6 ms·
The Server At Peak X86
- AstroJetson 10y agoI disagree with the article author and at the end of the super long article, so does IDC. For the big workloads, x86 systems are going to be on top for the next years. Yes ARM is making strides, but it will take time before the move into data centers at any significant rate. The trend lines from the IDC charts show continued growth, 5-6% growth is pretty decent as you remember manufacturing costs continue to drop.
- thr0waway1239 10y agoCan you give a little summary of why the article thinks it is peak x86 for those of us who are not very familiar with this field?
- AstroJetson 10y agoIt appears that he draws most of his conclusions based on what Gartner thinks is going on. Gartner thinks that the next generation of ARM is going to be a huge winner. It take a long time to get traction in the big server marketplace, he thinks it will be sooner. ARM has some spiffy stuff, but it's not what the big data centers are looking for. There is posts about the Apple CPUs that are out. Nice stuff and if I was building a phone, it would be one of my top choices. But if I'm doing data center then I'm going to want something more general purpose. If I have 6 cores in a chip and they are all the same I can load them up. If I have CPU and GPU cores then I have to move tasks around. If I move to ARM from Intel then I have the added task of trying to optimize my load/task to the new CPU. Granted compilers are a key driver, but lots of people have spent lots of time hand tweaking Intel CPU loads. 22 cores running at 2.2GHz in a single socket is pretty amazing. Haven't seen any ARM72's anywhere near that big. You might see some movement in this area, but the way companies are gobbling big servers, we are not at peak Intel. Hope that helps.
- thr0waway1239 10y agoThanks. I got most of it :-)
- ansible 10y ago22 cores running at 2.2GHz in a single socket is pretty amazing. I'm still trying to wrap my brain around the idea that the processes running on this system aren't going to be memory bandwidth starved. Yes, I know the Xeons have gobs of cache in multiple levels, but still. And yes, I know that distributing tasks across multiple systems can have its own severe performance problems.
- pcwalton 10y ago> the way companies are gobbling big servers, we are not at peak Intel. I think the point is that you're pretty much by definition at the peak when your market share is 99.3%. There's nowhere to go.
- AstroJetson 10y agoBut the market keeps getting bigger and bigger. Unless we are using a different version of what "peak" means in this context. "The hypothetical point in time when the global production of x86 equipment reaches its maximum rate, after which production will gradually decline." is the one that I'm using. As long as the demand is up there, then production will continue to grow.
- bitwize 10y agoThe Apple A10 is trouncing lower-end Intel kit already. We may be looking at a future of client-side computing dominated by Apple; if they can get their shit in one sock cloud-wise they'll make dents in the server space too. Think Amazon AWS, but running Mac OS X server and fully integrated with OS X. Easy peasy deployment of your Rails app straight from your MBP dev box right to the cloud, with almost zero config management required.
- richardwhiuk 10y agoI doubt it. Apple has been systematically withdrawing from the server space for years, and I doubt they are particularly likely to reverse that trend. Servers are relatively low margin with a small brand impact. Apple plays well in consumer electronics where brand has much more of an impact on margin.
- astrodust 10y agoApple buys generic Intel kit for their datacentres, and did this even when making their own server product. Consuming your own output isn't good for margins, and like many large-scale providers, you must acknowledge vanity hardware isn't any faster than bare motherboards in a rack. The more bare-bones the better. The XServe and friends were intended for small-scale deployments. They did a few partnerships to build clusters of them for HPC but that was largely a demonstration, not a target customer base.
- kalleboo 10y agoThey may have the CPU chops but no way do they have the institutional ability to sell clients and servers to business. They can't even hold onto the educational market which they're losing to Google Chromebooks.
- acdha 10y ago> They may have the CPU chops but no way do they have the institutional ability to sell clients and servers to business. Proprietary hardware is a hard sale for anyone these days but in Apple's case it's even harder because their previous attempts left many shops with a disinclination to ever use them again. It'd take a serious commitment to forget the era where you had to beg for OS X Server bugfixes by saying they were preventing the purchase of n Macs.
- kalleboo 10y agoWhen this article talks about "Unix systems" as something seperate from X86, what does that mean? Itanium and... SPARC? (Assuming POWER comes under "IBM"?)
- ajdlinux 10y agoPower is a completely separate architecture and product line from "IBM mainframes" (i.e. System z), and "traditional" (i.e. AIX) IBM Power Systems products are generally considered "Unix systems". (Disclaimer: I work for IBM Power Systems, opinions my own)
- kalleboo 10y agoI'm not in the space at all, so from outside "Unix systems" seems like a very arbitrary label - since I'm assuming most of the X86 machines are running Linux or BSD which are very much Unix, I guess the "systems" part is where there is some specific definition
- bandrami 10y ago"Unix systems" is a kind of antiquated term for when the big iron vendors (IBM, Sun, HP, DEC, MIPS) sold large RISC systems with the hardware (Power, SPARC, pa-risc, Alpha, MIPS) as a loss leader for the proprietary UNIX (AIX, Solaris, HPUX, Tru64, RiscOS) running on them. Linux ate most of those proprietary unices, and now the economic logic (for the remaining survivors) is reversed: the money is in the hardware and in support.
- gaius 10y agoLinux is not Unix by the classic definition and never has been - see www.opengroup.org
- kalleboo 10y agoThanks for the correction, I assumed some of the commercial Linux distributions like Red Hat or whatever were Unix certified, but I was wrong http://www.opengroup.org/openbrand/register/ http://www.opengroup.org/openbrand/register/
- imtringued 10y agoSo why does AMD bet on Zen instead of creating their next ARM SoC? The A1100 is pretty good on paper except the CPU but they released it two years too late and the availability still isn't great.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoAccording to the article, x86 constitutes 99.3% of the market. I think AMD would rather have a small piece of the 99.3% rather than a large piece of the 0.7%, even if that 0.7% grows dramatically.
- bluedino 10y agoGoogle has been quoted as stating if they could get a 20 percent power/performance advantage buy switching to IBM Power they would do so, even if it were only for a single generation. My question is, wouldn't this be possible with ARM?
- lallysingh 10y agoI don't think so. AFAIK, ARM performs well in computation/watt on the low end of computation. But you have to get above a certain performance level to amortize the power overhead of the rest of the computer (motherboard, ram, etc). But that's mostly a guess.
- jonstokes 10y agoThis comments thread is off-track. This is not yet another article about how ARM is poised to eat Intel's lunch, and that cites (worthless) Geekbench scores to make that claim. No, this was written by Timothy Prickett Morgan, who actually knows hardware. His basic argument, at least on my quick reading, is that right now, Intel's Xeon margins are insane -- some 50% -- and x86's market share is north of 99% in servers. Furthermore, Intel, Microsoft, and Red Hat are sucking up all of the margin in the stack, and leaving everyone else to fight for scraps. (We've seen this "Intel eats all the margin" movie before in the PC space, and I wrote about it here: https://techcrunch.com/2016/05/17/how-intel-missed-the-iphone-revolution/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/05/17/how-intel-missed-the-iphon...) So, these three things -- an x86 monoculture, crazy high margins, and three companies sucking up all the profits from the rest of the stack -- are both individually and collectively unsustainable. Morgan seems to be arguing that a rational market is going to take care of this arrangement one way or the other. By virtue of its margins and market dominance, Xeon has a massive target on its back, and there is a ton of ingenuity gunning for it. So at some point things will change. So no, this isn't yet another in a near-decade long string of "ARM vs. x86 as told by Geekbench, with a side of OMG Apple" articles. He's actually pointing out that, technical considerations aside, there is a set of market conditions currently prevailing that looks unsustainable on its face, and at some point, like when pressure builds up along a fault line and then gives way, there will be a big shift.
- AstroJetson 10y agoI agree that Intel margins are pretty high. But at 50% margins, when there is a shift, they can move the price point down some. I just re-read your article and it appears to be mostly about the mid->low power market (ie, Atoms from Intel) as an example. The Server article posted is about the high end Intel chips, the $4500 ones you find in servers. Your post is spot on about Intel in general, I think at the low ends we will start to see more shifts away from x86 at the desktop / laptop levels as other chipsets become faster / highly available. But I think in the server space, Intel has lots of running room left in the x86 space. Morgan is a very smart guy, but I think his reliance on Gartner may have pulled him off the mark.
- legulere 10y ago