3 ms·
I think the concept of some one watching child porn that was produced in the 80's and converted from VHS to DVD is harming a child today is a bit odd one. Don'
by dogma1138 10y ago
I think the concept of some one watching child porn that was produced in the 80's and converted from VHS to DVD is harming a child today is a bit odd one.
Don't get me wrong going after the producers of new material is very important just as it is important to go after the human traffickers that facilitate the production.
- XorNot 10y agoThose children are still alive today. They grow up, become adults, recover from their experiences. They'd be between 30-40 now.
- tbrownaw 10y agoAnd whether the associated videos are or aren't watched has no effect on that. Watching them causes no additional harm.
- Nursie 10y agoThat's callous and fairly nonsensical. We don't say to women who are targeted for 'revenge porn' that they should just live with it.
- nv-vn 10y agoYes, but we also don't consider it a crime to view said revenge porn.
- Ntrails 10y agoJennifer Lawrence declared that everyone who looked at the leaked nudes of her was committing sexual assault against her (or words to that effect). The idea being that by knowingly viewing "private" content without consent is invasive. I'm not sure you can legislate it, but I found her position far more satisfying than "oh no I should never have taken the pics in the first place what a mistake to think I wouldn't be hacked".
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago"we", what's your scope there. Most people would consider it a moral wrong I'd warrant. It's like not a crime only by virtue of being a relatively new thing, and other mitigations like it being difficult to police (is there a point in making crimes you don't police and can't prosecute under).
- Hondor 10y agoThose women are personally identified so they can suffer real world embarrassment from people they know. Children in child porn are probably far more anonymous and untraceable as adults just from their images. I think the idea of being imprisoned for viewing a picture on a website is pretty draconian. We would never stand for it if we weren't so obsessed with vilifying sexual deviants. The argument that consumers fuel the market for producers to abuse children surely fails when there's no payment being made. Perhaps the crime should be limited to paying for it, a bit like why we don't allow payment for organ donation.
- throwanem 10y ago> The argument that consumers fuel the market for producers to abuse children surely fails when there's no payment being made. Does it? In warez rings, new releases are the surest route to high reputation and broad access to content. I don't see an a priori reason why the same might not be true for other sorts of illicit content, including this.
- kahrkunne 10y agoRevenge porn will to me always be a copyright issue, and being one, it's up to those women (and men) to sue when they find someone violating their copyright.
- Hondor 10y agoHalf the time the copyright will belong to the abusive ex partner who photographed them. You don't own your own image.
- crottypeter 10y agoAre you saying that if you were abused in the 80s, you would be fine with people watching footage of it today for kicks?
- throwanem 10y agoI think that's unduly reductive. He seems instead to be saying that if you were abused in the 80s, you should just get over the thought of people watching footage of it today for kicks. Which is an interesting viewpoint, to be sure. I wonder whether he'd say the same to an adult victim of rape whose abuse was videoed and passed around for other people to get off on. That's a pretty close parallel, but it never seems to turn up in discussions like these, and I wonder why that is.
- tbrownaw 10y agoIt seems to me that distributing such videos would have far more in common with defamation than with the original abuse. Merely having or watching them... is probably bad and wrong but not something that ought to actually be legally punishable.
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>"Watching them causes no additional harm." // If I knew of images of me being raped as a child it would be a severe harm for me, albeit non-physical, to know that others were even now masturbating watching my defilement. Indeed I'd find it disturbing if someone were doing that to my image now, no matter if that image were pornographic or not. Now of course you may not share the same feelings as me, but thankfully such laws do protect others who do share those feelings and are in a position to be harmed in this way. Even far lesser cases of stigmatisation can be harmful, an image of one being non-sexually humiliated can cause genuine mental harm long after the initial production of that image. Is there nothing in your past that you wouldn't mind people seeing a picture of now? I got shit on by a swift [bird] the other day, it didn't bother me but I wouldn't want the image of me covered in bird-shit to be published in the paper for people to laugh at; personally I wouldn't be too bothered but it would certainly be a source of displeasure. I think we'll agree that's at the de minimis end of the scale of 'images that one might find humiliating'. FWIW lack of empathy for the suffering of others, as this appears to be, is an element of sociopathy.
- sevenless 10y agoWould it be better if they were dead? It's hard to take these kinds of rationalizations seriously. Simply, most people in our society find this sort of pornography revolting, and the law, which reflects public outrage, has banned it. We didn't reach that outrage from evidential reasoning. Moral revulsion is an irreducible position, and it's not subject to dispute. Likewise, we've never had a rigorous experiment to test whether murder should be illegal or not. That isn't how laws get made.
- syshum 10y agoThe problem with the public outrage however is that is makes any rational discussion almost impossible When the topic of child porn comes up, emotion takes over and logic goes away. One of the largest problems with child porn is the actual definition of child porn. To most people when they hear of child porn, they think of a Person under the age of puberty being forced to engage in a sex act with an adult person. However 2 17 year olds having sex and video taping it is also child porn, they can (and have been) charged with producing, and distributing said child porn Many many many teens were arrested and convicted before states starting passing exceptions to the law, and many states today it is still illegal for a 17year old person to send a nude photo of themselves to another 17year old person, haven forbid a 17 year and 364 day old person send picture to a 17 year and 366 day year old person....
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoYes, a lot of "child porn" charges are deeply stupid. When we talk about child porn rings and websites, we are not talking about those. We are talking about the "raping 8-year-olds" kind.
- syshum 10y agoYou believe this to be case because you are conditioned by the FBI to believe this is the case. Do you know that every image on this server was the "raping 8-year-olds" kind. Did you personally examine every image?
- pavel_lishin 10y agoIt might normalize child pornography in someone's mind. They could keep watching it long enough to the point where it just seems like another genre, albeit the only genre that works for them. They could start manufacturing their own, to join other rings and trade. I know it's all maybe's and could-be's, but they're maybe's and could-be's that ruin children's lives.
- Retric 10y agoIt could also work in the other direction preventing people from acting out. If you look at one path you can probably find people that became more violent from playing grand theft auto. But, looking at the other path more (or less) people may become less violent from playing GTA. As such it's the net effect that's important.
- Taek 10y agoMost of the academic research I am familiar with suggests fairly strongly that the legalization of pornography and child pornography is correlated with a reduced rate of rape and child molestation. http://m.phys.org/news/2010-11-legalizing-child-pornography-linked-sex.html http://m.phys.org/news/2010-11-legalizing-child-pornography-... https://www.springer.com/about+springer/media/springer+select?SGWID=0-11001-6-1042321-0 https://www.springer.com/about+springer/media/springer+selec...
- Hondor 10y agoThat's been the argument against porn in general, and against strip clubs and against prostitution. Without good science behind it, it's just more made-up political rationalizing. You could equally argue the opposite that having access to porn satisfies people so they don't need to use real children. Without science, we can't know. I recently saw an interview with a conservative Indian figure about porn where one man said "I'm not harming anyone by watching porn in my room" and the conservative man responded with "You might become corrupted and turn into a sex maniac". It sounded like hilariously backward thinking, but that's still how many people think of child porn.
- nylsaar 10y ago
- OneTimePatrick 10y agoIts not about the children. Never was. This is just where society originates from, instincts allowing for the forming of social contracts. For example if you exchanged resources with another party (your wife) for drugs and hugs, both sides would want for this contract to last. So you need a third party, which can be forced by both sides to enforce the contract. Enter the pedophiles and gays. Your wife is going to make certain you hate them and she can switch of that hate, via sanctioning there existence (e.g. church/political inclination). That instinct-switch is as important to her, as beauty is to you. Now, ten years into a cellphone society, where even thought offenders soon will be blatant obvious by constant NN observation all that remains are the instincts. The function is gone, but the gears of this bio-machinery still churn on. I miss those days, where i still felt burning hatred for some Gears and was involved in affairs of the species in general. Life was so much easier if one just glued arguments to what one feels. I looked into this whole messy affair, because one of those bastards tried to get on my younger brother when i was young. And for such there should be punishment, even a lifetime in prison. But though crimes, like a deprecated bio-machine, masturbating to a Victorian child-labour-sweatshop , to prosecute those is foolish.
- sdoering 10y agoDoes this comment read like written by a (not very well programmed) NLP script - or is it only me not understanding a single bit about what the (alleged) author tries to convey?
- Freak_NL 10y agoI always wonder if these kind of comments (they seem common amongst conspiracy theory debaters and on-line political extremists) are ever understood by any of their peers, or if it is just the author. It bewilders me that this comment makes perfect sense in someone's mind.
- mirimir 10y agoParent is arguing that sexual assault of children is evil, but viewing CP is OK. There's also something about enforcement of heterosexual monogamy through scapegoating. And a general misogynistic undertone. Yes?
- rifung 10y agoI suspect that this is not due to there being anything morally wrong with what they are doing but that instead of going after the perpetrators, which might be very difficult, we target the economy which pushes them to commit the crimes in the first place. Although it might be imperfect, from what I understand sometimes this is the best way to get results. In a way it's similar to prostitution, where there might be nothing morally wrong with selling or buying sex, but it (potentially?) promotes human trafficking. I doubt that'd the only reason it's illegal though, at least in the US.
- j_jochem 10y agoIt's illegal in the US because it goes against protestant religious morals.
- a3n 10y agoI think it's similar to ivory resale. It's illegal to sell ivory, and other endangered species products, even though the particular animal may have been killed before a ban. Because the market itself attracts new product.