4 ms·
It isn't, there's fanous people like Warren Buffet of course, but I personally know of 3 individuals in investing forums who post all their trades and handily b
by mistermann 10y ago
It isn't, there's fanous people like Warren Buffet of course, but I personally know of 3 individuals in investing forums who post all their trades and handily beat indexes over long periods.
- emodendroket 10y agoSince you mentioned him: http://finance.yahoo.com/news/buffett-most-mportant-investment-lesson-211351601.html http://finance.yahoo.com/news/buffett-most-mportant-investme... > Nearly a decade ago, Warren Buffett made a million-dollar bet: that by investing in a completely unmanaged, broad-market low-fee index fund, he could beat the gains earned by a high-powered hedge fund with a team of managers at the helm. His opponent was Protege Partners, LLC, a New York City hedge fund with $3.5 billion in assets under management. [...] > His simple Vanguard S&P 500 (VFINX) fund has delivered returns more than 40 points higher than those of the hedge fund. “I believe this is the most important investment lesson in the world,” he said.
- icebraining 10y agoBy the way, the bet is online at http://longbets.org/362/ http://longbets.org/362/
- bluGill 10y agoWarren Buffet has so much money in his control that he cannot beat the market - his very investments change the value of the good companies he invests in - and not in his favor. He can make small bets of companies, but even if the bets all pay off (they will not - even great investors make mistakes) it isn't enough to be very significant.
- falsestprophet 10y agoHis scale also works in his favor for some transactions like municipal bond insurance or paying cash to acquire Fortune 100 companies.
- yfhsjjskc 10y agoSo he beat one particular hedge fund, that hardly proves that "essentially no traders beat the performance of index funds long-term."
- emodendroket 10y agohttp://www.cnbc.com/2015/06/26/index-funds-trounce-actively-managed-funds-study.html http://www.cnbc.com/2015/06/26/index-funds-trounce-actively-... > Pity the active fund manager. > More dollars have flowed to index strategies that track a market benchmark, such as the S&P 500 index, partly because such funds typically have lower costs than active funds and more investors believe that stock-picking managers can't regularly beat the financial markets. > Now a new Morningstar study, released this week at the Morningstar Investment Conference, finds that actively managed funds lagged their passive counterparts across nearly all asset classes, especially over a 10-year period from 2004 to 2014.
- yfhsjjskc 10y agoThis evidence all suffers from the problem that you are trying to prove a very difficult claim. Information about averages won't help you here.
- emodendroket 10y ago"Essentially nobody" is admittedly not well-defined, but I don't take it to mean that a handful of guys doing better would disprove it (and in any case have trouble finding any data points in favor of the opposite position).
- yfhsjjskc 10y agoI claim that the top 20% (as specified in the headline) could not be reasonably described as "essentially nobody". And the article you linked two posts ago found that more than 20% of funds beat the market.
- goodcanadian 10y agoWarren Buffett is not a day trader. To paraphrase, "My favourite holding period is forever." He is a good data point to demonstrate that long term investors can beat the indices. Most don't, however, and it is my understanding that day trading is even worse. Just as there are professional poker players that can consistently make money, I'm sure there are some day traders that do very well, but it is not a skill that most people have.
- emodendroket 10y agoHe is also typically actively involved in companies he invests in, which sets him apart from somebody sitting around on e-Trade in a pretty big way.
- kasey_junk 10y agoPeople actually misstate the argument regularly. It is of course possible to beat the index over long periods, but there is little evidence that there is any skill that allows you to do it. That is, could those 3 individuals write down a prescriptive algorithm that allows someone to replicate their results ahead of time? Another way to describe the problem is, given the same number of bots, randomly picking tades, as members of a trading forum, how many would beat the index? Is the number more than 3?
- vonmoltke 10y agoI think you also have to define "the index". There are dozens of indexes on the NYSE alone, and many come with legitimate questions about how well they actually represent the market. In that sense, I think it is possible to choose (and not luck into) a better basket of stocks than what goes into the indexes. Of course, it isn't easy.
- emodendroket 10y agoIf there's no evidence that beating the market depends on any particular skill, that would seem to be saying it's essentially a matter of chance. If that is the case then it stands to reason that, as the period of time observed grows longer, it becomes less and less likely for anyone to beat the market.
- lordnacho 10y agoLink?