5 ms·
I think the point of the "either works or it doesn't" is a comparison versus analog. With an analog signal you could get slightly better results by getting bet
by matwood 17y ago
I think the point of the "either works or it doesn't" is a comparison versus analog. With an analog signal you could get slightly better results by getting better cables (or worse with worse cables). If you have a poor digital cable it flat out doesn't work. If the cable you're using works, buying a more expensive cable isn't going to make it work any better. Either the 1s and 0s made it from the source to the destination or they didn't.
No one is claiming that there isn't engineering that needs to happen to make a digital signal reliably travel from the source to the receiver.
- micks56 17y agoI think your understanding of cables is off. All signals are analog. Every single one. (Actually, I take that back. With the exception of quantum computers, to date, all signals are analog). A "digital" cable doesn't just work or not work. It is possible to receive spurious bit errors for many reasons. For example, you turn up the volume to your awesome surround sound speakers, which causes more current to flow through your speaker wires that happen to be running parallel to your horrible HDMI cable. The increased current causes interference in your low-power HDMI cable, causing bit errors in the transmission.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- axod 17y ago>> "It is possible to receive spurious bit errors for many reasons." Surely that's why there's error correction layered on top? Instead of arguing about what might happen, why not find an HDMI device that'll show you how many unrecoverable bit errors it has detected in the stream... Can't be that hard to do. If my hard disk can send data over a tiny crappy unshielded cheap USB cable without a single bit error, I'd be willing to bet money that an HDMI cable isn't that much different.
- tedunangst 17y agoHDMI doesn't do error correction for video.
- steveklabnik 17y agoIsn't HDMI supposed to do error correction on both sides, though? I could be totally making that up, I thought I remember hearing that a while back.
- Tichy 17y agoThere is this weird thing called error detection/correction.
- tedunangst 17y agowhich HDMI doesn't do.
- Tichy 17y agoHm, no idea, but I find that very hard to believe. I suspect digital transmission of information is almost impossible without error correction. IANAEE, though (I am not an electronics engineer).
- mansr 17y agoHDMI does have error correction. Every 8 bits of video data are sent as 10 bits on the wire.
- ErrantX 17y agough, I hated signals theory at uni... but let me dust off that knowledge... > All signals are analog. I see your reasoning in saying this ("on the wire" etc.); your incorrect though. Not all signals are considered analog (which is important to the point being made) Analog signals are generally susceptible to noise because they are usually non-recoverable; error checking is hard because it is a non-discrete continuous signal. >It is possible to receive spurious bit errors for many reasons. Yes, which is why error checking exists in all these systems. In the context of the wire alone, yes, it is not a case of "it just works". But in the case of the communications subsystem (i.e. the transmitter, medium, receiver) it really does either work or not work :) Ultimately thought the phrase "it's digital; either it works or it doesnt" is making no comment about the actual signal. It's really saying: an expensive cable is not, due to the digital sub-system, likely to make any difference to error rates (or more succinctly: the performance of the error correction is better than the noise affect of the transport medium)
- wwalker3 17y agoThat's still not correct. For HDMI in particular, there's no error correction at all on the video data (though there is on the audio and control data). So if one bit gets flipped in the video data as it goes through the cable, you're going to see that wrong bit on screen. You'd have to have an insanely high bit error rate for your eyes to notice it, but it's there, and it gradually gets worse as the error rate increases. What could flip a bit in a cable? Any number of things. EM interference from outside a badly shielded cable. EM crosstalk between conductors inside a badly designed cable. Signal reflections at badly designed connectors. Basically anything that can happen to any other cable, whether the signal that goes over it is considered to be analog or digital. I assume the reason HDMI applies EC to the audio and control data is that errors in those channels are more noticeable to the user, whereas errors at reasonable rates in the video will mostly sneak by. The HDMI spec at http://www.hdmi.org/download/HDMI_Spec_1.3_GM1.pdf http://www.hdmi.org/download/HDMI_Spec_1.3_GM1.pdf is a great source of information about this.
- ErrantX 17y agoIndeed. However it uses TMDS [1] which is a "blind mans" error reduction technique. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transition_Minimized_Differential_Signaling http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transition_Minimized_Differenti...
- wwalker3 17y agoTotally true. HDMI takes many steps to try to reduce errors to a reasonable rate. In practice, this rate is usually low enough to ignore, even with cheap cables. I was just making the point that there is indeed a progressive degradation in image quality with increasing error rate, even in HDMI.
- jcromartie 17y agoI've had this happen. You see what are called "sparkles" when you get a lot of failures (and it truly looks like sparkling glitter on your TV). It turned out to be the TV's connector more than the cable itself. The same $4 cable worked fine on a replacement set.
- 17y ago
- ghshephard 17y agoClearly you've never had an Ethernet Cable that got caught in a door. Or was terminated poorly. Or doesn't have the insulator sheath under the crimp. Or run parallel to a set of Florescent light ballasts. All of these events can reduce performance on Ethernet without causing it to fail outright. There is a reason why every single TIA/EIA 568 cable plant is carefully tested for things like Near End Cross Talk (NEXT), Latency, Skew, etc.. There is also a reason why there is an entire _discipline_ dedicated to ensuring that the "Digital" signal not only has a channel, but a meticulously crafted one. (See: http://www.linktionary.com/t/tia_cabling.html http://www.linktionary.com/t/tia_cabling.html for details) To reiterates the OP - there is no "Digital Signal" - signals are analog in nature, and they need an analog channel to transmit them. That analog channel needs to be engineered carefully to get the lowest EBR (Error Bit Rate) possible. What's interesting is the Failure case of the Digital CODEC on the other end - some may reduce transmit rate in the presence of an increased EBR resulting from dropped packets. Or some may seize up and cease to function. In the degraded case, having a pristine analog channel from the transmitter to the receiver will certainly result in a better digital signal. There is also the issue of future proofing - We're installing an entire plant of Category 6a cable right now in one of our data centers for a gigabit environment - Category 6a is like the "Monster" version of Category 5e/6 - It seems like a douchey way to do a network install, except when you consider the following - (1) this cable plant will be in use for 10-15 years, (2) We're testing a bunch of Nexus 5010s that will likely make good use of that 6a for 10 Gigabit. So, in addition to passing _today's_ signal flawlessly, it will also pass tomorrow's. This might be an important factor if your HDMI cable is being run through hard to access cabinets/walls. Now, with all that said, it is still probably the case that the $150 Monster Cables (under normal circumstances) don't have a lower EBR than a $10 cable, but, in the face of RF interference, It may actually be a better performer. I don't know, but I wouldn't discard the possibility without a bit of research and education.
- lkjhgvbnm 17y agoBut did you use audiophile, linear crystal aligned cables? And did you install them the correct way round? https://usa.denon.com/ProductDetails/3429.asp https://usa.denon.com/ProductDetails/3429.asp Presumably on ethernet you have to decide if you want the Tx or Rx signal to have the extra digital nuance?
- ghshephard 17y agoNote, it's traditional on HN to add the phrase [EDIT] when making substantive modifications to comments, particularly if someone has already responded to your original comment.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoOT: The site should really help to enforce such niceties. When you edit you should get a "reason for editing" box.