17 ms·
Uber's billion-dollar losses expose the fragile state of the on-demand economy
- endswapper 10y agoThe post has a misleading headline. It doesn't expose anything and mostly just whines about Uber's valuation. If anything it underscores the challenges of disruption and the fluid nature of the on-demand services. It may even be a case for opportunity in the space because this seems to indicate that people want it, but no one has gotten it right, yet. I don't know if this is a conclusion or an indictment, "It’s increasingly obvious that Uber’s $69 billion valuation makes sense only in a world where it’s the only player in town—with workers who are either squeezed or replaced with robots." Either way, it's silly.
- fu9ar 10y agoDo you realize that Uber and Lyft drivers are often making below minimum wage when you account for their costs? The only way they are getting drivers is by offering fat bonuses to both parties for driver referrals. The entire business model is unsustainable and now Uber is hemorrhaging money because all of their drivers figure this out, drive enough to get a bonus and move on.
- jonknee 10y agoDo you realize that most Uber drivers aren't working it as a full time job? They're working when they have downtime and can make a few bucks.
- JonFish85 10y ago"Do you realize that most Uber drivers aren't working it as a full time job? They're working when they have downtime and can make a few bucks." Isn't the entire point of "minimum wage" because of thinking like this? Most people working at McDonalds making minimum wage aren't doing it full time either. The minimum wage laws are trying to enforce that a person's time is worth a minimum amount, regardless of the total number of hours worked.
- jonknee 10y agoBut they aren't employees...
- lovich 10y agoEven if that's the case, why would someone contract themselves out for less than minimum wage, when any low-effort job would be paying more than that? The answer is that they wouldn't, and thats why Uber, Lyft, and other competitors have to pay out the bonuses to these drivers
- jonknee 10y ago> Even if that's the case, why would someone contract themselves out for less than minimum wage, when any low-effort job would be paying more than that? Because other low effort jobs don't let you start and stop whenever you want? Because other low effort jobs don't take anyone with a car and clean record? Because lots of reasons.
- danso 10y agoYeah, this is key. I've had countless drivers who were unemployed, either by choice (retirement) or circumstance. A few do try to make it a full-time job. But there's plenty who see it as a stop-gap, something to do when you have time and energy to help make ends meet, and that you can stop at any time, which is important when you're in job-interviewing mode.
- stormbrew 10y agoYou could actually ask them instead of aimlessly speculating.
- mamon 10y agoNot all jobs are supposed to pay all your bills and mortgage. McDonalds and similar jobs are there for students and other people who want just part-time gigs paying some additional cash for their non-crucial expenses. Such jobs are supposed to be temporary, therefore there's no point in enforcing minimum wage for them.
- spectrum1234 10y agoSure but if Uber didn't exist how would these people be making money? Why would they work for Uber if there were better options? They can choose to work wherever they want but they can't choose to work for Uber if it doesn't exist... Honestly who is losing vs the alternative where the job to take isn't even an option?!?!
- parfe 10y agoUber's insane valuation hinges on growing from a cab service into a Dominoes competitor? A Peapod competitor? A Zipcar competitor? An Amazon competitor? All of them? It just seems so improbable that one company would capture every single market segment that falls under "Cell phone app to get things in near-real time"
- freyir 10y agoAs I see it, the only acceptable outcome for Uber at this point is gaining a huge lead in the establishment of an autonomous driving fleet. I don't see any way its current businesses (e.g. app-based taxi service, food delivery, etc.) justify its valuation. The question then is whether reliable fully-autonomous cars are 2 years out, 10 years out, or more; even the experts can't agree. Uber needs it more than Google needs it, more than Tesla, more than anybody.
- parfe 10y agoUber needs it, but so many companies began moving towards self driving cars as well. Is Uber even doing any in house research? Does Volvo need Uber? Volvo can just license the Dominoes app and have the same technology backbone Uber has, plus cheesy bread. Sidenote: I thought of another market segment to compete in: AirBNB! Except instead of daily rentals it'll be half-hourly rentals. Brilliant! Ignore those pesky anti-prostitution laws. They're outdated regulations that just stifle the market. Plenty of guys named John that just need a bed for 30 minutes or less.
- AJ007 10y agoIt hinges on them getting public transportation agreements locked down with cities before Google or Tesla do. Imagine a major city where 80%+ of the vehicles are run by a single company and the rest are paying a toll to be on the road. Uber doesn't appear to be any more overvalued than stocks and bonds, broadly. It may be a big gamble but so is buying $1 billion of bonds that yield .25%.
- JonFish85 10y ago
- allendoerfer 10y agoOr it just exposes Uber's strategy to throw money at the problem to capture the market first and solve details like legality or profitibility later. Which is kind of what you have to do when you have billions lying around and investors that expect you to multiply them.
- ethanbond 10y ago> Which is kind of what you have to do when you have billions lying around and investors that expect you to multiply them. Which is also part of their awful strategy that they didn't have to do.
- allendoerfer 10y agoWe cannot tell yet whether it was awful or not. As we all know, many of the really big ideas looked awful.
- M_Grey 10y agoI wonder if they just thought that when they had enough market share, they could pressure regulators into folding? That seems so shortsighted and unlikely though, I find it hard to credit the idea. I'm not sure what the alternative explanation is though.
- uptown 10y agoI believe part of their positioning is to become beloved by regulators. Become part of the routine of the politically elite in Washington, and you're more likely to have favorable laws passed. Whether they're able to scale this to less-friendly jurisdictions is an open question.
- M_Grey 10y agoThey certainly missed the mark in China at least.
- prewett 10y agoThat was inevitable. I don't think you can be a foreign company and become "beloved by regulators" in China. (There are some good reasons for China to favor Chinese business, but it would be nice if they were honest and acknowledged that, instead of pretending like everything is fair when it's not.)
- M_Grey 10y agoAgreed on all points, but the inevitability makes the years dropping of a billion USD seem even more insane.
- stale2002 10y agoBut, they DID pressure regulators into folding. I remember a time when cities left and right were trying to get Uber shut down. When the question of "will Uber be able to continue to run in NYC" was actually up in the air. Does this even happen now, anywhere in the US or Europe? Uber won the regulation fight.
- elmar 10y agoAnd when there is a swift to driveless cars the business model economics is totally diferent, Uber will have to spend billions on a fleet, drivers costs will be replaced by fleet costs.
- abvdasker 10y agoThis would be a best-case scenario for them. While personnel costs will stay the same or increase fleet maintenance costs will only decrease over time as driverless tech gets cheaper. If they get to the point where their dominant cost is maintenance of an autonomous driving fleet they will have won the competition for the future of transportation which is today in its infancy.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoI am reading the book "The Sharing Platform" right now and it has a lot of discussion of Uber. I have mixed feelings about Uber's business model: as an occasional user when I travel to large cities I think that Uber provides a great service inexpensively; as a business model, I find it disturbing that heavy investment is used to temporarily keep prices low. I suppose it is common to 'buy into a market' but in Uber's and some other platform companys' cases I think it is getting to extreme.
- readhn 10y agoif it looks like a duck, if it walks like a duck.... UBER is on its sure way to bankruptcy, the model is not sustainable.
- zigzigzag 10y agoUber is an example of what happens when central banks attempt to 'stimulate' the economy through misguided central planning. By forcing down interest rates and essentially moving spending from the future into the present, they're stimulating investment in general. But what they forget (or more likely, choose to ignore) is that investments can be just bad investments. Uber is a bad investment. There is no barrier to entry in ride sharing. Drivers can install multiple hailing apps. Riders can too. Building a real time ridesharing engine is not hard - I did it once as a prototype years ago but it was unfortunately in the pre-smartphone era and you had to find ride matches using your regular computer. So central banks print money in order to buy up safe investments. That forces institutional investors to pour their money into risky investments like venture capital firms. VC firms look around at a field with slim pickings but that torrent of money has to go somewhere, so it ends up being used to fight vast unsustainable price wars. And in the end people's savings that they will depend on in retirement don't end up invested in productive assets that'll yield ROI into the future .... their money ends up subsidising a 10 minute taxi ride and being lost forever. The people who run Uber may feel that they 'have' to do this otherwise their competitors would do so instead, but that just reinforces how hopeless the situation is: they know perfectly well that their main competitive advantage is illusory, or at best, is merely a result of better access to capital flows. All it'll take is a sustained set of interest rate hikes and the end of QE, and suddenly Uber will have to charge the real underlying market rates. How will it end?
- jonknee 10y ago> Uber is an example of what happens when central banks attempt to 'stimulate' the economy through misguided central planning. By forcing down interest rates and essentially moving spending from the future into the present, they're stimulating investment in general. But what they forget (or more likely, choose to ignore) is that investments can be just bad investments. How do you explain things like the .com boom when interest rates were "normal"? Uber has raised a lot of money, but it's a drop in the bucket in the world of global finance (and a very small drop at that!).
- zigzigzag 10y ago
- Pharylon 10y agoWhy does Uber keep keep getting called a "ride share" service? Passengers don't share the ride with other customers. The driver wasn't already going in that direction. It's just a simple transaction. I'm paying X dollars to someone to drive me to Y place. It's a cab with an app. Uber is "ride sharing" like hiring a carpenter is "hammer sharing."
- jonknee 10y agoBecause for tax reasons Uber wants to make it very clear they aren't the ones with the vehicles. You're using (sharing?) the driver's vehicle.
- vkou 10y agoMany taxi drivers own their vehicle. (If you can afford it, it's often more profitable to do so, then to rent the cab from your company.)
- akiselev 10y agoI don't believe the vast majority of taxi drivers own their vehicles because in most jurisdictions the cars are tied to a taxi medallion number and those are much more expensive. I.e. before Uber taxi medallions in NYC cost on the order of two to three hundred thousand dollars because of limited supply. More often than not, taxi cab owners have more than one medallion/car and rent those out to drivers. This was a great investment pre-ride sharing
- vkou 10y agoEven in NYC, some drivers would own their medallions - many of them banked on being able to sell them when they retire.
- ndirish1842 10y ago> Passengers don't share the ride with other customers. This is no longer true with Uber Pool and Lyft Line
- readhn 10y agoRIP Uber. 8/29/2016. posted by readhn 16 days ago on: Google Takes on Uber with New Ride-Share Service
- apatters 10y agoI think Uber's future hinges on two things: 1. Whether they figure out how to cut costs with driverless automation 2. If not, how many people will keep using them when fiscal discipline is inevitably imposed and prices go up. They are in a tough spot. Without driverless cars they are a commodity service in a market with low barriers to entry. But no one has yet pulled off the type of driverless they need - no actual human in the car who needs to get paid.
- JonFish85 10y agoAs much as people seem to think "driverless cars" are obviously Uber's future, it's a pretty monumental change to their business model. It seems that their model now is to own essentially nothing; drivers own the cars and are responsible for 100% of the upkeep/maintenance, costs of insuring, etc. If that changes, where does that leave Uber? Are they going to own the cars? If so, that's a tremendous capital investment, which is something they've specifically avoided as much as possible. If they don't, and they just remain a brand name, then it's likely that someone like Ford/GM/Toyota/whomever will eat their lunch if cars are just on-demand and self-driving. Uber offers very little in that world.
- nerfhammer 10y agoIt seems to be w.r.t. self-driving cars Ford et al will just offer "Fords on demand" etc and not need Uber. The self-driving car is the hard part, not the app. Network effects are a lot less of a barrier to entry if you don't need drivers.
- Animats 10y agoFrom the article: "The company is primarily engaged in buying a monopoly to justify its status as the highest valued start-up on the market." That's it in one line.
- zxcvvcxz 10y agoDon't people see that this is analogous to China's steel dumping? http://www.industryweek.com/global-economy/aisis-gibson-china-has-get-out-steel-business http://www.industryweek.com/global-economy/aisis-gibson-chin... Lower your prices, dump your product, try to bankrupt the competition, then as sole market leader raise your prices.
- aitn 10y agoA huge subsidy is the illusion drivers have of making more per hour as they extract equity from their vehicle. After about six months the reality of vehicle costs sets in but Uber can refresh with new drivers. Stupid newbie drivers will be depleted from market in a few years.
- realworldview 10y agoThe über economy may be disappointed to hear about the anticipated surge in home-based working and local property redevelopments to support family-friendly working ours and distances. Can't wait for über buses though.
- gt565k 10y agoLast I checked Uber poached like 40 staff members from Carnegie Mellon's robotics lab. http://www.wsj.com/articles/is-uber-a-friend-or-foe-of-carnegie-mellon-in-robotics-1433084582 http://www.wsj.com/articles/is-uber-a-friend-or-foe-of-carne... They have driverless cars out on the streets in Pittsburgh to gather data. How are they not innovating again?
- jonathanjaeger 10y agoFreakonomics covered Uber in one of their recent episodes and a study claimed that there was a consumer surplus, with people willing to pay 50-60% more for Uber than they were otherwise paying. Curious if it would actually play out that way if they had a monopoly AND raised prices that much. http://freakonomics.com/podcast/uber-economists-dream/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/uber-economists-dream/
- tn13 10y agoRide sharing is like airlines. Even thought the providers might make huge losses and little profits I think it serves a very legitimate and real need. It is here to stay. I only expect their shine to go down a bit. More opaque pricing, more penalties etc. etc.
- tn13 10y agoI think Uber has complicated what is a simple business. It connect Taxies and Riders. I have never understood Uber's insistence to build a back office around it. Why not just act as a platform and let all taxi companies, independent drives etc. use your cool shiny app ? Uber should have been more like Yelp. Something that connects rider and drivers while letting riders know what to expect. At the moment it is like Yelp that wants to run all the places listed on their website. Besides there is absolutely nothing Uber that might help them be a monopoly that a service like Google or Facebook is. Since they have made themselves a physical company they have exposed themselves to politics that will destroy them at least in some markets.
- rubicon33 10y agoAs someone who is extremely excited about the prospect of self driving cars, I have to say that I love the situation Uber is in. They're flush with cash, and on a timeline to innovate. They NEED a solution, and they need it soon. An autonomous vehicle is their ticket out of this mess, and they know it
- victor9000 10y agoIt's pretty funny to read this headline. I interviewed with them about 3 months ago for a Senior Engineer position. I aced all the design, coding and algorithm questions and then spent an hour brainstorming the ways that Uber can improve the quality of life in a city. The brainstorming question was super ambiguous, so I explored lots of different angles and kept the conversation pretty high-level. I was rejected because "We have a really high bar and we expect good problem solving at the business level". Really? You want Senior Engineers to implement business initiatives? Yeah, ok. I'll say this much, burning through a billion dollars doesn't sound like good problem solving at the business level to me.
- grapehut 10y agoWhen ever I read a post like this, I can't help but reflexively think that their interview process must be a pretty good filter. Going through your post history, I see only two years ago, you were asking: > my app will need account creation, a map, REST requests, and notifications. what's the fastest way to get from 0 to mvp? do I need to build a native app for every platform? can I get away with a web app? and a year later was Lead Engineer at a couple of startups
- victor9000 10y agoYes, this may come as a surprise to you but some people do research before jumping into a new tech stack. And since you seem to be concerned, I ended up using Cordova/Ionic.
- megablast 10y agoRight, sure. But these are pretty basic questions. Questions that you wouldn't expect a lead to be asking a few years hence. You understand that right?
- victor9000 10y agoI think you're assuming that informed individuals don't ask basic questions. Or maybe you're assuming that all engineers are up to speed on the latest in mobile development. Either way, you're certainly off the mark. Actually, I go through a similar thought process when starting a new project, even if it's something I'm completely familiar with. It's a part of validating your assumptions, so you're always working with the best tools for the task.
- jokoon 10y agoI was delighted to learn that Uber raising money means subsidizing their prices. Still wondering why nobody has created a geo localized, mobile version of Craigslist.
- naveen99 10y agoanybody use a cheuffer service for your car instead of uber ? http://www.bemydd.com/ http://www.bemydd.com/ https://idriveyourcar.com/ https://idriveyourcar.com/