11 ms·
By 2030, 56 countries will have more people aged 65+ than children under 15
- Derpdiherp 10y agoSurely this is a good thing? We (as a species) have been growing exponentially in an unsustainable manner. It'll be tough as we transition into looking after more elderly with less of a young population to support them - but in the long run it's for the best.
- pmyjavec 10y agoTotally agree, although, hopefully they age with the environment in mind. There seems to be whole businesses building around milking elderly people's retirement money. I'm thinking about highly polluting cruise ships etc. Interesting times ahead.
- czechdeveloper 10y agoExactly what i thought. In light of us living unsustainably, we can either decrease consumption, or decrease amount of people living on the planet. Or little bit of both. And if that happens organically, without special policies, the better still.
- c3833174 10y agoTell that to people expecting continuous growth
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoPeople expecting continuous growth are in for a shock at some point, it's just a matter of when.
- Derpdiherp 10y agoPopulation control with the right to children is a very delicate subject and hard sell. My thoughts on the matter was always that nature itself will eventually take care of the numbers if we keep going the way we are without some form of measure to keep control - every population explosion has had it's eventual decline - sharp or smooth. We seem to believe that we're different but we're not. If we self regulate by choice - whether it's the lack of income, lifestyle or a lack of want to have children that has brought us here it's always going to be preferable. As unsavoury as it may be in some regards.
- CaptSpify 10y ago> nature itself will eventually take care of the numbers I don't think most people would disagree. It's just that nature isn't very merciful, and the way it enacts it's policies could lead to a lot of suffering. It'd be much more pleasant if we self-regulated so that nature didn't have to.
- Kenji 10y agoExactly. I always hear people saying "waa waa there need to be more young than old" nice logic mate, let's grow the human population infinitely.
- douche 10y agoThe only way that works, without exponential growth, in this day of modern medicine is if you start "Logan's Run"ing off the old people. Which, I'm going to go out on a wild limb here, is probably not an acceptable solution...
- tremon 10y agoIn the current economic climate, it is not a good thing. Due to the past 50+ years of policy making, a large part of the able-bodied workforce is excluded from contributing to the GDP. And as long as economic policy (both business and government) is still driven by the myopic vision that GDP is all that matters, all those "old people" are a burden, not an asset. In itself, having a more reasonably distributed age distribution is neutral (in my view). But it is a consequence of two good things: the population boom is leveling off, and healthcare has improved tremendously around the globe.
- pjc50 10y ago> a large part of the able-bodied workforce is excluded from contributing to the GDP Could you explain? Recent policy seems to have been about pushing everyone possible into the workforce, even the not-able-bodied. By every means short of actually putting up wages.
- douche 10y agoWe've got almost a third of the US population that has dropped out of the workforce completely[1], with another 5.5% unemployed but still trying. [1] http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/ali-meyer/americans-not-labor-force-exceed-93-million-first-time-627-labor-force http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/ali-meyer/americans-not-...
- marcosdumay 10y agoIt literally means there is high unemployment of young people. It can also be pushed into meaning that young people are mostly barred from effectively investing and creating successful business.
- tremon 10y agoI was referring to pensions and early retirement mainly. Yes, there have been recent efforts to shift the retirement age upwards, and I'm certainly not saying that people shouldn't be allowed to retire at all. But a population-wide cutoff at a certain age seems arbitrary, and I've seen plenty of examples around me of people starting self-employment in their 60s, simply because employers could no longer legally hire them. Of course, the other side of that coin is that there needs to be enough jobs available to employ everyone, and forcing retirement is one way to reduce a labour surplus...
- s_kilk 10y agoOne huge downside would be that older people tend to skew to the more conservative end of the political spectrum, and can end up drowning out the voices of the young. See the age breakdown of the recent Brexit vote for one example. I also remember with the Irish referendum on gay marriage in 2015, there was much worry that the older generations would swing the overall vote to "No", despite the legislation having no impact on them. Worth thinking about: How many Brexit "Leave" voters have simply died of old age in the two months between then and now?
- pc86 10y ago> One huge downside would be that older people tend to skew to the more conservative end of the political spectrum Only a downside if you (a) disagree with them; (b) for whatever reason, feel they are not entitled to their beliefs > and can end up drowning out the voices of the young. Funny how when your opinions are the majority it's democracy, and when they're not it's "voices being drowned out." > Worth thinking about: How many Brexit "Leave" voters have simply died of old age in the two months between then and now? It's not.
- cmdrfred 10y agoYou are correct if everyone gets to vote. If the elderly with little to do all day have an easier time getting to the polls than the working class single mom supporting them, then you have a problem. I say make election day a national holiday. The AARP likely disagrees. You don't even have to do that, I'd make July 4th election day in the states for example.
- nradov 10y agoWhile I don't particularly like the AARP, they haven't said anything against making voting day a national holiday. And with voting by mail it's totally unnecessary anyway. In CA now even postage is free so there are zero obstacles preventing the working class from voting.
- 10y ago
- tcoppi 10y agoDemographic shifts like this and the ensuing competition for limited resources are the kind of things that fuel major wars. It may be the transition that is needed long-term, but we should be very mindful of the way it is actually achieved.
- ekianjo 10y ago> Demographic shifts like this and the ensuing competition for limited resources Less resources are needed if you have less people. Ultimately everyone will benefit from it.
- tcoppi 10y agoThe thing is we don't have less people right now. The population is still growing rapidly, just getting older overall. That is going to lead to a massive grab for limited resources(not just physical like food and basic goods, but time for caretakers, medical services, etc.) that could be massively destabilizing. We've already seen rising food prices recently lead to unrest in poorer regions of the world, that could be only the beginning.
- ekianjo 10y agoI'd just like to remind people that at the beginning of the 20th century many were predicting the doom of Mankind once we would reach one billion folks. Needless to say it did not happen and we went much further than one billion and took care of starvation along the way. Of course there are many reasons for this, but let's not underestimate the resources of mankind to solve its problems.
- tcoppi 10y agoI completely agree, I don't think it will end up being a massive disaster in the long-run, precisely because people will be thinking about how to solve them. Quick dismissal of the potential problems that could result does not help us solve them.
- naasking 10y ago> Surely this is a good thing? We (as a species) have been growing exponentially in an unsustainable manner. Population growth has been slowing due to increases in quality of living, and is set to peak around 2050. Then we'll experience population deflation, which may be even more problematic than inflation.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoIt would be a good thing if not for a policy of covering losses by importing large number of people from struggling societies that many affected countries have adopted. Which BTW makes no sense when you look closer at demographics, since most depopulating areas are rural, but immigrants usually live compactly in countries' largest cities (where also existing youth flocks to), increasing population imbalance in fact. Yes they get total head count stable but at cost of getting everything else wrong.
- dracht 10y agoTell that to (most) EU governments. They are selling mass-immigration as a solution to an aging population.
- 2almalki 10y agoI think its a valid way to solve that problem. In Canada, the STEM programs are filled with 2nd/3rd generation immigrants that were labourers, servers, restaurent workers, etc. These guys/gals go on to get 40-80k salary jobs after uni/college and pay significant taxes WHICH help pay for medical/state pension for the aging populaion
- guard-of-terra 10y agoIt's not solving any problem[1], and Canada is an extreme example as a country and can't be used as a model for (mostly) monocultural countries. 1: First people argue there's no problem with low birth rate, and then people tell that they're solving the problem. Pick one.
- 2almalki 10y agoI'd say there is a problem with low birth rate :)
- icebraining 10y agoAnd that's exactly right: the only way to get more people of working age to a region without increasing the world population is with migration.
- drakonka 10y agoI would tend to agree. Of course having fewer young people to contribute to taking care of old people and such is going to be tough, but governments will need to adapt and find ways to deal with it. The problem of not enough young people to contribute to our worker churn system to me seems far preferable to population growth that our planet cannot sustain.
- mathattack 10y agoI was thinking the same thing. From an environmental point of view, less damage. From an economic point of view, more capital and wealth per person. The only downside is people will need to live longer.
- aiyodev 10y ago> We (as a species) have been growing exponentially in an unsustainable manner. This is a myth. In fact birth rates are decelerating at an alarming rate and actually starting to decrease in some parts of the world. In a couple of decades, population is projected to begin decreasing worldwide. Many governments are creating programs to encourage procreation to try to hold off the inevitable death spiral most countries will experience.
- AlexB138 10y agoWhen I read things like this, I can't help but feel like we're approaching The Behavioral Sink. When I first read about John B. Calhoun's work, I thought it was interesting but sort of moved on. For some reason, it stuck in my mind though, and it rises to the surface often when I read news about the world. For those who don't know, Calhoun's research was around the impact of population growth. He found that mice in a closed environment, among other behaviors, became anti-social, violent, strangely obsessed with grooming and stopped breeding once the population reached a certain size, even disregarding the wellbeing of the young that are born. Obviously we're not in a situation as bad as all that, but it's an interesting light to view today's world in.
- Derpdiherp 10y agoThe mice utopia experiment.. There are a surprising amount of small parallels between it and some of our recent cultural phenomenon. Interesting thought.
- thechao 10y agoWould you mind elaborating? My great grandmother used to laugh at the moral majority's antics---she said that people have been complaining about the moral degeneration of society since she was a small child---in the 1890s.
- Derpdiherp 10y ago"Newer generations born in the now dysfunctional mouse utopia became withdrawn, spending their days grooming obsessively and dedicating their time solely to eating , drinking and sleeping. This generation, for all the emphasis they placed on grooming, would not reproduce. Moreover, these mice were noted to be unintelligent compared to previous generations." Intelligence has surely risen in our population, obesity is becoming a real problem in successful populations. The "selfie" self absorbed cultural shift we're seeing at the moment is another parallel. Whilst we're not cannibalising each other or becoming any more aggressive than we have been in the past (although we are still plenty aggressive), I think we are starting to see some of symptoms for lack of a better term that are highlighted above to some degree or another. Edit - perhaps there are also similarities between the hikikomori NEET lifestyle that's arisen in Japan as well. This is purely an opinion without any statistics to back it up though, I'd be interested to hear counter arguments.
- fwn 10y agoThe only problem is probably the many funding models that assume otherwise, therefore rely on an uneven age distribution with a bigger share of younger participants (like many western pension funds, etc.) While I can imagine that it's not easy to redesign pension funds, but keeping the current systems at all costs is probably ideological by definition.
- sdoering 10y agoWhenever I read things like this. I am reminded of Hans Rosling's "Global population growth, box by box"[1]. The only question is, how to transition to a "steady state economy"[2][3] or "non growth economies", when population really reaches some kind of equilibrium. As growth is the only concept humans for the last tens of thousands of years knew, this transition, while absolutely necessary, will be hard and hurt lots of people I believe. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTznEIZRkLg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTznEIZRkLg [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steady-state_economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steady-state_economy [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutrality_of_money https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutrality_of_money
- 3pt14159 10y agoA steady state economy will never, ever happen. We'll sooner extinguish our planet. The reason is simple: technological progress is a national security matter. It can't be stopped. Even coordinated treatise would be subverted. With technological progress more and more output for the same amount of input is possible. Now you could argue for a steady state population. Or at least for a period of time where we have a steady state population (before starships are prevalent) and I could start to see that happening, but as long as there is intelligence and peace the economy will continue to grow.
- BatFastard 10y agoKnowledge will most likely grow, but with a steady population the only true GDP growth can come from moving people out of poverty and into the higher income brackets. Once everyone is there, what real growth is there?
- snowwrestler 10y agoEven higher income brackets? I don't know what you mean by "true" GDP growth. It feels like you're making some non-standard distinction but not explaining it.
- nradov 10y ago
- rahelzer 10y agoAny problem caused by an aging population cannot be a long-term problem.
- tux1968 10y agoUnless it triggers an event that has lasting consequences beyond their longevity.
- legulere 10y agoTo the contrary, it's getting even worse as longevity rises.
- antisthenes 10y agoBy that logic any problem cannot be a long-term problem because it will be solved at the heat death of the universe.
- jkot 10y ago> While the prospect of longer lives is a good thing, problems arise when a shrinking work force cannot foot the pension bill. Not true. In EU the retirement age is moving as population gets older. By 2040 retirement age could be around 75 years.
- c3833174 10y agoIsn't it great? Work almost all your life. No more grandparents taking care of children while parents work, decreasing the number of families that might have children. Less open positions for young people.
- tcoppi 10y agoYeah, this sounds like a great recipe for a stable economic system and orderly transition to steadier demographics over the next 20-50 years. Edit: An informative graph for the bleak jobs picture for young people this shift is creating in the US: http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/imageroot/2016/07/03/job%20additions%20total%20by%20age_0.jpg http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/im...
- BatFastard 10y agoZerohedge is not a reliable data source IMHO
- tcoppi 10y agoIt's straight from BLS data, throw it into something and graph it yourself if you want http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t09.htm http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t09.htm
- skewart 10y agoThere can be a lot of psychological, emotional, and health benefits to continuing to work in some capacity throughout old age. It gives people a sense of purpose and meaning in their lives. I'm a long way from retirement but I hope to have the kind of career where I work in at least a lightweight way well into old age (my grandfather didn't stop working completely until he was 93). One thing that would probably help would be much shorter work weeks.
- bArray 10y agoIt's humanity correcting the growth rate - it's been well overdue, it's just going to be tough for a little while but we'll manage. If anything, robots could make this a lot better for us. People are relatively content in the West and the rise in living costs are putting people off kids.
- collyw 10y agoSo far we have robots for doing the vacuuming. I don't see why everyone is so optimistic that there things are just around the corner.
- Joof 10y agoI think our robots that do manufacturing or driving are more sophisticated than the ones that vacuum. AI has hit a boom and is producing a lot of potentially useful achievements (that it hadn't before). It wouldn't surprise me if they become more prevelant. Of course, we still need the resources to build them...
- bArray 10y agoExactly, people take for granted the AI that drives Siri and Google talk - these are amazing advances. It's enabled family members who are dislexic to completely transform their ability to engage in technology and the world. Of course driverless cars are s massive feat and I see more robots entering the house soon in less subtle ways.
- Kristine1975 10y agoTitle was changed to "More Old Than Young: A Demographic Shock Sweeps the Globe". Guess someone realized that calling old people a plague wasn't the best choice of words.
- weatherlight 10y ago"While the prospect of longer lives is a good thing, problems arise when a shrinking work force cannot foot the pension bill." He underestimates the power of automation and the inevitable rise of a basic universal income.
- CaptSpify 10y agoHe didn't say we can't do it, but that there are problems. Automation will help, but it doesn't solve all of the problems associated.
- weatherlight 10y ago"shrinking work force" he's not taking automation into account. Robots and algorithm do indeed do work and do provide monetary value.
- CaptSpify 10y ago> Robots and algorithm do indeed do work and do provide monetary value. I'm not sure where anyone said otherwise. I'm just saying that automation doesn't solve all of the problems here.
- dominotw 10y agocan't these countries just import young people from India where more than 50% of its population below the age of 25 and more than 65% below the age of 35.
- skewart 10y agoBut will 65 always be a meaningful cut-off for "old" - if it even is today? What would the balance look like if you made the cut-off 75, or 80, or 90? Obviously current pension and retirement policy defines "old" at various ages in the 50s or 60s, and 65 is a reasonable cut-off in light of current laws. But the trend is generally longer lives and later retirements. I would be willing to bet that the 65-year-olds of the 2030s will be much less of a "burden" on society than, say, the 65-year-olds of the 1930s were.
- ihsw 10y ago65+ across the board is most definitely a burden -- those entering old age between now and 2030 are universally poor, underemployed, and in poor health, and there is no sign of it slowing down or getting better. They will rely on the young more than ever. That said, 65 isn't a hard number. Many exit regular employment permanently at 50, for example. A century ago and now are incomparable for a variety of reasons, one of them being a burgeoning middle class. The birth of a middle class brings incalculable improvements but many nations haven't ever adapted to that massive middle class approaching old age, but thankfully this will be staggered so we can respond to it gradually.
- skewart 10y ago> those entering old age between now and 2030 are universally poor, underemployed, and in poor health, and there is no sign of it slowing down or getting better. They will rely on the young more than ever. Could you elaborate on this? My impression is the exact opposite - that people are generally healthier and/or living longer than they have previously. Obviously things vary tremendously from country to country - and obesity in the US complicates the picture - but is general health and life expectancy around the world going down?
- Practicality 10y agoIf we can fix health problems this is no longer a problem. (Just saying). At that point it's just a population issue.
- Falkon1313 10y ago>a shrinking work force cannot foot the pension bill [...] >the political choices are unsavory — increase taxes or cut benefits Those are not solutions, those would both exacerbate the problems. A shrinking workforce, which has seen wages stagnating for decades while cost of living continues to increase, and which is increasingly being automated out resulting in high unemployment, cannot pay more taxes. That would result in even more working people needing benefits (or dropping out of the workforce because it's a net loss to work) and lower tax revenues. Cutting benefits would, of course, directly increase the problems that occur when there already aren't enough benefits to go around. And both of those 'solutions' would cause things to get increasingly worse as the population ages and automation continues. A possible solution would be increasing wages so that the workers, though fewer in number, could pay more taxes and support more retirees and benefits. Another would be decreasing the workweek, so that more people would have to be hired, resulting in lower unemployment and more people paying taxes instead of living on benefits. Both of those are also scalable, as the population ages and automation increases, wages can be increased and hours decreased to compensate. As a side benefit, workers with higher wages and more free time, in addition to paying more taxes, could buy more, stimulating the economy, resulting in even more tax revenues.
- pasbesoin 10y agoAs societies, we've chosen to pay for old people -- not for kids. You get what you pay for.