10 ms·
China Will Resurrect the World's Largest Plane
- djrogers 10y agoThere is very little chance that story is even remotely true. The story had 2 sources - Saddam Hussein, and Mohammed Saeed al-Sahhaf aka 'Baghdad Bob' (if you don't remember him, look him up - he was a meme before the Internet made memes a thing). On top of that, the story changed from a farmer to a few peasants and back again depending on who was talking and when. It was propaganda to make the US military look weak and ineffective - the same kind of propaganda that let us watch a split screen of al-Sahhaf's press conference saying the US hadn't taken Baghdad airport and US forces strolling around its tarmac.
- macintux 10y agoCurious to what in the world this is in reply.
- Luc 10y agoThis I guess (last paragraph): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12473552 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12473552
- commentreply 10y agoThe above comment was probably in reply to the following: "...a plane that big is probably a huge target, people would attempt to shoot at it even with small arms, and it is not impossible to get lucky with them (happened at least once in Iraq War for example, when a random farmer downed a US helicopter right on the start of the war with his hunting rifle... the chance of it working was tiny, the rifle didn't even had the range to ever reach the helicopter, but somehow, it did..."
- sschueller 10y agoNice to see this incredible cold war era plane not go the way of the concord. But in its case there is still a possibility of a profitable market for transporting very large and heavy machinery via aircraft.
- cm2187 10y agoIs this really meant for civilian usage or does anyone think China is trying to match the US military forces projection capabilities?
- prasadjoglekar 10y agoPerhaps a bit of both? The article cites both humanitarian and military power projection capabilities.
- finid 10y agoThanks for taking the time to read the article.
- to3m 10y ago"84 meters ... 88 meters ... 250 tons ... 300,000 lbs"
- maxerickson 10y agoThe US also operates a fleet of larger cargo planes than the one chosen for the comparison. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_C-5_Galaxy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_C-5_Galaxy (I think the typical reader will have little intuition for the cargo capacity of the C-17, so the more instructive comparison looks at the most capable operational US plane.)
- stangles1 10y agoThe comparison to the C-17 rather than the C-5 seems rather deliberate to me (along with using lbs instead of tons for the unit). It's more sensational if a future Chinese military cargo plane "beats" a US cargo plane in cargo capacity by XXX,000 of anything.
- to3m 10y agoAny time they don't translate between units, or mix different types together, I assume the writer is not only functionally innumerate, but also just repeating what somebody else has told them to say... Also note that (according to Wikipedia) the capacity is 250,000kg - so 275 tons, or 551,155 lbs. The C-17's cargo capacity (again, from Wikipedia) is 77,500kg - so 85 tons, or 170,858lbs. That looks a lot more like a difference of 380,000lbs than 300,000lbs to me, which, with some journalistic licence, could surely become "almost 400,000lbs more". You may well be correct about the sensationalism aspect, and here they are leaving some of that on the table. So I don't really know what's going on. Like I said, functionally innumerate... (Though of course, calculation error at this end is always a possibility! But nobody's paying me to do this, so I'm going to go with my gut here.)
- pcurve 10y agoside by side photo. http://www.avionale.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Lockheed_C-5_Galaxy_vs_Boeing_C-17_Globemaster_Size.jpg http://www.avionale.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Lockheed_... c5 Galaxy is massive. Interestingly, Boeing 747-8F is even bigger, heavier, and carries more load. Antonov 225? Well, it can carry the same load as both of those planes combined, which really put things into perspective.
- SandB0x 10y agoWriters! Please don't use "exponentially", which has a precise meaning, in place of a more modest word such as "greatly". > "China buying and building An-225s would exponentially increase its power capabilities not just in Asia, but across the world."
- kostyash 10y agoTo make it possible Ukraine and Chine will need to redevelop many technologies that were used to build Mriya. The technologies were gone when USSR collapsed.
- qaq 10y agoNot that many the bulk of manufacturing was done in Ukraine what was sourced externally can be sourced from subcontractors. For example engines are manufactured by Motor Sich (Ukraine based) which is still a fairly large engine manufacturer etc.
- avmich 10y agoHydrogen engines for Energiya, RD-0120, were made in Voronezh by KBKhA, which is still producing rocket engines. However this particular engine is practically lost - can't be recreated without extensive R&D program. It's not enough to have the original manufacturer survive... Can Rocketdyne manufacture another F-1 today? So it's quite possible - though not certain - that Motor Sich wouldn't be able to create a unique enough engine, even if it did that in the past.
- qaq 10y agoThe engine is not unique to Mria it was used on AN-124 and Motor Sich has a modernised version going through testing Д-18ТМ so should not be any issues on that front
- diarmuidie 10y agoThe AN-225's little brother the AN-124 was once used to fly a diesel locomotive from Canada to Ireland. It worked out cheaper for the train manufacture to pay to have it flown over, and meet the contractural delivery date, rather than shipping it by sea and paying the fine for missing the deadline. https://www.flickr.com/photos/48073612@N04/5124447894 https://www.flickr.com/photos/48073612@N04/5124447894
- garrettheaver 10y agoThat's pretty interesting! I see that train (or one very much like it) around Connolly station in Dublin when I'm commuting in and out of work.
- daurnimator 10y agoCan't see the article. It redirects me to http://www.popsci.com.au/?src=redirect http://www.popsci.com.au/?src=redirect with an error: "Oops! Something went wrong. Please scroll down to find your content."
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tomhoward 10y agoYeah, strangely this article isn't available on the Australian version of PopSci, but you can't view the US/Intl version from Australia. If you have an overseas VPN, you'll be able to see this article, or do a Google News search for something like "China AN-225" for other articles on the topic.
- a_bonobo 10y agoYes, it's a super dumb redirect on their side - the US Pop Science redirects to the Australian Pop Science which does not have the same content because the AUS Pop Science licenses the US Pop Science content, but not all of it. There are Grease Monkey scripts to stop the redirect or use a proxy, it's too much work for me to bother reading their content.
- Cyykratahk 10y agohttp://archive.is/LlIuW http://archive.is/LlIuW
- finid 10y agoIn cases like this, use Tor Browser.
- stepik777 10y agoOr Google Translate
- tgb 10y agoSo this was originally made to carry the USSR's Buran space-shuttle-like project. I'd never heard of Buran before, but I have heard many critiques of the US's space shuttle program. Yet Buran looks almost identical from a cursory view. Why would the Soviet's independently develop a highly flawed project? This article does a decent job answering that: http://www.popularmechanics.com/space/rockets/a9763/did-the-soviets-actually-build-a-better-space-shuttle-16176311/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/space/rockets/a9763/did-the-...
- corford 10y agoOT but if you've never heard of Buran, you might like this blog post: http://russiatrek.org/blog/history/two-abandoned-spaceships-of-energy-buran-project/ http://russiatrek.org/blog/history/two-abandoned-spaceships-... It's rammed with fantastic photos by Ralph Mirebs of the hangers at the Baikonur Cosmodrome used to house it (complete with an ageing, abandoned Buran inside).
- izacus 10y ago> Why would the Soviet's independently develop a highly flawed project? Probably a few reasons: * At the point of starting Shuttle operations, the flaws of the design weren't as apparent, especially not to general public. * Even though it LOOKS similar, it's actually not all that similar in design. The main difference is that it doesn't actually carry engines (which are the most expensive and problematic part of Shuttle due to their planned reuse) - Buran was taken into orbit by an expendable Energia rocket, which "solved" the problems with expensive engine rebuilds and testing. * At the end of the day, Buran never got past the prototype stage. It flew a single mission (empty, fully automated), landed and was then shelved. Only two prototypes were ever built.
- Retric 10y agoIt's not just rebuilding engines it's returning their weight that's a problem. The high temperatures are a result of pressure not friction. A smaller and or less dense craft has a vastly easier time during reentry. A shuttle actually works fairly well at around 1/5 the size. Lower thermal stress means no tiles. It would have a single ideally swappable engine large on board fuel and no external fuel tank. Still needs SRB's but those actually work fairly well.
- SideburnsOfDoom 10y agoIs an aircraft of this size economical, or is it a fuel hog useful only for carrying huge single-piece cargos that smaller aircraft cannot? Is it useful, or is it sheer size-vanity?
- finid 10y agoThe author of that article answered all your questions. Take a few moments to read it.
- SideburnsOfDoom 10y agoHm, the words "fuel" and "economic" do not occur in that article. You can infer something from phrases like "flying super heavy cargos" and "by bringing infrastructure ... that are normally too big for airlift" but it would be interesting to see if anyone has something to add directly on that topic as to what exactly the drawbacks to that scale are. The fact that only one was ever made also implies that the uses are limited.
- icegreentea 10y agoshrug it's honestly going to be a bit hard to compare. But for a rough guess, the AN-225 can lift like 300,000kg, and the AN-124 (from which its derived from) can lift like 230,000kg. The AN-225 has 6 of the same engines that the AN-124 has, so naively assuming roughly the same fuel use, the lift ratio is ~ 1.34 to 1 and the fuel use ratio is ~ 1.5 to 1. And the AN-124 is sufficiently cheap to operate to be in use commercially. So by those rough guesses, the AN-225 should be ok. That said, the moment you have a too heavy, or too big load for an AN-124, then the extra fuel cost of the AN-225 has almost infinite value. The drawbacks to scale always have to do with complexity, and ground infrastructure. The AN-225 can't operate from as wide a variety of fields that the AN-124 can (though this shouldn't be a huge concern from commercial use). Structurally, the modifications from the AN-124 to AN-225 aren't super complex. They basically added plugs before and after the wings to extend the fuselage, and added a wing extension. While these aren't trivial changes to an aircraft, they're basically the simplest type of structural change you can make. Oh, I guess there's a tail modification, but that's not that risky either. I mean I guess the point is that you probaly would not want a whole-scale replacement of AN-124 class lifters with AN-225, but keeping a few around enables entire types of lifts (and therefore operations) that simply aren't possible. The key would be to estimate what the appropriate amount of AN-225 are. For an example, the famous Beluga Airbus enables a form of manufacturing distribution (for good or for bad) that simply isn't possible without it existing. You would never want a giant fleet of Beluga, but having it is invaluable.
- ovi256 10y agoIt's obvious to me that China doesn't care that much about the AN-225 design as for the design of the D-18 turbofan. They still can't design or manufacture a heavy turbofan domestically. This has seriously hampered their heavy airlift project (the Y-20, who first flew using Soviet-designed low-bypass 12-ton thrust D-30 fans, which killed its range). The domestic WS-20 turbofan design that was supposed to power the production Y-20 airlifter is still under wraps, which usually means the prototype is not doing well. Getting access to a 20-ton thrust high-bypass turbofan design is a huge step for them.
- wallace_f 10y agoWhy is it difficult enough that not even a nation state as large and powerful as china has obstacles to develop a heavy turbofan? With respect to other tech they've developed I don't know what is technologically difficult here -- I'm asking genuinely as a layman, it's not a rhetorical statement of disagreement.
- crawshaw 10y agoFluid dynamics and combustion chambers. It's rocket science, a long, expensive trial-and-error development process. And unlike other sciences, most of the results are never published so each entity has to recreate the foundations themselves. It takes money, time, and dedicated careers.
- vasili111 10y agoWhy not to just buy one aircraft and reverse engineer its engines? What is the problem with just copying exact copy of existing engine?
- clintonb 10y agoIn this case U.S. government restrictions probably restrict China from buying U.S.-manufactured planes. I doubt Antonov wants to sell its only An-225.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- the_mitsuhiko 10y agoPretty sure it was resurrected before the Chinese came in. A second plane was started a few years back already.
- base 10y agoFor the people that want to know more about the AN-225 there is a very interesting documentary on youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lAyD16lWznc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lAyD16lWznc
- perrylaj 10y agoTyler Rogoway (formerly of Jalopnik's FoxtrotAlpha and now writing for TheDrive.com) had a take on China's goals(1). He seems to think that the plane's ability to act as a launch craft is a notable. I've found Rogoway to be a pretty good source of digestable and non-sensational military tech info. 1. http://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/5083/why-china-wants-to-put-the-gargantuan-antonov-an-225-mriya-back-into-production http://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/5083/why-china-wants-to...
- coredog64 10y agoAir launch is an incredibly tricky operation. Even something as trivial as a 500 lb. bomb undergoes lots of trials before it is accepted for use. The US Space Shuttle program only ever did glide testing of the orbiter off the back of the 747 carrier. A real launch of an orbital vehicle off the back of an AN-225 would mean serious envelope pushing and would be putting an extremely expensive aircraft at risk every time.
- dnh44 10y agoIs it just me that can't see the contents of the comments in the past couple days?
- Someone 10y ago"it carries a world record payload of 250 tons (to put this into comparison, it can carry around 300,000 lbs more than the US military's Boeing made C-17" What was the writer thinking? My readers won't understand what 250 tons is, so I'll use imperial metrics, too? Net effect is that this only makes full sense to those who understand both metric and imperial units. (I think a pound is 454 grams ('easy' to remember because that's the unit most jam is sold in in the EU (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metrication_in_the_United_Kingdom#Units_of_measurement) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metrication_in_the_United_King...). That would make 300,000 pounds about 135,000 kg or 135 tons, so it carries about double what a C17 can carry)
- chatmasta 10y agoI think it's more like "my readers don't grasp just how heavy 250 tons is." It's equivalent to saying "Mt Everest is nearly 6 miles, or 29,000 feet, high."
- Dylan16807 10y agoIf it actually gave both versions of the same number, that would be fine. But this way is just confusing. It would be like saying "Mt Everest is nearly 6 miles high, or in other words more than 16000 feet higher than Mt Fuji"
- ihaveajob 10y agoNot really. It's more like saying "Mt Everest is 8,848 meters high, or 2,483.6 ft taller than Mt Annapurna". Edit: Oops, I just saw the previous response. That's what happens when you open 8 tabs and read as you can.
- tw04 10y agoGiven the publication, I would imagine he's an American author writing to an American audience. I didn't think twice that 1 ton = 2,000 lbs so it made perfect sense here. Makes sense it would be confusing to people on the metric system, but I doubt he thought twice about it.
- Apocryphon 10y agoAw, I thought it meant that they're modernizing the Spruce Goose.
- kragen 10y agoFrom the title, I thought this was going to be about the Spruce Goose, but it turns out the Spruce Goose was designed only for a 75-ton capacity, not the 250 tons of the Ан-225. The Spruce Goose had a larger wingspan (97.5 m rather than 88 m) but the Ан-225 is longer (84 m rather than 66⅔ m). It's interesting to reflect that the previous "world's largest plane," and still the one with the widest wingspan, dates from WWII. In a sense this reflects changing social priorities, and in another sense it may reflect a generalized form of Conway's law: giant aircraft are produced by giant monolithic bureaucracies brooking no dissent, like countries in wartime or totalitarian governments. If that's the case, maybe we'll see more such planes if the wars in Syria and other places continue to spread, pushing countries like the US and the EU powers onto more of a wartime footing. But it's not clear they'll be strategically beneficial for fighting in the Drone Age; they're too hard to build and too easy to destroy.
- maxerickson 10y agoThey aren't super sized, but between the C-17 and C-5, the US has ~250 large cargo planes in service. There's also hundreds of 747s that could be pressed into service (or just utilized) in a world gone to hell scenario.
- kragen 10y agoI don't think of it as a "world gone to hell scenario" so much as a "World War II scenario" or a "Bronze Age collapse scenario". Smaller cargo planes should be somewhat more survivable than bigger ones in an environment full of Angels' Teeth and other micro-drones, but downing 250 large cargo planes still only requires landing 250 small robots on them and cutting a fuel line or something.
- maxerickson 10y agoOh, another WWII scale event meets my definition of world gone to hell. I suppose I could have more clearly stated that I was arguing that the US is already leaning on large aircraft strategically, it wouldn't be a shift.
- Animats 10y agoThe PLA is trying to establish a power projection capability. There are very few militaries in the world that can routinely operate on a large scale a long way from their home bases. The US can and does. Russia can do it with difficulty. Britain can do it on a small scale. Beyond that, few armies have the logistics capability. China is gearing up to join the club. There's also the PLA Navy's aircraft carrier program, which is progressing slowly. They have one refurbished USSR aircraft carrier in commission for training purposes, and two ramp-type carriers under construction. This doesn't seem to be the PLA's big effort, though. Most of their new weapon systems are for sea dominance in China's coastal waters, broadly defined.
- smegel 10y agoLink's broken for anyone else? I get: > Oops! Something went wrong. Please scroll down to find your content.
- sologoub 10y agoThe main problem for most post-Soviet production has long been that the supply chain now includes 2+ countries. Antonov is a prime example - had AN-124 and AN-225 been "Ukrainian" planes, we would have seen more production and commercializations. The problem is that these are Soviet planes and with the current Russian-Ukrainian relations in shambles, the production has stopped. Much of avionics and those turbofans are (were?) made in Russia: http://foxtrotalpha.jalopnik.com/ukraines-antonov-will-westernize-this-huge-soviet-era-c-1746015355 http://foxtrotalpha.jalopnik.com/ukraines-antonov-will-weste... In my view, this is just thrashing in a frantic bid to keep the company alive. Sad, given its storied past.
- doctorstupid 10y agoChina buying and building An-225s would exponentially increase its power projection capabilities... I expect a scientific publication to not popularize the misuse of 'exponential'.