10 ms·
FAA Urges Passengers to Not Use Samsung Galaxy Note 7 on Planes
- Hydraulix989 10y agoIs this a Samsung-specific problem, or is it more generally, a lithium ion battery problem (the regulations have always been in place for lion batteries on planes)? I suspect it's the latter -- in which case, it's pretty unfair to single out Samsung. On another note, I've always felt paranoid about keeping my phone in my pocket or having my laptop on my lap, especially if it starts to heat up. I might as well stick an M-80 in my pocket right next to my crotch.
- mcpherrinm 10y agoThe Galaxy Note 7 is being recalled over fires that have actually occurred. So I don't think it's unfair to single them out in this case.
- zmmmmm 10y agoMost models of phone experience reports of the occasional battery fire. Its just at a rate perhaps an order of magnitude less than the GN7. I suspect the fact that Samsung itself issued a recall is probably the main reason the FAA felt they needed to issue some kind of statement.
- smegel 10y ago> Is this a Samsung-specific problem A Samsung Galaxy Note 7 problem to be even more specific.
- mhmiles 10y agoIt's an issue with batteries manufactured by Samsung SDI. Hong Kong Note 7's have batteries from ATL and are not subject to the recall
- hackuser 10y agoWhat are SDI and ATL?
- mhmiles 10y agoSamsung SDI is their battery manufacturing subsidiary. ATL is Amperex Technology Limited, a Chinese battery manufacturer.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoCan anyone more familiar with batteries please describe the issue to us?
- urda 10y ago> it's pretty unfair to single out Samsung. Not at all when the common denominator is the fact that it's this specific device.
- kondro 10y agoAustralian airlines have just outright banned them. http://www.smh.com.au/business/innovation/qantas-jetstar-virgin-australia-tiger-airways-ban-samsungs-galaxy-note-7-use-charging-on-flights-20160909-grcjii.html http://www.smh.com.au/business/innovation/qantas-jetstar-vir...
- megablast 10y agoAre they banning them from being brought aboard the planes? Because it just looks like Qantas is stopping them from being charged or used while aboard?
- shavingspiders 10y agoI've heard second hand that they're being asked to not use them or charge them (just flew into Australia).
- josephcooney 10y agoWhat happens after I send my Note 7 back, and get a new one with the problem corrected? Will I still be banned on Australian airlines?
- bdcravens 10y agoI suspect it will be a few months, and they'll release the ban, based on numbers from Samsung (replacements as a percentage of initial sales)
- flashman 10y agoHere's the actual release: https://www.faa.gov/news/press_releases/news_story.cfm?newsId=20794 https://www.faa.gov/news/press_releases/news_story.cfm?newsI... Might as well just quote it in full: > In light of recent incidents and concerns raised by Samsung about its Galaxy Note 7 devices, the Federal Aviation Administration strongly advises passengers not to turn on or charge these devices on board aircraft and not to stow them in any checked baggage.
- bdcravens 10y agoI wonder why they aren't being banned, the way that hover boards were (though I believe the fire risk for the Note 7 is only present while charging)
- mveety 10y agoRisk might not be great enough. They're balancing convenience and safety. IIRC the hoverboards had a higher risk because of how many cheap ones burst into flames and people didn't want to use them in flight so it wouldn't bother them if they didn't have them.
- userbinator 10y agoThe "hoverboards" have a much bigger battery, with far more stored energy, and are also designed such that they can release that energy more quickly since the application requires it. A typical phone has around 10-15Wh capacity, hoverboards are in the 150-100Wh range, and laptop batteries are usually <100Wh; these are also cells which are designed more for long low-current discharges.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoOnce a battery starts releasing energy "more quickly than intended" it's only going to get quicker until it runs out of energy.
- madaxe_again 10y ago
- bwang29 10y agoIf I understood this correctly, this is based on a higher (but unknown to consumers?) chance that the Galaxy Note 7 's battery could explode during flight and catch fire. Then, what would be considered a chance high enough that a laptop battery's explosion would not be a concern? Would it be safer to lock these phones into an explosion-proof box before they onboard the flight?
- gilgoomesh 10y agoThe batteries don't "explode" – they self-combust. Better to have the phone out in the open (so you can see it catching fire) and throw it in a bucket of cold water – the water will absorb most of the heat and prevent the fire getting out of control (it won't extinguish the fire, which will continue in the water).
- wfunction 10y agoI'm confused. I thought trying to put out lithium fires with water was an awful idea?
- blkhawk 10y agoRechargable Lithium batteries contain surprisingly limited amounts of it. And its not in there in its elemental form anyway. Lithium batteries burn because of the potential energy they have after charging. You can drive nails through discharged Lithium Ion batteries without much happening.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tyho 10y agoPlease don't do this, when rechargable lithium batteries are "discharged", they are not discharged fully, doing so would damage the battery. Charging circuits have a "cutoff" voltage where they report the battery to be empty, but there is still plenty of stored energy in the cells.
- pcunite 10y agoThanks Samsung for ruining lucky 7. :-)
- noisy_boy 10y agoNot if you are iPhone 7
- pessimizer 10y agoStock dropped 3% on the announcement.
- rimantas 10y agoWas there any announcment by Apple where this was not the case?
- prklmn 10y ago"Urge."??? I think they can do better
- PacketPaul 10y agoLike say "pretty please".
- poopsintub 10y agoThey can, but they won't. How many Notes have been sold globally, a few million? The chances you're on a plane with someone with one in the U.S. or elsewhere is miniscule.
- wNk6A23YB 10y agoBig gubmint taking away my liberty to burn up an airplane full of passengers with my shoddy cell phone. Trump will fix this.
- sctb 10y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly violating the HN guidelines. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jcoffland 10y agoRegulators gonna regulate.
- peterwwillis 10y agoSo what's weird to me is how the FAA is issuing this notice, yet for hoverboards didn't issue any notice; airlines took it upon themselves to ban them.
- sschueller 10y agoNow I hope samsung will bring back the removable battery. The only reason I can still use my note 3 is because I was able to easily replace the battery with a new one. In fact all phones should have accessible batteries as the battery is in my opinion a consumable which will need replacing at some point.
- ddalex 10y ago> The only reason I can still use my note 3 is because I was able to easily replace the battery with a new one. that is exactly why you won't see removable batteries in new phones; how else do you drive the new buy cycle every 2 years? as speed and features, phones are pretty much 2010-desktops; good enough for what they do so they don't need replacement on the new hardware generation
- Tepix 10y agoI don't think that's the reason. If your battery is dead, it's easy and cheap to get it replaced nowadays. Not a good enough reason to buy a new phone.
- tammer 10y agoIt's psychology: people want an upgrade justification, and the threat of a few days without a phone is enough for most people.
- simonh 10y agoAlso you can usually swap the phone for a refurbished model with a new battery. I did that with my iPhone 4. Slightly more expensive than a battery replacement service, but same day.
- sschueller 10y agoIf you want me to buy another phone every year or two you will need to provide me with something I want and not force me because the old one is now broke. Especially at a price tag of almost $1000. I didn't buy the note 5 not because of the fixed battery but because they removed the SD slot.
- mrmondo 10y agoSo thats two models of phones that explode or set themselves on fire, a wall charger with illegal insulation imported to America, two models phone phones AND tablets that destroy SDCards likely due to faulty or cheap voltage regulators and a washing machine that sets houses on fire, not exactly a stellar record over the last 5-10 years...