 1TB SD card into your laptop and use it, then it doesn't have more storage than your laptop.
- pkaye 10y agoThis brings back my memories (maybe 12 years ago) developing the 1GB CompactFlash card firmware at a previous job. That amount of capacity felt unbelievably huge at that time. Infact the first cards I worked on had only 4MB capacity!
- vidarh 10y ago> (maybe 12 years ago) I've observed in the past that storage capacity per drive/media seems to grow at around roughly three magnitudes per decade. I'm looking forward to my 1PB SD card equivalent in the late 2020's.
- jbverschoor 10y agoThat's nice and all, but I've had to trow away too many SD cards. Was happy to pay Apple the extra cash for a 512GB ssd.
- rikkus 10y agoMy personal laptop has a 256GB SSD as OS/apps drive. I treat this as expendable. I have replaced the DVD drive with a 1TB SSHD. This is my 'storage' drive. There's a directory with stuff I need to keep, which is all on Dropbox and backed up to CrashPlan. The rest is just 'cache' (e.g. music files I can easily replace). Looking at newer laptops, there's no DVD drive any more, so I'm waiting for 1TB SD cards (at a reasonable price) so I can have my 'storage' drive. This is great news for me, though I may have to wait some time for prices to be reasonable.
- pstrateman 10y agoNo it doesn't.
- tunichtgut 10y ago"SanDisk's 1TB SD card has more storage than your laptop". It does not. Just saying.
- fao_ 10y agoMy laptop has 1.5tb of space. You don't know my life!
- creshal 10y ago2TB notebook HDDs and SSDs are available, step up your game.
- dharma1 10y agoWhat's the write speed on these things? Need much faster than current SD card write speed, for 4K Raw and faster FPS video
- everyone 10y agoTitle is not going to be right very often.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoEr, my laptop actually has a 1TB SSD. Am I missing something?