8 ms·
Toyota’s Prius Pays Price for Cheap Gasoline
- chmaynard 10y ago> “Toyota has put more energy into the mechanics of the [Prius] than the styling.” I'm a happy Toyota hybrid customer. Styling was not an important consideration when I chose the Prius. Gas mileage was much more important, along with price, quality, and comfort.
- melling 10y agook. So, there's still a smaller market. That doesn't address the bigger problem where many people buy SUV's when gas is cheap.
- Alupis 10y ago> Styling was not an important consideration when I chose the Prius. Gas mileage was much more important, along with price, quality, and comfort. Yes, that may be. But imagine if there had been an alternative to the Prius - was priced the same, had the same gas mileage and equivalent specs, but it looked a lot more stylish/sporty/refined, etc... Which do you buy now?
- viraptor 10y agoThe one that you like better. Which one "looked a lot more stylish/sporty/refined" is not going to be the same for every person.
- tw04 10y agoEVERY person? No. But the VAST majority of people think a McLaren P1 looks extremely sexy and a Pontiac Aztec looks like a committee of idiots were in charge of the exterior design. The Prius is known for many things: I don't know of anyone who would go out of their way to say it's a stylish or attractive looking car as one of it's top 20 attributes. I'm sure someone out there like that exists, but they are very clearly in the minority.
- pohl 10y agoThe one that gets the same gas mileage but has better styling would be the superior engineering achievement, so I'd choose that one. But now imagine a 3rd option that takes whatever advantages made that possible and puts them in the body with better aerodynamics: again I'd choose against style.
- mikeash 10y agoI don't know if that sort of tradeoff really exists. Looking at a list of low-drag cars, most of them look great: http://motorburn.com/2014/01/12-of-the-most-aerodynamic-cars-in-production-right-now/ http://motorburn.com/2014/01/12-of-the-most-aerodynamic-cars... Car styling is always a matter of taste, but I bet virtually everyone will find at least a couple of cars on that list that they think are nice to look at. The Prius's weird styling isn't so much to be efficient, but to look efficient. The latest generation makes that much more obvious. Those weird lines and mismatched rear panels aren't doing anything for aerodynamics, but they call out that this car is different.
- chmaynard 10y agoI think you're overlooking something. The Gen 2 Prius is classified as a mid-size hatchback. I suspect that had something to do with Toyota's decision to go with the odd shape. The extra space wasn't important to me when I bought it, but it is now. For example, I can put down the rear seats and place an assembled bicycle inside, without removing the front wheel or lowering the seat post. I couldn't even think about doing that with my last car, an Acura Integra.
- Alupis 10y ago> I think you're overlooking something. The Gen 2 Prius is classified as a mid-size hatchback It's one of the oddest shaped hatchbacks in production, and frankly looks weird to even a hatchback lover like myself. Take a look at the front runners in the hatchback field, you'll notice big differences in aerodynamics, "sleekness", and styling. Ford Focus, VW Golf, etc... all far better looking cars than the weirdly lined Prius.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 10y agoWhat "car people" see as a negative, some "eco people" see as a positive. In Cambridge, MA, there's a significant part of the population for whom "I am making an overt statement about my care and concern for the environment" that will cause them to prefer the unstylish Prius/LEAF/Volt.
- bane 10y agoThere is, is the Honda Accord Hybrid. Within spitting distance for mpg, bigger, better looking, faster, low end trims are about the same price.
- r00fus 10y agoYes - as a Prius '05 owner, I'd say back then it was the closest to a spaceship I could get in a production vehicle. Today, there's plenty of options, and the Volt would probably win (budget) or Tesla (best looking, pure electric). I think the latest Prius simply looks worse than previous designs.
- spking 10y agoI'm in the happy Prius owner camp, too. The styling (or lack thereof) is also driven by aerodynamic efficiency: http://motorburn.com/2014/01/12-of-the-most-aerodynamic-cars-in-production-right-now/ http://motorburn.com/2014/01/12-of-the-most-aerodynamic-cars... (#5) For people like me who consider cars a utility item, I couldn't really care much less about its outward appearance to other people.
- mikeash 10y agoHeh, we found the same link, except I looked it up in order to demonstrate that the Prius's looks aren't about efficiency. Most of those cars look great. The Prius stands out (along with the XL1) as a weirdmobile there, and it still only gets fifth place. I'm not going to bash it over its appearance, but I think that list shows that it doesn't have to look different to be efficient.
- karmicthreat 10y agoYea. Those were the same criteria I had. I commute about 90 miles a day. So even with cheap gas fuel efficiency is important to me. Also I went with the Prius over the Volt mostly because the Volt has WORSE styling and less reliability.
- brightball 10y agoGonna have to disagree with you there. My Volt was amazing. Drove like it had a V6 and looked really sleek. The Prius always looked like a box on wheels to me.
- Spoom 10y agoThis is exactly where I am. The Prius looks fine, but when you do the math on the mileage, it can't be beat by any other sedan in the price range. But then, I bought a used Gen 2 Prius, so I wouldn't show up in these stats anyway.
- clivestaples 10y agoMy Honda died at 300,000 miles in February. I used the occasion to explore buying a pickup truck and discovered that gas prices had fallen and Toyota Tacomas were selling at a record pace above MSRP. The Dodge Ecodiesel was $40k. The Prius' were sitting the lot and the fleet manager said he'd make me a killer deal. I drove it and enjoyed myself. The car was ~$20k, >50 mpg. I fill up every two to three weeks in SoCal for about ~$20.
- protomyth 10y agoWhat's the warranty like on Prius fleet cars?
- clivestaples 10y agoI got the standard 3/36k with 60k drive train. I'm not sure I got a "fleet deal", I just worked with him through Costco. EDIT: I did get a significant discount that was available to pretty much anyone who walked in to buy one. He told me there was considerable pressure to move them because sales completely dried up. In retrospect, I probably could have gotten a much better warranty :/ Oh well...
- protomyth 10y agoThanks. I drive quite a bit (about 45K a year, welcome to North Dakota) and I'm thinking I need to replace my Kio Rio with something that will get 40+ mpg (Rio gets 41 or 32 with a head wind and 50 with a tail wind). I haven't heard anything bad about the Prius. I was going to break down and buy a truck since it would be really useful, but the Colorado really is poor.
- SandersAK 10y agoFor me, the issue is that intellectuals, futurists, etc constantly downplay the crucial cultural role that cars play as part of our identity in America. America has really shitty public transit, so on average, you're driving (or being driven) somewhere and seeing other people driving. America is also a place that encourages and celebrates individuality (for better or worse). At the same time, it's a country of sub-cultures and mixed cultural identities. So you get people buying cars that they think fit their personal identity and their sub culture. Prius(i?) were a statement for the conscious movement, but it's damning that Toyota never pushed the bar further and explored (until recently) other cultural identity vehicles as eco-conscious (like Tacomas, imagine how awesome that would be!). tl;dr - cars are critical to American culture, and not just as practical tools for moving around. Even if you think you buy a prius because you "don't care" - that unto itself is a cultural and style decision you are making to express yourself. Hoodies forever. side rant: Why Tesla is the only car company to make an electric (or even hybrid) that doesn't look like vanilla boring practical dogshit is beyond me.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoIn one corner, cultural identity, a shared, commonly accepted fantasy, a set of semi-arbitrary rules for a role-playing game. In the other corner, the effort to stop the transformation of Earth into a smoldering pile of garbage that cannot sustain human life. It's a fight that "makes sense".
- bdcravens 10y agoI think you're painting a false dichotomy.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoWell... maybe. Sort of. But not really. It's satire. It's a way of cranking up the Sharpen filter all the way to 100, to make things more obvious. Clearly the contradiction right now is not as bad as that - but it could be, there are future timelines that could be conceived in ways similar to that. What I'm saying is - there's a dystopia in the future that looks like that. Let's make sure we don't take the wrong fork in the multiverse road and end up there somehow.
- guelo 10y agoWe are in desperate need of a carbon tax to continuously push the economy away from global warming emissions. It's crazy that we let Saudi Arabia's oil whims dictate our transportation policy.
- sokoloff 10y agoMaybe. (FTR, I support carbon taxation on balance.) Many carbon taxation implementations would amount to a regressive tax. Poor people on average drive more and spend more of their income on gasoline than the wealthy. Add in the fact that it becomes a hidden consumption tax as well and it could end up being a fairly regressive tax. Then the question becomes: are the ecological advantages worth the economic harm from the regressive nature? Since my wife buys about 200 gallons of gas per year, my daily driver is electric, and our income is enough that we'd never notice a carbon tax, it's easy for me to support it personally. That's far from true for many others.
- guelo 10y agoSaudi Arabia was imposing an extra $400 tax on your wife a couple years ago but we didn't have any say in it. My favorite idea is a dynamic gas tax that maintains a constant slowly increasing price level. And using the tax revenue to invest in shifting the economy to be less carbon intensive.
- Tiktaalik 10y agoYou can mitigate the regressive nature of the tax by making the carbon tax "revenue neutral" and funnelling the revenues of the tax completely into credits and tax cuts for those most impacted, which includes low income persons. British Columbia's carbon tax is claimed to be revenue neutral though I've noticed some criticism about the balance of resulting tax cuts. Other carbon tax jurisdictions such as Alberta are taking a different approach and are using revenues on green projects.
- twblalock 10y agoOr, even better, you could use the money from the tax to build decent public transit so fewer people need to drive to work. This would enable to poor to avoid the tax by driving less. If you don't build transit, people will have no choice but to drive just as much as they did before the tax was implemented, so the tax will have a minimal effect on vehicle emissions. Sure, people will cut back on non-required trips, but the vast majority of driving people do is commuting, and they can't stop doing that unless they have an alternative means of getting to work.
- anexprogrammer 10y ago"The entire market has dramatically shifted to light trucks and SUVs with gas under $3 a gallon." I did a double take at that as price per gallon seems markedly lower than when I was last in the US. UK prices ratchet seemingly inexorably upwards. When US prices peaked in 08 at $4.50 we paid pretty much exactly what we pay now - £5 approx. Tax is around 65% of pump price, though it's been higher in the past. I assume there's no US attempts to increase taxation to combat clmate change and encourage alternative behaviour.
- mikeash 10y agoAround here, prices are currently a little over $2/gallon, with occasional stations showing slightly under $2. Of course there's no attempt to increase taxes, because taxation is theft and government is the enemy. The federal gas tax hasn't been increased since 1993, and worse it's a fixed amount per gallon, not a percentage, so both inflation and increasing fuel efficiency cut into it. State gas taxes are a little more mutable but still face lots of resistance.
- anexprogrammer 10y agoBlimey. No surprise sales of hybrids aren't growing. We had, under Blair, yearly percentage increases above inflation in fuel tax as part of their climate change efforts. There was a point, I forget quite where - perhaps around 99p a litre or £4.40 a gallon, where behaviour and car use started to noticeably change.
- mikeash 10y agoYeah, it's kind of crazy. When gas prices started to retreat from the $4/gallon peak around 2008, there was talk of increasing gas taxes to compensate. Not just for climate change, but also because efficiency is hitting gas tax revenue and that money is needed to build and maintain roads. But it's a tough sell when half of the electorate thinks climate change is a conspiracy and government always wastes its money, so nothing happened.
- fps 10y ago
- Yhippa 10y ago> “The people with money buy a Tesla,” he said. The Prius looks like an old-man's car to me. Teslas have all the bells-and-whistles and don't look half bad. Much easier to peacock in a Model S than _any_ of the Prii.
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoTrue, but the Prius is the greatest ANTI-Peacock vehicle ever! To police, it is invisible. I have never been given a second glance by a police officer even when I am clearly speeding. Cops just seem to tune them out as granny cars.
- Yhippa 10y agoAnother benefit of being anti-peacock is that the thing will be easier to sell in the future. Lots of crafty folded sheet metal looks dated compared to more conservative designs.
- fps 10y agoa 10 year old prius, which originally sold for $21K, is worth a little over $5K today. a 10 year old Tacoma, which originally sold for $22K, is worth just under $13K today. Conservative design was the better buy.
- sixothree 10y agoToyota has made some awful design decisions in the last few years. I've owned Toyota's most of my life. I'm on year 11 of my Camry and would like a new Camry or Lexus. Instead I'm looking at other manufacturers.
- r00fus 10y agoHear, hear! In mid-2000s Toyota was an innovator and disruptor (hybrids). Now they're busy being disrupted by GM and Ford (Toyota has no production electrics) and, of course, Tesla. And the new Priuses don't look good. Everyone I talked to have said the same thing. It's like they wanted to ensure it'd fail - because Toyo is now all-in for fuel-cells.
- maxsilver 10y agoIs it really Cheap Gasoline that's the cause of the decline? Seems more like Toyota's Prius is paying the price for hanging onto a decade-old product. The type of customer who would have bought a Prius in 2002, has moved on to EV's and PHEV's, and Toyota doesn't appear to be selling those yet. Cheap Gasoline hasn't stopped Tesla from racking up multi-year-long waiting lists for the Model 3. "CMAX Energ-i" and Volts and LEAFs can be bought today at decent prices. But Toyota's response -- the "Prius Prime" -- doesn't appear to be for sale yet.
- mikeash 10y agoTesla's cars are awesome in just about every respect besides price. The Model 3 promises to preserve the awesomeness without the price tag. People want them, and it rarely has anything to do with saving money on gas. Priuses are kind of boring. (I owned one for a while so I hope I'm not too clueless on this.) They work, they're reliable, they're cheap to run, but few people come back from a Prius test drive thinking, holy shit, I'll do whatever it takes to own one of these cars. Nobody warns prospective Prius buyers, "don't test drive one unless you're ready to put down a bunch of money to buy it, because you will want to." If I had to buy a non-EV car again, I'd probably look at Priuses because efficiency pleases me, Toyota has a good reputation, and their stuff is pretty reliable, but it's not particularly compelling. For a lot of people, saving money on gas is the main reason to even consider a Prius. It's not even in most people's top 10 for a Model 3. Note that with a whopping 22 miles of electric range, the Prius Prime is far from a Model 3 competitor. Toyota seems to be betting on hydrogen rather than batteries, for reasons I've yet to comprehend, so I'd say their Model 3 competitor is the Mirai. Although I don't know why anyone would ever buy a Mirai.
- maxsilver 10y ago> Toyota seems to be betting on hydrogen rather than batteries, for reasons I've yet to comprehend I suspect this will go down in history as a major misstep. Especially given Toyota's experience / expertise in the space.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>Priuses are kind of boring. (I owned one for a while so I hope I'm not too clueless on this.) They work, they're reliable, they're cheap to run, but few people come back from a Prius test drive thinking, holy shit, I'll do whatever it takes to own one of these cars. The bumper sticker on my roommate's Prius goes... "Hey, cool Prius!" -Nobody
- cpprototypes 10y agoI don't understand why Toyota is not the leader in plugin hybrids. They had such a big lead in hybrid tech and the next natural step was plugin hybrid. Imagine a RAV4 or Highlander plugin hybrid with 50 mile range. The demand would be incredible. The marketing would be so easy, "Drive your SUV to get groceries with zero gas! Save money, help the environment, and drive a big car! win-win-win for everyone!" A SUV like this would fit so well with the suburban lifestyle in the US. Instead they are wasting time and money on the hydrogen fuel-cell nonsense. How can their management have enough vision to create the Prius and hybrid tech and yet so ignorant of this next obvious step?