10 ms·
Goldman Sachs Has Started Giving Away Its Most Valuable Software
- burnbabyburn 10y agoit's behind paywall, can someone tell just what's this software about?
- swampthinker 10y agoYou can click "web" which will provide you a link to the article without the paywall. But just for you: "Called Securities DataBase, or SecDB, the system remains Goldman’s prime tool for measuring risk and analyzing the prices of securities, and it calculates 23 billion prices across 2.8 million positions daily. It has played a crucial role in many of the seminal moments of the firm’s recent history, including its controversial trading just ahead of the financial crisis."
- molsongolden 10y agoJust to continue on: "Many of those tools are being offered in the form of web-based applications that customers can customize and operate on their own." Sounds like they are turning what used to be heavily guarded internal software into client-facing apps.
- internal_tools 10y agoI would assume because this space is becoming more of a commodity and their tool is no longer unique -- on it's face. So by making it available to customers they can garner goodwill and entrench themselves.
- p4wnc6 10y agoThe tool is also extremely messy internally, written in a proprietary language that resembled a very early version of Python and has accrued nearly unthinkable technical debt. Delivering usage via webservice lets them better hide the dysfunction on the other end of a service call. This whole topic is not all that newsworthy. The team within Goldman that had architected and developed this years ago had spun out into a consulting group that essentially reimplemented the same thing in Bank of America (Quartz), JPMorgan (Athena) and many others, now including Morgan Stanley, and even trickling down to smaller banks like PNC. I consider it one of the biggest ripoffs in modern finance that those organizations have paid untold fortunes to adopt the Goldman-like approach, sometimes even with new or additional proprietary languages brought in on the project. It also adds systemic risk for society because it further correlates these internal banking systems between the largest banks. If something goes systematically wrong with it in one place, there's a comparatively high risk the same sort of thing can or will go wrong in another too. If we were bearing that risk for a good reason it might be OK. But really we're only bearing it because of the superficial branding of Goldman, and the pressure on banks to hand wave and appear to be doing something in the aftermath of the 2008 crisis. And so they go for what looks politically defensible (e.g. "well, this is what Goldman did and they survived the crash" -- despite it being widely researched and reported that Goldman's position in the crash truly had nothing at all to do with superior risk management systems and was a mixture of political favors and luck) instead of anything sensible from a system design point of view.
- YuriNiyazov 10y agoKirat and his buddy are now "Washington square partners", and working on the same product to sell to "the masses." F9
- InternetPerson 10y agohaha, but of course you mean ctrl+F9 -- you probably edited multiple files... I completely agree with the parent and grandparent posts! I worked with one of the SecDB clones for three years at a Too Big To Fail bank, and it was criminally bad (imho). It's snake oil.
- Maven911 10y agoSorry for being dense, but can you expand: Why was it snake oil ?
- InternetPerson 10y agoI agree with jnordwick that "Quartz and Athena are both failed projects." For example, Mike Dubno, Kirat Singh, and three other managing directors on the Quartz project are all gone [1]. I agree with the grandparent post that "Goldman's position in the crash truly had nothing at all to do with superior risk management systems and was a mixture of political favors and luck" The snake oil in this case is what p4wnc6 (who's spot on) highlighted: "The team within Goldman that had architected and developed this years ago had spun out into a consulting group that essentially reimplemented the same thing" [at other banks]. The product that they sold (a SecDB clone) is pure snake oil, and the projects (which were massively expensive) delivered very little value. Consider: If SecDB really lives up to the hype, then why would Goldman let all these other banks steal Goldman developers and straight-up copy it? [1] http://news.efinancialcareers.com/us-en/253040/three-bank-of-america-merrill-lynch-technology-managing-directors-have-departed/ http://news.efinancialcareers.com/us-en/253040/three-bank-of...
- TheLarch 10y agoBesides introducing systematic risk, the sale of this software by Goldman smells fishy. Despite the Blankfein quote about maybe selling for $5 billion back in the day, if the software is what they purport it to be, wouldn't selling it be akin to Amazon licensing their product distribution to Walmart? I've wondered what these million dollar per month programmers do on Wall Street. This really puts it in perspective. On that note, it's completely depressing to see many of the best minds of our time working on shit software that adds nothing to society. Another swath of them are working on getting people to click on ads for Facebook and Google.
- Keyframe 10y agoAnd they can gauge where client's interests lie at. Something like google could (what I would do if I were google) gauge interest in various stocks and commodities people search for and make some kind of model based on that. Ye olde adage, if you're not paying for the product, you are the product.
- datr 10y agoI think that would be insider trading on Google's part.
- Keyframe 10y agoHow, why? Especially if they're not trading their own stock.
- datr 10y agoI was mainly thinking of this comment [0] and the story it was in response to. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8967902 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8967902
- Keyframe 10y agoKind of funny where Google decides what's legal or not.
- tsukikage 10y agoUsing non public information obtained from a client in dealings with another client, or at all on the public side of the firm, would breach Chinese walls. Never mind internal controls, most jurisdictions have relevant legislation to prevent exactly this behaviour.
- Keyframe 10y agoThere is no non-public info in this case. It's same as if you were in a public hall with a lot of people, who talk only about stocks, and writing down how many, how often and when particular stocks are mentioned and in which context (buy, sell, various). Morally ambiguous thing is that hall belongs to Google and they're the only one up in the balcony, which is the only place you can hear all the people from.
- snarfy 10y agoWe really need to stop with this practice of clicking web to work around their paywall. It doesn't work on mobile and is basically a dark pattern.
- Yhippa 10y ago"web" works inconsistently on mobile
- mschaef 10y agoI'm pretty sure they're referring to SecDB. There isn't much known about SecDB outside of Goldman, but I think the essence is that it: 1. Is a distributed data store for market positions, etc. 2. There's a dataflow/spreadsheet-like valuation engine on top of the data store 3. It's had long-term and senior level support among management, and most/all of GS's positions and businesses are available within SecDB. 4. There's a large pool of internal talent that's well acquainted with SecDB and how to use it. So... it gives GS an easy way to see where they are, and then run models to figure out where they might be under different hypothetical scenarios. What's noteworthy about this to me is that while they may be 'giving away' points 1 and 2 from my list, points 3 and 4 are the bigger competitive differentiators for Goldman. Even if another bank immediately adopts SecDB, while they may get the technology, it'll take them quite a while to integrate it as fully into their culture and business. SecDB implemented for a small bit of a big bank and run by a bunch of relative newcomers is a very different thing than SecDB as it might be implemented at Goldman.
- fnord123 10y agoIt's been available outside Goldman for a long time. Cantab Capital had based their systems on it as long ago as 2006. The founders were ex Goldman and wangled some kind of deal where they could use the GS systems.
- jamessb 10y agoIIRC from a conversation with an employee, the two were initially very close: I think the deal included something like CC co-locating servers in a GS datacenter as well as licensing its software, but both ended several years ago in anticipation of a change in regulation.
- rdtsc 10y ago> There isn't much known about SecDB outside of Goldman Erm... https://github.com/saleyn/secdb https://github.com/saleyn/secdb Written in Erlang with a C driver for low level stuff. Author is Serge Aleynikov. Ex-GS employee sued in multiple courts over many years by GS. But yeah, not "officially known" as in they released, but there is probably some association there. Just a guess ;-)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- seycombi 10y agouse search link instead https://www.google.com/search?q=Goldman+Sachs+Has+Started+Giving+Away+Its+Most+Valuable+Software&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&client=firefox-b https://www.google.com/search?q=Goldman+Sachs+Has+Started+Gi...
- gavanwoolery 10y agoSo now Goldman can create artificial risk with its software and further manipulate the market to its will? I think this "gift" fits under the definition of a Trojan horse. Conspiracy maybe, but think about how easy it would be for GS to make a trade based on the numbers its software spits out, before those numbers are public. The SEC has let far bigger things "slip" in the past.
- wintermute42 10y agoYou have no idea what you are talking about. How exactly does GS manipulate the markets to its will? You'd think their balance sheet would look better if that was case..
- cmdrfred 10y ago>How exactly does GS manipulate the markets to its will? They rig the ratings agencies and libor[0]. [0]http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-07-18/goldman-sachs-s-blankfein-says-libor-scandal-undermines-trust http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-07-18/goldman-sa...
- smallnamespace 10y agoYour article doesn't support your point; it's Goldman's CEO complaining about other people manipulating LIBOR. https://www.theice.com/iba/libor https://www.theice.com/iba/libor Goldman Sachs did not manipulate LIBOR because it's not even one of the banks that is asked for LIBOR submissions (they were an investment bank, not a commercial bank). I'm all for bashing banks when it's appropriate, but it's our obligation to get the facts straight first.
- gavanwoolery 10y agoAt minimum, GS has done this in the past via political back-patting. Any other means would not surprise me, although to be honest I could care less if I am right/wrong about this particular case. :) https://newrepublic.com/article/132628/goldman-sachs-settlement-5-billion-sham https://newrepublic.com/article/132628/goldman-sachs-settlem...
- runjake 10y agoTo save others a few seconds of their life, you can click the "web" link under the submission title on this page and avoid the paywall. h/t swampthinker
- gadders 10y agoDubno also went on to try and re-invent the same system when hired as CIO of BAML. It was called Quartz there.
- arthurcolle 10y agoDon't forget JPMorgan too ;) w/ Athena
- lucozade 10y agoThat wasn't Dubno but Kirat Singh who worked for Mike at GS. I thin kit was the first of the SecDB offspring with other attempts at BAML and Morgan Stanley. I believe Deutsche bank are also doing something similar.
- gadders 10y agoKiran worked for Dubno at BAML as well. It's not common from people to go from bank to bank re-creating the same system. Seems particularly common with people GS though.
- jonknee 10y agotl;dr By "give away" they mean allow their sophisticated clients access the tools to do business with Goldman. It's not open sourced or available publically in any manner.
- amelius 10y agoI'm missing the rest of the tl;dr. What is this software used for? Why is it so valuable?
- arthurcolle 10y agoPricing securities and position/risk management... Read the article!
- Maven911 10y agoIt's used for pricing & risk management. Considered the best in class for large banks and has been attributed (at least partially) for GS scathing away from the financial crisis relatively unharmed because of being able to quickly price things, determine risk throughtout the firm, and make quick decisions.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoGS scathed away with their former president as the Secretary of Treasury overseeing the rescue of their dependencies. Who has made such attribution?
- anotherarray 10y agoIt's part of the article's clickbait strategy. It's so distant from the truth that you can't even find information about pricing, plans ,conditions, etc. It's a nice way to get investors' attention though.
- mathattack 10y agoThis is "giving away" as in "Loss Leader." If a customer uses a bank's database to do their pricing, they tend be much more likely to do their trading with that firm. This is why firms like to have their models become the market standard. (Example: "Lehman Live" was used to price Mortgage Backed Securities. Unfortunately that didn't end well)
- 9NRtKyP4 10y agoMany other banks expose some of their pricing code as a web application to varying extents. For example https://live.barcap.com/ https://live.barcap.com/ which was inherited from LehmanLive, considered state of the art for fixed income back in the day. Also as the article states, anything that still has an actual competitive advantage won't be released.
- lordnacho 10y agoSo, is it data, a database, or a risk-management tool? Sounds like something that could have been hard with constraints of 1990s hardware, but these days any old person could rent a cloud to do this. Also, I suspect people who aren't involved directly in the technology talk it up a lot more than would someone who was involved in building it. The execs have bet on it with budget money, and they get to open or close the gate, making it seem more important than it really is. At the end of the day, every financial form has a bunch of code that lets them slice and dice their data. GS didn't survive the crisis because they had this system, they survived because they had a system and made some wise choices.
- jnordwick 10y agoSecDB has been in a class of its own for years now. I've seen and heard of many other banks try to replicate it and failed. It's customizability and performance are very well respected in fintech circles.
- Maven911 10y agoWhy do they fail to replicate it ? Especially if I am hearing it's the same people developing (re-developing) it over and over again
- kchoudhu 10y agoThe people who wrote SecDB are now in charge of the technology org at Goldman, and they have presented the stack as a core firm asset in need of constant development and investment to the business, which has -- surprisingly -- accepted this position. SecDB is not just another IT project with an end date for the business. Ultimately, that is what distinguishes it from all the other copycats on the Street.
- KMag 10y agoHaving some friends who were poached for one of those replication efforts, it sounds like an issue of scale, culture, and transplant rejection. A lot of the advantages of a unified cross-desk risk calculation system aren't realized until it's widely adopted, and it's difficult getting the desks to buy in to changing their thinking to an FRP mindset and adapting all of their existing code. At Goldman, SecDb was developed by the Strats, who were part of the individual desks in a hybrid tech/quant role, not part of the Tech division. To some extent, SecDb was a bottom-up system driven by the desks who needed it, but in the other firms, it has been the technology divisions trying to push the new system on the desks. It's partly a political problem. In order to jumpstart their systems, the other firms poached experienced talent from Goldman. Goldman's culture is generally receptive to suggestions and constructive criticism, at least comparatively. These new upstarts showing up and making suggestions to the old guard has not always gone over well at other firms. I'm told one ex-Strat who wrote discount curve calculation code at Goldman showing up at the new firm's technology division, noticing a discontinuity in his new firm's curve, poking around the code in the quant svn repository, and gently pointing out to the author that the same mistake had been made at Goldman several years prior. The response was not so much the expected "oh, hey thanks", but instead the very next day the entire technology division's read access to the quants' svn repository got revoked.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 10y agotl;dr The software is called SecDB. Giving it away is like giving a sports almanac to people that can't travel back in time. Somehow GS ended up using it at the right time, and even had fun speculating on how much to sell it for.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoDrats, I was hoping it was something mischievously strategic about "commoditizing the complement" and wondering which was what. (As in pushing for cheap software if you have exclusive hardware, and vice-versa.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- varcharlie 10y agoClickbait, shame on you! "Sign up or login"....
- hkmurakami 10y agoNot its excel models??