10 ms·
It is quite an interesting time. My liberal friends are all irked because Bernie got hosed by the DNC. My conservative friends are irked because the RNC did not
by matwood 10y ago
It is quite an interesting time. My liberal friends are all irked because Bernie got hosed by the DNC. My conservative friends are irked because the RNC did not do more to stop Trump. Talk about a role reversal with the party of the people and the party of the establishment.
Personally, I see so many problems with both candidates that it makes me sick that I have to vote for the least worst one.
- Alex3917 10y agoPeople aren't upset that the DNC was against Bernie, they're upset that they were against Bernie while telling the public they were neutral to solicit donations. I'm not a lawyer, but that sounds like felony wire fraud to me.
- jjuel 10y agoDo you though? There are more than 2 candidates...
- matwood 10y agoOf all of the candidates only two have a chance of winning. If I vote for someone other than those two, the one that I think is the worst may get elected.
- Retric 10y agoThe odds of you vote changing that is tiny. IMO, convincing others to vote for a 3rd party is a bad idea, but voting for them is just as 'meaningless' as any other vote in terms of changing who win. However, the power of voting is in the message not just who wins. Defacto third party's scare the primary party's so they are quick to gain the talking points as soon as those party gain any traction. Most recently Libertarian message was somewhat co opted by Tea Party Republicans. Though in a very mutated form that for example ignored their drug stance.
- bluejekyll 10y agoThis perspective is self-fulfilling. Vote for your best candidate, Dr. Jill Stein and Gary Johnson are real candidates, and could win, just like Bernie Sanders (which no one expected). We need to force the two parties to loosen their grip on the political machine in the US. The only way we do that is by supporting third party candidates. If you want to vote Green, go convince a conservative to vote Libertarian. I did this just last week in PA, a conservative that I don't agree with is completely upset about Trump and is going to vote for Gary Johnson.
- coldtea 10y ago>This perspective is self-fulfilling. Unless you can massively convince everyone to do vote for their actual best candidate, it's also very pragmatic. From experience from other countries, the way shifts that allow a third party/candidate break a "duopoly" happen is slowly -- they incresingly get 5, 10, 15% of the vote, until a momentum builds and people start (rightly) feeling than voting for them doesn't just waste their vote and lets their least favorite of the 2 major candidates elected.
- bluejekyll 10y agohttp://thehill.com/blogs/ballot-box/presidential-races/289859-third-party-support-surging http://thehill.com/blogs/ballot-box/presidential-races/28985... This is the year to do it. There is enough general dissatisfaction with the two parties that there is an opening for both the Green and Libertarian Parties to actually do something that's never been done before. Which instead of spoiling one major party (Perot and Nader), they would spoil both. Your wasting your vote if you don't use it to vote your mind.
- gotchange 10y ago> We need to force the two parties to loosen their grip on the political machine in the US. The only way we do that is by supporting third party candidates. May I suggest that you guys explore elections reform as an option to get fresh faces on the political stage and rejuvenate the whole political process?
- xlxlxlx 10y agoWhy do you feel you have to vote for one of the two?
- waterphone 10y agoBecause in the U.S. electoral system, voting outside of the two primary candidates selected by the system is effectively a wasted vote, and if there is one candidate you especially don't want, it is usually more effective to vote against them rather than for a candidate who cannot win under the system in place.
- ajmurmann 10y agoI don't understand why you are being downvoted. You are pointing out the biggest issue with the current political system in the US. It's de-facto a two party system. We could fix this by making it either a parliamentary system or changing the voting method to approval voting. With approval voting we wouldn't even need a primary and neither Trump nor Hilary would be anywhere near the Whitehouse, since they both had negative approval ratings during the primary.
- logfromblammo 10y agoA third-party vote is wasted in the context of the current election. It is definitely not wasted in terms of ballot access and public credibility for the subsequent elections. If you don't expect to die before the next election, it is never a waste to vote for the option closest to what you actually want. If you are always voting between your worst choice and your second-worst choice, it may be wiser to reconsider strategic voting altogether, and just pick what you want every time.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> A third-party vote is wasted in the context of the current election. It is definitely not wasted in terms of ballot access and public credibility for the subsequent elections. I think there is a pair of words reversed here: it is not definitely wasted in terms of ballot access and public credibility for subsequent elections (that is, it is possible for it to have some impact on those things), but its most likely also wasted for those purposes, so "definitely not" is not accurate.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cderwin 10y agoThere's another option (though scantily mentioned and likely unpopular): not voting at all. At least then you won't bare any responsible for putting a Trump or Clinton in the White House.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- humanrebar 10y ago> Talk about a role reversal with the party of the people and the party of the establishment I follow you up to here. The Democratic party has always been for centralized control of policy decisions. > My conservative friends are irked because the RNC did not do more to stop Trump. Mine don't really care about the party leadership. They are irked at the other primary voters more than the party leaders. Rubio, Paul, and Cruz were Tea Party candidates, so considering them establishment and voting for Trump screams ignorance more than anything.
- lettergram 10y agoYou don't actually have to vote for the least worst one... I recommend looking to third party candidates. The libertarian party has two pretty solid lineup and polls third at the moment (like 11% or something this election cycle). That being said, you can also protest vote by putting in "Edward Snowden" or something. Honestly, I find it horrifying people feel the need to vote for the "least worst option". You're essentially electing a temporary dictator (potentially at least), please don't vote for someone you dislike. Even if you dislike one less than the other, you still dislike them... Try not to let fear influence you when selecting a leader. A leader needs to guide and protect the group, not be the least bad member of the group.
- mikeash 10y agoVoting for a third party is pointless. You might as well just stay home if you're going to do that. You might feel better about voting libertarian or writing in Snowden, but it doesn't actually do anything. You're voting as if the system worked differently than it does. It's about as useful and productive as removing all the free() calls from your C code because you think that C really should have garbage collection.
- ende 10y agoUtterly false. If the expectation is the actual election of a third party candiate, then sure that is unrealistic given how the two party system actively supresses third party participation. But voting third party contributes to long term objectives of increasing ballot access, funding, visibility, media attention, and decreasing the two-party share of the vote which thereby decreases the legitimacy of two-party outcomes. These in turn can then pressure other politicians across all branches of government to ensact more inclusive electoral reform.
- jkarneges 10y agoIt's not very well known, but if a candidate gets at least 5% of the popular vote then their party gets access to government funding for the next election. 5% is still a pretty tall order (Libertarian party got around 1% in 2012), but it's in the realm of plausibility. The fact that it's based on the popular vote is great because the Electoral College doesn't get in way. Interestingly, if you live in a state that isn't a swing state, voting third party is possibly more meaningful than voting R or D. For example, if you live in California, voting for Clinton is unnecessary and voting for Trump is pointless, but voting for Stein or Johnson could actually have a real effect.
- Kinnard 10y agoYou may certainly boycott the farce— among other options.
- jondubois 10y agoYes I think that this election was just completely dominated by marketing/advertising. There seems to be no substance behind it at all. I don't think people really had the opportunity to hear about Bernie Sanders and other more worthy candidates. As a foreigner not living in the US (but following the process nevertheless) I hardly even heard about Bernie Sanders until he lost the candidacy to Hillary Clinton - After that, I did a bit of research on him and he actually seemed like the perfect candidate to solve the US's current problems - If I could, I would definitely have voted for him. Maybe it was different inside the US, but from outside, almost no one would even recognize the name "Bernie Sanders" because he just wasn't given any attention in the media. If the media doesn't give you a balanced description of what your options are, how can you even vote? This is downright corruption - Just as wrong as the kind that happens China, only a lot more sophisticated.
- threallytho 10y agoHere's a suggestion, for you and everyone suggesting you don't vote: Get over it. (Content intended for voters in a US-style FPTP system. Mileage in IRV and other systems may vary.) No one will see your vote. The structure of elections is not such that you can state your ideals. The question is about your preference for the actual outcome of the contest. In programming terms, you're not being asked to return the largest integer; you're given a choice of two integers, and asked to return the larger. It doesn't matter if neither one looks objectively "large"-- refusing to return anything will not help this algorithm generate larger numbers. Maybe it's a stupid algorithm, but that's not relevant, either. To stay HN-neutral I'll leave this generic, though it really isn't: Regardless of your feelings about the candidates in this election in an objective sense, you should have a strong dispreference for one candidate under the other. In a proper decision theory, that should translate into a strong relative preference for the other candidate to be the actual winner of the contest. That doesn't mean you support them absolutely, or morally. It just means you're voting in line with rather than against your true preference for outcome. And that should translate into strong support in the voting booth, though of course that doesn't and shouldn't have to translate into strong support in public opinion. If you don't vote for the candidate you strongly relatively prefer because your absolute preference for them is low -- you don't want to send a message that "this candidate is objectively good" -- you are using a different protocol than the election, and what will be received is "the relative preference for this candidate is fairly low". What you should expect is for the election to perceive that you support your dispreferred candidate significantly more than you actually do. And that's what should make you sick.
- syshum 10y ago>sick that I have to vote for the least worst one. Of course you dont, There are 2 Other people on the ballot in Most states given you 4 options. I personally will be voting for Gary Johnson this year. (as i did in 2012)
- Mindless2112 10y ago> it makes me sick that I have to vote for the least worst one. Perhaps you should vote for someone else then. “It comes from a very ancient democracy, you see..." "You mean, it comes from a world of lizards?" "No," said Ford, who by this time was a little more rational and coherent than he had been, having finally had the coffee forced down him, "nothing so simple. Nothing anything like so straightforward. On its world, the people are people. The leaders are lizards. The people hate the lizards and the lizards rule the people." "Odd," said Arthur, "I thought you said it was a democracy." "I did," said Ford. "It is." "So," said Arthur, hoping he wasn't sounding ridiculously obtuse, "why don't people get rid of the lizards?" "It honestly doesn't occur to them," said Ford. "They've all got the vote, so they all pretty much assume that the government they've voted in more or less approximates to the government they want." "You mean they actually vote for the lizards?" "Oh yes," said Ford with a shrug, "of course." "But," said Arthur, going for the big one again, "why?" "Because if they didn't vote for a lizard," said Ford, "the wrong lizard might get in. Got any gin?" ― Douglas Adams, So Long, and Thanks for All the Fish
- eternalban 10y agoDo your liberal friends know about this? https://citizensagainstplutocracy.wordpress.com/ https://citizensagainstplutocracy.wordpress.com/
- csorrell 10y agoWe really ought to shift to a rank based voting system where you can list your first choice, second choice, third etc. (Which Jill Stein wants to implement btw.) This system would reflect the average of preferences and the best candidates would emerge. There's no way Trump would have secured the Republican nomination in a rank based voting system because he is so polarizing. Instead they'd probably have Kasich, who was everyone's second best.