12 ms·
Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit
- chvid 10y agoNo way that the EU is going to remove the UK from its single market; the rest of EU is far too dependent on demand from the UK economy.
- jerven 10y agoI think that the EU will. The UK economy is a significant part of the EU economy but the interests of continental governments are now aligned against the UK. They are basically all thinking what can we get out of the UK, their horsetrading has started and the UK has a lot less horses to trade. There are just to many people the UK has to please at once to make the exit smooth for the UK. But for the next 2.5 years you wont really see it. In 2.5 years the crisis will start. Just like the Swiss are only now starting to sweat.
- polotics 10y agocould you clarify what you mean about the swiss?
- barrkel 10y agoThe Swiss have a more direct democracy than most, and recently voted to limit free travel - trouble is, free travel is a condition of free market access, and with this vote, they're going to lose that. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jul/03/eu-swiss-single-market-access-no-free-movement-citizens https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jul/03/eu-swiss-singl...
- 1wd 10y agoThe Swiss still try to find a compromise that is compatible with free movement. http://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/immigration-vote-_sommaruga-admits-major-eu-concession-is--unrealistic-/42420448 http://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/immigration-vote-_sommaruga-admi...
- Create 10y agofreedom of movement shall entail the abolition of any discrimination based on nationality between workers of the Member States as regards employment, remuneration and other conditions of work and employment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_movement_for_workers_in_the_European_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_movement_for_worker...
- 1wd 10y agoAs I understand it, even though the "informal proposal" is about "prioritising local workers over foreign ones" the actual proposal only requires informing the regional unemployment offices of open jobs, which might(?) not violate freedom of movement.
- Create 10y agoThe issue is the following: In February 2014, the Swiss voted in a referendum to introduce quotas for all migrants in Switzerland. The referendum, which requires Switzerland to have annual quotas for immigrants, does not take effect immediately but requires the Swiss government to implement a quota system within three years. Nothing to do with regional unemployment offices.
- 1wd 10y agoRight, the current proposal tries to implement that referendum in a "light" way. The regional unemployment office measure would be step 2, and only in step 3 might the actual quotas come up, with explicit approval by the EU only. https://www.parlament.ch/en/services/news/Pages/sda-spk-n-2016-09-02.aspx https://www.parlament.ch/en/services/news/Pages/sda-spk-n-20...
- flexie 10y agoNot at all. The UK is a 65 million population stagnant economy that derived most of its strength from the globalization it now wants to part from. It is likely to go to a 60 or 55 million population depressed economy in a few decades if Brexit really happens and foreigners and maybe Scotland leave. There are 450 million in the remaining Union and plenty of countries wanting to join. EU's growth will come from enlargement and from increasing demand in Central and Eastern European member states. EU will have to set an example and in the eyes of many Europeans the Brits must suffer from their foolish choice.
- vesinisa 10y agoThat's more like UK's own decision. Both EU and UK benefit from UK in the single market, and I am sure if UK so desires they can leave the EU but stay part of the single market (Norwegian model). That just makes the whole point of the referendum completely moot, since almost all the rules that were so berated by the Leave Campaign will continue to apply - greatest difference being that UK loses its say to affect the future direction of the single market regulation.
- barrkel 10y agoIt's not politically possible to retain single market access in any deal with the UK. The UK government can't sell the required package that retains access to the single market, and the EU can't reduce the price of the package without disintegrating - every other country would love single market access without harmonizing rules that prevent beggar-thy-neighbour policies etc. The biggest irony in all of this is that many working class brexiters were voting against globalization, yet more globalization is exactly where the Tory brexiters are going to sail.
- lispm 10y agoEverybody can trade with the EU. One does not need to be in the single market. China trades with the EU, a lot, without being a member. It's just that the single market makes it a lot easier to offer services, set up business, have reliability, move around ... in a region of 500 million people.
- woliveirajr 10y agoTL;DR: if japanese companies suffer losses in EU or other markets that import from the UK, since Brexit might have impact in taxes, they might reconsider the headquarters location and then move to continental EU.
- vermooten 10y agoThe knuckle-draggers who voted to leave the EU won't care about threats like this - they'll just use hate speech to dismiss it. Downvote me by all means :)
- martinko 10y agoThe bottom line is that it would be economic suicide to leave the single market, and both sides of the debate know this. If they do leave the EU it will mainly be a proforma move and their single market status will be affected less, if at all.
- ZenoArrow 10y agoI won't downvote you but I will question your choice of terms. You do realise there were rational arguments for wanting to leave the EU? It wasn't all about racism.
- michaelbuddy 10y agoIt wasn't about 'racism' at all. That is just what remainers wanted to get out as their media message because it's a typical leftist strategy.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoIt was about racism in the sense of blaming immigrants for the UK's own political failures. The UK has some of the worst infrastructure, least effective education, most unaffordable housing, least secure jobs, and least effective and generous social spending of any other major EU economy. This is not the fault of the EU, or of immigrants - it's the fault of government policy in the UK. Part of that policy has been to encourage immigration to keep wages down for UK nationals. The people who run this scam are the same as the people who play the race card politically. They benefit from both sides - cheap labour, and political control of the narrative. It's immensely cynical, but depressingly effective.
- alva 10y ago
- jerven 10y agoThe full text can be found here. http://www.mofa.go.jp/files/000185466.pdf http://www.mofa.go.jp/files/000185466.pdf Japans request is basically "Please don't Brexit or if you must pretend that you did, but don't really..." Brexit, will lead to an unforced reevaluation of the UKs governmental system by its people. The entire Brexit concept is the most radical development ever started by a conservative party in government.
- ZenoArrow 10y agoThinking about this from the perspective of the Japanese, they've got little to lose by making this kind of threat. Either the British government give them a deal that is just as good or better than they have now to encourage them to stay, or they give them a good excuse to move their manufacturing elsewhere. The real issue is when a community is overly reliant on jobs from a small number of employers. That gives the employers more leverage when it comes to extortion tactics like this.
- woliveirajr 10y agoDon't think this was some kind of extortion. More a previous warning, like "don't think that japan is in some retaliation by moving our companies, we just asked about taxes earlier and you didn't care"
- ZenoArrow 10y agoIt's not like this is pre-Brexit. The decision to leave the EU has already been made. The decision can't be ignored by the British government as it would be political suicide. I'm sure the Japanese government are aware of this. The question is then, why make these statements at all? The only explanation that makes sense to me is opportunism on behalf of Japanese corporations. Threatening to leave gives you bargaining power you wouldn't otherwise have.
- anonymousDan 10y agoNot really, there is still plenty of room for manoeuvre as to what exactly should be prioritised during the brexit negotiations. The Japanese are well within their rights to warn about the potential implications of a hard brexit.
- ZenoArrow 10y agoI'd argue that the Japanese corporations don't care what form of Brexit is followed, so long as it doesn't hurt their bottom line. Mitigation against potential losses could come in the form of tax breaks or other benefits negotiated with the British government.
- martinko 10y agoIndeed the most likely scenario appears to be the 'Norwegian model', where the UK in essence remains in the single market and thus will have to follow European regulations but will have a much smaller say when it comes to the future direction of the EU. They will, however, have officially left the EU so the leave camp can pat their shoulders over their Pyrrhic victory.
- Numberwang 10y agoUK Will never be allowed to have 'The Norwegian Model' set up by EU. That would have lot's of other countries asking for the same. UK is in for a long winter on GoT type scale.
- Scarblac 10y agoWhy would other countries want that model? It seems to be strictly worse than full membership.
- edko 10y agoI also wonder why Norway wants that model?
- gonvaled 10y agoActually, Norway itself mentioned that their deal is worse that EU membership: the politicians would prefer to join the EU, but this is not an easy sell to the electorate, so they do not bother.
- jcranmer 10y agoMost likely fisheries. The EU's fishery policy is traditionally held as horrible, and Norway and Iceland both have relative large fishing economies and better-maintained fisheries than the EU CFP.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y ago
- TillE 10y agoIt's really incredible that three months after the vote, we still haven't the slightest idea what post-Brexit UK will look like. Will they go for the EEA (the least destructive option), or will they - as Theresa May threatens - sacrifice everything just to limit immigration? Three months after the biggest decision in decades, and the subject is barely even being talked about seriously in the UK. I don't understand it.
- martinko 10y agoI think everyone in any position of power understands that they must remain in the single market - now the only question is how to position / sell this to the electorate.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoI don't think May and the Cabinet do. All the noises seem to suggest the real priority is xenophobia - i.e. immigration. ...Which is a purely political strategy to capture the continued support of leave voters - exactly the people whose lives will be destroyed when trade dries up. The problem is that the typical leave voter understands immigration because they have direct personal experience of immigrants. But leave voters don't understand the intricacies of trade deals, or the incredible damage poor trading conditions can do to an economy. May does, which is why she has been warning of "tough times ahead." If she was interested in continuing trade on realistic terms she wouldn't be saying that. My suspicion at this point is that the Tory party is willing to sacrifice the economic future of the UK in order to remain in power.
- dogma1138 10y agoThe typical leave voter lives in the areas with least immigration. The areas with any substantial immigration either from the EU or elsewhere voted remain.
- barrkel 10y agoThe places with the least immigration are usually the poorest places most fearful of immigrants taking their jobs (specifically, lowering their wages - and they're probably right) and least optimistic about the future. They are usually remnants of the industrial revolution getting marginalized by globalization (mostly China).
- michaelbuddy 10y agothis "warning" was totally unnecessary and those kinds of acts go without saying anyway. Whoever wrote it up doesn't realize that this attempt at posturing makes them looks weak rather than strong.
- martinko 10y agoI wouldn't say that this was a move to make them look strong. Its a plain reminder to British decision makers as well as people that there will be economic consequences if they decide to leave the single market. This is not a threat - pure and simple, companies that operate from the UK now will have a harder time post-exit.
- michaelbuddy 10y agoDidn't say it was a threat. The headline said it was a warning.
- showmustgoon 10y agoAre there any Japanese lobby or interest groups in the UK like the case in the USA? Any Brits to provide input about this point would be highly appreciated.
- randomname2 10y agoGuardian analysis: "Japan's Brexit demands range from possible to fanciful" (https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/sep/04/japan-brexit-demands-range-from-possible-to-fanciful https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/sep/04/japan-brexit-d...)
- alva 10y ago"With regard to unskilled workers, Japanese businesses rely on inexpensive labour from Eastern Europe in the manufacturing and agricultural industries in the UK" What a hypocritical demand from the Japanese. They have one of the strictest set of immigration policies in the world, largely for the sake of national homogeneity at the expensive of their economy. They believe that is a worthwhile sacrifice for them, why not us?
- pliny 10y agoI don't see the hypocrisy here, they're not taking a principled stand in favour of immigration by threatening to boycott the UK if they stop allowing immigrants, they're warning the UK that their business there may be unprofitable if they no longer have access to cheap labour.
- alva 10y agoThe warning itself, over concerns that their investments will suffer is totally fair. The hypocrisy however as I see it is that Japan is asking us to make a specific sacrifice for economic growth, that it absolutely will not do itself on principle.
- anonymousDan 10y agoI think the point is that some brexiteers are going around in lala land claiming that there will be negligible economic consequences to leaving the free trade zone.
- kalleboo 10y ago> They have one of the strictest set of immigration policies in the world [citation needed] My experience is that Japan has very permissive immigration for skilled labor (anyone with a college degree) or social ties (marriage). Far more so than e.g. the USA or Europe. They just don't have a green card lottery for unskilled labor (like the US) or open borders for refugees (like Europe).
- 10y ago
- matthewmorgan 10y agoDo people who keep talking 'trade deals' and 'single markets' actually know what they're talking about? This video is instructive https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=leKEUT1TiLU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=leKEUT1TiLU
- nbevans 10y agoA few thousand jobs that Japanese automakers bring to the UK is nothing compared to the jobs that can be created as a result of a successful Brexit. Jaguar Land Rover continues to go from strength to strength... how about turning the tables so we are actually selling more cars to Japan than they sell to us? Scary thought eh? That's what Brexit is about. It's about daring to think big. Like Great Britain used to do for centuries.
- alkonaut 10y agoYup, that's how jobs are made. Make some good cars. Back out of the single market where you can sell them easily. Hope the Japanese will buy more to offset the losses in EU sales. I don't think the reason more Japanese cars are sold to the UK than vice versa is the single market.
- msh 10y agoYou know that Jaguar is owned by a Indian company, right?
- Create 10y agoA Modest Proposal brexit means brexit: since English is not native to any remaining EU member country, drop it as an EU working language. With special regard to the European Central Bank (banking passport system). Irish could still remain as an official language^1, but the semi-official Welsh would need to go too. ^1 For Preventing The Children of Poor People in Ireland From Being a Burden to Their Parents or Country, and For Making Them Beneficial to The Public
- peteretep 10y ago> since English is not native to any remaining EU > member country Might be worth doing your research.
- Create 10y agoDon't be so Swift with those downvotes^1. You are suggesting, that Malta^2 is to command the ECB? ^1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_the_European_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_the_European_Unio... -- working is not the same as official ^2 or Ireland for that matter... Second thought: maybe English could merit a semi-official status though (if May succeeds). But most certainly not a working language (neither an official one).
- peteretep 10y ago> Don't be so Swift It wasn't that funny the first time. > working is not the same as official English is both an official language of Ireland, and a native language of Ireland. Irish is the third most commonly spoken language in Ireland, after English and Poland. A full 60% of the population of ROI considers itself to be incompetent at speaking Irish. Malta is indeed represented on the ECB's Governing Council.
- subzeross 10y agoEU is like a CANCER which slowly gets all over the body. UK should stay away from this deceased organisation.
- sjtgraham 10y agoThey really should have produced a television drama like 1984's Threads before the referendum, but substituting worst case economic Brexit implications for nuclear holocaust.
- hackuser 10y agoPeople supporting bad policies like to say there are no bad consequences. You hear this about Brexit, climate change, bankrupting the government, violence and war, etc. It's the same rhetorical tool used for a lot of propaganda: You can lie in a moment; it takes hours or days for people to gather the evidence to disprove it. (To disarm this propaganda: It's easy to construct nonsense that sounds plausible - even to you, smart person; don't let your ego be your weakness - and professionals make a study and art of it. Don't take anything seriously unless it has serious evidence and research behind it in the first place; the first claim has the burden of proof. Also, notice that their real argument is in the unspoken assumptions behind it, how the issue is defined and framed.) Here's why I think it works: Most policy consequences are difficult to notice if you are uninformed. You can't know nationwide unemployment, GDP growth, or climate change by looking around (with some exceptions). Western economies and societies are huge and complex; often changes are subtle and slow; often they affect one set of people - probably not you - more than another set of people. Finally, in an environment that complex, it's hard to provably connect outcomes to actions (is that hurricane due to climate change? did people get cancer because of the factory's carcinogen or because of bad luck?), and the propagandists can pump out enough lies to raise doubts in people's minds (look up "FUD").
- monk_e_boy 10y agoMost people I talked to were well informed. I think a lot of people were happy to stick it to big business, most of who pay less tax than a local chippy. We felt Brexit was about control, we wanted more of it. When the USA told us off for wanting more freedom it felt a little weird... but, but, you're the land of the free. We just want to be able to control immigration. We want control from Brussels.
- threatofrain 10y agoBrexit will do nothing for the fact that big businesses pay less taxes than smaller businesses. What is the most robust connection linking EU departure with reigning in big business practice? Or framed another way, what is the most robust relationship linking Brexit with the decline of big business dominance? How is the marketplace going to become more egalitarian now? Are people seriously predicting a more egalitarian and regulated UK business environment due to exiting the EU? As far as I understand, the UK's membership in the EU, along with Ireland, were part of the problem in helping businesses lower their tax rate, such as with the Isle of Man, which is technically not part of the UK, and is so wielded by the British government to help big businesses evade taxes and regulations.
- georgeecollins 10y agoThis is sad for the UK, but scary as an American facing an election where people want to build a wall and "make America great again." Like Brexit, the rhetoric sounds good to some, but those speaking have no idea how to implement what they are talking about or the likely consequences. I am not trying to make an argument for or against conservatism. I am saying we need to ask politicians to explain their policies in detail.