9 ms·
Knowing a few friends and other acquaintances with PhDs, all they have common is endurance and focus. They were not exceptionally creative, or apparently breath
by pas 10y ago
Knowing a few friends and other acquaintances with PhDs, all they have common is endurance and focus. They were not exceptionally creative, or apparently breathtakingly genius.
And I guess that's why Google et al. likes to hire PhDs. They can take all kinds of shit, and endure. Get to the bottom of those problems even in the face of internal politics/bureaucracy.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoA PhD doesn't show that you get to the bottom of problems, but rather that you can influence, and be influenced by, group-think. Edit: Looks like it is still a while before my speech ban is up, so I'm pasting my response to kevingwang's response (below) here: >To a particular degree, anyway. Convincing a University, or being published in peer-journal, for example. >I think some are more or less ignored, though I guess I can't say that has no influence whatsoever and I'm also not sure that you can entirely avoid the influence of others.
- kevinwang 10y agoSo, the same as every other human being?
- collyw 10y agoI have been working at academic institutes the last few years, where maybe a third of the staff are PhD students. The ones that have gone on to more senior positions are like you describe, but I wouldn't say its the majority. A fair few of them decide to quit science after the PhD.
- irrational 10y agoThis reminds me of the old joke that PhD stands for "Pile it on Higher and Deeper".
- wrp 10y agoIt goes B.S. => More of Same => Piled Higher and Deeper.
- kohanz 10y agoBS = Bulls--- MS = More s--- PhD = Piled higher and Deeper
- mordae 10y agoI prefer this one: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ OTOH, I bear neither.
- sharemywin 10y agoMy favorite was D stand for Diploma...
- clueless123 10y agoWhen you think you know everything you get your BS When you find out you know nothing, you get your Masters When you realize no one else knows either you get your PHD
- wrp 10y agoI know a Chemistry professor whose favorite remark on this is, "A PhD is a badge of endurance, not intelligence."
- Moshe_Silnorin 10y ago>A PhD is a badge of endurance, not intelligence It's very clearly both.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoNah, I forgot which top flight physicist (Nobel, I think) wrote in a book that he had explained to his mother that there were indeed very dumb PhDs, thanks to mere "sitzfleisch". Most anyone in the business knows cases.
- Panoramix 10y agoSmarter than average, for sure. But people tend to over estimate the intelligence of the average PhD.
- jack9 10y agoIt is not. The purpose of a PHD is to advance the sphere of human knowledge as it applies to a subset of existing data in a unique way. Getting the PHD by proving something empirically is the point of a PHD. This does not require a great deal of intelligence. Not enough to warrant more than a participation badge, anyway. e.g. Computer Science, where there's tons of data and few people have done the grunt work of organizing it for a statistician.
- gmarx 10y agoWhat those who contradict you above fail to appreciate is just how little IQ difference makes someone seem "dumb". Most people with 140 IQs rarely spend any time having discussion of any depth with anyone who has an IQ below 120. They have not the slightest idea how dense someone with an IQ of 100 seems. When I was training as a physician I routinely needed to explain important things in depth to people with average and below average intelligence. It is shocking. Most of us live in a narrow world and make poor assumptions about life outside
- pmoriarty 10y ago"Godlike genius.. Godlike nothing! Sticking to it is the genius! I've failed my way to success." -- Thomas Edison "Let me tell you the secret that has led me to my goal. My strength lives solely in my tenacity." -- Louis Pasteur "Men give me credit for genius; but all the genius I have lies in this: When I have a subject on hand I study it profoundly." -- Alexander Hamilton
- forgotmysn 10y agoSounds like an epic humblebrag by Hamilton. I don't think anyone, then or now, thinks he was a genius.
- omginternets 10y agoI don't think he's using genius to mean "a genius". I think it's instead meant as a term for "a bright idea". i.e.: "to have genius" vs "to be a genius".
- cfmcdonald 10y agoHe is saying he has been credited with genius, that is intellectual power or talent, not that he has been credited with being "a genius". The former is now an archaic way of using genius, the latter was pretty new in Hamilton's time.
- habitue 10y agoAlexander Hamilton was definitely super smart. Read his biography, it's nuts how young he was while he was writing treatises that shaped world events
- pjmorris 10y agoI am curious about how you come by your view. Have a look at this defense [0] of Hamilton on the $10. I can see from it how many could see him as a genius. [0] http://www.financialsense.com/contributors/michael-pettis/please-do-not-diminish-hamilton http://www.financialsense.com/contributors/michael-pettis/pl...
- karma_vaccum123 10y ago
- cubano 10y agoAlmost all of the education system is about signalling your abilty to be told what to do and doing it, and not hardly at all about actually learning things necessary for a successful and productive life.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoAlthough... Being able to do what your told is fairly necessary for a productive life. Don't do drugs, brush your teeth, get a good education, exercise regularly, shower regularly, spend less than you make, eat healthy. Do as your told.
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoDon't study CS, Law is where the money is, don't start a business, it will probably fail, don't date that girl, her parents are bumpkins. Do as your told.
- jimmaswell 10y agoThe vast majority of the time, you shouldn't start a tech startup.
- rsp1984 10y agoReally? As a PhD what you do is explore a -- best case: niche, usually: theoretical and worst case: completely made up -- problem thoroughly in absence of workplace realities like deadlines, office politics and backstabbery, and try to come up with a solution that's better in at least some sense than what's been written before, then write a big piece of documentation about it whose total number of individual readers in most cases won't reach double digits. This does not prepare you well for most workplaces, except for maybe Google, who have enough resources to create an alternate reality for their engineers so they don't have to grow up.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoNot a Ph.D but reports from (UK) doctorate holders suggest there's sometimes a lot of backstabbery, often deadlines (funding), very often lab/department politics.
- ci5er 10y ago> in absence of workplace realities like deadlines, office politics and backstabbery Really? I did not find that to be the case. I don't mind deadlines, but watching the day-to-day life of academics doing academia with their peers is what caused me to drop out of a PhD program and go finish my research project on my own. After seeing it in action, I wanted no part of being one of them for the rest of my career. I expect that I could have been at a rarely political university system, but after some medium-ish number of conferences (i.e. more than two dozen), I doubt that it was much worse than average. I found the whole thing quite "icky". In fact, I found it worse than any commercial environment I've been in (although I've been told I've been lucky in my experiences for failing to find it to such a degree in commercial environments).
- vacri 10y agoI'll support this with my experience. A PhD means you can do peer-reviewable original research. This means that you can't be too dumb, yes, but mostly that you have the elbow-grease to see it through. Maintaining motivation and stick-to-it-iveness are the most important qualities for doing a PhD. Disclaimer: dropped out of a PhD program due to lack of interest and elbow-grease.