14 ms·
Vancouver Tax on Empty Homes to Target Near-Zero Rental Supply
- tnli 10y agoSounds like a self-made problem with nimbys and inefficient planning for new housing.
- macspoofing 10y agoMaybe, but Vancouver doesn't have a lot place to grow.
- kitcar 10y agoThere has actually been a massive amount of high rise development - its just questionable if the "type" of high rise inventory coming online is inline with the type of places people want to love. The bigger issue is a non significant number of people are buying the new construction inventory as well as pre-existing inventory and not moving in / not renting them out...
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoThis is not like the Bay Area. Vancouver has grown upwards and increased density aggressively for the last 20 years. But the housing market in Toronto and Vancouver didn't go through a correction like the US did in 2008. Constantly low interest rates, high immigration rates, and high foreign investment has led to astronomical housing prices and an unaffordable market.
- Pxtl 10y agoTo be fair, there are a lot of areas of Vancouver holding on to suburbanity far longer than they should. When you have rail transit stops surrounded by low-density bungalows, you can tell NIMBYism is winning.
- adaml_623 10y agohttp://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/Buy_to_leave http://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/Buy_to_leave
- graeham 10y agoArguably, the main driver of the problem is foreign purchase of investment properties which aren't rented. Speculation drives this further, as lots of people have made high returns on a market that 'can only go up'. Nine students 'own' a combined $57M in vancouver property: http://www.news1130.com/2016/09/14/nine-students-own-57m-worth-of-vancouver-property/ http://www.news1130.com/2016/09/14/nine-students-own-57m-wor... Another point that is not often raised is the crazy increases are mainly in detached houses. Condos and attached properties have increased a lot, but not nearly as frothy as detached houses. Suggests the type of purchase that is driving the increases. http://www.news1130.com/2016/02/02/vancouver-house-price-new-record/ http://www.news1130.com/2016/02/02/vancouver-house-price-new...
- zo1 10y agoI must be missing some part of the equation here. How is it possible that these properties are not being rented out? Even if the price of the homes are over-inflated, the owners should still be able to get some extra money out of such a capital asset? Is there something that is tilting the balance the other way? I.e. Making renting out for some amount not worth it?
- mattm 10y agoOne possible reason is that house prices have gone up so much in the past few years that people can sell quickly and make a huge profit. If you have people renting, you can't just kick them out immediately if you want to sell. Renters would be a liability in this case.
- vkou 10y agoThis is nonsense. Have you been to Vancouver? It is adding new housing extremely aggressively. Anywhere you turn, you'll see a good dozen high-rises under construction. Five years ago, you'd have seen a different set of high-rises under construction. Five years before that, same story. Vancouver isn't San Francisco.
- mazatta 10y agoThat's quite true, but that development is only able to happen in very tiny bands of the city, and there is a cap on how tall new buildings can be. The vast majority is zoned for single family homes, and any kind of densification is resisted vigorously by existing property owners. E.g. http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/commercial-drive-tower-boffo-kettle-1.3656577 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/commercial-dr... There's no question Vancouver is building, but it is not building enough of the right kind of housing (i.e. rental, non-luxury, and > 1 bedroom units).
- nwah1 10y agoThe ability for people to speculate on rising land values basically ensures that a large portion of prime land will be underused, or held out of use entirely. If we shifted taxes away from production and onto land use in general, regardless of whether it is vacant or not, we would no longer see this underutilization of land, and also end the perverse incentives of taxes on productive activity.
- saiya-jin 10y agoi don't get that part about Airbnb rentals - those are probably as utilized as possible and are just different type of rental (or similar, depends on the choice of the owner)
- BrentOzar 10y agoThe owners may not be paying tax on the rental income, like if they're running it through a company. It's not just a tax on empty homes - it's an attempt to tax under-reporting AirBNB hosts. (Source: I'm just a guy wearing a tin foil hat)
- koolba 10y ago> The owners may not be paying tax on the rental income, like if they're running it through a company. It's sad that modern laws have to optimize for crap like this. > It's not just a tax on empty homes - it's an attempt to tax under-reporting AirBNB hosts. Which would also unfairly impact accurately reporting AirBnB hosts. Note that I don't actually think the tax itself is a bad idea. It's a clever way to get owners to live local and is a pretty smart as far as "Out of towner's tax"'s go.
- icebraining 10y agoWhy not ask Airbnb for the data? Around here, the city council decided to charge a tax on tourists and Airbnb has agreed to withhold and deliver it directly to them, so it seems like they're willing to cooperate with local governments.
- adaml_623 10y agoRenters are protected by various laws and regulations. These have been arrived at over many years to protect landlords and tenants to varying degrees. Airbnb properties side step laws governing hotels and laws governing rentals. And you can argue all you like from libertarian points of view about regulatory capture but Canada is pretty comfortable with consumer protection laws. I think the results are fairly easy to anticipate.
- serge2k 10y ago
- tacostakohashi 10y agoAs high as 2%? That doesn't seem nearly enough to have the desired effect. If you have an empty house, you've already decided to pay a "tax" in the form of lost potential rent, not to mention actual property taxes and maintenance, and and an extra 2% isn't going to make huge difference. Maybe 10% would be more like it.
- conanbatt 10y agoOr we can just send the policy and beat them up, why stop at 10%. /s I understand the problem but i dont see how raising taxes is the solution. Why are these houses vacant in the first place? In Buenos aires this is a huge problem, in a census they found like 20%+ of units are vacant. The economy minister once hinted at implementing this tax and had to retract quickly. The main reason property is vacant in Buenos Aires is because the state is failing to enforce contracts between tenants and owners, and owners do not trust tenants. A bad tenant can literally ruin you, because he can destroy the property, make himself impossible to evict, and a lawsuit can take up to 20 years to resolve, which is enough time for the perpetrator to liquidate his assets before the loses the trial. And as you mention, if the reason behind these vacant units is rich people, then such a tax will prove a poor deterrer.
- icebraining 10y agoWhy are these houses vacant in the first place? The city implies that many aren't, just that people don't declare the income to evade taxes.
- Jacqued 10y agoEven "rich people" don't like to take a 10% hit every year on their estate though. 2% is much less of a burden, especially in a bubbly market where the paper value rises by way more than that yearly. The vacant home issue is prevalent in nearly every large city in the world and it has a vast social cost. If you don't want to suppress it through tax (force them to live there, sell, or subsidize the locals by paying extortionate tax), another way would be facilitating squatting of empty property. When you do that, you actually have charities that specialize in "opening up" unoccupied spaces and setting them up for homeless people to live there. I actually like the way we do it in France where if you stay there for a couple of days you are legally an inhabitant so it takes up to a years worth of legal proceedings to expel you.
- crdb 10y agoA step in the right direction. However, the rule ought to be pretty simple: if it's your tax residential address, it's your home. Anything else isn't. If people want to invest in stuff, let them go for stocks, where their capital will at least be supposed to create value.
- cwmma 10y agoIs a 'tax residential address' that a Canadian thing your guaranteed to only have one of world wide and it would never make sense to live at an address other then your 'tax residential address' for legitimate reasons ?
- crdb 10y agoWell, I can't speak for Canada, but in most countries I've lived with the exception of the UK (non-dom rules) global income is taxed in your primary residence. So if your main economic activity is in Singapore and you declare your residence there so as to take advantage of its lenient tax rates (for example no capital gains tax), your Canadian home is not your primary tax residence and you should get hit by the land tax. Conversely if you declare that you live in Canada whereas you're busy making a million a year in Dubai, that million ought to be taxed according to Canadian tax law as if you resided there. There's plenty of rules already in existence to determine what is your primary tax residence as far as taxes are concerned, precisely to stop, say, a French resident from incorporating in Switzerland, getting paid into the structure, and not paying tax on his income (he can always try not to declare it, but then he becomes a criminal hoping that the rule of law is not thorough).
- hackerboos 10y agoClaiming a property as your main residency is not the same as claiming to be resident in Canada for tax purposes. You need only stay in a property for 1 day a year, you need to spend much longer in Canada (183 days in that tax year). This allows foreign based property speculators to avoid capital gains on property.
- AstroJetson 10y agoIt's interesting how the government is working on different tax schemes to try to fix the housing problem. But the people that are buying these houses from overseas have the money, so it's not going to make a difference. But locally it's a problem. There are lots of non-Canadians living there and the purchase tax is a real problem for them, it adds to the cost of really overinflated homes. My plan is to start a business call "Sim-Live", I'll make your house looked lived in for a small fee every month. Lights on, people in an out, small party every other month, trash out to be picked up, Amazon boxes, mail, etc.
- gtirloni 10y agoI hope your are joking because it would be trivial to sue your company and its customers ;) But yeah, what are the criteria for deciding whether it's empty or not. People will get creative quickly.
- AstroJetson 10y agoYep, a joke. There are people that when they go away on an extended trip they stage their homes to look lived in while they are gone. Real Estate Agents stage empty homes that they are selling to help the sale. A sofa, table and two chairs, etc. from a second hand place isn't much effort. And because of your post I've changed my company name to "Sim-Secure" We keep your house from being broken into and vandalized by making it look lived in. Thanks for suggesting the pivot! :-)
- aurelienb 10y agoWe have a similar tax in Paris, France. Tips: it doesn't work (in current design). Plenty of room for improvement, either around the full renting subject (ex: lowering barriers to set up a new contract between landlord and renter, to remove some laws which overprotect some renters) or around this particular subject (decreasing time before the tax, increase tax, increase control or fine, or even more violent solution (huge fine, jail, etc)) Note that I don't know what would be the most efficient
- carlob 10y agoI don't think the housing shortage will be fixed with tweaks to rental laws. Most of France happens in Paris (jobs, culture, …) and Paris has not kept up with the pace. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/66/Croissance_population_Paris.PNG?uselang=fr https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/66/Croissan... If you look at this plot you will see that the metro area has grown a lot, while the boundaries of the city haven't moved since 1860. There are various incentives in living in the city proper as opposed to one of the neighboring counties. This is horizontal growth. Vertical growth has been forbidden for a while now as there are very tight laws about how tall new buildings can be and whether old buildings can be torn down. Without relaxing at least one of these two constraints regulations on rent are going to do very little.
- aurelienb 10y agoFixed: no. But temporary improved: yes. Why: Because around 10% of Parisian flat are currently unoccupied. For a city like Paris, that's huge!
- pouetpouet 10y agoNot really. France has a ridiculous thing called taxe d'habitation. Which means that unhabited dwellings are less taxed than inhabited ones. The tax on unhabited dwelling units in Paris can just help to recover a part of the unperceived taxe d'habitation. Canada, Germany and many other don't have such a scheme.
- jacquesm 10y agoUntil 2010, in NL in areas with housing shortages if a house was not occupied for 12 months it was legal to squat. This was a pretty good deterrent against 'empty homes'.
- robk 10y agoSo theft is ok? Jacques what if I saw your camper was unused for a few weeks and wanted to take it?
- crdoconnor 10y agoWhat gives you the right to own land that you didn't create and you didn't make valuable?
- nibs 10y agoProperty law. Good luck "sharing the land" peacefully with 8 billion people. Have you ever been a country without zoning laws (let alone property ownership)? It is chaos. Very little sharing to speak of. More like problems are settled with guns instead of contracts.
- crdoconnor 10y ago>Property law Rights do not derive from law. Owning slaves used to be legal, but that didn't give slaveholders the right to own humans. >Good luck "sharing the land" peacefully with 8 billion people. It's straightforward enough. Tax the value of the unimproved land at 100%. Use the proceeds to build roads, treat the sick, dole out welfare, pay pensions, etc. and all the other stuff our governments already do that they apparently don't have enough money for. All that is required is a tweak to property law that wrests control over a natural resource. This would eliminate hoarding and share this huge wealth which is not created, but is captured by the ultrawealthy.
- icebraining 10y agoAdverse possession is part of that property law.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- djfergus 10y agoThere is a lot of speculation that Chinese buyers are driving up the Canadian market. I have no insight to whether this is true but leaving homes vacant does correlate with my observations - Asian and especially Chinese property buyers value a home that has never been lived in significantly higher than a 'used' home. This is regardless of age. From my understanding its a combination of feng shui/superstition (bad spirits!) and lack of taste/trust (interior decor preferences, dodgy renovations). I saw this a lot in the Malaysian market during the previous frothy years until 2014, many many vacant units, zero ability to negotiate rent - owners were going to get their asking price (rent or sale) or sit on an empty house/apartment. They were making ~10% a year so who can blame them. Then the Malaysian government slapped a retroactive (!) punitive capital gains tax on foreigners. In addition Selangor state (think most of the Kuala Lumpur suburban area) banned foreigners from buying landed, non-strata property. Instead of lowering prices, this had the effect of driving the transactions to almost zero (very few forced sellers), very little property over RM1m (the minimum limit for foreigner purchase) sells these days. Lots of RE agents are losing their jobs/driving uber to make ends meet. The foreign (predominantly Chinese) owners have deep pockets and holding power. The coming years will be interesting if it continues though. I look forward to reading the economic thesis papers in the future on whether this Canadian measure works and what the unintended 2nd/3rd order effects are. Its fun when govt's experiment like this, good grist for the mill for economic/psychological research.
- jhobag 10y agoAs an Asian, this comment.
- jlewis7272 10y agoJust out of curiosity, are there many squatters in these empty homes?
- darryl42 10y agoI having seen any articles about squatters. For actual houses owners will hire companies to make them look lived in. Setting out pumpkins on Halloween for example. For Condos you need a fob to enter and use the elevator so not many people who don't belong are going to get in. Some newspaper articles have quoted that around 10% of the condos in Vancouver are empty.
- djfergus 10y agoDoes anyone have any insight as to whether this 2% additional cost can/will trigger the banks to reassess borrowers and potentially hit them with a margin call? If it doesn't drive forced sales I can't see the prices falling significantly.
- reverend_gonzo 10y agoBanks can't perform margin calls on property. That simply doesn't exist. If you have a mortgage, that is a contract. As long as you are paying the mortgage off as agreed upon, the banks can't take your house.
- jcriddle4 10y agoActually I think something like it used to exist. While not a "margin call" a bank could call you and tell you to repay the full amount immediately. I think even today some loans are structured so if you miss a few payments the full amount becomes due. In theory, in a more libertarian market, a loaner could structure the loan any way they pleased.
- beachstartup 10y agothere are no margin calls on a mortgage, and most of these buyers paid cash out of pocket anyway.
- estefan 10y agoThey should do this in London, but unfortunately our officials rarely seem to give a shit in the face of foreign money.
- estefan 10y agoThe should ban leaseholds as well while they're at it.
- dood 10y agoI was curious so I did a quick bit of Googling: Since 2013 councils can levy an “empty homes premium” of an additional 50% council tax [1]. No idea how many actually do. The rate of unoccupied dwellings in London is 1.7% [2] 1. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/feb/21/tens-thousands-london-homes-deemed-long-term-vacant https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/feb/21/tens-thousan... 2. http://www.emptyhomes.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/Empty-Homes-in-England-Final-September-2016.pdf http://www.emptyhomes.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/Empty-H...
- estefan 10y agoEmpty homes is one thing. Taxing foreign investors would make a massive difference over night.
- 2AF3 10y agoSome cultures don't trust banks and prefer to park their money in real estate.
- inputcoffee 10y ago"A trickier issue facing the city is defining what constitutes an empty house. A city-sponsored study in 2014 used electricity-usage data to determine that about 5 percent of homes in Vancouver were uninhabited over 12-month periods." If that becomes the criterion, we will have empty homes running power for no reason! Worst of both worlds.
- Tiktaalik 10y agoGiven that Vancouver has a sub 1% vacancy rate, a tax on unoccupied housing is good policy. My concern however is that the city's implementation of the concept is really weak and this will be difficult to enforce. Some economists at the local university proposed instead a property surtax that would be waived if there was enough locally generated income. That seems to me to be a more elegant solution. https://www.biv.com/article/2016/1/local-economists-have-solution-unaffordable-vancou/ https://www.biv.com/article/2016/1/local-economists-have-sol...
- itisbiz 10y agowww.lonelyhomes.ca is a new "registry" of empty residential dwellings in Vancouver. These "lonely homes" are shown only by first 3 characters of the postal code (aka FSA) to preserve their anonymity. The goal is to identify how much of an issue this is and show how it affects neighbourhoods.