8 ms·
That's an unrealistic approach CIs and undercover agents are needed to break apart crime syndicates because otherwise you'll end up arresting the "street level"
by dogma1138 10y ago
That's an unrealistic approach CIs and undercover agents are needed to break apart crime syndicates because otherwise you'll end up arresting the "street level" peddlers and nothing more.
Now as far as entrapment goes there are legal definitions for it under most cases law enforcement isn't allowed to change the outcome of an event.
For example it is ok for an undercover officer to sell you drugs in a sting operation but it is not ok to come to you and convince you to do drugs and then sell them to you.
For the most part wether the fbi was operating this server or not the people who visit the server came there out of their own free will in an attempt to acquire child pornography.
If the fbi did not operate the server they would still have acquired it just from a different source.
The ATF sting was a pretty shitty operation with dubious legal backing but it's not an case for not running intelligence gathering or sting operation, it's just evidence that they should be planned and executed better and that certain restrictions should apply especially in cases where public safety might be put at risk.
- pixelbash 10y ago> If the fbi did not operate the server they would still have acquired it. I'm a little dubious of this brand of logic. The one that goes if X was not supplied they would just get it from the <potentially slightly harder to find &/or riskier> place. Perhaps, but surely the point is to reduce the incentive by making it harder/riskier - as making it impossible is generally not a viable option?
- caf 10y agoSurely this sort of thing does make it riskier, because now the thought must be there that "perhaps this site is run by the FBI too?"
- trendia 10y agoThat argument would be irrelevant if we just made drugs legal in the first place.
- syshum 10y agoLegal Protections against entrapment are very minimal and not what people think. FBI routinely creates, plots, then recruits people for made up terrorism plots, then arrests them The DEA, in partnership with the ATF, recently ran a operation where they recruited people to rob fake stash houses, then arrested the people that were coerced into the plot Entrapment is often used in prostitution stings as well. None of these instances are tossed by the courts, entrapment is very much alive and well in the legal system >>>>For the most part wether the fbi was operating this server or not the people who visit the server came there out of their own free will in an attempt to acquire child pornography. While true, there are some very significant problems with this. For decades now the basis of the law against viewing child pornography is that each time the image is viewed the child is victimized. Thus by running the server for even 1 second the FBI was, according to the law, victimizing children in order to catch criminals. If you then claim is no children were actually harmed by the FBI's action then one has to start looking at the very foundation of the Child Porn laws. Personally I think the ethical and moral position (and should be the obvious one) is that the FBI should not, under any circumstances, be distributing child porn. Period. Edit: Sources for above can be found in this comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12432737 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12432737
- dogma1138 10y agoI think the concept of some one watching child porn that was produced in the 80's and converted from VHS to DVD is harming a child today is a bit odd one. Don't get me wrong going after the producers of new material is very important just as it is important to go after the human traffickers that facilitate the production.
- FireBeyond 10y ago"For the most part wether the fbi was operating this server or not the people who visit the server came there out of their own free will in an attempt to acquire child pornography." That was one of the core questions here - why logins went up 350% under the control of the FBI. Was there any advertising, inducements? And "part of the role of of maintaining a non-suspicious facade was uploading new material for members".
- syshum 10y agoI believe that was answered, the FBI simply ran it on better and faster hardware, with better uptime. I do not believe the FBI continued to operate it as is on the criminals hardware, I believe they took possession of the "server" then likely imaged it and spun up a new instance of the site on the FBI own servers, these servers likely had much better specs, and a much better connection to the internet.
- CamperBob2 10y agoThat's an unrealistic approach CIs and undercover agents are needed to break apart crime syndicates because otherwise you'll end up arresting the "street level" peddlers and nothing more. Too bad. Police work isn't supposed to be easy. If it is, that means you're living in a police state.
- throwanem 10y agoI love this casual implicit assumption that the existence of large-scale crime syndicates with nothing in practice to fear from the law is in no way noxious to society. Tell me more.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- CamperBob2 10y agoSome might say that your description could basically be used as the dictionary entry for "police." It's been suggested that they're the best-armed gang on the streets, if not the best-disciplined. They're certainly beyond the reach of the law, at least by the standards the rest of us are held to.
- throwanem 10y ago"Some might say"..."it's been suggested". What do you say? What do you suggest?
- CamperBob2 10y agoOverall, I think the police catch a lot of heat and resentment for the actions of their political bosses. Like corporations and unions, a community usually gets the police force it deserves. Unfortunately, that's no consolation to the individual citizens who cross paths with them. A good start on repairing relations with the police would involve holding them to higher standards of behavior than the rest of us are expected to exhibit, instead of lower ones. I think most good cops would agree with that basic sentiment, since they're the ones who behave as if it were already the case. Ultimately, though, when the government decides to launch an impossible war on drugs, terror, pornography, or some other abstract noun, the police will have to do the inevitable dirty work, and they will have to take much of the blame for the consequences. The real problem here isn't the FBI agents running the servers, but the administrative and legislative bosses they answer to.
- l33tbro 10y agoExactly. It's not a one size-fits-all deal here. We're talking about a honeypot that is only accessed by people knowingly harming the welfare of others - as opposed to harming themselves (which is why I think drug honeypots are terrible, particularly for small quantity, personal use purchases). Entrapment, at least in my mind, just doesn't enter the equation when you're operating in an environment which is difficult to access, siloed from the public, and known to be populated exclusively by dangerous criminals.
- GarrisonPrime 10y agoSit 100 people down in front of a button that will detonate a nuclear weapon in a major city on the other side of the world (where no one they know lives). Tell them to decide whether to push the button or not. If you understand human psychology, I hope you understand how there is an excellent chance at least one person would push the button. Possibly 5 would. Possibly more. Simply because the opportunity is presented to them on a silver platter. Does that mean those people are actively seeking out how to detonate a nuclear weapon? No, of course not. Should we actively seek out people with such "inclinations" and deal with them preemptively? If you say we should, what happens when your particular mental tic is deemed a danger to society? Who deems what is a danger? Are you so sure you are entirely safe? So were many people in societies of ages past, under Mao, Stalin, Hitler, etc.
- throwanem 10y agoYour counterfactual is inapplicable. We're not talking about people who just stumbled over an opportunity one day. We're talking about people who went looking, and many of whom employed strong opsec in so doing. That doesn't happen by accident.
- collyw 10y agoIts quite easy to stumble upon dodgy search results without trying. Watersports for example often comes up with search results that are nothing to do with what I am looking for. Paddles.net used to be a spanking fetish site (I was looking for a kayak magazine when I discovered that). An ex-collegue said he attended a talk where they explained that images are often hidden under layers in a word document. You may be unaware that you have illegal on your machine.
- throwanem 10y agoAgain, we're not talking about something that happened by accident, or about sexual interests which are somewhat abstruse but entirely lawful to pursue. I'm not sure what you imagine it adds to the discussion to raise points that aren't germane to the matter at hand. But perhaps they are and I merely fail to see how. Perhaps you'll elucidate the connection.
- awqrre 10y agoPeople downloading from the FBI's servers would be synonym to "street level" by your standard (not child porn producers)